This is a feat that initially got me very excited, as I've always liked fey touched. However, I haven't really found a way to make it work. Yes, there are some good second level spells, but that's not enough to justify spending a feat on it and also picking the relevant origin feat, especially when a different character can basically get the spell for free. That's part of what makes fey touched so nice, misty step is useful regardless of who else also has the spell.
Anyone have good experiences or interesting character concepts for this feat?
One of the best uses I have seen for it is on a Sorcerer - Find Familiar and Battle Familiar. This gives the Sorcerer a good summon-style spell which they usually don't have access to. It's one of the glaring differences between their spell list and other casters.
Other ideas I have considered:
Spike Growth on a Warlock with the Repelling Blast invocation to push enemies through the spikes using Eldritch Blast.
Pass Without Trace on an Arcane Trickster to become ridiculously stealthy with reliable talent and expertise.
Elminster's Elusion on pretty much anyone for a nice defensive spell against enemy casters.
Part of the issue is that the vast majority of feats within a given resource book are not designed with most other feats in mind, and tend to follow the premise of their setting. Same with backgrounds. Free Sword's Will is objectively the best feat in the game, and Chef is one of the worst.... but that's only if you compare the mechanics directly, and ignore the settings they are related to. This doesn't justify the difference in mechanical power, only that feats tend to make sense if you view them through narrative.
In fact..... a better example is the Artificer Spell list. Its the closest thing to a non-core class being mistaken for an official class, yet almost nothing outside of Eberron books supports it. Whenever an Artificer gets a spell added to its list from another resource book, I immediately wonder if it was a mistake. Wizard gets literal game breaking spells, even in context of their adventure settings, yet Artificer is hard pressed to get even one new spell despite being able to pull from every spell list.
I'm willing to bet if you black list most books not related to the setting you're in, a lot of the "bad" options start to feel like they do something. Do the same with the spell list, and Wizards stop overshadowing every other class in their own specialties.
Part of the issue is that the vast majority of feats within a given resource book are not designed with most other feats in mind, and tend to follow the premise of their setting. Same with backgrounds. Free Sword's Will is objectively the best feat in the game, and Chef is one of the worst.... but that's only if you compare the mechanics directly, and ignore the settings they are related to. This doesn't justify the difference in mechanical power, only that feats tend to make sense if you view them through narrative.
In fact..... a better example is the Artificer Spell list. Its the closest thing to a non-core class being mistaken for an official class, yet almost nothing outside of Eberron books supports it. Whenever an Artificer gets a spell added to its list from another resource book, I immediately wonder if it was a mistake. Wizard gets literal game breaking spells, even in context of their adventure settings, yet Artificer is hard pressed to get even one new spell despite being able to pull from every spell list.
I'm willing to bet if you black list most books not related to the setting you're in, a lot of the "bad" options start to feel like they do something. Do the same with the spell list, and Wizards stop overshadowing every other class in their own specialties.
Excellent points! Especially about removing books not related to the setting you're in - that would change a lot!
I sure hope they add more official Artificer-specific spells soon.
Part of the issue is that the vast majority of feats within a given resource book are not designed with most other feats in mind, and tend to follow the premise of their setting. Same with backgrounds. Free Sword's Will is objectively the best feat in the game, and Chef is one of the worst.... but that's only if you compare the mechanics directly, and ignore the settings they are related to. This doesn't justify the difference in mechanical power, only that feats tend to make sense if you view them through narrative.
In fact..... a better example is the Artificer Spell list. Its the closest thing to a non-core class being mistaken for an official class, yet almost nothing outside of Eberron books supports it. Whenever an Artificer gets a spell added to its list from another resource book, I immediately wonder if it was a mistake. Wizard gets literal game breaking spells, even in context of their adventure settings, yet Artificer is hard pressed to get even one new spell despite being able to pull from every spell list.
I'm willing to bet if you black list most books not related to the setting you're in, a lot of the "bad" options start to feel like they do something. Do the same with the spell list, and Wizards stop overshadowing every other class in their own specialties.
Back in the 3.5e days many games used a PHB +1 expansion book format for this reason. Good call, though I'm not sure I agree about how good Free Sword Mercenary's Will is.
This is a feat that initially got me very excited, as I've always liked fey touched. However, I haven't really found a way to make it work. Yes, there are some good second level spells, but that's not enough to justify spending a feat on it and also picking the relevant origin feat, especially when a different character can basically get the spell for free. That's part of what makes fey touched so nice, misty step is useful regardless of who else also has the spell.
Anyone have good experiences or interesting character concepts for this feat?
One of the best uses I have seen for it is on a Sorcerer - Find Familiar and Battle Familiar. This gives the Sorcerer a good summon-style spell which they usually don't have access to. It's one of the glaring differences between their spell list and other casters.
Other ideas I have considered:
Spike Growth on a Warlock with the Repelling Blast invocation to push enemies through the spikes using Eldritch Blast.
Pass Without Trace on an Arcane Trickster to become ridiculously stealthy with reliable talent and expertise.
Elminster's Elusion on pretty much anyone for a nice defensive spell against enemy casters.
Part of the issue is that the vast majority of feats within a given resource book are not designed with most other feats in mind, and tend to follow the premise of their setting. Same with backgrounds. Free Sword's Will is objectively the best feat in the game, and Chef is one of the worst.... but that's only if you compare the mechanics directly, and ignore the settings they are related to. This doesn't justify the difference in mechanical power, only that feats tend to make sense if you view them through narrative.
In fact..... a better example is the Artificer Spell list. Its the closest thing to a non-core class being mistaken for an official class, yet almost nothing outside of Eberron books supports it. Whenever an Artificer gets a spell added to its list from another resource book, I immediately wonder if it was a mistake. Wizard gets literal game breaking spells, even in context of their adventure settings, yet Artificer is hard pressed to get even one new spell despite being able to pull from every spell list.
I'm willing to bet if you black list most books not related to the setting you're in, a lot of the "bad" options start to feel like they do something. Do the same with the spell list, and Wizards stop overshadowing every other class in their own specialties.
Excellent points! Especially about removing books not related to the setting you're in - that would change a lot!
I sure hope they add more official Artificer-specific spells soon.
Back in the 3.5e days many games used a PHB +1 expansion book format for this reason. Good call, though I'm not sure I agree about how good Free Sword Mercenary's Will is.