I would agree with Gothicshark that the Con might be a bit high.
What ability would I put in instead of con if it's too high?
Dex for an AC boost or Int to give a boost to Nature and Religion but you could also drop it into Cha and RP proselyting people with your gift of gab. Just depends really. Having a high Con isn't exactly a negative but it is one of your classes saves so placing it in an attribute that is tied to a different save might behoove you.
I would agree with Gothicshark that the Con might be a bit high.
What ability would I put in instead of con if it's too high?
Dex for an AC boost or Int to give a boost to Nature and Religion but you could also drop it into Cha and RP proselyting people with your gift of gab. Just depends really. Having a high Con isn't exactly a negative but it is one of your classes saves so placing it in an attribute that is tied to a different save might behoove you.
Clerics wouldn't get much of an AC boost from high DEX, they're usually in medium armour so can only take advantage of +2 to AC from DEX so they're already as high as they need it to be. If they're aiming for a very tanky spell caster I think they're already where they need to be, although higher strength for hitting people with a mace might be nice
I was more leaning into a caster cleric. That being said, I haven't played one before, so I don't know a lot about it. Would a more martial type be better?
I would say that Clerics can be a lot of fun, they are full casters can wear full plate shield and a one handed martial weapon, they can cast some great control and damage spells. Everything great about a paladin without extra attack but some of the best spells. And they can stop a TPK.
Going pure healer caster you run into issues, sure Light is an "A Tier" cleric subclass, but the cantrips like all cleric cantrips leave a lot to be desired. Which is why taking a background which gives access to Magic Initiative (Wizard) or (Druid) helps a ton espcially if you go Thaumaturgy.
Also if you are leaning into the pure caster Con isn't for HP it's for maintaining Spells when you get hit, you have high AC from Armour and a shield, and if you take from the wizards list you can take the Shield spell. 18+5 = 23 for a turn. Just saying a Cleric who focuses on casting needs a Good Cantrip and the Shield Spell. If you go with low stregth you will need a cantrip melee spell, True Strike or Shillelagh are my suggestions. True Strike is from the wizards list and can be used on all melee weapons, and Shillelagh is druid and can be used with Quarterstaves. The power of Shillelagh should never be under estimated either. Which is why Druid cantrips are worth not having the Shield spell.
The Farmer Background is for Martial Melee tanks. I would take that with Barbarians, Paladins, and Fighters going full tank mode. As a cleric taking it it's only worth it if you are building a Cleric Tank.
I would agree with Gothicshark that the Con might be a bit high.
What ability would I put in instead of con if it's too high?
Dex for an AC boost or Int to give a boost to Nature and Religion but you could also drop it into Cha and RP proselyting people with your gift of gab. Just depends really. Having a high Con isn't exactly a negative but it is one of your classes saves so placing it in an attribute that is tied to a different save might behoove you.
Clerics wouldn't get much of an AC boost from high DEX, they're usually in medium armour so can only take advantage of +2 to AC from DEX so they're already as high as they need it to be. If they're aiming for a very tanky spell caster I think they're already where they need to be, although higher strength for hitting people with a mace might be nice
You can plan around it and lean into it. Med Armor master ups the limit +3, and there are magical med armors that have that built in.
Ok... the Character looks legit as of this moment in time, 1700 (GMT) 11/18/26
You have made a pure healer, which will not be a very satisfying character. As D&D is not really about combat healing, it's about keeping people from having to make death saving throws.
Clerics have heals, take them but build for hybrid Melee and Spell damage. You are a caster with martial weapons and can have full armour. You stand behind the melee helping with spells and hitting enemies who try and run with oprotunity attacks.
If you did this character with Point buy I would even out Strenght and Wisdom lower dex to 10, dump int and Chr. If you ended up with 20 str 20 wis and 16 con that would be perfect. (Con is just to maintain spells, you don't need to worry about HP, and your AC should be high enough that baddies will have a hard time hitting you.)
Also for melee weapons versatile weapons gives you options. One of the reasons why I like the War domain is you get better melee and spells with the Subclass. And while Thaumaturge is great for a pure caster, Protector is better for a battleline healer. Thaumaturge is great for a caster subclass like Arcana.
