It is absolutely possible to be disrespectful when playing a character with a physical or mental condition, regardless of intention, especially if it's a subject you're not well versed on. Not meaning to be offensive is very different from not being offensive.
This road leads to not being allowed to play a character which isn't precisely like you. That strikes at the very heart of what a roleplaying game is.
That is not even remotely true. There is no slippery slope, but trying to claim that there is raises immediate questions as to how respectful one is actually planning to play the character.
Alright, doing this practically. Trauma is the typical trigger for a personality change, and an adventurer should regularly face trauma. I would put the DM in charge of deciding when you switch personalities, and let the player pick which one (ideally the personalities are designed to handle different stresses, and that creates a consistent logic for which one is switched to).
Not having precisely the skill you want when you want it would be the entire point of playing such a character. Roleplay that.
For practicality, I would choose a multiclass that reduces MAD in some way. ie, Cha and Dex primary classes would be ideal. That creates a logical Cha-Dex-Con build with minimal MAD. (15+2 - 15+1 - 14 - 10 - 8 - 8 ideal stat distribution, which is Dex or Cha up to you). Rogue probably makes a good first class to get enough skills to play with. Maybe one character is stealthy, one is talkative but honest, and one lies through its teeth (or intimidates the heck out of people; either is a good way to split the cha skills).
This character would work best for a story-driven rather than combat-driven game.
In other words, putting a bunch of extra work on the GM to make them deal with this custom jerry-rigged character. Thus taking away from the attention they can spend on the other players or the game itself.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
If I was in your position I'd say the bard stumbled upon an tomb where 2 dead skeletons are holding a magic item of sorts. When the bard decides to touch it they gain the voices of 2 new people, an heroic fighter who was a legendary hero in times of yore, and their mortal enemy, an warlock who wanted to unleash their master. They both died fighting over the artifact, both too stubborn to let the other win, so they both died due to overflowing wild magic or whatever. They do not know about each other being in the same body but the bard probably knows about both. However, this may create the problem of having an evil personality. A possible solution is to have them just be really petty now because they've mellowed out like this...
"What? Genocide? Why would I do that when I could steal all the porches in the village so people can't get to their doors without climbing, so all the old people can't go inside anymore due to weak knees?"
Whenever the fighter gets swapped back in they just assumes they got wasted and whenever the warlock is swapped back in they just assumes their master took matters into their own hands.
We have a version of this in our current campaign. One of our players has a Barbarian and flavors the Rage mechanic as actually transforming into another character entirely. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (cartoon style) if you will. Going beyond that would create a LOT of work for not much gain IMHO.
Good luck with your build, enjoy your games!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
That is not even remotely true. There is no slippery slope, but trying to claim that there is raises immediate questions as to how respectful one is actually planning to play the character.
In other words, putting a bunch of extra work on the GM to make them deal with this custom jerry-rigged character. Thus taking away from the attention they can spend on the other players or the game itself.
Find your own truth, choose your enemies carefully, and never deal with a dragon.
"Canon" is what's factual to D&D lore. "Cannon" is what you're going to be shot with if you keep getting the word wrong.
If I was in your position I'd say the bard stumbled upon an tomb where 2 dead skeletons are holding a magic item of sorts. When the bard decides to touch it they gain the voices of 2 new people, an heroic fighter who was a legendary hero in times of yore, and their mortal enemy, an warlock who wanted to unleash their master. They both died fighting over the artifact, both too stubborn to let the other win, so they both died due to overflowing wild magic or whatever. They do not know about each other being in the same body but the bard probably knows about both. However, this may create the problem of having an evil personality. A possible solution is to have them just be really petty now because they've mellowed out like this...
"What? Genocide? Why would I do that when I could steal all the porches in the village so people can't get to their doors without climbing, so all the old people can't go inside anymore due to weak knees?"
Whenever the fighter gets swapped back in they just assumes they got wasted and whenever the warlock is swapped back in they just assumes their master took matters into their own hands.
We have a version of this in our current campaign. One of our players has a Barbarian and flavors the Rage mechanic as actually transforming into another character entirely. Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (cartoon style) if you will. Going beyond that would create a LOT of work for not much gain IMHO.
Good luck with your build, enjoy your games!