So i'm trying a new idea in a homebrew campaign, where there are no racial ASIs (They're all human anyway), however men get +2 STR and +1 CON, while Women get +1 DEX, +1 WIS, and +1 CHA. I'm all for race-based ASIs, but for this one where they're all human, it seems like a cool idea to at least playtest, what do you think?
In the campaign there are no non-human players and most NPCs will be human.
so where am I trying to convince others to try it, i'm merely responding to the baseless and hurtful accusations that i'm a sexist, i'm not, i was just updating people on an idea i had for a campaign, said i was gonna try it, and ask opinions, not on me, but whether it was a cool idea or no. People obviously think it's not, it's whatever i don't really care, im still gonna play it at least once. and I repeatedly told others they don't have to play it if they don't want to, but you guys don't seem to care. peace out.
So i'm trying a new idea in a homebrew campaign, where there are no racial ASIs (They're all human anyway), however men get +2 STR and +1 CON, while Women get +1 DEX, +1 WIS, and +1 CHA. I'm all for race-based ASIs, but for this one where they're all human, it seems like a cool idea to at least playtest, what do you think?
In the campaign there are no non-human players and most NPCs will be human.
so where am I trying to convince others to try it, i'm merely responding to the baseless and hurtful accusations that i'm a sexist, i'm not, i was just updating people on an idea i had for a campaign, said i was gonna try it, and ask opinions, not on me, but whether it was a cool idea or no. People obviously think it's not, it's whatever i don't really care, im still gonna play it at least once. and I repeatedly told others they don't have to play it if they don't want to, but you guys don't seem to care. peace out.
You asked for playtesting earlier. That makes it sound you want others to use this and see how it works. I have not accused you that you're sexist, you've got a ton of opinions, more of them negative than not, and you obviously care because otherwise you would drop the topic. If people are attacking you personally, settle that with Personal Messages and Moderators.
I don't care if you say that we don't have to use it, we all understood that without you saying so. We are here to fight against the concept because of character equality, explaining that this concept is offensive, and trying to get you to understand that.
If you don't care about this anymore, let it go. Actions speak louder than words. If you really don't care about what people think about it anymore and have learned what the community feels about this, let the thread die. If you keep replying and defending yourself in this thread, and not in PMs with Moderators if you feel like you have been wronged, you absolutely do care about this.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Please check out my homebrew, I would appreciate feedback:
So i'm trying a new idea in a homebrew campaign, where there are no racial ASIs (They're all human anyway), however men get +2 STR and +1 CON, while Women get +1 DEX, +1 WIS, and +1 CHA. I'm all for race-based ASIs, but for this one where they're all human, it seems like a cool idea to at least playtest, what do you think?
In the campaign there are no non-human players and most NPCs will be human.
so where am I trying to convince others to try it, i'm merely responding to the baseless and hurtful accusations that i'm a sexist, i'm not, i was just updating people on an idea i had for a campaign, said i was gonna try it, and ask opinions, not on me, but whether it was a cool idea or no. People obviously think it's not, it's whatever i don't really care, im still gonna play it at least once. and I repeatedly told others they don't have to play it if they don't want to, but you guys don't seem to care. peace out.
You asked for playtesting earlier. That makes it sound you want others to use this and see how it works. I have not accused you that you're sexist, you've got a ton of opinions, more of them negative than not, and you obviously care because otherwise you would drop the topic. If people are attacking you personally, settle that with Personal Messages and Moderators.
I don't care if you say that we don't have to use it, we all understood that without you saying so. We are here to fight against the concept because of character equality, explaining that this concept is offensive, and trying to get you to understand that.
If you don't care about this anymore, let it go. Actions speak louder than words. If you really don't care about what people think about it anymore and have learned what the community feels about this, let the thread die. If you keep replying and defending yourself in this thread, and not in PMs with Moderators if you feel like you have been wronged, you absolutely do care about this.
I don't know, i kinda like having the last word....
and let me clear it up.... i was going to be playtesting it in a campaign, not asking anybody else to. I was never trying to fight over equality or being offensive. As far as i'm concerned i wasn't hurting anybody by having an idea, or by testing it in a group of people who *signed up* for it.
Alright, I think this thread is going no where but downhill at this point.
I_Love_Tarrasques
At this point, it might be best to ask a moderator to close this thread. You have let your idea and your opinions on it be known, and likewise others have come and given you their own opinions. Some offering ideas and different mechanics to try that's in line with your idea, and others giving your their reasonings for disliking your idea and how to accomplish something that follows a similar concept of realism that doesn't line in with what they take issue with regarding the initial idea.
It's clear you wish to try what you came up with and as others have stated, if you and your table are ok with your plans then that's between you and them. I don't think the current back and forth is getting anywhere though. You aren't changing your opinion and others that are debating with you aren't changing theirs. Might be best to call it quits before things get heated.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"Meddle not in the affairs of dragons, for thou art crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
Alright, I think this thread is going no where but downhill at this point.
