I am a DM of 14 years. What I would like is a monster generator. I type my idea in a text field with my idea for a monster and it gives me a D&D Beyond generated monster character sheet based on that idea, but i can also prompt to make changes.
If this isnt possible I would like some sort of API where the monsters I do create can be instantly generated in D&D beyond format, without having to go through the laborious manual process of filling out the online template.
That's not possible. (Well, it sort of is with LLMs, but those are rather unpopular with the fanbase, and also I assume you want good monster design that works in the rules. But you can always try to get a chatbot to do it, and then copy the results over.)
What probably would be possible would be some kind of monster creation wizard (we know monster creation wizards are a thing, because the owlbear exists), where you give it your desired CR and a general type (caster, tank, etc) and it gives you a pre-filled template for you to customize.
It's something a third party could do, although with no official API, you'd have to copy over the info by hand into the homebrew form.
(Once they're done rebuilding the character backend, there's some hope that the homebrew tools will get an improvement, but they're not going to be what you're asking for.)
I think a monster generator like what jl8e is describing would be possible and very useful, but I fear it would be a bit too much work without a lot of profit for WOTC to want to invest in it.
OP, what you're describing would almost certainly have to be done with AI, and that's divisive enough in the community that I'm guessing the devs wouldn't want to touch that with a 10ft pole. There's been enough pushback against official artwork that has been perceived to have been made or edited with AI tools, so a full-on AI tool for this is probably a no-go.
Here would be my vision for the generator. There's already a lot of options for homebrew monsters in the official rules, in the way of actions, features, resistances, etc. What I imagine is you select from a list of options abilities for your creature (vulnerability to radiant damage, resistance to Piercing, bludgeoning, and slashing damage from non-magical weapons, the Amphibious trait, multiattack, the bite option with the swallow ability, etc). You select traits, actions, resistances and vulnerabilities, senses, saving throw proficiencies, spellcasting, etc. Then you add AC and HP, and it calculates your CR. Want a different CR? You can lower or raise the HP or the AC.
Then of course you could add or edit the abilities, but it warns you that CR calculation might be inaccurate when abilities are edited.
Is this possible? Probably! Cataloging the different traits, actions, etc would be very easy (though potentially time-consuming). Adding tags to the traits and actions so they are more easily found using filters or keywords would also be tricky and time consuming (although you probably could dump them all into a LLM and it would give you something serviceable where you would just need to review it and make some edits).
The hard part I think would be creating the CR calculator with this. Each trait would need some kind of modifier for how it interacted with the CR. Does it double the CR? reduce it by 12%? Etc. That is the part that I think would be the most challenging, especially with how some actions, traits, etc could work together to make something a lot stronger than it normally would be. But it is at least a though. Honestly, even without the CR calculator, I would love a generator with just a searchable list of all the actions and traits already made for official monsters. When I homebrew a monster that's usually where I start, and it can be frustrating just having to go through a bunch of different creatures searching for the type of trait I'm looking for.
Do not want. Exercising creativity is part of the fun of being a DM. It can be challenging but the productive challenge makes it more rewarding. There's nothing appealing about replacing all the challenge and reward of creative effort with yet another generative AI program. I don't even want to engage in cognitive surrender when it comes to the work I do for my job. I absolutely don't want to outsource thinking about how to do the hobby I love and enjoy spending time and effort on.
Just the ability to import JSON files and have the data converted over would be highly convenient, considering free sites like BestiaryBuilder or CritterDB are so much easier to work in.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Hi everyone. Hope you are all well.
I am a DM of 14 years. What I would like is a monster generator. I type my idea in a text field with my idea for a monster and it gives me a D&D Beyond generated monster character sheet based on that idea, but i can also prompt to make changes.
If this isnt possible I would like some sort of API where the monsters I do create can be instantly generated in D&D beyond format, without having to go through the laborious manual process of filling out the online template.
Appreciate everything y'all do.
Thank you!
That's not possible. (Well, it sort of is with LLMs, but those are rather unpopular with the fanbase, and also I assume you want good monster design that works in the rules. But you can always try to get a chatbot to do it, and then copy the results over.)
What probably would be possible would be some kind of monster creation wizard (we know monster creation wizards are a thing, because the owlbear exists), where you give it your desired CR and a general type (caster, tank, etc) and it gives you a pre-filled template for you to customize.
It's something a third party could do, although with no official API, you'd have to copy over the info by hand into the homebrew form.
(Once they're done rebuilding the character backend, there's some hope that the homebrew tools will get an improvement, but they're not going to be what you're asking for.)
I think a monster generator like what jl8e is describing would be possible and very useful, but I fear it would be a bit too much work without a lot of profit for WOTC to want to invest in it.
OP, what you're describing would almost certainly have to be done with AI, and that's divisive enough in the community that I'm guessing the devs wouldn't want to touch that with a 10ft pole. There's been enough pushback against official artwork that has been perceived to have been made or edited with AI tools, so a full-on AI tool for this is probably a no-go.
Here would be my vision for the generator. There's already a lot of options for homebrew monsters in the official rules, in the way of actions, features, resistances, etc. What I imagine is you select from a list of options abilities for your creature (vulnerability to radiant damage, resistance to Piercing, bludgeoning, and slashing damage from non-magical weapons, the Amphibious trait, multiattack, the bite option with the swallow ability, etc). You select traits, actions, resistances and vulnerabilities, senses, saving throw proficiencies, spellcasting, etc. Then you add AC and HP, and it calculates your CR. Want a different CR? You can lower or raise the HP or the AC.
Then of course you could add or edit the abilities, but it warns you that CR calculation might be inaccurate when abilities are edited.
Is this possible? Probably! Cataloging the different traits, actions, etc would be very easy (though potentially time-consuming). Adding tags to the traits and actions so they are more easily found using filters or keywords would also be tricky and time consuming (although you probably could dump them all into a LLM and it would give you something serviceable where you would just need to review it and make some edits).
The hard part I think would be creating the CR calculator with this. Each trait would need some kind of modifier for how it interacted with the CR. Does it double the CR? reduce it by 12%? Etc. That is the part that I think would be the most challenging, especially with how some actions, traits, etc could work together to make something a lot stronger than it normally would be. But it is at least a though. Honestly, even without the CR calculator, I would love a generator with just a searchable list of all the actions and traits already made for official monsters. When I homebrew a monster that's usually where I start, and it can be frustrating just having to go through a bunch of different creatures searching for the type of trait I'm looking for.
Do not want. Exercising creativity is part of the fun of being a DM. It can be challenging but the productive challenge makes it more rewarding. There's nothing appealing about replacing all the challenge and reward of creative effort with yet another generative AI program. I don't even want to engage in cognitive surrender when it comes to the work I do for my job. I absolutely don't want to outsource thinking about how to do the hobby I love and enjoy spending time and effort on.
Just the ability to import JSON files and have the data converted over would be highly convenient, considering free sites like BestiaryBuilder or CritterDB are so much easier to work in.