I should point out there is no such thing as AI art, there is AI images, not art.
Art is described as an emotion, a perspective, a feeling transcribed into a medium, a form, a picture, or a sound. AI uses maths and programming along side data to generate a likeness of the data based on inputs and available data. AI can not make art as AI does not have emotions.
I mean, I don't think Damien Hirst's polka dot... products should be called "art" either, but the world seems to use a much looser definition of the term
Its worth nothing that, historically, trying to assign hard definitions of what "is or isn't" art was often a stepping stone to infer the creations of a certain culture to be inferior, and that the superior art of the super culture is proof they are justified in doing a thing to that other group. The AI discourse has not been shy about this either.
That's not what's going on in the case of guys like Hirst, Jeff Koons etc. They just learned the wrong lessons from Warhol
I suppose you could argue they've turned commodification into an art form, but their work by and large is just empty. Any emotion someone happens to feel viewing it is purely coincidental, and beside the point
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Active characters:
Edoumiaond Willegume "Eddie" Podslee, Vegetanian scholar (College of Spirits bard) Lan Kidogo, mapach archaeologist and treasure hunter (Knowledge cleric) Peter "the Pied Piper" Hausler, human con artist/remover of vermin (Circle of the Shepherd druid) PIPA - Planar Interception/Protection Aeormaton, warforged bodyguard and ex-wizard hunter (Warrior of the Elements monk/Cartographer artificer) Xhekhetiel, halfling survivor of a Betrayer Gods cult (Runechild sorcerer/fighter)
I mean, we can throw out the word objective because this is all about feelings and subjective values.
GenAI can at best only approximate what you're imagining in your head based on your prompts. You can keep refining it with repeated prompts, but all it knows how to do is steal from other artists' work and imitate their styles. Something in the style, proportions, details, etc., is going to fall short of the mental image and the person doing the prompting will have to settle for some version of "good enough." In the most optimistic case it can only attempt to do the same as commissioning a human artist who can get close to what you're picturing in your head but never perfectly reproduce your mental image. We have to settle for "almost exactly right" no matter what since perfect reproduction of the DM's mental image is off the table.
I'll take messy, amateur art as more immersive than well composed slop. I'd rather have a verbal description than slop, because then at least I can form my own mental picture.
I think that rather than "objective," the term Caerwyn meant here was "equanimous." He's trying to put aside his personal distaste for GenAI (which I think most folks here share) and answer in an emotionally neutral way the originally posed question of why, despite the clear and numerous negatives that accompany it, the technology continues to be adopted in creative contexts, including gaming.
I'm currently playing WoW Forever, which released a little over a week ago as of this writing. One add-on that many players (not me - I'm going completely add-on free for my playthrough) have downloaded for it in that brief span of time is called "Spoken"; it uses GenAI to voice every one of the millions of lines of quest dialogue in the game, along with other in-game text sources like lore books and signs, in a way that previous text-to-speech tech couldn't match. These include applying unique inflections that attempt to match the species, class, gender, emotional state, and other attributes of the NPC speaking to the player, and even creating variation within those sets such that for example, not every male dwarf warrior NPC sounds the same as every other.. This is an addon that in no way adds anything to the game that is necessary to play it - I'm willing to bet the vast majority of WoW players skip quest text entirely beyond the parts they need in order to know what they're doing - and yet, in the span of a mere few days, the addon has been downloaded over 3 million times and counting. Whether that's due to a belief that the AI-voiced lines do in fact add to the immersion of those using it or simple curiosity, the data on the addon's adoption is publicly available for anyone to look at.
Me pointing that out is in no way an endorsement or positive reaction to GenAI. But I do think that in some circles, any commentary on the tech that isn't vociferous repudiation, even something as bland as citing a statistic, is viewed as support when that isn't the case.
I hope our OP has found an agreeable AI-free table that meets their needs. They are absolutely out there. I am seeing more DMs call out their policy for such things when advertising a game.
I think too that there's a lot of value in... handmade images. Even if they're not pristine. Making it badly is how you get better, and the charm of something a little quirky is honestly fine.
I have played with GMs who make beautiful maps and tokens, and yes that's fun. I've also played with a GM who makes all their maps as just colored shapes with scrawled labels full of puns. This is hilarious and just as functional.
