Thri-kreen have four arms, and CAN'T HOLD A SHIELD WITH A TWO-HANDED WEAPON? I think they should.
A Thri-kreen can hold a weapon and a shield, two light weapons and a shield, but the minute they try to hold a two-handed one, they can't. They're not able to wield shields in their Secondary Arms, and neither can they hold any weapons other than light one.
I think it's fair they should. Here's why: First off, it's a +2 AC that other species can't do. It really helps STR based Martials, especially since right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds. It also won't make it feel broken compared to other species I feel, given humans get a extra origin feat, goliath get awesome perks depending on which one you choose, and even gnomes get advantage versus spell saves! I feel like it would make them a top contending species to play, but not outshine anyone, given it would really mostly open up new possibilities for STR based Martials again.
And example for this build, would be someone with a two-handed polearm maybe, a light or one-handed weapon, and a shield, which would open up possibilities for weapon mastery stacking, which would be awesome with the new Gladiator subclass for Fighter, and would allow builds like that to remain a bit defensive, and not super frail. I feel like this would help make Thri-kreen unique, viable, and awesome for a character concept.
Thri-kreen have four arms, and CAN'T HOLD A SHIELD WITH A TWO-HANDED WEAPON? I think they should.
A Thri-kreen can hold a weapon and a shield, two light weapons and a shield, but the minute they try to hold a two-handed one, they can't. They're not able to wield shields in their Secondary Arms, and neither can they hold any weapons other than light one.
I think it's fair they should. Here's why: First off, it's a +2 AC that other species can't do. It really helps STR based Martials, especially since right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds. It also won't make it feel broken compared to other species I feel, given humans get a extra origin feat, goliath get awesome perks depending on which one you choose, and even gnomes get advantage versus spell saves! I feel like it would make them a top contending species to play, but not outshine anyone, given it would really mostly open up new possibilities for STR based Martials again.
And example for this build, would be someone with a two-handed polearm maybe, a light or one-handed weapon, and a shield, which would open up possibilities for weapon mastery stacking, which would be awesome with the new Gladiator subclass for Fighter, and would allow builds like that to remain a bit defensive, and not super frail. I feel like this would help make Thri-kreen unique, viable, and awesome for a character concept.
Yeah, I mean..that's true, and I've made builds like that, but..it just kinda feels like "I can do everything you can, but with a shield." That's how I quote it, and well..at least I'm 5e (2014), it was outshined a lot, and other species just beat it out—but it doesn't stop it from being fun, they're my favorite race, it's just kinda sucks when the option you're picking isn't the best for what you're going for. Though, don't get me wrong, I play the Cylcer Rifle on Star Wars Battlefront 2😂. I just feel like this would help STR builds a lot, especially since all I see are DEX builds or dual wielders now, and no one using stuff like polearms.
And speaking of polearms, the Gythka is/might be one, and that's a thri-kreen signature, and I was also hoping this would help that weapon be truly viable.
I think it's fair they should. Here's why: First off, it's a +2 AC that other species can't do. It really helps STR based Martials, especially since right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds. It also won't make it feel broken compared to other species I feel, given humans get a extra origin feat, goliath get awesome perks depending on which one you choose, and even gnomes get advantage versus spell saves! I feel like it would make them a top contending species to play, but not outshine anyone, given it would really mostly open up new possibilities for STR based Martials again.
You have provided the best reason why this shouldn't be allowed. I'm looking at the last Thri-Kreen (Spelljammer) and the traits seem like quite enough, perhaps unbalanced already.
Creature Type
You are a Monstrosity.
Size
You are Medium or Small. You choose the size when you select this race.
Speed
Your walking speed is 30 feet.
Chameleon Carapace
While you aren’t wearing armor, your carapace gives you a base Armor Class of 13 + your Dexterity modifier.
As an action, you can change the color of your carapace to match the color and texture of your surroundings, giving you advantage on Dexterity (Stealth) checks made to hide in those surroundings.
Darkvision
You can see in dim light within 60 feet of yourself as if it were bright light, and in darkness as if it were dim light. You discern colors in that darkness only as shades of gray.
Secondary Arms
You have two slightly smaller secondary arms below your primary pair of arms. The secondary arms can manipulate an object, open or close a door or container, pick up or set down a Tiny object, or wield a weapon that has the light property.
Sleepless
You do not require sleep and can remain conscious during a long rest, though you must still refrain from strenuous activity to gain the benefit of the rest.
