I'm RPing that my copy and myself will not fight each other unless they are the last ones left, so in that case, he will move to L1 and attack Dorro, seeing that he is back up.
So I assume the attacks transfer from above, dealing 11 damage to Dorro
Flowyn copy will make his way over to Mako prime and take two attacks, one with shortsword and bonus action handaxe
Attack: 16 Damage: 5
Attack: 16 Damage: 6
Those are the attacks targeting Dorro then, right? Neither hits.
Having Folwyn in his face and attacking him would certainly change Dorro's move. DDP, not sure how much retconning you want here? Before I post variations on the turn, please set the table and discuss how much or little I should change the turn.
(OOC: Now that I think about it though, if Folwyn moved up to Dorro before it was Dorro's turn, Dorro would still have been prone and Folwyn's attacks should have been with advantage.
Moving forward we'll definitely need to figure out a way to minimize retconning. It's round 1 and we will obviously have a learning curve, but this will slow down the pacing too much in higher rounds.
For now I'll wait for DDP to make his rulings and reset the board. Dorro will then take his turn, assuming he's still alive. I think the Urilan Copy move will stay the same.)
OOC: I don't ever want to cast fog cloud again. Even though it made the fight a lot more interesting! I guess it's also that we're all keeping track of a new character, and some of the names are similar, and this is the first time with everything, so I bet next time we'll have it more under control...
OOC: I don't ever want to cast fog cloud again. Even though it made the fight a lot more interesting! I guess it's also that we're all keeping track of a new character, and some of the names are similar, and this is the first time with everything, so I bet next time we'll have it more under control...
(OOC: Yeah. PbP creates a lot of challenges that would be easily overcome at a table. Rule details like that take 2 seconds at a table top game, but 10 posts and 3 days in PbP. It's less important when you're just murdering a group of level 1 goblins, you can fudge some of that, but when we're doing something like this where we really want to see how it shakes out, the details like that really matter. I expect we'll get better at managing things like this after a few rounds.)
@jasmol81: Avoiding melee with Folwyn, Folwyn's copy can make it to L2 with your 30 feet.
Folwyn's copy takes a round-about path to end up beside the prone Dorro. (Rolling advantage for Folwyn's copy's two attacks against Dorro: 2324) He swings both his shortsword and handaxe at the firbolg, striking him down once again.
Folwyn swings at Urilan's copy, but misses. Narrowing his eyes at the halfling, the half-orc takes a deep breath and feels energy refresh his body (second wind).
OOC: The good thing about playing both sides is you're assured a win. :)
Urilan's copy doesn't like being stabbed at. He slashes at Folwyn, but the half-orc brings up his weapons to block the attack. The halfling then draws a second weapon and prepares to attack again.
Dorro fights walking into the light.
laa2736, you're up!
OOC2: I have a request that I hope will help. If/when we need to do a little retconning, and you need to change your move, please edit the previous post and strike through the part of the post that no longer applies. If you'd like to strike through the entire thing and copy and paste the portion that still applies into the new post, that might even be better. I'm not going to make it a rule that we don't have any OOC posts here, but there were a lot of posts to go through to get a few moves straightened out, and it was a little overwhelming. Just remember that we do have the OOC chat, so if you're so inclined, you could ask those questions there. Again, I'm not saying you need to.
OOC3: Thanks, everyone, for your patience when we need to work out changes and challenges.
Dorro's copy calls down a sacred flame on Folwyn. (Folwyn's DEX save (DC13): 17) Folwyn dodges the attack.
OOC: Everyone, if you use a spell or any kind of action that requires a saving throw by another player, go ahead and roll it for them. Everyone can see everyone else's saving throws. This will also help keep the action going.
The dwarven druid, confused and frustrated at the general circumstances of life right now, can hear sounds of battle and peeks out, hoping that Dorro, newly healed, has turned the tide. But the firbolg is again crumpled to the ground with a Folwyn standing over his form, so he's even more confused. Mako can't tell which Urilan is which, and so decides to (1) attack Folwyn's copy with frostbite. (CON 13 save: 20). Folwyn's copy shrugs it off. He ducks back into the cloud, fear beginning to settle in.
