Someone on the design team REALLY seems to like "treat 1's as 2's", and no one involved seems to know how math works. It's 'acceptable' if the feat/item/ability/etc... has additional bonuses, but when it's -all- you're getting then it's pretty much garbage.
Great Weapon Fighting Style treats 1's & 2's as 3's. This works out to a paltry +0.3 bonus damage on d10's, +0.25 on a d12, and a much more respectable but still sad +1 on 2d6. For comparison, most other Fighting Styles are worth +2 damage, and Great Weapon Master Feat is worth anywhere from +2 to +6 on most Two-Handed weapons.
The Warcraft books came out and added at least 2 Feats and 4 magic items with similar pathetic "bonuses".
Fists of Fury, 1's>2's on Unarmed and Light weapon attacks. Unarmed damage can be anywhere from a d4 to a d12. A d4 gets a +0.25 bonus. All the way up to a +0.083 bonus on a d12. (Tavern Brawler at least gives you a full reroll of 1's, which is also kinda sad, but not +0.08 sad) Light Weapons top out at d6. Enjoy your +0.17.
Clearcasting Feat, 1's>2's on Force Damage Spells. See Fists of Fury for damage spread per die.
Ashen Band of [whatever] FOUR of them have some form as a 'bonus'. From Most Acceptable to Least Acceptable: Wisdom, Uncommon, applies it to -all- healing you cause. Weak, but it is the 'starter' bonus. Destruction, Very Rare, applies it to all spell damage, also bumps Spell Attack Roll/DC from +2 to +3. Might, Very Rare, applies to Melee Weapon damage, also bumps "set your STR" from 19 to 21. And the worst one: Vengeance, Legendary, 1&2's count as 3's for Ranged Weapon damage. The biggest bonus comes from using a d4 weapon, which is worth a +0.75 damage bump. But you're more likely to be using a d6 > +0.5, d8 > +0.375, or d10 > +0.3. Compare +0.75 (at best) to the _Uncommon_ level bonus _from the same item_ of a +2 damage -and- ignoring Half-cover.
Can the designers please just stop already. The bonus is not worth anything.
While you are correct that this particular ability is not overly powerful, it is worth noting that every single one of the WoW pieces of content are extremely good even if you completely ignore these abilities. Fists of Fury stacks to incredible damage on a Monk. Clearcaster is essentially "action surge nearly 25% of your Eldritch Blast turns, and likely higher if you can consistently blind folks with Hunger of Hadar." The Ashen bands provide (a) additional healing for the same resources - extremely helpful in resource-heavy campaigns, (b) a hefty +3 to attack and your saving throw value, in addition to increasing your spellcasting modifier +2 (effectively meaning your attacks and saves are +5, not to mention any skill check bonuses); (c) increasing your damage with ranged weapons, letting you ignore cover, and letting you attack at long range without disadvantage; (d) giving you a whopping 25 strength and +1 to damage roles.
While you are correct that this is lackluster for early 5.5e content created under the old design team, applying this complaint to the WoW book seems a little silly. Each of the WoW pieces of content are extremely potent, and this is just a tiny bonus on top of bonuses any player would be happy to have. It kind of seems like you are complaining about sprinkles on an ice cream sundae - you are there for the sundae and are going to enjoy your sundae either way, but the sprinkles add a nice little touch (even if an insignificant one).
You are partially correct. Most of these items/feats have more bonuses than just the garbage"sprinkles". But I also already noted that in my opening statement.
But Great Weapon Fighting and the LEGENDARY bonus of Ashen-Vengeance are still utter trash. If you put Vengeance's Legendary bonus at Uncommon with ignore cover, and moved the +2 Damage to Legendary, then I would feel differently about that item.
Fists of Fury is misleading. It has potential damage sure, but you need to land 3 hits to get to +3 total damage for the turn (+1 per hit). And landing all 5 hits is still only +10 total damage (+2 per hit). It is effectively the "Monk Fighting Style Feat", but a miss or two will quickly tank your bonus damage.
Clearcaster isn't bad on a Warlock, but it's still not great. You're locked into +1 INT, and you either need to be high level, and/or have a reliable way of getting Advantage to actually get use out of it. (or be content to gamble and hope for the best).
I agree about the math, but D&D is more than Math: The Game. It may not do a lot for you in terms of damage output, but it feels good when it happens. You see that 1 on the die, and get to say, but I’m a little special and for me, that’s a 2. You get that little dopamine hit and it feels good.
In games where critical fails occur perhaps, but it sounds like you are talking more damage than ability checks. It would be nicer if they were more like the halfling luck feature that let you reroll a 1 once.
The damage from the weapon die is often less then half of the total damage from a weapon attack. Is it really any more exciting to occasionally deal 7 points of damage instead of 6? For me, it feels like it might as well be a rounding error.
