A lot of player hate Legendary Resistance on boss monsters, as they can say no to a cool ability they have. It is limited, but a lot of high level bosses will be succeeding on half their saves anyway. Although, there are some alternatives. Do you think these are better than the core feature?
Alternatives:
MCDM. The bosses designed by MCDM have a similar feature. They can succeed, but at the cost of something else, such as losing Hit Points or not being able to use another one of their abilities. (This is also usually limited per day).
Curse of Strahd Reloaded. All the bosses in that supplement instead have a Reaction called Indomitable, triggered by an enemy ending their turn. (Those bosses also all take multiple Reactions instead of Legendary Actions). Basically if they're under a condition or other effect (like a spell) that required them to make a saving throw to avoid, it they can repeat that save, ending the effect on a success.
The epic boss monsters in the Monsters of Drakkenheim have something similar.
Epic monsters don't get an action or bonus action on their turn (which is always initiative 20). Instead they take an epic action at their end of each player's turn, and one of those actions is always Epic Resistance that gives a flat 50/50 chance to end any effect on them.
Mike Mearls was bringing this up in his patreon. He said LR was a sort of last minute idea they had to put in because 5e control spells are too strong, and they can end up turning what was meant to be an epic boss battle into something that ends halfway through the first round when an enemy fails its hold monster save.
FWIW, in the system he’s designing (one which we’ll see next year when it releases as part of Universes Beyond) he changes them to be more in line with what Colville is doing. They can shake off the failed save, but it costs them something else. The other way to get at it would be to tone down control spells, which might be a better solution overall.
Personally, I really like that idea, as it turns the action into a tactical decision for the DM.
Yeah, something like Legendary Resistance does seem to be necessary to prevent boss fights from getting shut down by one control spell. Not perfect, but on average I think it keeps things balanced. You just have to go in expecting that getting them to fail a save will be harder, just like most everything else in the combat. You have to burn through their resistances before you can shut them down.
That said, I am quite open to slightly different systems of mitigated effects. Like having some homebrewed resistances to effects. One DM said he wanted to make his bosses immune to stun due to my Monk's Stunning Strike, even though this is a 2024 Monk who could only attempt once a turn. It's a weaker effect, only being one round, but it is enough to really tilt the fight if the boss gets stunned. But that just negates a core feature of my build, so we negotiated that upon a fail, it would just lose one part of its action economy or something. That way, your action has a real effect, but the boss still feels like a boss by shrugging some of it off and still being able to function.
So with problems like that, a boss is by themselves on an island, often because DM puts all their energy into that one character for dramatic effect. I think more often than not, boss fights need other factors to keep it competitive, like a combo of minions, lieutenants, and lair/environmental factors that keep players on their toes and less able to focus fire.
I personally think that Legendary Resistances as an patch for Hypnotic Pattern, Wall of Force & Forcecage is patently absurd. Just give charm(& frighten) immunity & a property that makes them un-imprisonable short of using the 9th-level spell Imprisonment if you overtuned your spells.
Mearls's fundamental deliberate blunders when he was lead creative are immeasurable.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
I'd prefer it if rather than an automatic success, legendary resistance was just a reroll (spending multiple of them on the same roll would be fine). There would of course have to be more of them available to balance things out.
I think this gets at the question of magic and specifically control features in the D&D world. I would not favor blanket immunities I don't think. Cuz like is control a part of this magical world or not? It feels pretty cheesy to by fiat have things that just don't apply to the toughest fights. I'd rather keep or rework Legendary Resistance while mitigating control's effect (similar to damage resistance). Obviously the latter could be tougher to itemize, but I find my DMs mostly homebrew and customize their big bads anyway.
For what it's worth, I feel the same way about control spells & abilities versus players. Losing agency is one of my least favorite moments, and no one wants players just sitting there. However, to ensure none of that happens, you'd effectively just have to skip a whole aspect of the game. Which just feels, I dunno, kinda goofy. Better to have the risk and the challenge, ideally if there is some way to undo it: like an effect that one of your party members can cure, but also as few no-save abilities/spells that completely shut someone down as possible.