(Urilan Copy is raging and takes half damage from Folwyn's attacks.)
Urilan Copy uses a free action to draw his other handaxe.
(OOC: I interpret the above posts to mean that Urilan moved to K4 and Folwyn Copy moved to K3. Request that all movement comes with a grid coordinate to ease confusion.)
Urilan Copy's mastiff will step to K5, flanking Urilan, opposite Folwyn Copy. He'll attack Urilan with both handaxes. (Advantage for flanking.)
Attack: 12 Damage: 7
Attack: 22 Damage: 6 (no str modifier damage for the offhand.)
Nehala's copy fires another eldritch blast at Folwyn, but once again misses the half-orc.
Urilan rides up to his copy (I had also assumed K4) and swings his greataxe, but his target is table to move out of the way.
Oritar's copy takes a step toward the light. (He was knocked out in the second half of Round 2, saved in Round 3 and failed in Round 4. That's one fail and one save.)
The dwarven druid, confused and frustrated at the general circumstances of life right now, can hear sounds of battle and peeks out, hoping that Dorro, newly healed, has turned the tide. But the firbolg is again crumpled to the ground with a Folwyn standing over his form, so he's even more confused. Mako can't tell which Urilan is which, and so decides to attack Folwyn's copy with frostbite. Folwyn's copy shrugs it off. He ducks back into the cloud, fear beginning to settle in.
Folwyn's copy moves next to Urilan (I had also assumed K3) and attacks with his shortsword and handaxe. The shortsword misses, but the handaxe strikes the barbarian on the leg. The halfling's rage reduces the damage by half.
Folwyn turns and attacks Urilan's copy with his shortsword and handaxe. Both weapons hit, but that halfling's similar rage keeps him from receiving as much damage as he would have otherwise.
Urilan's copy draws his other handaxe as his mastiff steps through Folwyn and Urilan to flank Urilan opposite Folwyn's copy. He attacks Urilan with both handaxes. The first cuts nothing but air, but the second hits. The barbarian's rage once again protects the halfling from the full force of the attack.
This post has potentially manipulated dice roll results.
Oritar copy death save: 7
(Believe Oritar copy gives up the ghost)
***
Mako strength save: 10
The dwarf finally succeeds in breaking free of the vines. From his few peeks out of the fog cloud, he thinks the situation is dire. He hefts his shillelagh and wades into the fray, striking at 1 Urilan's copy after moving to K6:
Attack: 6 Damage: 6 (flanking Urilan's copy with Urilan if Urilan hasn't moved... second roll with advantage if Mako can flank: 14)
(So it seems like Urilan did in fact move, because Folwyn prime is not down? Meaning Mako prime wouldn't have advantage, so his melee attack on Urilan's copy would not hit? Think I have that right.)
Those are the attacks targeting Dorro then, right? Neither hits.
Having Folwyn in his face and attacking him would certainly change Dorro's move. DDP, not sure how much retconning you want here? Before I post variations on the turn, please set the table and discuss how much or little I should change the turn.
(OOC: Now that I think about it though, if Folwyn moved up to Dorro before it was Dorro's turn, Dorro would still have been prone and Folwyn's attacks should have been with advantage.
Moving forward we'll definitely need to figure out a way to minimize retconning. It's round 1 and we will obviously have a learning curve, but this will slow down the pacing too much in higher rounds.
For now I'll wait for DDP to make his rulings and reset the board. Dorro will then take his turn, assuming he's still alive. I think the Urilan Copy move will stay the same.)
OOC: I don't ever want to cast fog cloud again. Even though it made the fight a lot more interesting! I guess it's also that we're all keeping track of a new character, and some of the names are similar, and this is the first time with everything, so I bet next time we'll have it more under control...
(OOC: Yeah. PbP creates a lot of challenges that would be easily overcome at a table. Rule details like that take 2 seconds at a table top game, but 10 posts and 3 days in PbP. It's less important when you're just murdering a group of level 1 goblins, you can fudge some of that, but when we're doing something like this where we really want to see how it shakes out, the details like that really matter. I expect we'll get better at managing things like this after a few rounds.)
