Sorry if this is answered elsewhere, just looking for clarification.
Warlock's prepared spell list is per the column on the Warlock Feature table. A single spell can be swapped for another each level. If a "Warlock Feature" gives a spell that's always prepared, those "don't count" against the list number.
If I prepare Charm Person at first level, and then advance to level 4, I get Ability Score improvement or another feat of my choosing.
If I choose Fey Touched, or more specifically to the scenario in my mind, Treacherous Allure, either could give me Charm Person as "always prepared" and eligible to be cast with Pact Magic slots.
My question: Is gaining that feat my 4th level Warlock Class feature, and therefore the spell becomes a "Warlock Feature?" Does it therefore just drop out of the count and I have a vacancy on my list, not a swap I am making?
Or are feats by definition class-agnostic, so I have two independent sources of the Charm Person spell being prepared and two independent routes to cast it with slots? If I want to rectify that redundancy, I am required to utilize one of my designated 1/level exchanges?
Does that answer change if I prepare Tasha's Hideous Laughter at 1 and get it via the Great Old One Subclass at 3? In that case does a vacancy open up, but not in the feat scenario?
Or are feats by definition class-agnostic, so I have two independent sources of the Charm Person spell being prepared and two independent routes to cast it with slots? If I want to rectify that redundancy, I am required to utilize one of my designated 1/level exchanges?
It's this one. Spells that you get from a feat (or any source outside your class) don't have any impact on the spells you have prepared via your class. In this situation you'd probably want to use your 1/level swap to prepare a different spell.
Does that answer change if I prepare Tasha's Hideous Laughter at 1 and get it via the Great Old One Subclass at 3? In that case does a vacancy open up, but not in the feat scenario?
No, the answer is the same in this scenario.
In practice, if gaining a level results in you getting a bunch of spells that you already have, your DM might well let you swap out more than one, especially if you're new to the game.
Sorry if this is answered elsewhere, just looking for clarification.
Warlock's prepared spell list is per the column on the Warlock Feature table. A single spell can be swapped for another each level. If a "Warlock Feature" gives a spell that's always prepared, those "don't count" against the list number.
If I prepare Charm Person at first level, and then advance to level 4, I get Ability Score improvement or another feat of my choosing.
If I choose Fey Touched, or more specifically to the scenario in my mind, Treacherous Allure, either could give me Charm Person as "always prepared" and eligible to be cast with Pact Magic slots.
My question: Is gaining that feat my 4th level Warlock Class feature, and therefore the spell becomes a "Warlock Feature?" Does it therefore just drop out of the count and I have a vacancy on my list, not a swap I am making?
Or are feats by definition class-agnostic, so I have two independent sources of the Charm Person spell being prepared and two independent routes to cast it with slots? If I want to rectify that redundancy, I am required to utilize one of my designated 1/level exchanges?
Does that answer change if I prepare Tasha's Hideous Laughter at 1 and get it via the Great Old One Subclass at 3? In that case does a vacancy open up, but not in the feat scenario?
You have to retrain it in all cases so it would use your 1 spell per level swap.
It's this one. Spells that you get from a feat (or any source outside your class) don't have any impact on the spells you have prepared via your class. In this situation you'd probably want to use your 1/level swap to prepare a different spell.
No, the answer is the same in this scenario.
In practice, if gaining a level results in you getting a bunch of spells that you already have, your DM might well let you swap out more than one, especially if you're new to the game.
pronouns: he/she/they