For control spells & abilities to matter, we just have to accept that sometimes bosses and players alike will lose their saves. Because magic. I think we can accept that there will be big moments spread across combats. Big bosses should be able to absorb some of these control effects, but not all of them, IMHO.
Legendary resistance is a patch to prevent stunlocking bosses. I don't particularly like them; in general if I'm designing a boss I will make LR not free. There are a couple of ways of doing this. The easiest method with existing bosses is to just add two new traits:
Legendary Recovery: spend two legendary actions or a use of legendary resistance to remove any number of status effects.
Legendary Survival: if killed or reduced to 0 hp, spend a use of legendary resistance to instead have HP set to (CR*2).
This means there's always a point to using up the boss's legendary resistance (as if you don't, they get spend on legendary survival), and deals with no-save status effects that LR doesn't help against to start with.
Legendary Resistance is a good ability. It prevents first-round nova tactics from taking down a boss monster before it can act without giving it a bunch of immunities that shut down the tactical options of characters.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
Legendary Resistance is a good ability. It prevents first-round nova tactics from taking down a boss monster before it can act without giving it a bunch of immunities that shut down the tactical options of characters.
Well, sort of. The problem with LR is that just telling people "nope, your special trick did nothing at all" isn't a great experience. It's not great even when they just succeed at a roll, but if there's LR in there you have a choice of "don't even bother with things that require saves" or "spam save-or-suck to eat up all of its LR", as opposed to having a mixture of tactics still be worthwhile.
You can still toss out mid-tier spells and effects that force the monster to have to consider whether or not to use the ability when the Wizard casts Slow on it or choose to hold a use of Legendary Resistance in reserve in case they try casting Hold Monster later. That honestly adds a pretty strong tactical consideration to the game that simply giving it immunity to paralysis or a higher Wisdom save does not.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
You can still toss out mid-tier spells and effects that force the monster to have to consider whether or not to use the ability when the Wizard casts Slow on it or choose to hold a use of Legendary Resistance in reserve in case they try casting Hold Monster later.
Often you're better off just using damage at that point. You certainly can grind away legendary resistance, but it tends to be "either focus on save or suck, or focus on damage".
You can still toss out mid-tier spells and effects that force the monster to have to consider whether or not to use the ability when the Wizard casts Slow on it or choose to hold a use of Legendary Resistance in reserve in case they try casting Hold Monster later.
Often you're better off just using damage at that point. You certainly can grind away legendary resistance, but it tends to be "either focus on save or suck, or focus on damage".
Thus encouraging party coordination and tactical play. Sounds like a feature, not a bug.
At the end of the day, you can't have meaningfully debilitating effects without some way for powerful enemies to say "no" to them unless you're okay with the enemies not seeming powerful when they get stunlocked throughout what should be the climactic battle. Blanket immunity is generally even more frustrating because it outright negates the point of having things like Mental Prison, Hold Monster, Stunning Strike, etc. Looking at your earlier examples, Legendary Survival just makes a fight drag on, particularly if you're sharing enough HP information that someone who thinks they're getting a chance at "how do you want to do this" doesn't get it after all. Legendary Recovery is honestly just excessively better Resistance- it's constantly reusable rather than a few times per fight, the use of Legendary Actions makes the distinction between it and LRs fairly moot, and it also wipes any low tier conditions the party has managed to tag the boss with.
I lean towards keeping Legendary Resistance, but with a cost attached, much like the MCDM approach in the opening post. A flat 'no' can feel deflating when a player has saved a high-level spell for exactly that moment, whereas losing hit points, a legendary action, or another ability in exchange keeps the decision meaningful for both sides. I also liked Frachese's reroll suggestion for the same reason: the boss still has a strong chance to shrug the effect off, but the player can see that a chance was taken rather than the result being decided in advance. Pantagruel666's Legendary Recovery idea appeals to me too, because it gives the party a reason to keep pressing with conditions instead of abandoning control spells altogether. In practice, the coordination point raised later in the thread matters most to me. If the party works together to force the boss to spend those uses on mid-tier effects, the big spell landing afterwards feels earned rather than wasted.