In games where critical fails occur perhaps, but it sounds like you are talking more damage than ability checks. It would be nicer if they were more like the halfling luck feature that let you reroll a 1 once.
Agree with the ability check/test thing. Especially if you’re playing a Rogue or Bard and you’re doing something you have expertise in and you’re stated out so, barring an extremely high DC, the only way to fail is to get a Nat 1.
I think you're overlooking the experiential effect. Rolling 1s sucks, so an ability that negates that feels good. A lot of people play D&D without crunching the numbers and instead enjoy stuff like "it's almost impossible for me to roll 1s".
Designing for this mode of play is valid and needs to continue
I agree about the math, but D&D is more than Math: The Game. It may not do a lot for you in terms of damage output, but it feels good when it happens. You see that 1 on the die, and get to say, but I’m a little special and for me, that’s a 2. You get that little dopamine hit and it feels good.
I agree about the math, but D&D is more than Math: The Game. It may not do a lot for you in terms of damage output, but it feels good when it happens. You see that 1 on the die, and get to say, but I’m a little special and for me, that’s a 2. You get that little dopamine hit and it feels good.
I think you're overlooking the experiential effect. Rolling 1s sucks, so an ability that negates that feels good. A lot of people play D&D without crunching the numbers and instead enjoy stuff like "it's almost impossible for me to roll 1s".
Designing for this mode of play is valid and needs to continue
The Math should support the flavor/'fun'. There was a guy in my group once that wanted to play a Fighter with a hand-and-a-half sword (Long Sword) because it had Versatile, so he could attack while leaving one hand free to grapple, or grab a ladder, or whatever, but then he'd also have the option to 2-hand it "for the extra damage". Had to explain to him that he can -say- he's attacking 2-handed, but it was always numerically better to attack 1-handed+Dueling. (d10+GWF is worse than d8+2)
In games where critical fails occur perhaps, but it sounds like you are talking more damage than ability checks. It would be nicer if they were more like the halfling luck feature that let you reroll a 1 once.
Agree with the ability check/test thing. Especially if you’re playing a Rogue or Bard and you’re doing something you have expertise in and you’re stated out so, barring an extremely high DC, the only way to fail is to get a Nat 1.
Nat 1's / Crit Fails only exist for Attack Rolls and Death Saves. They have no special rules for Skills and (normal) Saves.
I don't entirely agree with you on this. IF you have a 2d6 damage roll you have a minimum of 6 points of damage plus whatever your bonuses are.
While it may only be worth 1 point in average damage, that 6 minimum gives you more reliable damage.
Congrats, you've just discovered the 2nd best* potential fix for GWF: "Minimum 6 Weapon damage" 1d10 gets a +1.5 boost, 7 average 1d12 gets a +1.25 boost, 7.75 average
I don't entirely agree with you on this. IF you have a 2d6 damage roll you have a minimum of 6 points of damage plus whatever your bonuses are.
While it may only be worth 1 point in average damage, that 6 minimum gives you more reliable damage.
And then you can also get into that argument about the new vicious rules, since mentions damage dice, not specifically what type of damage dice. Even something like flametounge weapons.
The other argument to be had is that even if its not Exceptionally high DPR uplift, what else are you going to use the fighting style on? There is a point where +1 AC doesn't make that much of a difference, and you're stacking other buffs to get 23+ resting AC. And AC bonus is useless to Barbarians since they don't need armor. So may as well get a minimum damage uplift on what is the highest damage scale weapon you can get.
It hasn't been brought up yet, but you also have to remember that GWF, at least, is adding onto (last time I looked into it) the highest damage martial builds of the game already. They don't need ANY boost to outperform DW builds (barring incredible setup like stacking HM, DS, Hex, and maybe a couple others over several turns). In order to keep DW builds from being so underpowered by comparison, the bonus for GWF can't really be that large.
And I mean, at least for 2d6 weapons, it's essentially reliable talent on damage rolls. Who doesn't like RT??
It hasn't been brought up yet, but you also have to remember that GWF, at least, is adding onto (last time I looked into it) the highest damage martial builds of the game already.
Which is true but not really relevant to balancing; it just means you take GWF plus another fighting style; blind fighting or defense performs better at most levels, interception performs better at low level (but has terrible scaling).
I don't entirely agree with you on this. IF you have a 2d6 damage roll you have a minimum of 6 points of damage plus whatever your bonuses are.
While it may only be worth 1 point in average damage, that 6 minimum gives you more reliable damage.
While true, this only has narrow use cases. Let's consider an ideal case: you have a strength bonus of +3 and are fighting warrior infantry.