Note the most useful healing spell is Healing Word, as you can use it as a bonus action while still using a cantrip or melee attack. After the fight, you can take time to do short rests and big heals as needed. Spare the Dying is a good cantrip but it should be used only if you are out of spell slots. Your main cantrip should be one of the actually good damage dealing spells. Toll the dead is OK, but sacred flame is bad, and always has been. (Dex saves are easy for most NPCs and Monsters, same with Con, and Will) which is why Cleric Cantrips are terrible. As they all are save based and target the monster stats most monsters are good at. Avoid relying on Dex, Con, and WIll saves unless you have no other choice.
The best Cantrips are 5.5 True Striike, Starry Wisp, Sorcerous Burst, Shillelagh, Eldrich Blast, Firebolt, Mind Sliver (Int save is one of the good ones), Poison Spray (d12 attack spell, better than toll the dead. The negative is it's poison the most resisted damage type), and Ray of Frost.
Now to get a good weapon cantrip either you need a level in Druid, or take a magic initive feat, or another feat that gives access to cantrips. Druid and Wizard cantrips are the best for you, if you want to be a pure caster with heals.
BTW my favorite Subclasses are Grave and War.
I was more leaning into a caster cleric. That being said, I haven't played one before, so I don't know a lot about it. Would a more martial type be better?
This is where creating a character in a void is an issue. IF you have plenty of strong martial characters a caster cleric is great, if you are going to be taking a share of the melee then the Protector option is absolutely better. Best of luck!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
What ability would I put in instead of con if it's too high?
Dex for an AC boost or Int to give a boost to Nature and Religion but you could also drop it into Cha and RP proselyting people with your gift of gab. Just depends really. Having a high Con isn't exactly a negative but it is one of your classes saves so placing it in an attribute that is tied to a different save might behoove you.
"Life is Cast by Random Dice"
Burn my candle twice.
I have done my life justice
Against random dice.
Clerics wouldn't get much of an AC boost from high DEX, they're usually in medium armour so can only take advantage of +2 to AC from DEX so they're already as high as they need it to be. If they're aiming for a very tanky spell caster I think they're already where they need to be, although higher strength for hitting people with a mace might be nice
True true
"Life is Cast by Random Dice"
Burn my candle twice.
I have done my life justice
Against random dice.
I would say that Clerics can be a lot of fun, they are full casters can wear full plate shield and a one handed martial weapon, they can cast some great control and damage spells. Everything great about a paladin without extra attack but some of the best spells. And they can stop a TPK.
Going pure healer caster you run into issues, sure Light is an "A Tier" cleric subclass, but the cantrips like all cleric cantrips leave a lot to be desired. Which is why taking a background which gives access to Magic Initiative (Wizard) or (Druid) helps a ton espcially if you go Thaumaturgy.
Also if you are leaning into the pure caster Con isn't for HP it's for maintaining Spells when you get hit, you have high AC from Armour and a shield, and if you take from the wizards list you can take the Shield spell. 18+5 = 23 for a turn. Just saying a Cleric who focuses on casting needs a Good Cantrip and the Shield Spell. If you go with low stregth you will need a cantrip melee spell, True Strike or Shillelagh are my suggestions. True Strike is from the wizards list and can be used on all melee weapons, and Shillelagh is druid and can be used with Quarterstaves. The power of Shillelagh should never be under estimated either. Which is why Druid cantrips are worth not having the Shield spell.
The Farmer Background is for Martial Melee tanks. I would take that with Barbarians, Paladins, and Fighters going full tank mode. As a cleric taking it it's only worth it if you are building a Cleric Tank.
How I would build based on your core choices: Pure Caster - https://www.dndbeyond.com/characters/173776240
How I normally do clerics https://www.dndbeyond.com/characters/173778184 ... although normally it's grave.
You can plan around it and lean into it. Med Armor master ups the limit +3, and there are magical med armors that have that built in.
This is where creating a character in a void is an issue. IF you have plenty of strong martial characters a caster cleric is great, if you are going to be taking a share of the melee then the Protector option is absolutely better. Best of luck!