I mean, most players learn pretty quickly either from experience, hearing about it, or reading through monster entries that LRs are a thing and will probe a boss monster before trying their one big control effect. And rerolls don't address the actual issue of a boss potentially being sidelined in an instant and stomped on. My DM forgot all the stuff Faerie Fire does one time, and the party stomped all over a bad guy who was supposed to be making a dramatic escape. Didn't kill the campaign since he was a lieutenant rather than the BBEG, but it highlights how readily one missed save can skew a fight. If you're going to sell a high tier fantasy being, they need some ability to straight up say "no" to what enemies can throw at them, particularly in a pure dice rolling context where you can't express skill or evasiveness or suchlike more organically.
Thus encouraging party coordination and tactical play. Sounds like a feature, not a bug.
It doesn't encourage party coordination unless everyone has save or suck, or everyone has high damage; otherwise it just means "sorry, your character is not relevant because we're using a different strategy on this boss" (most bosses before tier IV are easier to run out of hit points than run out of LR).
Thus encouraging party coordination and tactical play. Sounds like a feature, not a bug.
It doesn't encourage party coordination unless everyone has save or suck, or everyone has high damage; otherwise it just means "sorry, your character is not relevant because we're using a different strategy on this boss" (most bosses before tier IV are easier to run out of hit points than run out of LR).
Let's see: any Arcane caster will have a broad selection of options, Monks have Stunning Strike, Clerics have Banish, Druids have Charm Monster, both have Contagion, several Fighter subclasses have Restrain, Stun, Charm, etc. abilities, Rogues have two debilitating Cunning Strike options. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's over half the classes in the game, and only one where subclass is a factor. This isn't some narrow and sharp limit, it's taking a bare minimum of effort to decide "okay, we're gonna run the BBEG out of LRs". Or, if that's too complicated for you, you can default to damage. Which, again, by definition means that players are presented with options and may choose the one that fits their circumstances and preferences.
Think y'all have highlighted the tension well. I've certainly felt the "sorry, your character is not relevant because we're using a different strategy on this boss" mentioned by Pantagruel, and it's not fun and should be avoided. There should be a range of degree & type of impactfulness across fights - where different members shine or are challenged, however if too much of any given character's abilities are rendered irrelevant, they cannot engage. And that is the point really - to maximize engagement whenever possible and allow players to feel their characters contribute most of the time.
That said, having just one ability minimized in a combat is much more measured - it's simply a form of challenge. That does involve less choice for that player in that particular combat, but that is the other side of the coin of prompting or forcing characters to play a little differently than they usually do, ideally prompting more teamwork as Ace of Rogues said. And I think that is fine most of the time, though in my limited experience I think it's much easier for casters to adjust because it usually means just picking another of their many spells. Martials who say, can't reach their target, may be stuck throwing javelins instead of engaging with a well-designed melee build. A boss fight with more targets, a mcguffin, or other variations goes a long way to making this feel less bad.
LRs, while not perfect, are a fine default because they don't target anyone and of course are not inexhaustible. I'm not sure it should feel that deflating to use an ability to burn through 1 of usually 3 LRs, anymore than dealing 30 damage not killing a boss should feel deflating. It's progress. Again, I think people are getting caught up in the nature of save or suck abilities: they are inherently not incremental the way damage is, because they kind of have to have greater value on a win since you get zero value otherwise. But that greater value and impact could be a combat-ender, which is less fun gameplay and breaks some immersion for storytelling a big boss. Hence some barriers like LR. Re-rolls I don't think cut it, as all they do is lessen the % they will fail, but if they fail, it's the same combat-ending result.