Your token can just be a colored dot, as long as it's not the same color as someone else's dot. It can be a photograph of a stick figure you drew in pencil. It can be very abstract. You can use one of those avatar generators that just swaps in different face features. You can use heroforge. I love quirky and bespoke personal art, it's just way more fun to feel the effort and human behind it.
As for words, I pretty much always hate AI-generated text. I'd rather you use your own imperfect words. The one thing LLMs are good for is transcripts, if you feel the need for them. But then it's clearly a transcript, a mechanical rendition of what was said in session.
Anyway, AI or not AI, it's a choice, and I do get a little salty when someone suggest they just can't live without it.
Me pointing that out is in no way an endorsement or positive reaction to GenAI. But I do think that in some circles, any commentary on the tech that isn't vociferous repudiation, even something as bland as citing a statistic, is viewed as support when that isn't the case.
I am at the front of the resistence against generative AI and espically the Tech industries big push for it. I switched to Linux, I refuse to update my phone, and my next phone will be a Linux phone, I refuse to support the use of AI to replace humans. This said, I have vision issues, and have used Text to speech since 1997. And the improvements to it since learning algorithms have made me want an addon just like that one. And I think the future use of AI could be benifical if the nations of the world could stop this generation of CEOs, their thief, and abuse of people and the enviroment.
Also I play on RP Blue Side NA, an Elf Mage and Gnome Warlock are my mains. I also play "normal" on Fridays and have jouned 'The Unbound' guild.
Me pointing that out is in no way an endorsement or positive reaction to GenAI. But I do think that in some circles, any commentary on the tech that isn't vociferous repudiation, even something as bland as citing a statistic, is viewed as support when that isn't the case.
I am at the front of the resistence against generative AI and espically the Tech industries big push for it. I switched to Linux, I refuse to update my phone, and my next phone will be a Linux phone, I refuse to support the use of AI to replace humans. This said, I have vision issues, and have used Text to speech since 1997. And the improvements to it since learning algorithms have made me want an addon just like that one. And I think the future use of AI could be benifical if the nations of the world could stop this generation of CEOs, their thief, and abuse of people and the enviroment.
Also I play on RP Blue Side NA, an Elf Mage and Gnome Warlock are my mains. I also play "normal" on Fridays and have jouned 'The Unbound' guild.
I certainly respect your convictions, but keep in mind there is a fair amount of privilege inherent to a stance such as this.
I have a hybrid remote/office job; to connect to my employer's VPN, I am required to keep my phone (which must be iOS or Android) current with the latest OTA updates from my carrier. So even if I had the time or inclination to teach myself Linux as a means of opting out of mainstream technology platforms that are becoming increasingly intertwined with AI, my hands would still be tied. And that's without considering the direct usage of such platforms being mandated and measured by said employer too.
As for the addon itself - while you're totally right that it has very strong accessibility use cases, at the end of the day it still gives a company a much cheaper alternative to hiring voice actors while still maintaining a degree of immersion that is - apparently - compelling to a lot of people. I don't realistically believe that Blizzard had any intention of voicing all their quest dialogue the old-fashioned way - one of the benefits to being the top dog is that you don't need such a differentiator to get people to engage with your game - so any jobs this app is taking likely never existed in the first place... but several of their competitors like ESO do have fully voiced quests, and I have no doubt that they're watching the reception of AI use cases like this with great interest. And it's not that far a leap from voicing NPC quest dialogue in an MMO to voicing NPC quest dialogue in a tabletop module either.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
That's not what's going on in the case of guys like Hirst, Jeff Koons etc. They just learned the wrong lessons from Warhol
I suppose you could argue they've turned commodification into an art form, but their work by and large is just empty. Any emotion someone happens to feel viewing it is purely coincidental, and beside the point
Active characters:
Edoumiaond Willegume "Eddie" Podslee, Vegetanian scholar (College of Spirits bard)
Lan Kidogo, mapach archaeologist and treasure hunter (Knowledge cleric)
Peter "the Pied Piper" Hausler, human con artist/remover of vermin (Circle of the Shepherd druid)
PIPA - Planar Interception/Protection Aeormaton, warforged bodyguard and ex-wizard hunter (Warrior of the Elements monk/Cartographer artificer)
Xhekhetiel, halfling survivor of a Betrayer Gods cult (Runechild sorcerer/fighter)
I think that rather than "objective," the term Caerwyn meant here was "equanimous." He's trying to put aside his personal distaste for GenAI (which I think most folks here share) and answer in an emotionally neutral way the originally posed question of why, despite the clear and numerous negatives that accompany it, the technology continues to be adopted in creative contexts, including gaming.
