#1 sounds like a fairly linear and short story. #2 sounds incredibly difficult to run well and might be frustrating for the players. #3 would require consent from the players because of the techy element of the AI.
I'd want to play #2 most, but only if I was very confident in the DM's abilities.
Why not while doing quests for a genie the party infiltrate the lair of Dr giant, and steal the time dragon egg that was being used to keep the AI in stasis and is now awakening, the time egg knows its use thanks and wants to be put back, and the giant wants to know how they moved the egg so is planning some experiments/ wants to get the egg back too?
We already live in a world where AI is trying to destroy the magic of creativity and imagination. Feels redundant to play that daily struggle as a D&D campaign. The time dragon campaign sounds interesting but extraordinarily convoluted and seems like it could easily go in a direction where every action the player characters take would be used against them in the form of unintended consequences. That novelty would wear off real quick. So I suppose the campaign that sounds like it would be the most fun is the giant chase through underdark. But why is it trying to dissect the players?
Underdark chase, definitely. I don't think you need to worry about consent or trigger warnings with the tech angle. I would suggest savings those for a limited number of very specific content/cases, otherwise you risk signal fatigue and people stop paying attention. But personally, I think the other two kind of sound overly complicated and very tough to follow or invest in.
I do think the Underdark chase needs more. I'm not sure I get why the worm would want to dissect the heroes. I'd have it be more story driven. Like, where are the heroes running to? What triggered the chase? Who sent the worm? What happens when they get their destination? What is in the Underdark that can hinder or help their flight? Can they only escape the worm, or can they amass power and allies to turn around and confront it?
I might suggest using the worm as context for the campaign, rather than the core of it. Like, the worm pursuing them creates an overwhelming time pressure that they can't ignore as they proceed through the story. Everything that they do, then, happens in the context of this Big Thing That's Coming. Maybe start by coming up with your Beginning, Middle and End. What started this chase? What are they trying to accomplish while being chased? What does success or failure look like at the end of it?
Feel free to ask questions!
"You remember me. Just think a little harder"
Maniacal Unseelie Nightmare Enby
She/they
If all 3 BBEG's fought who would win?
"Surely Jeff is my salvation; I will trust and not be afraid. Jeff, Jeff himself, is my strength and my defense; he has become my salvation."
Some of my hobbies include videogames, reading fantasy books, DND(Duh) and worshipping Jeff
Take a look at my homebrew races and subclasses based off one of my favorite videogame series, Remnant From the Ashes and Remnant 2.
I find the first one the least problematic, so I’d pick the giant.
#1 sounds like a fairly linear and short story. #2 sounds incredibly difficult to run well and might be frustrating for the players. #3 would require consent from the players because of the techy element of the AI.
I'd want to play #2 most, but only if I was very confident in the DM's abilities.
Why not while doing quests for a genie the party infiltrate the lair of Dr giant, and steal the time dragon egg that was being used to keep the AI in stasis and is now awakening, the time egg knows its use thanks and wants to be put back, and the giant wants to know how they moved the egg so is planning some experiments/ wants to get the egg back too?
We already live in a world where AI is trying to destroy the magic of creativity and imagination. Feels redundant to play that daily struggle as a D&D campaign. The time dragon campaign sounds interesting but extraordinarily convoluted and seems like it could easily go in a direction where every action the player characters take would be used against them in the form of unintended consequences. That novelty would wear off real quick. So I suppose the campaign that sounds like it would be the most fun is the giant chase through underdark. But why is it trying to dissect the players?
Underdark chase sounds fun to me
Underdark chase, definitely. I don't think you need to worry about consent or trigger warnings with the tech angle. I would suggest savings those for a limited number of very specific content/cases, otherwise you risk signal fatigue and people stop paying attention. But personally, I think the other two kind of sound overly complicated and very tough to follow or invest in.
I do think the Underdark chase needs more. I'm not sure I get why the worm would want to dissect the heroes. I'd have it be more story driven. Like, where are the heroes running to? What triggered the chase? Who sent the worm? What happens when they get their destination? What is in the Underdark that can hinder or help their flight? Can they only escape the worm, or can they amass power and allies to turn around and confront it?
I might suggest using the worm as context for the campaign, rather than the core of it. Like, the worm pursuing them creates an overwhelming time pressure that they can't ignore as they proceed through the story. Everything that they do, then, happens in the context of this Big Thing That's Coming. Maybe start by coming up with your Beginning, Middle and End. What started this chase? What are they trying to accomplish while being chased? What does success or failure look like at the end of it?