I've found this to be less of a problem in campaigns that have more frequent combats, because it allows for more variation between combats. I think it's okay for bosses to fail more dramatically than intended once and a while. It respects freedom & agency of players. Ace of Rogues' example of the would-be escapee illustrates this I think. From a 10,000-ft. game design perspective, you want to create longer-lasting boss fights most of the time, but also a world where player choices matter. If they figure out a way to defeat a boss, then hats off to em. It makes sense that not all fights would be perfectly balanced. If the story crumbles because a boss is caught when the DM wanted them to escape, then either the story needs work, or the boss' ability to escape needs work.
But that should be the exception to the rule. LRs ensure the resiliency of bosses and by extension the quality of the fight.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
A lot of player hate Legendary Resistance on boss monsters, as they can say no to a cool ability they have. It is limited, but a lot of high level bosses will be succeeding on half their saves anyway. Although, there are some alternatives. Do you think these are better than the core feature?
Alternatives:
MCDM. The bosses designed by MCDM have a similar feature. They can succeed, but at the cost of something else, such as losing Hit Points or not being able to use another one of their abilities. (This is also usually limited per day).
Curse of Strahd Reloaded. All the bosses in that supplement instead have a Reaction called Indomitable, triggered by an enemy ending their turn. (Those bosses also all take multiple Reactions instead of Legendary Actions). Basically if they're under a condition or other effect (like a spell) that required them to make a saving throw to avoid, it they can repeat that save, ending the effect on a success.
So what do you think?
The epic boss monsters in the Monsters of Drakkenheim have something similar.
Epic monsters don't get an action or bonus action on their turn (which is always initiative 20). Instead they take an epic action at their end of each player's turn, and one of those actions is always Epic Resistance that gives a flat 50/50 chance to end any effect on them.
Mike Mearls was bringing this up in his patreon. He said LR was a sort of last minute idea they had to put in because 5e control spells are too strong, and they can end up turning what was meant to be an epic boss battle into something that ends halfway through the first round when an enemy fails its hold monster save.
FWIW, in the system he’s designing (one which we’ll see next year when it releases as part of Universes Beyond) he changes them to be more in line with what Colville is doing. They can shake off the failed save, but it costs them something else. The other way to get at it would be to tone down control spells, which might be a better solution overall.
Personally, I really like that idea, as it turns the action into a tactical decision for the DM.
Yeah, something like Legendary Resistance does seem to be necessary to prevent boss fights from getting shut down by one control spell. Not perfect, but on average I think it keeps things balanced. You just have to go in expecting that getting them to fail a save will be harder, just like most everything else in the combat. You have to burn through their resistances before you can shut them down.
That said, I am quite open to slightly different systems of mitigated effects. Like having some homebrewed resistances to effects. One DM said he wanted to make his bosses immune to stun due to my Monk's Stunning Strike, even though this is a 2024 Monk who could only attempt once a turn. It's a weaker effect, only being one round, but it is enough to really tilt the fight if the boss gets stunned. But that just negates a core feature of my build, so we negotiated that upon a fail, it would just lose one part of its action economy or something. That way, your action has a real effect, but the boss still feels like a boss by shrugging some of it off and still being able to function.
So with problems like that, a boss is by themselves on an island, often because DM puts all their energy into that one character for dramatic effect. I think more often than not, boss fights need other factors to keep it competitive, like a combo of minions, lieutenants, and lair/environmental factors that keep players on their toes and less able to focus fire.
I personally think that Legendary Resistances as an patch for Hypnotic Pattern, Wall of Force & Forcecage is patently absurd. Just give charm(& frighten) immunity & a property that makes them un-imprisonable short of using the 9th-level spell Imprisonment if you overtuned your spells.
Mearls's fundamental deliberate blunders when he was lead creative are immeasurable.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
I'd prefer it if rather than an automatic success, legendary resistance was just a reroll (spending multiple of them on the same roll would be fine). There would of course have to be more of them available to balance things out.