Greatsword, no GWF: 1.38 hits to drop a warrior infantry
Greatsword, with GWF: 1.00 hits to drop a warrior infantry (+38%)
So yeah, it's good there. Now, how does this works if instead our target is an 11 hp bandit
Greatsword, no GWF: 1.58 hits to drop a bandit
Greatsword, with GWF: 1.55 hits to drop a bandit (+2%)
Almost nothing.
But you are back to average damage. The distinction I'm making is that you could roll two ones on the dice, add three for 5. Two threes plus the STR add is nine damage, which is why I kind of like it for a Fighter. Good minimum damage is guaranteed.
Someone on the design team REALLY seems to like "treat 1's as 2's", and no one involved seems to know how math works.
It's 'acceptable' if the feat/item/ability/etc... has additional bonuses, but when it's -all- you're getting then it's pretty much garbage.
Great Weapon Fighting Style treats 1's & 2's as 3's.
This works out to a paltry +0.3 bonus damage on d10's, +0.25 on a d12, and a much more respectable but still sad +1 on 2d6.
For comparison, most other Fighting Styles are worth +2 damage, and Great Weapon Master Feat is worth anywhere from +2 to +6 on most Two-Handed weapons.
The Warcraft books came out and added at least 2 Feats and 4 magic items with similar pathetic "bonuses".
Fists of Fury, 1's>2's on Unarmed and Light weapon attacks. Unarmed damage can be anywhere from a d4 to a d12.
A d4 gets a +0.25 bonus. All the way up to a +0.083 bonus on a d12. (Tavern Brawler at least gives you a full reroll of 1's, which is also kinda sad, but not +0.08 sad)
Light Weapons top out at d6. Enjoy your +0.17.
Clearcasting Feat, 1's>2's on Force Damage Spells. See Fists of Fury for damage spread per die.
Ashen Band of [whatever] FOUR of them have some form as a 'bonus'. From Most Acceptable to Least Acceptable:
Wisdom, Uncommon, applies it to -all- healing you cause. Weak, but it is the 'starter' bonus.
Destruction, Very Rare, applies it to all spell damage, also bumps Spell Attack Roll/DC from +2 to +3.
Might, Very Rare, applies to Melee Weapon damage, also bumps "set your STR" from 19 to 21.
And the worst one:
Vengeance, Legendary, 1&2's count as 3's for Ranged Weapon damage. The biggest bonus comes from using a d4 weapon, which is worth a +0.75 damage bump. But you're more likely to be using a d6 > +0.5, d8 > +0.375, or d10 > +0.3. Compare +0.75 (at best) to the _Uncommon_ level bonus _from the same item_ of a +2 damage -and- ignoring Half-cover.
Can the designers please just stop already. The bonus is not worth anything.
While you are correct that this particular ability is not overly powerful, it is worth noting that every single one of the WoW pieces of content are extremely good even if you completely ignore these abilities. Fists of Fury stacks to incredible damage on a Monk. Clearcaster is essentially "action surge nearly 25% of your Eldritch Blast turns, and likely higher if you can consistently blind folks with Hunger of Hadar." The Ashen bands provide (a) additional healing for the same resources - extremely helpful in resource-heavy campaigns, (b) a hefty +3 to attack and your saving throw value, in addition to increasing your spellcasting modifier +2 (effectively meaning your attacks and saves are +5, not to mention any skill check bonuses); (c) increasing your damage with ranged weapons, letting you ignore cover, and letting you attack at long range without disadvantage; (d) giving you a whopping 25 strength and +1 to damage roles.
While you are correct that this is lackluster for early 5.5e content created under the old design team, applying this complaint to the WoW book seems a little silly. Each of the WoW pieces of content are extremely potent, and this is just a tiny bonus on top of bonuses any player would be happy to have. It kind of seems like you are complaining about sprinkles on an ice cream sundae - you are there for the sundae and are going to enjoy your sundae either way, but the sprinkles add a nice little touch (even if an insignificant one).
You are partially correct. Most of these items/feats have more bonuses than just the
garbage"sprinkles".But I also already noted that in my opening statement.
But Great Weapon Fighting and the LEGENDARY bonus of Ashen-Vengeance are still utter trash.
If you put Vengeance's Legendary bonus at Uncommon with ignore cover, and moved the +2 Damage to Legendary, then I would feel differently about that item.
Fists of Fury is misleading. It has potential damage sure, but you need to land 3 hits to get to +3 total damage for the turn (+1 per hit). And landing all 5 hits is still only +10 total damage (+2 per hit). It is effectively the "Monk Fighting Style Feat", but a miss or two will quickly tank your bonus damage.
Clearcaster isn't bad on a Warlock, but it's still not great. You're locked into +1 INT, and you either need to be high level, and/or have a reliable way of getting Advantage to actually get use out of it. (or be content to gamble and hope for the best).