@jasmol81: Avoiding melee with Folwyn, Folwyn's copy can make it to L2 with your 30 feet.
Folwyn's copy takes a round-about path to end up beside the prone Dorro. (Rolling advantage for Folwyn's copy's two attacks against Dorro: 23 24) He swings both his shortsword and handaxe at the firbolg, striking him down once again.
Folwyn swings at Urilan's copy, but misses. Narrowing his eyes at the halfling, the half-orc takes a deep breath and feels energy refresh his body (second wind).
@Bierp: Recon away!
(Oof, well, I at least got to type a turn with Dorro, even if he didn't get to actually do it. :) )
Urilan's Copy makes the move I posted earlier, which missed.
---
Dorro makes a death save: 11
(Okay so I will put the 11 hp back on Mako Prime... and Oritar's copy is indeed unconscious and dying.)
(Have we caught up with everything, and if so, where are we in the round? I have faith in us! We can do it!)
OOC: The good thing about playing both sides is you're assured a win. :)
Urilan's copy doesn't like being stabbed at. He slashes at Folwyn, but the half-orc brings up his weapons to block the attack. The halfling then draws a second weapon and prepares to attack again.
Dorro fights walking into the light.
laa2736, you're up!
OOC2: I have a request that I hope will help. If/when we need to do a little retconning, and you need to change your move, please edit the previous post and strike through the part of the post that no longer applies. If you'd like to strike through the entire thing and copy and paste the portion that still applies into the new post, that might even be better. I'm not going to make it a rule that we don't have any OOC posts here, but there were a lot of posts to go through to get a few moves straightened out, and it was a little overwhelming. Just remember that we do have the OOC chat, so if you're so inclined, you could ask those questions there. Again, I'm not saying you need to.
OOC3: Thanks, everyone, for your patience when we need to work out changes and challenges.
Mako's copy takes the dodge action.
Nehala death saving throw: 4
Round 4: Dorro copy, Oritar (unconscious: 1 fail/1 save), Nehala copy (hex on Nehala), Urilan (rage), Oritar copy (unconscious: 0 fails/1 save), Mako (restrained), Folwyn copy, Folwyn, Urilan copy (rage), Dorro (unconscious: 0 fails/1 save), Mako copy (shillelagh; dodge), Nehala (unconscious: 1 fail/1 save)
Dorro's copy calls down a sacred flame on Folwyn. (Folwyn's DEX save (DC13): 17) Folwyn dodges the attack.
OOC: Everyone, if you use a spell or any kind of action that requires a saving throw by another player, go ahead and roll it for them. Everyone can see everyone else's saving throws. This will also help keep the action going.
Oritar death saving throw: 12
Swiftgale, you're up!
I have quite a hectic day so very brief post, Nehala copy eldritch blast folwyn. Attack: 14 Damage: 10
Urilan will ride up to Urilan copy and will attack with his greataxe. Attack: 9 Damage: 15
After joining more my signature got out of hand so I am now a proud member of the extended signature club!! :)
Oritar copy death save: 1 (That's two failures)
***
Mako strength check to escape entanglement: 3
The dwarven druid, confused and frustrated at the general circumstances of life right now, can hear sounds of battle and peeks out, hoping that Dorro, newly healed, has turned the tide. But the firbolg is again crumpled to the ground with a Folwyn standing over his form, so he's even more confused. Mako can't tell which Urilan is which, and so decides to (1) attack Folwyn's copy with frostbite. (CON 13 save: 20). Folwyn's copy shrugs it off. He ducks back into the cloud, fear beginning to settle in.
Folwyn's copy will move next to Urilan and attack with his shortsword and handaxe
Attack: 13 Damage: 5
Attack: 21 Damage: 4
Folwyn will stay where he is and attack Urilan's copy with his shortsword and handaxe
Attack: 24 Damage: 4
Attack: 18 Damage: 6
(Urilan Copy is raging and takes half damage from Folwyn's attacks.)
