Dungeons & Dragons 2024 – New Weapon Mastery Proposal
New Weapon Mastery: Disarm
Proposed Weapons: Whip and Sword Breaker (Sword Catcher)
Submitted for consideration to the Dungeons & Dragons Game Design Team at Wizards of the Coast
1. Introduction
I would like to propose a new Weapon Mastery property for the 2024 edition of Dungeons & Dragons called Disarm.
The goal of this proposal is to expand tactical combat options for martial characters by introducing a weapon mastery that allows characters to disarm opponents during combat.
Currently, Weapon Mastery provides several ways to influence the battlefield, including pushing enemies, knocking them prone, slowing their movement, and weakening their attacks. Disarm would introduce another tactical option that focuses on weapon control and close-quarters combat.
I propose that this new mastery be available to two weapons:
Whip (existing weapon)
Sword Breaker, also known as Sword Catcher (proposed new martial weapon)
2. Proposed Weapon Mastery: Disarm
Disarm. When you hit a creature with an attack using a weapon that has the Disarm mastery property, you can force the target to make a Dexterity saving throw.
The saving throw DC is calculated as follows:
DC = 8 + your Proficiency Bonus + the ability modifier used for the attack.
On a failed saving throw:
The target drops one weapon it is holding.
The dropped weapon lands in an unoccupied space within 5 feet of the target.
The target cannot make attacks with that weapon until the end of its next turn.
On a successful saving throw, the target retains its weapon.
This effect represents the wielder using leverage, entanglement, or weapon manipulation to force an opponent to lose their grip.
3. Existing Weapon: Whip
I propose adding Disarm as an alternative Weapon Mastery property for the Whip.
Proposed characteristics:
Damage: 1d4 Slashing
Properties: Finesse, Reach
Proposed Mastery: Disarm
The Whip would use its reach and flexibility to catch an opponent's weapon or arm, allowing the wielder to pull the weapon out of the opponent's grasp.
This would give the Whip a specialized battlefield-control role beyond simply dealing damage or reducing an enemy's movement.
4. Proposed New Weapon: Sword Breaker (Sword Catcher)
I also propose introducing a new Martial Melee Weapon called the Sword Breaker, sometimes referred to as a Sword Catcher.
The Sword Breaker is inspired by historical parrying daggers featuring specially notched blades designed to catch, trap, and control an opponent's sword.
Proposed weapon statistics:
Characteristic
Proposed Value
Weapon Category
Martial Melee
Damage
1d6 Piercing
Properties
Finesse, Light
Weapon Mastery
Disarm
Weight
2 lb.
Cost
15 GP
Weapon Description:
The Sword Breaker is a specialized dagger with a reinforced blade featuring deep notches along one side. These notches are designed to catch an opponent's weapon, allowing the wielder to trap, twist, and manipulate an enemy's weapon during close-quarters combat.
Unlike a conventional dagger, the Sword Breaker is primarily designed for defensive weapon control and disarming techniques.
Its Finesse and Light properties would make it particularly appealing to Rogues, Fighters, Rangers, and other martial characters who specialize in Dexterity-based combat or two-weapon fighting.
5. Design Intent and Gameplay Benefits
The proposed Disarm mastery would introduce several tactical opportunities:
Weapon Control: Characters could temporarily remove an opponent's primary weapon from combat.
Combat Variety: Martial characters would gain another battlefield-control option alongside Push, Topple, Sap, and Slow.
Weapon Identity: The Whip and Sword Breaker would have distinctive mechanical identities based on their physical designs.
Character Diversity: Characters specializing in finesse weapons and tactical combat would gain additional equipment choices.
Roleplaying Opportunities: Disarming an opponent rather than simply defeating them could create interesting opportunities for nonlethal encounters, duels, and capturing enemies.
6. Balance Considerations
The Disarm mastery is intended to provide tactical utility rather than additional damage.
Several limitations are included to help maintain game balance:
The attack must successfully hit before the saving throw is triggered.
The target receives a Dexterity saving throw to resist the effect.
Only one held weapon can be disarmed per successful application.
The effect does not automatically remove a creature's entire turn or prevent it from using other weapons.
The target can retrieve its dropped weapon or use another available weapon, subject to the normal rules for doing so.
These limitations are intended to make Disarm useful without making it overwhelmingly powerful.
7. Closing Statement
I believe the addition of Disarm as a Weapon Mastery property would expand the tactical possibilities of martial combat in Dungeons & Dragons.
The Whip and the proposed Sword Breaker offer two distinct ways of achieving the same battlefield effect: one through reach and entanglement, the other through close-quarters weapon manipulation.
