When a person objects to AI use, they are usually of the opinion that this other person is disrespecting them by not displaying a greater understanding of the content than they are.
This is...really not the main problem people have with AI use.
I think what the anti-AI debate boils down to is the following: does the author have a full understanding of what he calls his own work? Think this through. When we look at something and say "that is obviously AI generated," we can tell that because the person is reading stunted words, or presenting images that aren't precisely in line with the described concepts, and so on. When a person objects to AI use, they are usually of the opinion that this other person is disrespecting them by not displaying a greater understanding of the content than they are.
I suspect that every single person who is reading this post sees that it was not AI generated because it displays that I've thought about the issue and understand it, whether you agree with what I say or not. The post lacks the subtle omissions and slightly-off context that AI-generated content displays.
Besides being 100% AI slop, with a AI slop picture for a User Profile. No your LLM did not give you anything similar to a correct answer. The major issues with LLMs are as follows:
1: Thieft by corprate entities to maximize profits.
2: Enviromental impact.
3: Hogging of personal computing power.
4: CEOs are universally the most vile humans on Earth.
5: Generative Algorithms not being art, and failing to have emotions behind them.
Anyone who uses AI in anyway for anything D&D related should be shunned from the TTRPG community.
I've been working on a campaign book for some time and have been trying to figure out where to use AI. I could not create an entire campaign without some use of it.
Why?
Many, many, people have created campaign books without any assistance from LLMs. Indeed, due to the flaws and limitations of LLMs, it's probably easier to not use it if you want to produce a good work.
I created an account just to post about this.
While I'm asking why: why? Do you need us to bless your LLM usage?
I think what the anti-AI debate boils down to is the following: does the author have a full understanding of what he calls his own work? Think this through. When we look at something and say "that is obviously AI generated," we can tell that because the person is reading stunted words, or presenting images that aren't precisely in line with the described concepts, and so on. When a person objects to AI use, they are usually of the opinion that this other person is disrespecting them by not displaying a greater understanding of the content than they are.
I suspect that every single person who is reading this post sees that it was not AI generated because it displays that I've thought about the issue and understand it, whether you agree with what I say or not. The post lacks the subtle omissions and slightly-off context that AI-generated content displays.
Besides being 100% AI slop, with a AI slop picture for a User Profile. No your LLM did not give you anything similar to a correct answer. The major issues with LLMs are as follows:
1: Thieft by corprate entities to maximize profits.
2: Enviromental impact.
3: Hogging of personal computing power.
4: CEOs are universally the most vile humans on Earth.
5: Generative Algorithms not being art, and failing to have emotions behind them.
Anyone who uses AI in anyway for anything D&D related should be shunned from the TTRPG community.
why can't people just steal art off the internet like they used to?
me stealing a picture from the Warhammer Store page vs a company making profits from stealing an image from a starving artist, there is a differance.
Yeah, the difference is the company will typically get away with it or only be charged a fine whereas the individual will likely face prison.
Yeah, no.
Grabbing an individual image for private purposes would be a civil violation at most, and, at least in the US, likely be fair use. (Whether it's ethical is a different question.) It would also never be noticed, and, were it noticed, the first step would be a cease and desist or a DMCA report to one's internet service.
While criminal copyright violation is a thing, that ain't it. I'm not even sure the LLM companies hoovering up everything on the internet qualifies. IIRC the criminal copyright laws were written for things like mass DVD counterfeiting. (But I am in no way an expert.)
Tell that to Nintendo. I mean I love Nintendo don't get me wrong, but they've ruined people's lives over posting fan art or copying their art before. I am sure with a lawyer one could get off with fair use but let's be real who here has the money for that?
I've threatened to sue over stolen music before. The label dropped the band and pulled their album offering me a small sum I used to move to Sweden for a bit. The song got radio play for like all of a day on a country and western station (The Ranch in the Texas Metroplex) and they played it at Austin City Limits as they were about to be the next big thing getting signed in Nashville, but my actions also shot me in the foot because everyone loved my song and were absolutely pissed when I forced it off the air. My voice just wasn't there at the time to sing it, and I didn't really mind them performing the song, but I wrote it years before I was in that band. The thing is I didn't even ask the band who stole it for money. I did session work for them in the past and they hired me for a tour. I just wanted the credit in the liner notes, and they wanted to go to court to try to keep it. The label didn't want to do all that, so they canned the band and then they wanted to sue me over it but never got a lawyer to pick up the case because I still have the copyright. Man, I pissed a lot of people off back then by being the talent in the room. It is the worst luck to have being a bassist who has talent because "Primus sucks" as the slogan goes. No one wants to hear us they just want our music.
