Good evening, I have a player who is going to need a resurrection at the start of my next session. I’ve always liked the way Critical Role does resurrections, as it brings in good role play opportunities. But I wanted to make it have a lasting effect if successful, so I was thinking about having the PC roll a d20 to figure out which of their main attributes or max HP takes a hit. Then, they would roll a d4 at advantage for their attributes or a d10 at advantage for their max HP, and whatever they roll, they lose that permanently. Is that too punishing for the PC?
The Dungeon Master's Guide already has Injuries. Now granted they're not the best optional rule, but I'd suggest using those before dishing out negative stat modifiers.
D&D used to have mechanics where entire levels could be wiped from a character - Mummies used to be scary. I doubt any modern players would be up for that in their games anymore, and 5e isn't really built that way. Using injuries instead brings an effect into the game that (presumably) the designers already factored into the balance of things. Negative stat modifiers on the other hand can be really punishing and limit player options on level ups. If they're a multiclass for example a negative stat modifier could legitimately push them down below the prerequisites for their second class. It could also lead a player to be forced to take an ASI rather than a feat at a level up which may end up feeling less fun.
In general, I'd urge any DM to remember that Critical Role and it's ilk are entertainment - they're not 'how to play' guides. Enjoy them for the entertainment value by all means, but I've lost count of the number of DMs and players who've been inspired to try and mimic CR, only to drop out of the hobby because it doesn't meet their expectations. Our local game shop now has a big sign up to remind people that 'Actual plays are designed to entertain an audience; TTRPGs are designed to entertain its players.' So just because you enjoyed watching their show, does not follow that it will be as enjoyable for your players to experience. Every table is different, what works for one won't work for all tables.
If you're intent on trying however, I'd suggest sitting down and thinking about all the ways it could go wrong. Don't ask how this will be fun for players, ask instead how it will aggravate players. Ask yourself what impact it has on the mechanics. If a player character suffers a -4 to their CON for example, that's going to by default affect their max HP anyway. At level 10, a character could see their Max HP drop 20 points as a result. A Bard losing that same -4 to CHA would be seriously impacted. It takes down not just their CHA, but all the derivative skills too (Intimidation, Persuasion, Performance). A spellcaster taking that hit to their spellcasting ability would slash their spell save DC too. You get the point I imagine. Give more consideration to how much the idea sucks and weight it twice and highly as the 'cool' factor. Then decide if the idea is a good one to enact.
Dying tends to suck pretty hard to begin with since your character is at the very least going be unable to play for a few rounds (which could be an hour real-time) and then unable to really act lest you be KOed again. And that's just for Revivify IF someone has it memorized. If it isn't memorized, then they'll need to use Raise Dead or something similar, which likely means the party having to take a long rest. That can mean not getting to act for most of a session. That's a pretty big penalty for the player already, stacking extra drawbacks on their character after that is not going to increase anyone's fun.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
Good evening, I have a player who is going to need a resurrection at the start of my next session. I’ve always liked the way Critical Role does resurrections, as it brings in good role play opportunities. But I wanted to make it have a lasting effect if successful, so I was thinking about having the PC roll a d20 to figure out which of their main attributes or max HP takes a hit. Then, they would roll a d4 at advantage for their attributes or a d10 at advantage for their max HP, and whatever they roll, they lose that permanently. Is that too punishing for the PC?
Why try to make your players resent you? Don't do it. This is how you get a table to fall apart. I could get behind a DM giving me a temp consequence like this IF they got buy in from the table and if they made it clear it was temporary, but that's it.
Find a way to have a lasting effect that is fun for the players, not the malicious DM. My recommendation is RP if you want a permanent effect. Players can sometimes get behind that.
I don't hate the idea of mixing a little "came back wrong" in with player character resurrection, but I'd caution against anything permanent because a permanent punishment for being resurrected is just that: a punishment. I don't hate the injuries table from the 2014 DMG that martintheactor suggested, and I like that it has ways the player can overcome the long-term injuries baked in. For a little extra punch, you can make the recovery option something of a side-quest.
I would strenuously recommend avoiding any permanent reduction on the character sheet. Maybe they lose a few points of Constitution, but they recover one point per long rest. Or maybe they wake up with several levels of exhaustion, and they remove one level of exhaustion per long rest. If you're going to impose a reduction, make it temporary and let the player know that they will eventually recover fully. Otherwise it will feel punitive. Any homebrew rulings on Life & Death that deviate from RAW should be spelled out clearly in the Session Zero before the campaign begins.
Why would you want to put a damper on the player's elation of not being dead dead?
Why would you want to punish a party for either having prepared the spell or gained the resources to pay for the service?
As a player that doesn't sound fun to me. I understand that you might feel the threat of death becomes less impactful without some consequence. However the game can still be fun without killing off the party.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"Sooner or later, your Players are going to smash your railroad into a sandbox."
-Vedexent
"real life is a super high CR."
-OboeLauren
"............anybody got any potatoes? We could drop a potato in each hole an' see which ones get viciously mauled by horrible monsters?"