I agree about the math, but D&D is more than Math: The Game. It may not do a lot for you in terms of damage output, but it feels good when it happens. You see that 1 on the die, and get to say, but I’m a little special and for me, that’s a 2. You get that little dopamine hit and it feels good.
In games where critical fails occur perhaps, but it sounds like you are talking more damage than ability checks. It would be nicer if they were more like the halfling luck feature that let you reroll a 1 once.
The damage from the weapon die is often less then half of the total damage from a weapon attack. Is it really any more exciting to occasionally deal 7 points of damage instead of 6? For me, it feels like it might as well be a rounding error.
Agree with the ability check/test thing. Especially if you’re playing a Rogue or Bard and you’re doing something you have expertise in and you’re stated out so, barring an extremely high DC, the only way to fail is to get a Nat 1.
I think you're overlooking the experiential effect. Rolling 1s sucks, so an ability that negates that feels good. A lot of people play D&D without crunching the numbers and instead enjoy stuff like "it's almost impossible for me to roll 1s".
Designing for this mode of play is valid and needs to continue
Find my D&D Beyond articles here
This is it!
DM mostly, Player occasionally, He/Him/They/Them, Doctor, Published Scholar, Science and Healthcare Advocate, Reader, Critter, Trekkie, Gandalf with a Glock, Make it so (RIP SPS) | Archived PCs: Barbarian: Rhoc, Bard: Ravinia, Blood Hunter: Steffen, Cleric: Belora, Mjornier, Morana, Wren, Fighter: Shri'tanabryn, Monk: Cassandra, Paladin: Eirikur, Rogue: Joy, Warlock: Arkros, Wizard: Suki
Rolling 2s also sucks. At least reroll (like 2014) had an element of excitement, even if it was also objectively bad.
The Math should support the flavor/'fun'.
There was a guy in my group once that wanted to play a Fighter with a hand-and-a-half sword (Long Sword) because it had Versatile, so he could attack while leaving one hand free to grapple, or grab a ladder, or whatever, but then he'd also have the option to 2-hand it "for the extra damage". Had to explain to him that he can -say- he's attacking 2-handed, but it was always numerically better to attack 1-handed+Dueling.
(d10+GWF is worse than d8+2)
Nat 1's / Crit Fails only exist for Attack Rolls and Death Saves.
They have no special rules for Skills and (normal) Saves.
^This^
"reroll 1" is better than "1>2", and has much more excitement value (and is still always worth less than 0.5).
I don't entirely agree with you on this. IF you have a 2d6 damage roll you have a minimum of 6 points of damage plus whatever your bonuses are.
While it may only be worth 1 point in average damage, that 6 minimum gives you more reliable damage.
While true, this only has narrow use cases. Let's consider an ideal case: you have a strength bonus of +3 and are fighting warrior infantry.
So yeah, it's good there. Now, how does this works if instead our target is an 11 hp bandit
Almost nothing.
Congrats, you've just discovered the 2nd best* potential fix for GWF: "Minimum 6 Weapon damage"
1d10 gets a +1.5 boost, 7 average
1d12 gets a +1.25 boost, 7.75 average
*I still vote for "+2 damage" to keep it simple
And then you can also get into that argument about the new vicious rules, since mentions damage dice, not specifically what type of damage dice. Even something like flametounge weapons.
The other argument to be had is that even if its not Exceptionally high DPR uplift, what else are you going to use the fighting style on? There is a point where +1 AC doesn't make that much of a difference, and you're stacking other buffs to get 23+ resting AC. And AC bonus is useless to Barbarians since they don't need armor. So may as well get a minimum damage uplift on what is the highest damage scale weapon you can get.
It hasn't been brought up yet, but you also have to remember that GWF, at least, is adding onto (last time I looked into it) the highest damage martial builds of the game already. They don't need ANY boost to outperform DW builds (barring incredible setup like stacking HM, DS, Hex, and maybe a couple others over several turns). In order to keep DW builds from being so underpowered by comparison, the bonus for GWF can't really be that large.
And I mean, at least for 2d6 weapons, it's essentially reliable talent on damage rolls. Who doesn't like RT??
Which is true but not really relevant to balancing; it just means you take GWF plus another fighting style; blind fighting or defense performs better at most levels, interception performs better at low level (but has terrible scaling).
But you are back to average damage. The distinction I'm making is that you could roll two ones on the dice, add three for 5. Two threes plus the STR add is nine damage, which is why I kind of like it for a Fighter. Good minimum damage is guaranteed.
No, I am not. I was pointing out the number of attacks required to drop an enemy, which is the reason you care about good minimum damage.