I think this gets at the question of magic and specifically control features in the D&D world. I would not favor blanket immunities I don't think. Cuz like is control a part of this magical world or not? It feels pretty cheesy to by fiat have things that just don't apply to the toughest fights. I'd rather keep or rework Legendary Resistance while mitigating control's effect (similar to damage resistance). Obviously the latter could be tougher to itemize, but I find my DMs mostly homebrew and customize their big bads anyway.
For what it's worth, I feel the same way about control spells & abilities versus players. Losing agency is one of my least favorite moments, and no one wants players just sitting there. However, to ensure none of that happens, you'd effectively just have to skip a whole aspect of the game. Which just feels, I dunno, kinda goofy. Better to have the risk and the challenge, ideally if there is some way to undo it: like an effect that one of your party members can cure, but also as few no-save abilities/spells that completely shut someone down as possible.
For control spells & abilities to matter, we just have to accept that sometimes bosses and players alike will lose their saves. Because magic. I think we can accept that there will be big moments spread across combats. Big bosses should be able to absorb some of these control effects, but not all of them, IMHO.
Legendary resistance is a patch to prevent stunlocking bosses. I don't particularly like them; in general if I'm designing a boss I will make LR not free. There are a couple of ways of doing this. The easiest method with existing bosses is to just add two new traits:
This means there's always a point to using up the boss's legendary resistance (as if you don't, they get spend on legendary survival), and deals with no-save status effects that LR doesn't help against to start with.
Legendary Resistance is a good ability. It prevents first-round nova tactics from taking down a boss monster before it can act without giving it a bunch of immunities that shut down the tactical options of characters.
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
Well, sort of. The problem with LR is that just telling people "nope, your special trick did nothing at all" isn't a great experience. It's not great even when they just succeed at a roll, but if there's LR in there you have a choice of "don't even bother with things that require saves" or "spam save-or-suck to eat up all of its LR", as opposed to having a mixture of tactics still be worthwhile.
You can still toss out mid-tier spells and effects that force the monster to have to consider whether or not to use the ability when the Wizard casts Slow on it or choose to hold a use of Legendary Resistance in reserve in case they try casting Hold Monster later. That honestly adds a pretty strong tactical consideration to the game that simply giving it immunity to paralysis or a higher Wisdom save does not.
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
Often you're better off just using damage at that point. You certainly can grind away legendary resistance, but it tends to be "either focus on save or suck, or focus on damage".
Thus encouraging party coordination and tactical play. Sounds like a feature, not a bug.
At the end of the day, you can't have meaningfully debilitating effects without some way for powerful enemies to say "no" to them unless you're okay with the enemies not seeming powerful when they get stunlocked throughout what should be the climactic battle. Blanket immunity is generally even more frustrating because it outright negates the point of having things like Mental Prison, Hold Monster, Stunning Strike, etc. Looking at your earlier examples, Legendary Survival just makes a fight drag on, particularly if you're sharing enough HP information that someone who thinks they're getting a chance at "how do you want to do this" doesn't get it after all. Legendary Recovery is honestly just excessively better Resistance- it's constantly reusable rather than a few times per fight, the use of Legendary Actions makes the distinction between it and LRs fairly moot, and it also wipes any low tier conditions the party has managed to tag the boss with.
I lean towards keeping Legendary Resistance, but with a cost attached, much like the MCDM approach in the opening post. A flat 'no' can feel deflating when a player has saved a high-level spell for exactly that moment, whereas losing hit points, a legendary action, or another ability in exchange keeps the decision meaningful for both sides. I also liked Frachese's reroll suggestion for the same reason: the boss still has a strong chance to shrug the effect off, but the player can see that a chance was taken rather than the result being decided in advance. Pantagruel666's Legendary Recovery idea appeals to me too, because it gives the party a reason to keep pressing with conditions instead of abandoning control spells altogether. In practice, the coordination point raised later in the thread matters most to me. If the party works together to force the boss to spend those uses on mid-tier effects, the big spell landing afterwards feels earned rather than wasted.