If you're intent on trying however, I'd suggest sitting down and thinking about all the ways it could go wrong. Don't ask how this will be fun for players, ask instead how it will aggravate players. Ask yourself what impact it has on the mechanics. If a player character suffers a -4 to their CON for example, that's going to by default affect their max HP anyway. At level 10, a character could see their Max HP drop 20 points as a result. A Bard losing that same -4 to CHA would be seriously impacted. It takes down not just their CHA, but all the derivative skills too (Intimidation, Persuasion, Performance). A spellcaster taking that hit to their spellcasting ability would slash their spell save DC too. You get the point I imagine. Give more consideration to how much the idea sucks and weight it twice and highly as the 'cool' factor. Then decide if the idea is a good one to enact.
As everyone has said already don't do this, it's a terrible idea, but Martin makes a very good point here by asking you to consider the effects a reduction of up to 4 points could make to each stat. I don't know what class they're playing but a reduction in strength could lead to them not being able to wear certain armour or use certain weapons, a hit to dex could mean a huge impact to to their AC, as well as those two stats being key to melee characters attacks. As Martin says con will hit their HP or any of the mental stats would reduce the attacks of spell casters. You could be permanently impairing their character at a point when they're high enough level that PCs are dying and they'll never catch back up so the chances of them dying again are increased. It's a recipe for the player feeling resentful and not enjoying the game
Just leave the character dead if you intend to cripple the character after they are resurrected. As a player I'd rather make a new character than be stuck with an old character that now is permanently weaker than everyone else in the party. I'd probably just RP the character retiring from adventuring if they took a permanent hit to their stats.
"Hey, Bob, I just wanted to let you know that since you were revived, your Charisma score was reduced by 4. I know you were playing a Bard, that's just how the dice turned out. Now please reduce every Charisma modifier on your character sheet by 2. This is permanent."
...I was thinking about having the PC roll a d20 to figure out which of their main attributes or max HP takes a hit. Then, they would roll a d4 at advantage for their attributes or a d10 at advantage for their max HP, and whatever they roll, they lose that permanently.
I assume you do this because you would rather they create a new character and/or leave your game then to keep an established character that they they have probably spent hours and hours with planning and getting into the "mindset" which helps with RPing the character. With this example, knowing that if you die, you would lose so much would probably affect how I play whether that is my PC or a mate's PC.
The other extremely painful punishment You list is to have them roll two dice and take the higher of the two. You aren't just dropping stats a little but ensuring that you are taking as much of the stat as possible.
Personally, if my DM did that to a mates PC, I would put that up as a huge red flag. I assume there are other flags based on this example. I would probably look to leaving if I could find another game. This type of DM behavior to extract the most punishment to a PC would get me out of your campaigns if there is any sign I could play elsewhere.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Good evening, I have a player who is going to need a resurrection at the start of my next session. I’ve always liked the way Critical Role does resurrections, as it brings in good role play opportunities. But I wanted to make it have a lasting effect if successful, so I was thinking about having the PC roll a d20 to figure out which of their main attributes or max HP takes a hit. Then, they would roll a d4 at advantage for their attributes or a d10 at advantage for their max HP, and whatever they roll, they lose that permanently. Is that too punishing for the PC?
The Dungeon Master's Guide already has Injuries. Now granted they're not the best optional rule, but I'd suggest using those before dishing out negative stat modifiers.
D&D used to have mechanics where entire levels could be wiped from a character - Mummies used to be scary. I doubt any modern players would be up for that in their games anymore, and 5e isn't really built that way. Using injuries instead brings an effect into the game that (presumably) the designers already factored into the balance of things. Negative stat modifiers on the other hand can be really punishing and limit player options on level ups. If they're a multiclass for example a negative stat modifier could legitimately push them down below the prerequisites for their second class. It could also lead a player to be forced to take an ASI rather than a feat at a level up which may end up feeling less fun.
In general, I'd urge any DM to remember that Critical Role and it's ilk are entertainment - they're not 'how to play' guides. Enjoy them for the entertainment value by all means, but I've lost count of the number of DMs and players who've been inspired to try and mimic CR, only to drop out of the hobby because it doesn't meet their expectations. Our local game shop now has a big sign up to remind people that 'Actual plays are designed to entertain an audience; TTRPGs are designed to entertain its players.' So just because you enjoyed watching their show, does not follow that it will be as enjoyable for your players to experience. Every table is different, what works for one won't work for all tables.
If you're intent on trying however, I'd suggest sitting down and thinking about all the ways it could go wrong. Don't ask how this will be fun for players, ask instead how it will aggravate players. Ask yourself what impact it has on the mechanics. If a player character suffers a -4 to their CON for example, that's going to by default affect their max HP anyway. At level 10, a character could see their Max HP drop 20 points as a result. A Bard losing that same -4 to CHA would be seriously impacted. It takes down not just their CHA, but all the derivative skills too (Intimidation, Persuasion, Performance). A spellcaster taking that hit to their spellcasting ability would slash their spell save DC too. You get the point I imagine. Give more consideration to how much the idea sucks and weight it twice and highly as the 'cool' factor. Then decide if the idea is a good one to enact.
