Also, shouldn't the Whistle have a checkbox for each ability that can only be used once per day?
This is a current system limitation. That's not something magic items can do.
re Whistle- I removed and readded, still adds spells. I tested it on other characters, and it still adds the spells. And I tested the +3, it also adds a leveled spell and shouldn't. 5.5e classes.
Not sure what you mean about a system limitation because some official magic items have checkboxes for charges. I can even create homebrew magic items with checkboxes.
Are you saying you expect the item to never add spells? Those are added intentionally so that players can access the details of the spell from their sheet.
As for the system limitation, magic items can only have a single pool of charges. It's not possible to give each of this item's abilities its own separate pool, which is what would be required to implement this as written.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Need help with D&D Beyond? Come ask in the official D&D server on Discord: https://discord.gg/dnd
Are you saying you expect the item to never add spells? Those are added intentionally so that players can access the details of the spell from their sheet.
As for the system limitation, magic items can only have a single pool of charges. It's not possible to give each of this item's abilities its own separate pool, which is what would be required to implement this as written.
Well, I don't expect items to grant spells unless they say they grant spells. It's not uncommon for magic items to have limitations and those don't show up in spell lists. Players have to notice the spell has a magic item listed under it, switch to inventory, click on the item and read the description. It's extra overhead and will confuse players (it already has in my game). For example, the Whistle can banish an Undead creature 1/day. The spell list doesn't tell players that, they only see the details in their inventory screen. Also, dndbeyond is giving the Banishment spell to classes that wouldn't normally have it like druids. IMO, Steam Cloud and Ghastly Charge fall into the same category. Actually, I just noticed other magic items are doing the same thing, granting spells as if they were a subclass feature. This is a bad decision imo.
re; magic item checkboxes... thanks for the clarification.
Are you saying you expect the item to never add spells? Those are added intentionally so that players can access the details of the spell from their sheet.
As for the system limitation, magic items can only have a single pool of charges. It's not possible to give each of this item's abilities its own separate pool, which is what would be required to implement this as written.
Well, I don't expect items to grant spells unless they say they grant spells. It's not uncommon for magic items to have limitations and those don't show up in spell lists. Players have to notice the spell has a magic item listed under it, switch to inventory, click on the item and read the description. It's extra overhead and will confuse players (it already has in my game). For example, the Whistle can banish an Undead creature 1/day. The spell list doesn't tell players that, they only see the details in their inventory screen. Also, dndbeyond is giving the Banishment spell to classes that wouldn't normally have it like druids. IMO, Steam Cloud and Ghastly Charge fall into the same category. Actually, I just noticed other magic items are doing the same thing, granting spells as if they were a subclass feature. This is a bad decision imo.
re; magic item checkboxes... thanks for the clarification.
I just added the Rare (+1), Very Rare (+2), and Legendary (+3) versions to my characters inventory.
When I equipped and attuned the Rare version, only Gentle Repose was added (with correct source attribution)
When I equipped the Very Rare version, Fog Cloud and Banishment were added in addition to Gentle Repose, again with correct attribution
And finally, the Legendary version grants all the above spells plus Ghastly Charge
When I click on the spell, only the spell description appears. If I click on the color words (Whistle of the Vagrant) underneath, only the spell description appears.
edit,
Same with the Scythe of the Harvest Terror (CM) which adds the Fear spell.
Contrast with ... The Wand of Lightning Bolts (DMG) adds Lightning Bolt as a spell and 'casting' it ticks off the checkboxes on the item and the casting button eventually grays out when the charges are spent. The CM items don't have those checkboxes and don't display the item like your screenshot.
Someone commented on the Occultist Overwhelming mind ability targeting all creatures vs 1 creature for disadvantage on saving throws as being incorrectly printed and implimented; the original PDF and the physical book have it as 1 creature. It was said earlier it was fixed but it's still all creatures.
Someone commented on the Occultist Overwhelming mind ability targeting all creatures vs 1 creature for disadvantage on saving throws as being incorrectly printed and implimented; the original PDF and the physical book have it as 1 creature. It was said earlier it was fixed but it's still all creatures.
The physical book is not the most up-to-date version. Also, are you going by the 2014 or 2024 version of The Crooked Moon's physical book?
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
ModeratorThese all look correct on my sheet. You might try removing and re-adding the item.
This is a current system limitation. That's not something magic items can do.
Need help with D&D Beyond? Come ask in the official D&D server on Discord: https://discord.gg/dnd
re Whistle- I removed and readded, still adds spells. I tested it on other characters, and it still adds the spells. And I tested the +3, it also adds a leveled spell and shouldn't. 5.5e classes.
Not sure what you mean about a system limitation because some official magic items have checkboxes for charges. I can even create homebrew magic items with checkboxes.
-
View User Profile
-
View Posts
-
Send Message
ModeratorAre you saying you expect the item to never add spells? Those are added intentionally so that players can access the details of the spell from their sheet.
As for the system limitation, magic items can only have a single pool of charges. It's not possible to give each of this item's abilities its own separate pool, which is what would be required to implement this as written.
Need help with D&D Beyond? Come ask in the official D&D server on Discord: https://discord.gg/dnd
Well, I don't expect items to grant spells unless they say they grant spells. It's not uncommon for magic items to have limitations and those don't show up in spell lists. Players have to notice the spell has a magic item listed under it, switch to inventory, click on the item and read the description. It's extra overhead and will confuse players (it already has in my game). For example, the Whistle can banish an Undead creature 1/day. The spell list doesn't tell players that, they only see the details in their inventory screen. Also, dndbeyond is giving the Banishment spell to classes that wouldn't normally have it like druids. IMO, Steam Cloud and Ghastly Charge fall into the same category. Actually, I just noticed other magic items are doing the same thing, granting spells as if they were a subclass feature. This is a bad decision imo.
re; magic item checkboxes... thanks for the clarification.
I just added the Rare (+1), Very Rare (+2), and Legendary (+3) versions to my characters inventory.
When I equipped and attuned the Rare version, only Gentle Repose was added (with correct source attribution)
When I equipped the Very Rare version, Fog Cloud and Banishment were added in addition to Gentle Repose, again with correct attribution
And finally, the Legendary version grants all the above spells plus Ghastly Charge
Does this differ from what you're seeing?
Find my D&D Beyond articles here
That is different. I can't reproduce that view.
When I click on the spell, only the spell description appears. If I click on the color words (Whistle of the Vagrant) underneath, only the spell description appears.
edit,
Same with the Scythe of the Harvest Terror (CM) which adds the Fear spell.
Contrast with ... The Wand of Lightning Bolts (DMG) adds Lightning Bolt as a spell and 'casting' it ticks off the checkboxes on the item and the casting button eventually grays out when the charges are spent. The CM items don't have those checkboxes and don't display the item like your screenshot.
That sidebar is the magic item description. I'm just showing that I have the item equipped
Find my D&D Beyond articles here
Someone commented on the Occultist Overwhelming mind ability targeting all creatures vs 1 creature for disadvantage on saving throws as being incorrectly printed and implimented; the original PDF and the physical book have it as 1 creature. It was said earlier it was fixed but it's still all creatures.
The physical book is not the most up-to-date version. Also, are you going by the 2014 or 2024 version of The Crooked Moon's physical book?
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.