Urilan Copy uses a free action to draw his other handaxe.
(OOC: I interpret the above posts to mean that Urilan moved to K4 and Folwyn Copy moved to K3. Request that all movement comes with a grid coordinate to ease confusion.)
Urilan Copy's mastiff will step to K5, flanking Urilan, opposite Folwyn Copy. He'll attack Urilan with both handaxes. (Advantage for flanking.)
Attack: 12 Damage: 7
Attack: 22 Damage: 6 (no str modifier damage for the offhand.)
---
Dorro makes a death save: 14
Nehala's copy fires another eldritch blast at Folwyn, but once again misses the half-orc.
Urilan rides up to his copy (I had also assumed K4) and swings his greataxe, but his target is table to move out of the way.
Oritar's copy takes a step toward the light. (He was knocked out in the second half of Round 2, saved in Round 3 and failed in Round 4. That's one fail and one save.)
The dwarven druid, confused and frustrated at the general circumstances of life right now, can hear sounds of battle and peeks out, hoping that Dorro, newly healed, has turned the tide. But the firbolg is again crumpled to the ground with a Folwyn standing over his form, so he's even more confused. Mako can't tell which Urilan is which, and so decides to attack Folwyn's copy with frostbite. Folwyn's copy shrugs it off. He ducks back into the cloud, fear beginning to settle in.
Folwyn's copy moves next to Urilan (I had also assumed K3) and attacks with his shortsword and handaxe. The shortsword misses, but the handaxe strikes the barbarian on the leg. The halfling's rage reduces the damage by half.
Folwyn turns and attacks Urilan's copy with his shortsword and handaxe. Both weapons hit, but that halfling's similar rage keeps him from receiving as much damage as he would have otherwise.
Urilan's copy draws his other handaxe as his mastiff steps through Folwyn and Urilan to flank Urilan opposite Folwyn's copy. He attacks Urilan with both handaxes. The first cuts nothing but air, but the second hits. The barbarian's rage once again protects the halfling from the full force of the attack.
Dorro takes a step away from the light.
laa2736, you're up!
Mako's copy takes the dodge action.
Nehala death save: 2
Round 5: Dorro copy, Oritar (unconscious: 1 fail/2 saves), Nehala copy (hex on Nehala), Urilan (rage), Oritar copy (unconscious: 2 fails/1 save), Mako (restrained), Folwyn copy, Folwyn, Urilan copy (rage), Dorro (unconscious: 0 fails/2 saves), Mako copy (shillelagh; dodge), Nehala (unconscious: 2 fails/1 save)
Dorro's copy calls his death toll on Folwyn once again. (Toll the dead: WIS save DC13 — Folwyn's WIS save: 17 — or damage: 9 necrotic damage)
Oritar death save: 3
Swiftgale, you're up!
Nehala copy will eldritch blast Folwyn, Attack: 21 Damage: 7 and stay where she is
Urilan will take an AoO from Folwyn copy (unless Folwyn Prime is down) to move to J5 and flank Urilan copy. HAttack: 17 Damage: 13
After joining more my signature got out of hand so I am now a proud member of the extended signature club!! :)
Oritar copy death save: 7
(Believe Oritar copy gives up the ghost)
***
Mako strength save: 10
The dwarf finally succeeds in breaking free of the vines. From his few peeks out of the fog cloud, he thinks the situation is dire. He hefts his shillelagh and wades into the fray, striking at 1 Urilan's copy after moving to K6:
Attack: 6 Damage: 6 (flanking Urilan's copy with Urilan if Urilan hasn't moved... second roll with advantage if Mako can flank: 14)
(21 hits Urilan's copy, half damage (5) for bludgeoning while raging leaves him at 1 HP)
(So it seems like Urilan did in fact move, because Folwyn prime is not down? Meaning Mako prime wouldn't have advantage, so his melee attack on Urilan's copy would not hit? Think I have that right.)
Who's turn is it, Folwyn's/jasmol80's?
Ok so first AoO on Urilan from Folwyn's copy Attack: 17 Damage: 6