By definition, a Solo boss fight is against one enemy/boss. However, in 5.5e, it always just seems a little underwhelming. Are these boss fights designs flawed or not?
They haven’t been in my experience. Without knowing your specific issues, it’s tough for me to make suggestions. But I can say in general over the years when this crops up, I’ve noticed two major issues. The first is terrain. Most of the time, these solo fights are going to be in the boss’s lair. They are going to design that lair to favor them and make use of their abilities.
The second big one (which really follows on to the first) is movement. Dragons really come to mind here. If the dragon just stands on the ground, the action surging fighter and smiting paladin are going to cut it to pieces. But a flying dragon, using its 15’ reach, is just going to leave melee classes throwing javelins. Or beyond flying, other movement speeds. Swimming, burrowing underground while it waits for its breath to recharge, that kind of thing. Which ties in to terrain, so a black dragon with its swim speed, will have a nice, deep body of water as part of the lair, as an example.
By definition, a Solo boss fight is against one enemy/boss. However, in 5.5e, it always just seems a little underwhelming. Are these boss fights designs flawed or not?
D&D 5.5e does not give you good tools for a solo boss fight -- the encounter building rules have serious scaling problems, even most legendary monsters are a bit bland, and the DM advice is lacking -- and solo fights in general are hard to make good, but it's possible to make an interesting solo boss fight, it just requires a lot of work by the DM with very little assistance from the rules.
Personally I LOVE making and running boss monsters... BUT: that being said: most of the mechanics I use to do that are my home-brewed stuff that dnd does not include by default. Movement is, as others have said; aa major problem in dnd combat already: you want a fight to feel dynamic; but 5e and 5.5e both encourage your combatants to just stick to one another because of the opportunity attack.
Some of those include: - Separate "movement", "pick targets" and "attack" points in the initiative order for the boss - Makes teh boss unique and adds a "ticking clock" element to teh rounds of combat. - Telegraph attack impact areas - Which forces players to move; pairs with the next one. - Major boost to both attack damage and health - Avoid players just nova-ing the boss with everythign they have and makes them actually worry about being hit instead of just deciding to tank the hit. - Minions -They don't ahve to be complex; but they force players to expend resources on something other than the boss - Phases - Obviously stolen from video games: but having a boss have 2 phases triggered by hittinga n amount of health adds both feedback and challenge to a boss fight.
All the tools the game, the website, and most adventures give you assume a party of 4 players. its not obvious, but at its core the issue is Action Economy and Bounded Accuracy; both of which look at long term averages.
So Solo fights, fundamentally, have to be tailored to the specific player, their habits, their chosen class options, their inventory, and the location you intend to use. Most DMs are going to fail with at least two of these, unless they have a lot of experience dealing with your own players. Even then, most parties can come up with some wild BS ideas that are, at the very least, plausible enough parts of the fight. So when designing, you need 2 or 3 things (at minimum) to pose a threat to the player, so they can shut it down and feel good about it. Try as much as possible to not rely on 1v1 trading blows, because thats where dice roll WILL make you lose control.
Less world of warcraft raid boss, and more Dark Souls boss arenas. Letting players be more precise with calling out their actions, letting them add narrative descriptors, tip the scales in their favor, dynamically adjusting behaviors on the fly. You don't have to tell them "no", but you also don't want to say "it doesn't do anything" either. Small win/advantages that they can't cheese, but looks like progress to them. Do that, and the more creative players will run with it. While the less creative players will probably try to find the shortest path to a win condition; and those are the ones you have to bounce more things off of.
If your party is not familiar with the mundane equipment list, you need to start finding ways to make those more enticing to carry around. Just having an Artificer in a party is going to force the DM to learn the 40% of the game rules that get ignored. So I encourage both DMs and Players to try running them as a guest spot or a one shot, just to discover how much a party can do with mundane gear and unassuming magic items.
List of Suggested Common magic items to just give a party to see what they do with; Earrings of Messaging, Walloping arrows, Redsmith Hammer, Cleaning Cube, Pole of Collapsing, Thermal Cube, cast off armor, shift weave, Ropecaster, catnip amulet, bottle of boundless coffee, eternal chalk, Heward's Spice pouch, drybrooch, grass carpet, mystery key, pot of awakening, tears of gaia, staff of flowers, sticky hand (obojima book), wand of pyrotechnics, seat belt, and wand of conducting, Sleepy time stuffy.
Suggested Uncommon magic items to consider. Nutmat's Trick Tubes (except in heist missions), Portable Cannon balls, Camper's Respite, Devils Detail Eyepatch, Decanter of Endless Water, Staff of Cubic Cultivation, Socks of Well rested, knocking boots, Gloves of storing (and be very aware of the bag of holding rules), Bloodhound Amulet, Alchemy Jug, Barricade Shield, Living Net, Ring of Water Walking, Ring of Barrels.
All the tools the game, the website, and most adventures give you assume a party of 4 players. its not obvious, but at its core the issue is Action Economy and Bounded Accuracy; both of which look at long term averages.
No, those really aren't the core issues. Most of the issues don't even have to do with D&D per se (building good solo encounters is inherently hard, particularly for turn-based games), and the specific D&D problem is mostly with encounter rules and monster designs.
Generally speaking the requirements for an interesting 'event' fight (whether or not it's a solo) are
Tension. The players should be at least somewhat worried about failing (which is not necessarily the same thing as losing).
