so I've had the 5e Players Handbook and DM Guide for years, but for some reason never got the actual Monster Manual. I just got one, but it's the 5.5e version, is that still compatible or should I have found the old version?
There will be some differences to note. For example in 5e, lots of monsters would resist damage from nonmagical b/p/s damage. In 5.5, they removed the “nonmagical” part, so the monster just plain resist that damage. And there may be some odd rules interactions as 5.5 might refer to things like emanations, which didn’t exist in 5.0.
Its stuff you can probably work around fairly easily, but there’s likely to be a few friction points.
There will be some differences to note. For example in 5e, lots of monsters would resist damage from nonmagical b/p/s damage. In 5.5, they removed the “nonmagical” part, so the monster just plain resist that damage. And there may be some odd rules interactions as 5.5 might refer to things like emanations, which didn’t exist in 5.0.
Its stuff you can probably work around fairly easily, but there’s likely to be a few friction points.
But its also not difficult to adapt either, since you're just adding or subtracting common system rules. The changes to BSP resistance ultimately don't break any of the game work flows. And on the off chance a stat block is lifted from an adventure book, non-magical BSP resistance/immunity is baked into same paradigm as the PCs. And since its removed from the 5.5MM, thats just less contention when paired in that direction.
Plus 5.5e classes against older monster stat blocks is still a relatively minor issue, since a lot of BSP-bound class archetypes, like Monk, moved to Force damage; which also gets around that problem.
There will be some differences to note. For example in 5e, lots of monsters would resist damage from nonmagical b/p/s damage. In 5.5, they removed the “nonmagical” part, so the monster just plain resist that damage. And there may be some odd rules interactions as 5.5 might refer to things like emanations, which didn’t exist in 5.0.
Its stuff you can probably work around fairly easily, but there’s likely to be a few friction points.
But its also not difficult to adapt either, since you're just adding or subtracting common system rules. The changes to BSP resistance ultimately don't break any of the game work flows. And on the off chance a stat block is lifted from an adventure book, non-magical BSP resistance/immunity is baked into same paradigm as the PCs. And since its removed from the 5.5MM, thats just less contention when paired in that direction.
Plus 5.5e classes against older monster stat blocks is still a relatively minor issue, since a lot of BSP-bound class archetypes, like Monk, moved to Force damage; which also gets around that problem.
I think that's the point Xalthu is making though, the DM will have to be aware of things like that. If you're pitting a 5.5e monster against 5.0 characters, these sorts of differences will affect some characters more strongly than others. A 5.0 Monk will do full damage to most monsters with B/P/S resistance in 5.0 for example, but against a 5.5 monster their effectiveness will be sharply diminished unless you port in 5.5's Force damage on their attacks instead.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
so I've had the 5e Players Handbook and DM Guide for years, but for some reason never got the actual Monster Manual. I just got one, but it's the 5.5e version, is that still compatible or should I have found the old version?
Yeah, it's fine. The monsters are tuned up some, but 5e characters aren't that much weaker than 5.5.
There will be some differences to note. For example in 5e, lots of monsters would resist damage from nonmagical b/p/s damage. In 5.5, they removed the “nonmagical” part, so the monster just plain resist that damage.
And there may be some odd rules interactions as 5.5 might refer to things like emanations, which didn’t exist in 5.0.
Its stuff you can probably work around fairly easily, but there’s likely to be a few friction points.
But its also not difficult to adapt either, since you're just adding or subtracting common system rules. The changes to BSP resistance ultimately don't break any of the game work flows. And on the off chance a stat block is lifted from an adventure book, non-magical BSP resistance/immunity is baked into same paradigm as the PCs. And since its removed from the 5.5MM, thats just less contention when paired in that direction.
Plus 5.5e classes against older monster stat blocks is still a relatively minor issue, since a lot of BSP-bound class archetypes, like Monk, moved to Force damage; which also gets around that problem.
I think that's the point Xalthu is making though, the DM will have to be aware of things like that. If you're pitting a 5.5e monster against 5.0 characters, these sorts of differences will affect some characters more strongly than others. A 5.0 Monk will do full damage to most monsters with B/P/S resistance in 5.0 for example, but against a 5.5 monster their effectiveness will be sharply diminished unless you port in 5.5's Force damage on their attacks instead.