Granted these are different situations from stealing art to use at home in a campaign, and I've taught that song to several bands only asking they tell people I wrote it and not asking for any money; but my music business is a business and stealing art from a business to use for your own profit making is a serious matter that courts will respond to.
why can't people just steal art off the internet like they used to?
me stealing a picture from the Warhammer Store page vs a company making profits from stealing an image from a starving artist, there is a differance.
Yeah, the difference is the company will typically get away with it or only be charged a fine whereas the individual will likely face prison.
Yeah, no.
Grabbing an individual image for private purposes would be a civil violation at most, and, at least in the US, likely be fair use. (Whether it's ethical is a different question.) It would also never be noticed, and, were it noticed, the first step would be a cease and desist or a DMCA report to one's internet service.
While criminal copyright violation is a thing, that ain't it. I'm not even sure the LLM companies hoovering up everything on the internet qualifies. IIRC the criminal copyright laws were written for things like mass DVD counterfeiting. (But I am in no way an expert.)
Tell that to Nintendo. I mean I love Nintendo don't get me wrong, but they've ruined people's lives over posting fan art or copying their art before. I am sure with a lawyer one could get off with fair use but let's be real who here has the money for that?
I've threatened to sue over stolen music before. The label dropped the band and pulled their album offering me a small sum I used to move to Sweden for a bit. The song got radio play for like all of a day on a country and western station (The Ranch in the Texas Metroplex) and they played it at Austin City Limits as they were about to be the next big thing getting signed in Nashville, but my actions also shot me in the foot because everyone loved my song and were absolutely pissed when I forced it off the air. My voice just wasn't there at the time to sing it, and I didn't really mind them performing the song, but I wrote it years before I was in that band. The thing is I didn't even ask the band who stole it for money. I did session work for them in the past and they hired me for a tour. I just wanted the credit in the liner notes, and they wanted to go to court to try to keep it. The label didn't want to do all that, so they canned the band and then they wanted to sue me over it but never got a lawyer to pick up the case because I still have the copyright. Man, I pissed a lot of people off back then by being the talent in the room. It is the worst luck to have being a bassist who has talent because "Primus sucks" as the slogan goes. No one wants to hear us they just want our music.
Granted these are different situations from stealing art to use at home in a campaign, and I've taught that song to several bands only asking they tell people I wrote it and not asking for any money; but my music business is a business and stealing art from a business to use for your own profit making is a serious matter that courts will respond to.
Nintendo doesn't sue people over Surprised Pikachu, they sue for mods to games, making PC emulators, and other things which makes them look bad. But a meme in a social media post is not going to cause them to send lawyers. Now if you own a Pizza place in Sweden and put that meme on your sign that's when the lawyers are called.
The idea of fair use means that you are not damaging their product or profits or causing confusion to offical products and locations.
why can't people just steal art off the internet like they used to?
me stealing a picture from the Warhammer Store page vs a company making profits from stealing an image from a starving artist, there is a differance.
Yeah, the difference is the company will typically get away with it or only be charged a fine whereas the individual will likely face prison.
Yeah, no.
Grabbing an individual image for private purposes would be a civil violation at most, and, at least in the US, likely be fair use. (Whether it's ethical is a different question.) It would also never be noticed, and, were it noticed, the first step would be a cease and desist or a DMCA report to one's internet service.
While criminal copyright violation is a thing, that ain't it. I'm not even sure the LLM companies hoovering up everything on the internet qualifies. IIRC the criminal copyright laws were written for things like mass DVD counterfeiting. (But I am in no way an expert.)
Tell that to Nintendo. I mean I love Nintendo don't get me wrong, but they've ruined people's lives over posting fan art or copying their art before. I am sure with a lawyer one could get off with fair use but let's be real who here has the money for that?
I've threatened to sue over stolen music before. The label dropped the band and pulled their album offering me a small sum I used to move to Sweden for a bit. The song got radio play for like all of a day on a country and western station (The Ranch in the Texas Metroplex) and they played it at Austin City Limits as they were about to be the next big thing getting signed in Nashville, but my actions also shot me in the foot because everyone loved my song and were absolutely pissed when I forced it off the air. My voice just wasn't there at the time to sing it, and I didn't really mind them performing the song, but I wrote it years before I was in that band. The thing is I didn't even ask the band who stole it for money. I did session work for them in the past and they hired me for a tour. I just wanted the credit in the liner notes, and they wanted to go to court to try to keep it. The label didn't want to do all that, so they canned the band and then they wanted to sue me over it but never got a lawyer to pick up the case because I still have the copyright. Man, I pissed a lot of people off back then by being the talent in the room. It is the worst luck to have being a bassist who has talent because "Primus sucks" as the slogan goes. No one wants to hear us they just want our music.