I mean, most players learn pretty quickly either from experience, hearing about it, or reading through monster entries that LRs are a thing and will probe a boss monster before trying their one big control effect. And rerolls don't address the actual issue of a boss potentially being sidelined in an instant and stomped on. My DM forgot all the stuff Faerie Fire does one time, and the party stomped all over a bad guy who was supposed to be making a dramatic escape. Didn't kill the campaign since he was a lieutenant rather than the BBEG, but it highlights how readily one missed save can skew a fight. If you're going to sell a high tier fantasy being, they need some ability to straight up say "no" to what enemies can throw at them, particularly in a pure dice rolling context where you can't express skill or evasiveness or suchlike more organically.
It doesn't encourage party coordination unless everyone has save or suck, or everyone has high damage; otherwise it just means "sorry, your character is not relevant because we're using a different strategy on this boss" (most bosses before tier IV are easier to run out of hit points than run out of LR).
Let's see: any Arcane caster will have a broad selection of options, Monks have Stunning Strike, Clerics have Banish, Druids have Charm Monster, both have Contagion, several Fighter subclasses have Restrain, Stun, Charm, etc. abilities, Rogues have two debilitating Cunning Strike options. Correct me if I'm wrong, but that's over half the classes in the game, and only one where subclass is a factor. This isn't some narrow and sharp limit, it's taking a bare minimum of effort to decide "okay, we're gonna run the BBEG out of LRs". Or, if that's too complicated for you, you can default to damage. Which, again, by definition means that players are presented with options and may choose the one that fits their circumstances and preferences.
Think y'all have highlighted the tension well. I've certainly felt the "sorry, your character is not relevant because we're using a different strategy on this boss" mentioned by Pantagruel, and it's not fun and should be avoided. There should be a range of degree & type of impactfulness across fights - where different members shine or are challenged, however if too much of any given character's abilities are rendered irrelevant, they cannot engage. And that is the point really - to maximize engagement whenever possible and allow players to feel their characters contribute most of the time.
That said, having just one ability minimized in a combat is much more measured - it's simply a form of challenge. That does involve less choice for that player in that particular combat, but that is the other side of the coin of prompting or forcing characters to play a little differently than they usually do, ideally prompting more teamwork as Ace of Rogues said. And I think that is fine most of the time, though in my limited experience I think it's much easier for casters to adjust because it usually means just picking another of their many spells. Martials who say, can't reach their target, may be stuck throwing javelins instead of engaging with a well-designed melee build. A boss fight with more targets, a mcguffin, or other variations goes a long way to making this feel less bad.
LRs, while not perfect, are a fine default because they don't target anyone and of course are not inexhaustible. I'm not sure it should feel that deflating to use an ability to burn through 1 of usually 3 LRs, anymore than dealing 30 damage not killing a boss should feel deflating. It's progress. Again, I think people are getting caught up in the nature of save or suck abilities: they are inherently not incremental the way damage is, because they kind of have to have greater value on a win since you get zero value otherwise. But that greater value and impact could be a combat-ender, which is less fun gameplay and breaks some immersion for storytelling a big boss. Hence some barriers like LR. Re-rolls I don't think cut it, as all they do is lessen the % they will fail, but if they fail, it's the same combat-ending result.
I've found this to be less of a problem in campaigns that have more frequent combats, because it allows for more variation between combats. I think it's okay for bosses to fail more dramatically than intended once and a while. It respects freedom & agency of players. Ace of Rogues' example of the would-be escapee illustrates this I think. From a 10,000-ft. game design perspective, you want to create longer-lasting boss fights most of the time, but also a world where player choices matter. If they figure out a way to defeat a boss, then hats off to em. It makes sense that not all fights would be perfectly balanced. If the story crumbles because a boss is caught when the DM wanted them to escape, then either the story needs work, or the boss' ability to escape needs work.
But that should be the exception to the rule. LRs ensure the resiliency of bosses and by extension the quality of the fight.