Thri-kreen Telepathy
Without the assistance of magic, you can’t speak the non-thri-kreen languages you know. Instead you use telepathy to convey your thoughts. You have the magical ability to transmit your thoughts mentally to willing creatures within 120 feet of yourself. A contacted creature doesn’t need to share a language with you to understand your thoughts, but it must be able to understand at least one language. Your telepathic link to a creature is broken if you and the creature move more than 120 feet apart, if either of you is incapacitated, or if either of you mentally breaks the contact (no action required).
If you are looking at something different with reduced traits, perhaps there is a case to be made but not starting with this version.
I think it's fair they should. Here's why: First off, it's a +2 AC that other species can't do. It really helps STR based Martials, especially since right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds. It also won't make it feel broken compared to other species I feel, given humans get a extra origin feat, goliath get awesome perks depending on which one you choose, and even gnomes get advantage versus spell saves! I feel like it would make them a top contending species to play, but not outshine anyone, given it would really mostly open up new possibilities for STR based Martials again.
See, this is exactly why I think thri-kreen shouldn't be able to wield shields. A free +2 AC to thri-kreen martials is ridiculous, and breaks the balancing factor of sword-and-board versus two handed weapons.
I think it's fair they should. Here's why: First off, it's a +2 AC that other species can't do. It really helps STR based Martials, especially since right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds. It also won't make it feel broken compared to other species I feel, given humans get a extra origin feat, goliath get awesome perks depending on which one you choose, and even gnomes get advantage versus spell saves! I feel like it would make them a top contending species to play, but not outshine anyone, given it would really mostly open up new possibilities for STR based Martials again.
You have provided the best reason why this shouldn't be allowed. I'm looking at the last Thri-Kreen (Spelljammer) and the traits seem like quite enough, perhaps unbalanced already.
Creature Type
You are a Monstrosity.
Size
You are Medium or Small. You choose the size when you select this race.
Speed
Your walking speed is 30 feet.
Chameleon Carapace
While you aren’t wearing armor, your carapace gives you a base Armor Class of 13 + your Dexterity modifier.
As an action, you can change the color of your carapace to match the color and texture of your surroundings, giving you advantage on Dexterity (Stealth) checks made to hide in those surroundings.
Darkvision
You can see in dim light within 60 feet of yourself as if it were bright light, and in darkness as if it were dim light. You discern colors in that darkness only as shades of gray.
Secondary Arms
You have two slightly smaller secondary arms below your primary pair of arms. The secondary arms can manipulate an object, open or close a door or container, pick up or set down a Tiny object, or wield a weapon that has the light property.
Sleepless
You do not require sleep and can remain conscious during a long rest, though you must still refrain from strenuous activity to gain the benefit of the rest.
Thri-kreen Telepathy
Without the assistance of magic, you can’t speak the non-thri-kreen languages you know. Instead you use telepathy to convey your thoughts. You have the magical ability to transmit your thoughts mentally to willing creatures within 120 feet of yourself. A contacted creature doesn’t need to share a language with you to understand your thoughts, but it must be able to understand at least one language. Your telepathic link to a creature is broken if you and the creature move more than 120 feet apart, if either of you is incapacitated, or if either of you mentally breaks the contact (no action required).
If you are looking at something different with reduced traits, perhaps there is a case to be made but not starting with this version.
Holy cow, that is an awesome species, why would anyone play anything else if they have that access.
They have 3 attacks, a base 13 AC. Adding in a shieled give them 15 AC with nothing else and they get 3 attacks. Wow, an unbelievable species.
...right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds
What is wrong with light weapons, why is that a bad think if you can attack three times? I can't believe there is any dex build that outshines this species. A dex build probably has to build limitations to shine at dex and then you look at this species additional bonuses.
Holy cow, that is an awesome species, why would anyone play anything else if they have that access.
They have 3 attacks, a base 13 AC. Adding in a shieled give them 15 AC with nothing else and they get 3 attacks.
Just for the record, there is nothing in there saying that they "have 3 attacks". Thri-Kreen's extra arms don't give them the ability to attack more times than anyone else.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
pronouns: he/she/they
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Thri-kreen have four arms, and CAN'T HOLD A SHIELD WITH A TWO-HANDED WEAPON? I think they should.
A Thri-kreen can hold a weapon and a shield, two light weapons and a shield, but the minute they try to hold a two-handed one, they can't. They're not able to wield shields in their Secondary Arms, and neither can they hold any weapons other than light one.