I hope Wizards of the Coast will consider this proposal for future Unearthed Arcana playtesting, a future Player's Handbook update, or other supplemental Dungeons & Dragons material.
Thank you for your continued work on Dungeons & Dragons and for considering community-created ideas that help expand the game.
Basically, you made an attack roll opposed by the target's Athletics or Acrobatics roll. If your roll is higher the target is disarmed. You had disadvantage on your roll if the target used two hands, the target had advantage on its roll if it was larger than the attacker or disadvantage if smaller. No damage is done to the target in any case.
It adds a second WM to all the Versatile weapons so they are truly versatile opening up combos like using a Longsword in one hand to give your second attack an advantage then switching to two hands for the second attack to give the attacker a disadvantage on their attacks or using Quarterstaff to Push a enemy or Topple them. No longer is it merely about having the option to also use a shield or not.
I've only had one player use the feat and they liked it. It made they character feel very much like a tactician during combat and they had fun chaining the attacks together. There are some WMs I'd like to change so all the Versatile Weapons have nice combos when switching from one to two hands but I wanted to keep the original WMs.
[If you do include the Feat please let me know how it works out in your campaign. I want to get more play testing feedback.]
Edit: Oh and that Sword Breaker does indeed look cool but they didn't actually see wide use historically from my understanding. They weren't really that effective but then neither did fails. And whips just suck. Slow? Really? Yes, I support a Disarm or anything else for the Whip like Topple which makes more sense.
I think that in the late Middle Ages, as body armor was slowly being phased out of use, such a weapon did exist. It was variously known as the "left hand dagger", the "main gauche" and in edition 4.0, there was a specialty weapon known as the parrying dagger.
For a duelist type of fighter, such a weapon would be appropriate.
As for the whip being given the "disarm", option that would be appropriate. Indeed, rogues might well switch to whips to disarm opponents and to keep opponents from drawing a weapon.
After you use your turn to disarm, the target can pick up the weapon for free and attack with it.
True, you can also use a free item interaction to pick up the dropped weapon but you need to have a hand free and available action.
Even in the opposite direction it ruins the action economy, and is more likely to be used against player than by them, considering the only enemy NPCs vulnerable to it are Bandits and Guards.
I have never played the 2014 version, so thank you for letting me know about that. Can you explain to me the mechanics of disarming?
Using the 2024 PHB rules, I would use the rule under the Cunning Strike of a rogue. If a whip wielder scores a hit, the target must make a Dexterity check to retain his/her weapon. The Dexterity check would be ( 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the Attribute modifier used).
I have never played the 2014 version, so thank you for letting me know about that. Can you explain to me the mechanics of disarming?
Using the 2024 PHB rules, I would use the rule under the Cunning Strike of a rogue. If a whip wielder scores a hit, the target must make a Dexterity check to retain his/her weapon. The Dexterity check would be ( 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the Attribute modifier used).
My two cents worth.
It's a good idea, though I think a Strength saving throw would be more appropriate than a Dexterity check.
I have never played the 2014 version, so thank you for letting me know about that. Can you explain to me the mechanics of disarming?
Using the 2024 PHB rules, I would use the rule under the Cunning Strike of a rogue. If a whip wielder scores a hit, the target must make a Dexterity check to retain his/her weapon. The Dexterity check would be ( 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the Attribute modifier used).
My two cents worth.
It's a good idea, though I think a Strength saving throw would be more appropriate than a Dexterity check.
Okay. The check could be then.....8 + whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the target's Strength modifier. Is the whip wielder able to yank the weapon out of the target's hand OR is the whip wielder able to "sting" the target's hand sufficiently to cause the target to drop the weapon?
Back in an earlier edition of D&D, there was a variation of a gnoll, called a flind(?), that had the ability to hit its opponent's hand and force the opponent to drop whichever weapon it was holding. I think this might be where this discussion is heading.
Flind come from 1e, they weren't in 2e but they re-appeared in 3e and then were absent in 4e but came back in 5e and are now missing in 5.5e. They're cousins of Gnolls. Higher CR and all that. I've only ever seen them brought up once and it is in a MUD. They're nasty buggers but they drop mad gems in that game so they're great for lower-level loot grinding. The MUD is or was based on D&D 3.5 but it went to Pathfinder and now it is a hodgepodge of both and spans levels 1-50. Originally they only had levels 1-20 and then 20-30 went in as Epic levels but they just keep adding content. I've been playing it for years because the devs have added a ton of stuff I asked for and there is some seriously good RP in the game. I'm so happy someone brought them up.
