Everything has been just fine while the items had been Private.
I shared them both with the community today. When I initially published everything, Rhunecel was in My Homebrew Creations and findable in the Homebrew Magic Item search, but Andunecel was missing from both.
My guess is that since I created them from the same root item, they're both considered versions of the same item and can't both be Shared at the same time.
So I made a copy of Rhunecel, rewrote it to be the "Andunecel" item, and then shared that.
The "Create New Version" feature allows you to do just that: Create a new version of a piece of homebrew. This is how you can update content that you've published when you make revisions.
If you're looking to create new content based on things you've done previously, you'll want to create a new item entirely, and select the thing you would like to base it on from the drop-down list that appears in the first creation screen.
I originally created a magic item that represented two swords. My player couldn't use that, so I "Created New Version" of the original item (private, but here's the link: https://www.dndbeyond.com/magic-items/601492-thorn-of-dawns-grace-thorn-of-dusks-embrace ) and made two new magic items that my player could add to their Equipment:
https://www.dndbeyond.com/magic-items/1518871-rhunecel-thorn-of-dawns-grace
&
https://www.dndbeyond.com/magic-items/1518894-andunecel-thorn-of-dusks-embrace
Everything has been just fine while the items had been Private.
I shared them both with the community today. When I initially published everything, Rhunecel was in My Homebrew Creations and findable in the Homebrew Magic Item search, but Andunecel was missing from both.
My guess is that since I created them from the same root item, they're both considered versions of the same item and can't both be Shared at the same time.
So I made a copy of Rhunecel, rewrote it to be the "Andunecel" item, and then shared that.
Except the missing item switched: Rhunecel is now missing, and Andunecel is back in My Homebrew Creations (and is also discoverable in the Homebrew Magic Item search).
I didn't want to keep recreating and resharing anything, since some of the rules about Homebrew say to not spam submissions.
Ideally, I end up with the latest version of each Shared, but I'm not sure how to get there from here.
Hello!
The "Create New Version" feature allows you to do just that: Create a new version of a piece of homebrew. This is how you can update content that you've published when you make revisions.
If you're looking to create new content based on things you've done previously, you'll want to create a new item entirely, and select the thing you would like to base it on from the drop-down list that appears in the first creation screen.
Thank you MellieDM.
Is there a way to flag something for removal myself because it's a duplicate?