I_Love_Tarrasques
At this point, it might be best to ask a moderator to close this thread. You have let your idea and your opinions on it be known, and likewise others have come and given you their own opinions. Some offering ideas and different mechanics to try that's in line with your idea, and others giving your their reasonings for disliking your idea and how to accomplish something that follows a similar concept of realism that doesn't line in with what they take issue with regarding the initial idea.
It's clear you wish to try what you came up with and as others have stated, if you and your table are ok with your plans then that's between you and them. I don't think the current back and forth is getting anywhere though. You aren't changing your opinion and others that are debating with you aren't changing theirs. Might be best to call it quits before things get heated.
oof, i wasn't trying to debate or change anybodies my mind, and i wasn't aksing anybody to try to do the same to do, i was just giving a "fun" idea that i was gonna try.
also, i'm stupid, but not that stupid, i knew what was going on.
This thread has devolved into real world political discussions, personal attacks, and discriminatory discussion and language. As such it will be locked
so where am I trying to convince others to try it, i'm merely responding to the baseless and hurtful accusations that i'm a sexist, i'm not, i was just updating people on an idea i had for a campaign, said i was gonna try it, and ask opinions, not on me, but whether it was a cool idea or no. People obviously think it's not, it's whatever i don't really care, im still gonna play it at least once. and I repeatedly told others they don't have to play it if they don't want to, but you guys don't seem to care. peace out.
Cult of Sedge
Rangers are the best, and have always been the best
I love Homebrew
I hate paladins
Warrior Bovine
You asked for playtesting earlier. That makes it sound you want others to use this and see how it works. I have not accused you that you're sexist, you've got a ton of opinions, more of them negative than not, and you obviously care because otherwise you would drop the topic. If people are attacking you personally, settle that with Personal Messages and Moderators.
I don't care if you say that we don't have to use it, we all understood that without you saying so. We are here to fight against the concept because of character equality, explaining that this concept is offensive, and trying to get you to understand that.
If you don't care about this anymore, let it go. Actions speak louder than words. If you really don't care about what people think about it anymore and have learned what the community feels about this, let the thread die. If you keep replying and defending yourself in this thread, and not in PMs with Moderators if you feel like you have been wronged, you absolutely do care about this.
Please check out my homebrew, I would appreciate feedback:
Spells, Monsters, Subclasses, Races, Arcknight Class, Occultist Class, World, Enigmatic Esoterica forms
I don't know, i kinda like having the last word....
and let me clear it up.... i was going to be playtesting it in a campaign, not asking anybody else to. I was never trying to fight over equality or being offensive. As far as i'm concerned i wasn't hurting anybody by having an idea, or by testing it in a group of people who *signed up* for it.
guess what? I have feelings too.
Cult of Sedge
Rangers are the best, and have always been the best
I love Homebrew
I hate paladins
Warrior Bovine
Biology? I'm a fat guy who doesn't exercise. A lot of women are stronger than me. Really, this is the 21st century
but if they live the same lifestyle they're not gonna be as strong as you.
Cult of Sedge
Rangers are the best, and have always been the best
I love Homebrew
I hate paladins
Warrior Bovine
Alright, I think this thread is going no where but downhill at this point.
I_Love_Tarrasques
At this point, it might be best to ask a moderator to close this thread. You have let your idea and your opinions on it be known, and likewise others have come and given you their own opinions. Some offering ideas and different mechanics to try that's in line with your idea, and others giving your their reasonings for disliking your idea and how to accomplish something that follows a similar concept of realism that doesn't line in with what they take issue with regarding the initial idea.
It's clear you wish to try what you came up with and as others have stated, if you and your table are ok with your plans then that's between you and them. I don't think the current back and forth is getting anywhere though. You aren't changing your opinion and others that are debating with you aren't changing theirs. Might be best to call it quits before things get heated.
"Meddle not in the affairs of dragons, for thou art crunchy and taste good with ketchup."
Characters for Tenebris Sine Fine
RoughCoronet's Greater Wills
oof, i wasn't trying to debate or change anybodies my mind, and i wasn't aksing anybody to try to do the same to do, i was just giving a "fun" idea that i was gonna try.
also, i'm stupid, but not that stupid, i knew what was going on.
Cult of Sedge
Rangers are the best, and have always been the best
I love Homebrew
I hate paladins
Warrior Bovine
that's what you think
right. chalk it up to that.
Cult of Sedge
Rangers are the best, and have always been the best
I love Homebrew
I hate paladins
Warrior Bovine
This thread has devolved into real world political discussions, personal attacks, and discriminatory discussion and language. As such it will be locked
Find my D&D Beyond articles here