DM session planning template - My version of maps for 'Lost Mine of Phandelver' - Send your party to The Circus - Other DM Resources - Maps, Tokens, Quests - 'Better' Player Character Injury Tables?
Actor, Writer, Director & Teacher by day - GM/DM in my off hours.
Losing points in an ability score would be awful.
Dying tends to suck pretty hard to begin with since your character is at the very least going be unable to play for a few rounds (which could be an hour real-time) and then unable to really act lest you be KOed again. And that's just for Revivify IF someone has it memorized. If it isn't memorized, then they'll need to use Raise Dead or something similar, which likely means the party having to take a long rest. That can mean not getting to act for most of a session. That's a pretty big penalty for the player already, stacking extra drawbacks on their character after that is not going to increase anyone's fun.
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
Why try to make your players resent you? Don't do it. This is how you get a table to fall apart. I could get behind a DM giving me a temp consequence like this IF they got buy in from the table and if they made it clear it was temporary, but that's it.
Find a way to have a lasting effect that is fun for the players, not the malicious DM. My recommendation is RP if you want a permanent effect. Players can sometimes get behind that.
DM mostly, Player occasionally, He/Him/They/Them, Doctor, Published Scholar, Science and Healthcare Advocate, Reader, Critter, Trekkie, Gandalf with a Glock, Make it so (RIP SPS) | Archived PCs: Barbarian: Rhoc, Bard: Ravinia, Blood Hunter: Steffen, Cleric: Belora, Mjornier, Morana, Wren, Fighter: Shri'tanabryn, Monk: Cassandra, Paladin: Eirikur, Rogue: Joy, Warlock: Arkros, Wizard: Suki
I don't hate the idea of mixing a little "came back wrong" in with player character resurrection, but I'd caution against anything permanent because a permanent punishment for being resurrected is just that: a punishment. I don't hate the injuries table from the 2014 DMG that martintheactor suggested, and I like that it has ways the player can overcome the long-term injuries baked in. For a little extra punch, you can make the recovery option something of a side-quest.
I would strenuously recommend avoiding any permanent reduction on the character sheet. Maybe they lose a few points of Constitution, but they recover one point per long rest. Or maybe they wake up with several levels of exhaustion, and they remove one level of exhaustion per long rest. If you're going to impose a reduction, make it temporary and let the player know that they will eventually recover fully. Otherwise it will feel punitive. Any homebrew rulings on Life & Death that deviate from RAW should be spelled out clearly in the Session Zero before the campaign begins.
Just my 2 c.p.
Anzio Faro. Protector Aasimar light cleric. Lvl 18.
Viktor Gavriil. White dragonborn grave cleric. Lvl 20.
Ikram Sahir ibn-Malik al-Sayyid Ra'ad. Brass dragonborn draconic sorcerer Lvl 9. Fire elemental devil.
Wrangler of cats.
Why would you want to put a damper on the player's elation of not being dead dead?
Why would you want to punish a party for either having prepared the spell or gained the resources to pay for the service?
As a player that doesn't sound fun to me. I understand that you might feel the threat of death becomes less impactful without some consequence. However the game can still be fun without killing off the party.
"Sooner or later, your Players are going to smash your railroad into a sandbox."
-Vedexent
"real life is a super high CR."
-OboeLauren
"............anybody got any potatoes? We could drop a potato in each hole an' see which ones get viciously mauled by horrible monsters?"
-Ilyara Thundertale
As everyone has said already don't do this, it's a terrible idea, but Martin makes a very good point here by asking you to consider the effects a reduction of up to 4 points could make to each stat. I don't know what class they're playing but a reduction in strength could lead to them not being able to wear certain armour or use certain weapons, a hit to dex could mean a huge impact to to their AC, as well as those two stats being key to melee characters attacks. As Martin says con will hit their HP or any of the mental stats would reduce the attacks of spell casters. You could be permanently impairing their character at a point when they're high enough level that PCs are dying and they'll never catch back up so the chances of them dying again are increased. It's a recipe for the player feeling resentful and not enjoying the game
Just leave the character dead if you intend to cripple the character after they are resurrected. As a player I'd rather make a new character than be stuck with an old character that now is permanently weaker than everyone else in the party. I'd probably just RP the character retiring from adventuring if they took a permanent hit to their stats.
"Hey, Bob, I just wanted to let you know that since you were revived, your Charisma score was reduced by 4. I know you were playing a Bard, that's just how the dice turned out. Now please reduce every Charisma modifier on your character sheet by 2. This is permanent."
Imagine if you were in that position.
I assume you do this because you would rather they create a new character and/or leave your game then to keep an established character that they they have probably spent hours and hours with planning and getting into the "mindset" which helps with RPing the character. With this example, knowing that if you die, you would lose so much would probably affect how I play whether that is my PC or a mate's PC.
The other extremely painful punishment You list is to have them roll two dice and take the higher of the two. You aren't just dropping stats a little but ensuring that you are taking as much of the stat as possible.
Personally, if my DM did that to a mates PC, I would put that up as a huge red flag. I assume there are other flags based on this example. I would probably look to leaving if I could find another game. This type of DM behavior to extract the most punishment to a PC would get me out of your campaigns if there is any sign I could play elsewhere.