I took a quick peek at some of the Druid stuff in the new WoW book and personally - and in my opinion - I feel like Moon Druid (5.5e) got cheated.
Why? Because whether you're a Feral Specialist or Guardian Specialist, any time you Wildshape into the Cat or Bear (respectively), your WIS score overrides the STR/DEX Scores for the animal you Wildshape into, get to use your Spell Attack bonus for your Wildshape attack. The form's damage dice upscales as you level up. I am baffled that Moon Druids didn't get this feature at the start of 5.5e because they're a Druid subclass that uses more dangerous animals (CR 1 starting at level 3) and - in my opinion - should mechanically look like it.
I would understand that the damage dice wouldn't change or scale up, but why couldn't Moon Druids use their Spell Attack bonus for Wild Shape attacks??
Why did they do this to Moon Druids? (Help me understand)
Because when such forms were considered as part of the 5.5 playtest, they replaced ALL options for druids. People who got decent mileage out of small or odd forms hated it. Introducing the WoW stuff (which is directly out of the online game) is likely more popular because it is an addition rather than a replacement.
There were a lot of good ideas that got dropped in the playtest because they either went too far or had very bad execution.
From what I have seen of the WoW stuff, some is pretty good, some is pretty bad, and much is somewhere in between. The sweet spot is good enough for people to want to play but not the obviously "best" option.
No resemblance to the WoW spec, and pathetically weak compared to every other healer. Super disappointing.
I have to agree, basing a spellcaster on a class that can't cast spells when using it's primary class ability is, well, it's certainly A choice, but not one I can understand outside of a mandate to not use any D&D class twice. And the Shaman drew the short straw on that one.
I took a quick peek at some of the Druid stuff in the new WoW book and personally - and in my opinion - I feel like Moon Druid (5.5e) got cheated.
Why? Because whether you're a Feral Specialist or Guardian Specialist, any time you Wildshape into the Cat or Bear (respectively), your WIS score overrides the STR/DEX Scores for the animal you Wildshape into, get to use your Spell Attack bonus for your Wildshape attack. The form's damage dice upscales as you level up. I am baffled that Moon Druids didn't get this feature at the start of 5.5e because they're a Druid subclass that uses more dangerous animals (CR 1 starting at level 3) and - in my opinion - should mechanically look like it.
I would understand that the damage dice wouldn't change or scale up, but why couldn't Moon Druids use their Spell Attack bonus for Wild Shape attacks??
Why did they do this to Moon Druids? (Help me understand)
Were you around for the 5e24 playtest? Because that would answer your questions.
Short version is that they tried to do wild shape templates for the baseline moon druid, botched the implementation, and then either interpreted the negative feedback as people hating templates more broadly, or they simply ran out of time to iterate on them due to losing months of valuable playtesting time as a result of the OGL scandal. Either way the end result was the same, they retreated to using beast statblocks from the MM like the 5e14/5.0 version.
I'm just happy we have an official version of templates in druids going forward - first here, and likely later in that upcoming Kaiju druid which seems like it's being well-received. Better late than never.
People hated the templates on core Druid because it defeats the main point of wildshaping for everyone but Moon Druid or other combat shifters to only have three basic options. For everyone else, the point is to be able to pick the right creature for a given situation- spider for covert recon, burrowing speed creature for trying to dig someplace, etc. Even for Moon, the versatility of options is a major feature. There's no practical way to replicate that with templates without creating so many you might as well just pull from the MM instead. Templates work for Kaiju and WoW because those particular vibes are specifically about changing to fit a particular set of characteristics.
Not to mention that turning into a generic beast also leads to endless rules lawyering over the beast it's flavored as.
Just like what happens w/Beastmaster generic beasts. Had a player once that tried to argue his Beast of the Land, flavored as a Toad, had access to poison. Another tried to argue that her "Peregrine Falcon" Beast of the Air could pull off the IRL animal's speed feats.
There's no practical way to replicate that with templates without creating so many you might as well just pull from the MM instead.
I disagree; getting to use your Wisdom in place of your physical stats enables a very large number of concepts, especially since you also keep your proficiencies in Wild Shape (and may even gain additional ones.) A Cat Form Moon Druid for example might not be as stealthy baseline as the party rogue, but they're likely far better at it than other classes like cleric or sorcerer, and can readily play the role of party scout while also being in a lot less danger if they're caught alone than some other options for that role.
Not to mention that turning into a generic beast also leads to endless rules lawyering over the beast it's flavored as.
Just like what happens w/Beastmaster generic beasts. Had a player once that tried to argue his Beast of the Land, flavored as a Toad, had access to poison. Another tried to argue that her "Peregrine Falcon" Beast of the Air could pull off the IRL animal's speed feats.
Players who aren't interested in following the rules can try arguing whatever they want, but you have the statblock right in front of you. Any capabilities outside of that should not be slowing a reasonable game down, and those of us who find templates valuable should not be punished simply because unreasonable people exist.
No resemblance to the WoW spec, and pathetically weak compared to every other healer. Super disappointing.
I have to agree, basing a spellcaster on a class that can't cast spells when using it's primary class ability is, well, it's certainly A choice, but not one I can understand outside of a mandate to not use any D&D class twice. And the Shaman drew the short straw on that one.
Using Artificer for Resto and Elemental, and replacing the tech toys with equivalent totems, seems like it could have worked.
There's no practical way to replicate that with templates without creating so many you might as well just pull from the MM instead.