Variety. You probably don't want to be doing the same thing every round (though that's up to the players), and you certainly don't want the monster(s) doing the same thing round after round. This tends to be an issue with solos -- you generally want a solo to have around three different major moves that it will actually want to use, and most D&D monsters don't have that (non-solo fights with a variety of enemies produce this naturally).
Meaningful decisions. There should be tactical choices to make, and it should not be utterly obvious which option is correct. Again, this is more of a problem with solo encounters than multi monster encounters, because things like "which enemy should I attack first" can be a meaningful decision in a multi-monster encounter.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
By definition, a Solo boss fight is against one enemy/boss. However, in 5.5e, it always just seems a little underwhelming. Are these boss fights designs flawed or not?
They haven’t been in my experience.
Without knowing your specific issues, it’s tough for me to make suggestions. But I can say in general over the years when this crops up, I’ve noticed two major issues.
The first is terrain. Most of the time, these solo fights are going to be in the boss’s lair. They are going to design that lair to favor them and make use of their abilities.
The second big one (which really follows on to the first) is movement. Dragons really come to mind here. If the dragon just stands on the ground, the action surging fighter and smiting paladin are going to cut it to pieces. But a flying dragon, using its 15’ reach, is just going to leave melee classes throwing javelins. Or beyond flying, other movement speeds. Swimming, burrowing underground while it waits for its breath to recharge, that kind of thing. Which ties in to terrain, so a black dragon with its swim speed, will have a nice, deep body of water as part of the lair, as an example.
D&D 5.5e does not give you good tools for a solo boss fight -- the encounter building rules have serious scaling problems, even most legendary monsters are a bit bland, and the DM advice is lacking -- and solo fights in general are hard to make good, but it's possible to make an interesting solo boss fight, it just requires a lot of work by the DM with very little assistance from the rules.
Personally I LOVE making and running boss monsters... BUT: that being said: most of the mechanics I use to do that are my home-brewed stuff that dnd does not include by default. Movement is, as others have said; aa major problem in dnd combat already: you want a fight to feel dynamic; but 5e and 5.5e both encourage your combatants to just stick to one another because of the opportunity attack.
Some of those include:
- Separate "movement", "pick targets" and "attack" points in the initiative order for the boss - Makes teh boss unique and adds a "ticking clock" element to teh rounds of combat.
- Telegraph attack impact areas - Which forces players to move; pairs with the next one.
- Major boost to both attack damage and health - Avoid players just nova-ing the boss with everythign they have and makes them actually worry about being hit instead of just deciding to tank the hit.
- Minions -They don't ahve to be complex; but they force players to expend resources on something other than the boss
- Phases - Obviously stolen from video games: but having a boss have 2 phases triggered by hittinga n amount of health adds both feedback and challenge to a boss fight.
All the tools the game, the website, and most adventures give you assume a party of 4 players. its not obvious, but at its core the issue is Action Economy and Bounded Accuracy; both of which look at long term averages.
So Solo fights, fundamentally, have to be tailored to the specific player, their habits, their chosen class options, their inventory, and the location you intend to use. Most DMs are going to fail with at least two of these, unless they have a lot of experience dealing with your own players. Even then, most parties can come up with some wild BS ideas that are, at the very least, plausible enough parts of the fight. So when designing, you need 2 or 3 things (at minimum) to pose a threat to the player, so they can shut it down and feel good about it. Try as much as possible to not rely on 1v1 trading blows, because thats where dice roll WILL make you lose control.
Less world of warcraft raid boss, and more Dark Souls boss arenas. Letting players be more precise with calling out their actions, letting them add narrative descriptors, tip the scales in their favor, dynamically adjusting behaviors on the fly. You don't have to tell them "no", but you also don't want to say "it doesn't do anything" either. Small win/advantages that they can't cheese, but looks like progress to them. Do that, and the more creative players will run with it. While the less creative players will probably try to find the shortest path to a win condition; and those are the ones you have to bounce more things off of.
If your party is not familiar with the mundane equipment list, you need to start finding ways to make those more enticing to carry around. Just having an Artificer in a party is going to force the DM to learn the 40% of the game rules that get ignored. So I encourage both DMs and Players to try running them as a guest spot or a one shot, just to discover how much a party can do with mundane gear and unassuming magic items.
List of Suggested Common magic items to just give a party to see what they do with; Earrings of Messaging, Walloping arrows, Redsmith Hammer, Cleaning Cube, Pole of Collapsing, Thermal Cube, cast off armor, shift weave, Ropecaster, catnip amulet, bottle of boundless coffee, eternal chalk, Heward's Spice pouch, drybrooch, grass carpet, mystery key, pot of awakening, tears of gaia, staff of flowers, sticky hand (obojima book), wand of pyrotechnics, seat belt, and wand of conducting, Sleepy time stuffy.
Suggested Uncommon magic items to consider. Nutmat's Trick Tubes (except in heist missions), Portable Cannon balls, Camper's Respite, Devils Detail Eyepatch, Decanter of Endless Water, Staff of Cubic Cultivation, Socks of Well rested, knocking boots, Gloves of storing (and be very aware of the bag of holding rules), Bloodhound Amulet, Alchemy Jug, Barricade Shield, Living Net, Ring of Water Walking, Ring of Barrels.
No, those really aren't the core issues. Most of the issues don't even have to do with D&D per se (building good solo encounters is inherently hard, particularly for turn-based games), and the specific D&D problem is mostly with encounter rules and monster designs.
Generally speaking the requirements for an interesting 'event' fight (whether or not it's a solo) are