So I just read Flee, Mortals! By MCDM, and the monster designs were very interesting. Maybe even better designed than the official MM? I'd be curious if anyone else had the book and what their experiences of it were.
I do not think there is any question that Flee Mortals! is better monster design than 5e and, thus far, 5.5e. Minions fix a necessary missing element of D&D by allowing for mass combat. The categories of monster, like Lurker and such, make sorting and finding the type of monster you need much, much easier than the utter lack of meaningful categories in the MM and other core content. A focus on abilities that are interesting, instead of the fairly generic monsters dominated by “BPS multi attack” also leads to more dynamic encounters.
But the amusing part of all of that? Those are all WotC design elements at heart. Everything good about Flee Mortals! was directly lifted from 4th Edition D&D, though minions were improved and expanded on to better fit 5e design. In Wizards quest to distance itself from 4e, Wizards simply avoided 4e design all together, instead of learning from what elements did work. Flee Mortals! does exactly what WotC should have done from the start - directly copy the elements of 4e that worked perfectly and improve on those that were great ideas but needed a bit of additional work.
No, I personally don't think it's better monster design. It's just, largely speaking, a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined with Colville's propensity to make bespoke sub-systems for everything that takes his fancy. Sidekicks get a system, pets get system, minions get a system! Everybody gets a system. Even his boss type monsters get a clunky "on turn one they do this, on turn two they do that" style system. I personally find it inelegant and obtuse, and clunky at the table.
I'm generally not a fan of MCDM design because I don't think it's well informed design. For example, when Colville made the illrigger, he gave the class it's own unique fighting styles because he didn't know that fighting styles were a common pool of options. During his short-lived kickstarter reward live-play, he homebrewed a base class (or used an existing homebrew, I struggle to recall) because he didn't know that College of Swords Bard existed. These are all small indicators of his very narrow design vision that doesn't seem to pull in, or demonstrate awareness of, the game he's designing for outside his own narrow perspective.
That's not even getting into the dumpster fire that was Strongholds & Followers vs Kingdoms & Warfare....
No, I personally don't think it's better monster design. It's just, largely speaking, a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined with Colville's propensity to make bespoke sub-systems for everything that takes his fancy. Sidekicks get a system, pets get system, minions get a system! Everybody gets a system. Even his boss type monsters get a clunky "on turn one they do this, on turn two they do that" style system. I personally find it inelegant and obtuse, and clunky at the table.
I'm generally not a fan of MCDM design because I don't think it's well informed design. For example, when Colville made the illrigger, he gave the class it's own unique fighting styles because he didn't know that fighting styles were a common pool of options. During his short-lived kickstarter reward live-play, he homebrewed a base class (or used an existing homebrew, I struggle to recall) because he didn't know that College of Swords Bard existed. These are all small indicators of his very narrow design vision that doesn't seem to pull in, or demonstrate awareness of, the game he's designing for outside his own narrow perspective.
That's not even getting into the dumpster fire that was Strongholds & Followers vs Kingdoms & Warfare....
What I think is the best part about Flee, Mortals! Is the solo boss designs. I just don't think any single monster in 5.5e is as good for that purpose.
I think Matt has some good ideas in there (whether sourced from 4e or not), but I don't think every table needs to belabor monsters to this degree. It's useful for the groups that want to shake things up, but my groups are getting plenty of mileage out of the Monster Manual as-is.
To build on Davyd's point as an example - I don't need a "minion" tag with its own bespoke rules to have minions in an encounter, I can just run groups of weaker monsters alongside the main ones in a fight that are designed to go down quickly relative to the party's current level/capabilities.
a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined
While I agree with a lot of your complaints about Colville’s other products, I am not sure this is all that fair. Minions are an incredibly useful tool for a DM to have in their toolbox - they feel frightening with their volume and can be quite dangerous, without adding a bunch of extra hitpoint sponges that bog down combat. Very quick way to add lethality players can immediately feel accomplished in addressing, as well as useful tools for repeated spawns and in-combat puzzles.
The 4e Minions, however, were flawed. They still generally acted individually, meaning they took a while to resolve. Colville’s solution on this front is a fairly elegant one - they move, attack, and act together, with some fairly simple multiplication resolving what otherwise would be a significant number of slow rolls. Having extensively played 4e and deployed the Flee Mortals minions, I feel very comfortable saying that the rules might be very slightly more complex, but ultimately lead to a better game state and less convoluted actual play.