I am loving this discussion about whips. They shouldn't be powerful weapons, but they should be able to Topple or as suggested Disarm. Something of that nature at least. My current character in that MUD I just mentioned has a couple of whips but only because I'm trying to stick to Exotic weapons just cuz and because they're both +2 weapons with a chance to trip the opponent in combat. I started the character as a Monk and now I am multi-classed into Thief. Next up is Wizard and then Cleric so I can cast spells too but really, I'm just trying to get all the pre-requisites to craft different things.. except for Monk. I just went Monk in case I get disarmed and my armor is removed. Otherwise, thief gave me tools of the trade so I can make caltrops, wizard will give me scribing, and cleric will let me craft holy items.
I have never played the 2014 version, so thank you for letting me know about that. Can you explain to me the mechanics of disarming?
Using the 2024 PHB rules, I would use the rule under the Cunning Strike of a rogue. If a whip wielder scores a hit, the target must make a Dexterity check to retain his/her weapon. The Dexterity check would be ( 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the Attribute modifier used).
My two cents worth.
It's a good idea, though I think a Strength saving throw would be more appropriate than a Dexterity check.
Okay. The check could be then.....8 + whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the target's Strength modifier.
Well, again, what we're looking for is a Strength saving throw from the target. The DC wouldn't incorporate any of the target's stats. It would be 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the whip wielder's Dexterity Modifier (as specified in the Cunning Strike feature).
Is the whip wielder able to yank the weapon out of the target's hand OR is the whip wielder able to "sting" the target's hand sufficiently to cause the target to drop the weapon?
I think the difference there is mostly flavor, so it'd be up to the player. Either way, usually an attempt to hold onto something when someone else is trying to take it away from you involves a Strength saving throw.
I have never played the 2014 version, so thank you for letting me know about that. Can you explain to me the mechanics of disarming?
Using the 2024 PHB rules, I would use the rule under the Cunning Strike of a rogue. If a whip wielder scores a hit, the target must make a Dexterity check to retain his/her weapon. The Dexterity check would be ( 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the Attribute modifier used).
My two cents worth.
It's a good idea, though I think a Strength saving throw would be more appropriate than a Dexterity check.
Okay. The check could be then.....8 + whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the target's Strength modifier.
Well, again, what we're looking for is a Strength saving throw from the target. The DC wouldn't incorporate any of the target's stats. It would be 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the whip wielder's Dexterity Modifier (as specified in the Cunning Strike feature).
Is the whip wielder able to yank the weapon out of the target's hand OR is the whip wielder able to "sting" the target's hand sufficiently to cause the target to drop the weapon?
I think the difference there is mostly flavor, so it'd be up to the player. Either way, usually an attempt to hold onto something when someone else is trying to take it away from you involves a Strength saving throw.
Either a Strength save to hold on OR a Constitution save to endure the pain of the sting.
Also, I think that it should be less of an attempt to yank the weapon from a person's hand and more of an attempt to sting the hand to drop the weapon.
My opinion about whips: Topple is doubtful but Trip (as in the Cunning Strike action mentioned above) is a decent possibility as is the possibility of a Disarm.
A whip is a Dexterity weapon and it ought to be an option for dexterity players, such as rogues, rangers, monks (I had not considered that class) and warlocks with Great Old One patrons (you know, those beings with whip like tentacles).
Addendum: I am imagining a character much like the mythic character Zorro from the Disney TV series of the late 1950's.
Addendum #2: I am imagining the whip snagging an opponent's lower leg and then pulling the leg to one side. If the opponent fails a check (Strength or Dexterity), the opponent falls Prone and then your allies get Advantage on their melee attacks.
Dungeons & Dragons 2024 – New Weapon Mastery Proposal
New Weapon Mastery: Disarm
Proposed Weapons: Whip and Sword Breaker (Sword Catcher)
Submitted for consideration to the Dungeons & Dragons Game Design Team at Wizards of the Coast
1. Introduction
I would like to propose a new Weapon Mastery property for the 2024 edition of Dungeons & Dragons called Disarm.
The goal of this proposal is to expand tactical combat options for martial characters by introducing a weapon mastery that allows characters to disarm opponents during combat.
Currently, Weapon Mastery provides several ways to influence the battlefield, including pushing enemies, knocking them prone, slowing their movement, and weakening their attacks. Disarm would introduce another tactical option that focuses on weapon control and close-quarters combat.