Granted these are different situations from stealing art to use at home in a campaign, and I've taught that song to several bands only asking they tell people I wrote it and not asking for any money; but my music business is a business and stealing art from a business to use for your own profit making is a serious matter that courts will respond to.
Nintendo doesn't sue people over Surprised Pikachu, they sue for mods to games, making PC emulators, and other things which makes them look bad. But a meme in a social media post is not going to cause them to send lawyers. Now if you own a Pizza place in Sweden and put that meme on your sign that's when the lawyers are called.
The idea of fair use means that you are not damaging their product or profits or causing confusion to offical products and locations.
Fair, they have sued over fan art but it was NSFW art on prawn sites.
The idea of fair use means that you are not damaging their product or profits or causing confusion to offical products and locations.
Well, not exactly. Fair use allows "criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research". Grabbing images off of the internet and using it for your private campaign is most likely not fair use, just nearly impossible to actually do anything about.
The idea of fair use means that you are not damaging their product or profits or causing confusion to offical products and locations.
Well, not exactly. Fair use allows "criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research". Grabbing images off of the internet and using it for your private campaign is most likely not fair use, just nearly impossible to actually do anything about.
the exact term is "stifling the very creativity which [copyright] law is designed to foster."
This is...really not the main problem people have with AI use.
pronouns: he/she/they
Besides being 100% AI slop, with a AI slop picture for a User Profile. No your LLM did not give you anything similar to a correct answer. The major issues with LLMs are as follows:
1: Thieft by corprate entities to maximize profits.
2: Enviromental impact.
3: Hogging of personal computing power.
4: CEOs are universally the most vile humans on Earth.
5: Generative Algorithms not being art, and failing to have emotions behind them.
Anyone who uses AI in anyway for anything D&D related should be shunned from the TTRPG community.
Why?
Many, many, people have created campaign books without any assistance from LLMs. Indeed, due to the flaws and limitations of LLMs, it's probably easier to not use it if you want to produce a good work.
While I'm asking why: why? Do you need us to bless your LLM usage?
*Anyone who uses Ai in anyway for any ttrpg
signature loading...
Tell that to Nintendo. I mean I love Nintendo don't get me wrong, but they've ruined people's lives over posting fan art or copying their art before. I am sure with a lawyer one could get off with fair use but let's be real who here has the money for that?
I've threatened to sue over stolen music before. The label dropped the band and pulled their album offering me a small sum I used to move to Sweden for a bit. The song got radio play for like all of a day on a country and western station (The Ranch in the Texas Metroplex) and they played it at Austin City Limits as they were about to be the next big thing getting signed in Nashville, but my actions also shot me in the foot because everyone loved my song and were absolutely pissed when I forced it off the air. My voice just wasn't there at the time to sing it, and I didn't really mind them performing the song, but I wrote it years before I was in that band. The thing is I didn't even ask the band who stole it for money. I did session work for them in the past and they hired me for a tour. I just wanted the credit in the liner notes, and they wanted to go to court to try to keep it. The label didn't want to do all that, so they canned the band and then they wanted to sue me over it but never got a lawyer to pick up the case because I still have the copyright. Man, I pissed a lot of people off back then by being the talent in the room. It is the worst luck to have being a bassist who has talent because "Primus sucks" as the slogan goes. No one wants to hear us they just want our music.
Granted these are different situations from stealing art to use at home in a campaign, and I've taught that song to several bands only asking they tell people I wrote it and not asking for any money; but my music business is a business and stealing art from a business to use for your own profit making is a serious matter that courts will respond to.
"Life is Cast by Random Dice"
Burn my candle twice.
I have done my life justice
Against random dice.
Nintendo doesn't sue people over Surprised Pikachu, they sue for mods to games, making PC emulators, and other things which makes them look bad. But a meme in a social media post is not going to cause them to send lawyers. Now if you own a Pizza place in Sweden and put that meme on your sign that's when the lawyers are called.
The idea of fair use means that you are not damaging their product or profits or causing confusion to offical products and locations.
Fair, they have sued over fan art but it was NSFW art on prawn sites.
"Life is Cast by Random Dice"
Burn my candle twice.
I have done my life justice
Against random dice.
Well, not exactly. Fair use allows "criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research". Grabbing images off of the internet and using it for your private campaign is most likely not fair use, just nearly impossible to actually do anything about.
the exact term is "stifling the very creativity which [copyright] law is designed to foster."