That is not something I would say about his other content, but on this front, I think his minion system is ultimately very good for the game.
Edit: To PsyrenXY’s point above about using smaller monsters, I think that is also a perfectly acceptable option for lots of fights. But as a tool, it is very helpful to have a system to quickly resolve a dozen or so bad guys, so you can accomplish popular story beats like mowing down a zombie horde or a swarm of insects.
So I just read Flee, Mortals! By MCDM, and the monster designs were very interesting. Maybe even better designed than the official MM? I'd be curious if anyone else had the book and what their experiences of it were.
I do not think there is any question that Flee Mortals! is better monster design than 5e and, thus far, 5.5e. Minions fix a necessary missing element of D&D by allowing for mass combat. The categories of monster, like Lurker and such, make sorting and finding the type of monster you need much, much easier than the utter lack of meaningful categories in the MM and other core content. A focus on abilities that are interesting, instead of the fairly generic monsters dominated by “BPS multi attack” also leads to more dynamic encounters.
But the amusing part of all of that? Those are all WotC design elements at heart. Everything good about Flee Mortals! was directly lifted from 4th Edition D&D, though minions were improved and expanded on to better fit 5e design. In Wizards quest to distance itself from 4e, Wizards simply avoided 4e design all together, instead of learning from what elements did work. Flee Mortals! does exactly what WotC should have done from the start - directly copy the elements of 4e that worked perfectly and improve on those that were great ideas but needed a bit of additional work.
No, I personally don't think it's better monster design. It's just, largely speaking, a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined with Colville's propensity to make bespoke sub-systems for everything that takes his fancy. Sidekicks get a system, pets get system, minions get a system! Everybody gets a system. Even his boss type monsters get a clunky "on turn one they do this, on turn two they do that" style system. I personally find it inelegant and obtuse, and clunky at the table.
I'm generally not a fan of MCDM design because I don't think it's well informed design. For example, when Colville made the illrigger, he gave the class it's own unique fighting styles because he didn't know that fighting styles were a common pool of options. During his short-lived kickstarter reward live-play, he homebrewed a base class (or used an existing homebrew, I struggle to recall) because he didn't know that College of Swords Bard existed. These are all small indicators of his very narrow design vision that doesn't seem to pull in, or demonstrate awareness of, the game he's designing for outside his own narrow perspective.
That's not even getting into the dumpster fire that was Strongholds & Followers vs Kingdoms & Warfare....
Find my D&D Beyond articles here
What I think is the best part about Flee, Mortals! Is the solo boss designs. I just don't think any single monster in 5.5e is as good for that purpose.
I think Matt has some good ideas in there (whether sourced from 4e or not), but I don't think every table needs to belabor monsters to this degree. It's useful for the groups that want to shake things up, but my groups are getting plenty of mileage out of the Monster Manual as-is.
To build on Davyd's point as an example - I don't need a "minion" tag with its own bespoke rules to have minions in an encounter, I can just run groups of weaker monsters alongside the main ones in a fight that are designed to go down quickly relative to the party's current level/capabilities.
While I agree with a lot of your complaints about Colville’s other products, I am not sure this is all that fair. Minions are an incredibly useful tool for a DM to have in their toolbox - they feel frightening with their volume and can be quite dangerous, without adding a bunch of extra hitpoint sponges that bog down combat. Very quick way to add lethality players can immediately feel accomplished in addressing, as well as useful tools for repeated spawns and in-combat puzzles.
The 4e Minions, however, were flawed. They still generally acted individually, meaning they took a while to resolve. Colville’s solution on this front is a fairly elegant one - they move, attack, and act together, with some fairly simple multiplication resolving what otherwise would be a significant number of slow rolls. Having extensively played 4e and deployed the Flee Mortals minions, I feel very comfortable saying that the rules might be very slightly more complex, but ultimately lead to a better game state and less convoluted actual play.
That is not something I would say about his other content, but on this front, I think his minion system is ultimately very good for the game.
Edit: To PsyrenXY’s point above about using smaller monsters, I think that is also a perfectly acceptable option for lots of fights. But as a tool, it is very helpful to have a system to quickly resolve a dozen or so bad guys, so you can accomplish popular story beats like mowing down a zombie horde or a swarm of insects.