I think it's fair they should. Here's why: First off, it's a +2 AC that other species can't do. It really helps STR based Martials, especially since right now they're being pushed towards light weapons or outshined by DEX based builds. It also won't make it feel broken compared to other species I feel, given humans get a extra origin feat, goliath get awesome perks depending on which one you choose, and even gnomes get advantage versus spell saves! I feel like it would make them a top contending species to play, but not outshine anyone, given it would really mostly open up new possibilities for STR based Martials again.
And example for this build, would be someone with a two-handed polearm maybe, a light or one-handed weapon, and a shield, which would open up possibilities for weapon mastery stacking, which would be awesome with the new Gladiator subclass for Fighter, and would allow builds like that to remain a bit defensive, and not super frail. I feel like this would help make Thri-kreen unique, viable, and awesome for a character concept.
#ProKreen #ThriKreen #DarkSun #DnD #SeasonOfSurvival
Have you tried making a Thri-Kreen doing Two-Weapon Fighting as a martial w/the Two-Weapon Fighting Fighting Style, 2 scimitars, & Dual Wielder?
Don't need to alter the rules to make Thri-Kreen fun.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Yeah, I mean..that's true, and I've made builds like that, but..it just kinda feels like "I can do everything you can, but with a shield." That's how I quote it, and well..at least I'm 5e (2014), it was outshined a lot, and other species just beat it out—but it doesn't stop it from being fun, they're my favorite race, it's just kinda sucks when the option you're picking isn't the best for what you're going for. Though, don't get me wrong, I play the Cylcer Rifle on Star Wars Battlefront 2😂. I just feel like this would help STR builds a lot, especially since all I see are DEX builds or dual wielders now, and no one using stuff like polearms.
And speaking of polearms, the Gythka is/might be one, and that's a thri-kreen signature, and I was also hoping this would help that weapon be truly viable.
You have provided the best reason why this shouldn't be allowed. I'm looking at the last Thri-Kreen (Spelljammer) and the traits seem like quite enough, perhaps unbalanced already.
Creature Type
You are a Monstrosity.
Size
You are Medium or Small. You choose the size when you select this race.
Speed
Your walking speed is 30 feet.
Chameleon Carapace
While you aren’t wearing armor, your carapace gives you a base Armor Class of 13 + your Dexterity modifier.
As an action, you can change the color of your carapace to match the color and texture of your surroundings, giving you advantage on Dexterity (Stealth) checks made to hide in those surroundings.
Darkvision
You can see in dim light within 60 feet of yourself as if it were bright light, and in darkness as if it were dim light. You discern colors in that darkness only as shades of gray.
Secondary Arms
You have two slightly smaller secondary arms below your primary pair of arms. The secondary arms can manipulate an object, open or close a door or container, pick up or set down a Tiny object, or wield a weapon that has the light property.
Sleepless
You do not require sleep and can remain conscious during a long rest, though you must still refrain from strenuous activity to gain the benefit of the rest.
Thri-kreen Telepathy
Without the assistance of magic, you can’t speak the non-thri-kreen languages you know. Instead you use telepathy to convey your thoughts. You have the magical ability to transmit your thoughts mentally to willing creatures within 120 feet of yourself. A contacted creature doesn’t need to share a language with you to understand your thoughts, but it must be able to understand at least one language. Your telepathic link to a creature is broken if you and the creature move more than 120 feet apart, if either of you is incapacitated, or if either of you mentally breaks the contact (no action required).
If you are looking at something different with reduced traits, perhaps there is a case to be made but not starting with this version.
See, this is exactly why I think thri-kreen shouldn't be able to wield shields. A free +2 AC to thri-kreen martials is ridiculous, and breaks the balancing factor of sword-and-board versus two handed weapons.
Holy cow, that is an awesome species, why would anyone play anything else if they have that access.
They have 3 attacks, a base 13 AC. Adding in a shieled give them 15 AC with nothing else and they get 3 attacks. Wow, an unbelievable species.
What is wrong with light weapons, why is that a bad think if you can attack three times? I can't believe there is any dex build that outshines this species. A dex build probably has to build limitations to shine at dex and then you look at this species additional bonuses.
Advantage on stealth
Telepathy
no sleep.
The more I read the more awesome this species is.
Just for the record, there is nothing in there saying that they "have 3 attacks". Thri-Kreen's extra arms don't give them the ability to attack more times than anyone else.
pronouns: he/she/they