I propose that this new mastery be available to two weapons:
2. Proposed Weapon Mastery: Disarm
Disarm. When you hit a creature with an attack using a weapon that has the Disarm mastery property, you can force the target to make a Dexterity saving throw.
The saving throw DC is calculated as follows:
DC = 8 + your Proficiency Bonus + the ability modifier used for the attack.
On a failed saving throw:
On a successful saving throw, the target retains its weapon.
This effect represents the wielder using leverage, entanglement, or weapon manipulation to force an opponent to lose their grip.
3. Existing Weapon: Whip
I propose adding Disarm as an alternative Weapon Mastery property for the Whip.
Proposed characteristics:
The Whip would use its reach and flexibility to catch an opponent's weapon or arm, allowing the wielder to pull the weapon out of the opponent's grasp.
This would give the Whip a specialized battlefield-control role beyond simply dealing damage or reducing an enemy's movement.
4. Proposed New Weapon: Sword Breaker (Sword Catcher)
I also propose introducing a new Martial Melee Weapon called the Sword Breaker, sometimes referred to as a Sword Catcher.
The Sword Breaker is inspired by historical parrying daggers featuring specially notched blades designed to catch, trap, and control an opponent's sword.
Proposed weapon statistics:
Weapon Description:
The Sword Breaker is a specialized dagger with a reinforced blade featuring deep notches along one side. These notches are designed to catch an opponent's weapon, allowing the wielder to trap, twist, and manipulate an enemy's weapon during close-quarters combat.
Unlike a conventional dagger, the Sword Breaker is primarily designed for defensive weapon control and disarming techniques.
Its Finesse and Light properties would make it particularly appealing to Rogues, Fighters, Rangers, and other martial characters who specialize in Dexterity-based combat or two-weapon fighting.
5. Design Intent and Gameplay Benefits
The proposed Disarm mastery would introduce several tactical opportunities:
6. Balance Considerations
The Disarm mastery is intended to provide tactical utility rather than additional damage.
Several limitations are included to help maintain game balance:
These limitations are intended to make Disarm useful without making it overwhelmingly powerful.
7. Closing Statement
I believe the addition of Disarm as a Weapon Mastery property would expand the tactical possibilities of martial combat in Dungeons & Dragons.
The Whip and the proposed Sword Breaker offer two distinct ways of achieving the same battlefield effect: one through reach and entanglement, the other through close-quarters weapon manipulation.
I hope Wizards of the Coast will consider this proposal for future Unearthed Arcana playtesting, a future Player's Handbook update, or other supplemental Dungeons & Dragons material.
Thank you for your continued work on Dungeons & Dragons and for considering community-created ideas that help expand the game.
Respectfully submitted,
A Dungeons & Dragons player and community member
Disarm is also already available as an optional rule from the 2014 DMG that can still be used with the new ruleset.
I have never played the 2014 version, so thank you for letting me know about that. Can you explain to me the mechanics of disarming?
Basically, you made an attack roll opposed by the target's Athletics or Acrobatics roll. If your roll is higher the target is disarmed. You had disadvantage on your roll if the target used two hands, the target had advantage on its roll if it was larger than the attacker or disadvantage if smaller. No damage is done to the target in any case.
Current rules make disarming not the greatest.
After you use your turn to disarm, the target can pick up the weapon for free and attack with it.
True, you can also use a free item interaction to pick up the dropped weapon but you need to have a hand free and available action.
"Sooner or later, your Players are going to smash your railroad into a sandbox."
-Vedexent
"real life is a super high CR."
-OboeLauren
"............anybody got any potatoes? We could drop a potato in each hole an' see which ones get viciously mauled by horrible monsters?"
-Ilyara Thundertale
I think you might enjoy this Fighting Style Feat.
https://www.dndbeyond.com/feats/2186116-versatility
It adds a second WM to all the Versatile weapons so they are truly versatile opening up combos like using a Longsword in one hand to give your second attack an advantage then switching to two hands for the second attack to give the attacker a disadvantage on their attacks or using Quarterstaff to Push a enemy or Topple them. No longer is it merely about having the option to also use a shield or not.
I've only had one player use the feat and they liked it. It made they character feel very much like a tactician during combat and they had fun chaining the attacks together. There are some WMs I'd like to change so all the Versatile Weapons have nice combos when switching from one to two hands but I wanted to keep the original WMs.
[If you do include the Feat please let me know how it works out in your campaign. I want to get more play testing feedback.]
Edit: Oh and that Sword Breaker does indeed look cool but they didn't actually see wide use historically from my understanding. They weren't really that effective but then neither did fails. And whips just suck. Slow? Really? Yes, I support a Disarm or anything else for the Whip like Topple which makes more sense.