I'm currently playing WoW Forever, which released a little over a week ago as of this writing. One add-on that many players (not me - I'm going completely add-on free for my playthrough) have downloaded for it in that brief span of time is called "Spoken"; it uses GenAI to voice every one of the millions of lines of quest dialogue in the game, along with other in-game text sources like lore books and signs, in a way that previous text-to-speech tech couldn't match. These include applying unique inflections that attempt to match the species, class, gender, emotional state, and other attributes of the NPC speaking to the player, and even creating variation within those sets such that for example, not every male dwarf warrior NPC sounds the same as every other.. This is an addon that in no way adds anything to the game that is necessary to play it - I'm willing to bet the vast majority of WoW players skip quest text entirely beyond the parts they need in order to know what they're doing - and yet, in the span of a mere few days, the addon has been downloaded over 3 million times and counting. Whether that's due to a belief that the AI-voiced lines do in fact add to the immersion of those using it or simple curiosity, the data on the addon's adoption is publicly available for anyone to look at.
Me pointing that out is in no way an endorsement or positive reaction to GenAI. But I do think that in some circles, any commentary on the tech that isn't vociferous repudiation, even something as bland as citing a statistic, is viewed as support when that isn't the case.
I hope our OP has found an agreeable AI-free table that meets their needs. They are absolutely out there. I am seeing more DMs call out their policy for such things when advertising a game.
I think too that there's a lot of value in... handmade images. Even if they're not pristine. Making it badly is how you get better, and the charm of something a little quirky is honestly fine.
I have played with GMs who make beautiful maps and tokens, and yes that's fun. I've also played with a GM who makes all their maps as just colored shapes with scrawled labels full of puns. This is hilarious and just as functional.
Your token can just be a colored dot, as long as it's not the same color as someone else's dot. It can be a photograph of a stick figure you drew in pencil. It can be very abstract. You can use one of those avatar generators that just swaps in different face features. You can use heroforge. I love quirky and bespoke personal art, it's just way more fun to feel the effort and human behind it.
As for words, I pretty much always hate AI-generated text. I'd rather you use your own imperfect words. The one thing LLMs are good for is transcripts, if you feel the need for them. But then it's clearly a transcript, a mechanical rendition of what was said in session.
Anyway, AI or not AI, it's a choice, and I do get a little salty when someone suggest they just can't live without it.
I am at the front of the resistence against generative AI and espically the Tech industries big push for it. I switched to Linux, I refuse to update my phone, and my next phone will be a Linux phone, I refuse to support the use of AI to replace humans. This said, I have vision issues, and have used Text to speech since 1997. And the improvements to it since learning algorithms have made me want an addon just like that one. And I think the future use of AI could be benifical if the nations of the world could stop this generation of CEOs, their thief, and abuse of people and the enviroment.
Also I play on RP Blue Side NA, an Elf Mage and Gnome Warlock are my mains. I also play "normal" on Fridays and have jouned 'The Unbound' guild.
I certainly respect your convictions, but keep in mind there is a fair amount of privilege inherent to a stance such as this.
I have a hybrid remote/office job; to connect to my employer's VPN, I am required to keep my phone (which must be iOS or Android) current with the latest OTA updates from my carrier. So even if I had the time or inclination to teach myself Linux as a means of opting out of mainstream technology platforms that are becoming increasingly intertwined with AI, my hands would still be tied. And that's without considering the direct usage of such platforms being mandated and measured by said employer too.
As for the addon itself - while you're totally right that it has very strong accessibility use cases, at the end of the day it still gives a company a much cheaper alternative to hiring voice actors while still maintaining a degree of immersion that is - apparently - compelling to a lot of people. I don't realistically believe that Blizzard had any intention of voicing all their quest dialogue the old-fashioned way - one of the benefits to being the top dog is that you don't need such a differentiator to get people to engage with your game - so any jobs this app is taking likely never existed in the first place... but several of their competitors like ESO do have fully voiced quests, and I have no doubt that they're watching the reception of AI use cases like this with great interest. And it's not that far a leap from voicing NPC quest dialogue in an MMO to voicing NPC quest dialogue in a tabletop module either.