I disagree; getting to use your Wisdom in place of your physical stats enables a very large number of concepts, especially since you also keep your proficiencies in Wild Shape (and may even gain additional ones.) A Cat Form Moon Druid for example might not be as stealthy baseline as the party rogue, but they're likely far better at it than other classes like cleric or sorcerer, and can readily play the role of party scout while also being in a lot less danger if they're caught alone than some other options for that role
Okay, you've addressed a single particular niche. But once we add flying, tiny Stealth- since if we're talking WoW Moon here that cat is gonna be a bit big for skulking around a typical building without attracting attention- spider climbing, regular climging, burrowing, riding, swimming, swimming but able to move on land, etc. what's the point of trying to reinvent the wheel rather than just use the pre-existing Beast statblocks.
WIS mod being in the mix somewhere is a whole other matter, but the reason people hated most of the playtest attempts to consolidate stuff like familiars and wildshape into 1-3 blocks is because the appeal of those features is finding the option that sounds fun and/or fits with a particular playstyle image the player has.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I took a quick peek at some of the Druid stuff in the new WoW book and personally - and in my opinion - I feel like Moon Druid (5.5e) got cheated.
Why? Because whether you're a Feral Specialist or Guardian Specialist, any time you Wildshape into the Cat or Bear (respectively), your WIS score overrides the STR/DEX Scores for the animal you Wildshape into, get to use your Spell Attack bonus for your Wildshape attack. The form's damage dice upscales as you level up. I am baffled that Moon Druids didn't get this feature at the start of 5.5e because they're a Druid subclass that uses more dangerous animals (CR 1 starting at level 3) and - in my opinion - should mechanically look like it.
I would understand that the damage dice wouldn't change or scale up, but why couldn't Moon Druids use their Spell Attack bonus for Wild Shape attacks??
Why did they do this to Moon Druids? (Help me understand)
Because when such forms were considered as part of the 5.5 playtest, they replaced ALL options for druids. People who got decent mileage out of small or odd forms hated it. Introducing the WoW stuff (which is directly out of the online game) is likely more popular because it is an addition rather than a replacement.
There were a lot of good ideas that got dropped in the playtest because they either went too far or had very bad execution.
From what I have seen of the WoW stuff, some is pretty good, some is pretty bad, and much is somewhere in between. The sweet spot is good enough for people to want to play but not the obviously "best" option.
Restoration Shaman is just awful.
No resemblance to the WoW spec, and pathetically weak compared to every other healer. Super disappointing.
I have to agree, basing a spellcaster on a class that can't cast spells when using it's primary class ability is, well, it's certainly A choice, but not one I can understand outside of a mandate to not use any D&D class twice. And the Shaman drew the short straw on that one.
Were you around for the 5e24 playtest? Because that would answer your questions.
Short version is that they tried to do wild shape templates for the baseline moon druid, botched the implementation, and then either interpreted the negative feedback as people hating templates more broadly, or they simply ran out of time to iterate on them due to losing months of valuable playtesting time as a result of the OGL scandal. Either way the end result was the same, they retreated to using beast statblocks from the MM like the 5e14/5.0 version.
I'm just happy we have an official version of templates in druids going forward - first here, and likely later in that upcoming Kaiju druid which seems like it's being well-received. Better late than never.
People hated the templates on core Druid because it defeats the main point of wildshaping for everyone but Moon Druid or other combat shifters to only have three basic options. For everyone else, the point is to be able to pick the right creature for a given situation- spider for covert recon, burrowing speed creature for trying to dig someplace, etc. Even for Moon, the versatility of options is a major feature. There's no practical way to replicate that with templates without creating so many you might as well just pull from the MM instead. Templates work for Kaiju and WoW because those particular vibes are specifically about changing to fit a particular set of characteristics.
Not to mention that turning into a generic beast also leads to endless rules lawyering over the beast it's flavored as.
Just like what happens w/Beastmaster generic beasts. Had a player once that tried to argue his Beast of the Land, flavored as a Toad, had access to poison. Another tried to argue that her "Peregrine Falcon" Beast of the Air could pull off the IRL animal's speed feats.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
I disagree; getting to use your Wisdom in place of your physical stats enables a very large number of concepts, especially since you also keep your proficiencies in Wild Shape (and may even gain additional ones.) A Cat Form Moon Druid for example might not be as stealthy baseline as the party rogue, but they're likely far better at it than other classes like cleric or sorcerer, and can readily play the role of party scout while also being in a lot less danger if they're caught alone than some other options for that role.
Players who aren't interested in following the rules can try arguing whatever they want, but you have the statblock right in front of you. Any capabilities outside of that should not be slowing a reasonable game down, and those of us who find templates valuable should not be punished simply because unreasonable people exist.
Using Artificer for Resto and Elemental, and replacing the tech toys with equivalent totems, seems like it could have worked.
Okay, you've addressed a single particular niche. But once we add flying, tiny Stealth- since if we're talking WoW Moon here that cat is gonna be a bit big for skulking around a typical building without attracting attention- spider climbing, regular climging, burrowing, riding, swimming, swimming but able to move on land, etc. what's the point of trying to reinvent the wheel rather than just use the pre-existing Beast statblocks.
WIS mod being in the mix somewhere is a whole other matter, but the reason people hated most of the playtest attempts to consolidate stuff like familiars and wildshape into 1-3 blocks is because the appeal of those features is finding the option that sounds fun and/or fits with a particular playstyle image the player has.