"Life is Cast by Random Dice"
Burn my candle twice.
I have done my life justice
Against random dice.
I think that in the late Middle Ages, as body armor was slowly being phased out of use, such a weapon did exist. It was variously known as the "left hand dagger", the "main gauche" and in edition 4.0, there was a specialty weapon known as the parrying dagger.
For a duelist type of fighter, such a weapon would be appropriate.
As for the whip being given the "disarm", option that would be appropriate. Indeed, rogues might well switch to whips to disarm opponents and to keep opponents from drawing a weapon.
Even in the opposite direction it ruins the action economy, and is more likely to be used against player than by them, considering the only enemy NPCs vulnerable to it are Bandits and Guards.
Using the 2024 PHB rules, I would use the rule under the Cunning Strike of a rogue. If a whip wielder scores a hit, the target must make a Dexterity check to retain his/her weapon. The Dexterity check would be ( 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the Attribute modifier used).
My two cents worth.
It's a good idea, though I think a Strength saving throw would be more appropriate than a Dexterity check.
(Cunning Strike saving throws are always 8 + Proficiency Bonus + Dexterity Modifier.)
pronouns: he/she/they
Okay. The check could be then.....8 + whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the target's Strength modifier. Is the whip wielder able to yank the weapon out of the target's hand OR is the whip wielder able to "sting" the target's hand sufficiently to cause the target to drop the weapon?
Back in an earlier edition of D&D, there was a variation of a gnoll, called a flind(?), that had the ability to hit its opponent's hand and force the opponent to drop whichever weapon it was holding. I think this might be where this discussion is heading.
Flind come from 1e, they weren't in 2e but they re-appeared in 3e and then were absent in 4e but came back in 5e and are now missing in 5.5e. They're cousins of Gnolls. Higher CR and all that. I've only ever seen them brought up once and it is in a MUD. They're nasty buggers but they drop mad gems in that game so they're great for lower-level loot grinding. The MUD is or was based on D&D 3.5 but it went to Pathfinder and now it is a hodgepodge of both and spans levels 1-50. Originally they only had levels 1-20 and then 20-30 went in as Epic levels but they just keep adding content. I've been playing it for years because the devs have added a ton of stuff I asked for and there is some seriously good RP in the game. I'm so happy someone brought them up.
I am loving this discussion about whips. They shouldn't be powerful weapons, but they should be able to Topple or as suggested Disarm. Something of that nature at least. My current character in that MUD I just mentioned has a couple of whips but only because I'm trying to stick to Exotic weapons just cuz and because they're both +2 weapons with a chance to trip the opponent in combat. I started the character as a Monk and now I am multi-classed into Thief. Next up is Wizard and then Cleric so I can cast spells too but really, I'm just trying to get all the pre-requisites to craft different things.. except for Monk. I just went Monk in case I get disarmed and my armor is removed. Otherwise, thief gave me tools of the trade so I can make caltrops, wizard will give me scribing, and cleric will let me craft holy items.
"Life is Cast by Random Dice"
Burn my candle twice.
I have done my life justice
Against random dice.
Well, again, what we're looking for is a Strength saving throw from the target. The DC wouldn't incorporate any of the target's stats. It would be 8 + the whip wielder's Proficiency Bonus + the whip wielder's Dexterity Modifier (as specified in the Cunning Strike feature).
I think the difference there is mostly flavor, so it'd be up to the player. Either way, usually an attempt to hold onto something when someone else is trying to take it away from you involves a Strength saving throw.
pronouns: he/she/they
Either a Strength save to hold on OR a Constitution save to endure the pain of the sting.
Also, I think that it should be less of an attempt to yank the weapon from a person's hand and more of an attempt to sting the hand to drop the weapon.
My opinion about whips: Topple is doubtful but Trip (as in the Cunning Strike action mentioned above) is a decent possibility as is the possibility of a Disarm.
A whip is a Dexterity weapon and it ought to be an option for dexterity players, such as rogues, rangers, monks (I had not considered that class) and warlocks with Great Old One patrons (you know, those beings with whip like tentacles).
Addendum: I am imagining a character much like the mythic character Zorro from the Disney TV series of the late 1950's.
Addendum #2: I am imagining the whip snagging an opponent's lower leg and then pulling the leg to one side. If the opponent fails a check (Strength or Dexterity), the opponent falls Prone and then your allies get Advantage on their melee attacks.
There are a lot of good ideas and explanations of different concepts from many individuals. Thanks for the input.