So in the Curse of Strahd, no official stat block for Strahd is objectivly good.
His original one is outdated, and wasn't perfect to begin with. His Death House one is effectively just a worse version of his original one.
And his new Ravenloft one? A Joke.
So I could really use some decent stats for this iconic Dnd villian, so does anyone have any ideas? (Also don't suggest the Dragnacarta 3-phase one, I've read that one, and I like it, but I don't think it really suits what I'm planning).
I'd even be happy with someone just suggesting some ideas that I could homebrew. Edit: (Btw I ran one of the bosses from Flee, Mortals! And the players loved it, I'd be interested in a similar thing for Strahd). Re-Edit: I know there's already a vampire boss in that book, but I wouldn't use that for Strahd. Just doesn't feel like him.
The core problem with Strahd in CoS is that a CR 15 is something a 10th level party can beat without any special tools, but the adventure has you going around picking up special tools. The easiest to make him a reasonable challenge is to just be really harsh on leveling (against a 7th level party he'd be pretty terrifying), but the problem for answering your question is "what feels like him to you?"
A version of him with Mythic Actions would be suitably satisfying. The problem with his new Ravenloft one is that it prioritizes locking down players actions (Command as a LA, and a spammable charm ability). This is very bad for a climatic boss fight, where players will want to use everything at their disposal.
I'm a fan of the Dragnacarta stat block, but it's missing one thing I always liked about Curse of Strahd. The whole adventure is similar to a massive chess game, in a way. The party has pieces, (I.e, Ezmerelda, Van Richten, etc,) and so does Strahd. (I.e, Rahadin, the Brides, etc). This means that, on both sides, if you take out some of the other's pieces, they're "Out of Play." For instance, if you kill Rahadin midway through the adventure, Strahd won't be able to use him to track/fight/kidnap/etc the players later on. This is one of the factors that makes every campaign different, as sometimes Strahd might retain these pieces until the very end.
So Strahd is in a way, the most powerful piece on the opposing side, similar to a Queen. So I always liked the idea that once the party hit level 7-8 and got a sunlight item, they "reached Strahd's power." Once this happens, Strahd is no longer able to leave the castle, waiting for the players to come and take the fight to him, where he'll be able to use all his Lair Actions, Minions, etc, but not be able to just go up to them in a random part of Barovia and kill them.
The Dragnacarta stat block, though, just doesn't do that. Strahd is so powerful, he's basically impossible (and Dragna said this himself,) to beat unless the players are level 10, have all the relics, and about two allies. So, I'm basically aiming for a Strahd stat block that's strong enough to give the players an epic final showdown within the castle, but not strong enough so that he can destroy the players anywhere once they've reached the endgame.
That might have been a little confusing, but I think DM's who've run CoS will get what I mean.
I'd suggest here that a couple of you are missing the point of Curse of Strahd which appears in the epilogue. Strahd isn't some climactic boss fight. Even if your players drop him to 0hp, he's going to come back. Even if you give the people of the lands a way to get free, they find their way back because they've nowhere else to go. He almost should be anti-climactic. Think about any real horror film. Once you see the monster the tension often breaks.
The real bitter pill of it all isn't that Strahd is a difficult and epic boss fight. It's that removing him doesn't do anything. The players aren't killing the BBEG, they're simply trying to survive the circumstance to get home. That's their goal. Their victory is in getting back home safely, free of lingering effects like indefinite madness and with their souls still their own.
Let's clarify some stuff though:
A party facing Strahd should be no higher than level 9 by the time they do so.
The adventure likely assumes a party of 4 or 5 players (as most adventures published at the time did).
Move is an under-rated and under-utilised Legendary Action which helps place him next to the squishiest party members.
Dropping Blight on a party as they enter Strahd's Lair as a surprise attack is likely an immediate 12 hp lost to all party members. Surprise rounds are effective tools when used right and if any villain is going to get that off, it'll be Strahd. Even a rogue's Evasion doesn't trigger here so they'll be taking a minimum of 12hp here.
Strahd is a guerrilla fighter. He gets in, makes an attack, and drops out again. He doesn't stand and fight.
Strahd has anywhere between 85 and 204 hit points. The older DMs among us know to either roll the HP, or take the 144 as his starting pool with the option to increase on the fly in the event the encounter seems unsatisfying for the players.
Fighters rarely see the Polymorph coming, and their (generally) lower WIS saving throws mean that Polymorph can take them out of the fight incredibly quickly.
Lair Actions are more powerful than they seem if used in the right areas. Having Strahd move from one room to another allows for doors to be locked so that he can again get the drop on the party, or isolate the weak.
A detatched shadow can be terrifying for a squishy Wizard, or Rogue who used STR as a dump stat. A few lucky hits and that character is dead. Heck a lucky hit against a fighter, and they're suddenly less effective.
Most of the complaints I've ever heard about the stat block come down to unimaginative DMs who've just never learnt how to use a monster to their full effect. Or they've been DMs who've been overly generous with the magic items. Strahd doesn't require you to be a chess grandmaster - he's not that smart. He's a cowardly, cunning b****** who will use every advantage he can get. He'll hide, he'll take the low blow, he'll stab in the back. He'll use darkness.
I'd suggest you don't want a more nasty stat block for him, you want to play him differently.
I'd suggest here that a couple of you are missing the point of Curse of Strahd which appears in the epilogue.
Honestly, that epilogue is something I would expect most players and DMs to ignore, because "everything you did was pointless" is an annoying way to end an adventure.
I'd suggest here that a couple of you are missing the point of Curse of Strahd which appears in the epilogue.
Honestly, that epilogue is something I would expect most players and DMs to ignore, because "everything you did was pointless" is an annoying way to end an adventure.
Yeah. I always homebrew that there's a hidden path to "Dethrone" Strahd for good.
I'd suggest here that a couple of you are missing the point of Curse of Strahd which appears in the epilogue.
Honestly, that epilogue is something I would expect most players and DMs to ignore, because "everything you did was pointless" is an annoying way to end an adventure.
Yeah. I always homebrew that there's a hidden path to "Dethrone" Strahd for good.
In which case you entirely missed the point of the genre. Gothic Horror does not, and in fact should not always have a happy ending. Frankenstein for example has a terribly sad ending in the 1818 text (yes there's more than one text). It ends on what I consider to be pure heartbreak. Heck even Buffy the Vampire Slayer which ended on the high note of having destroyed the Hellmouth comes with the dual gut punch of an important character being dead and 'there's another one in Cleveland'. Success with drawbacks generally seems to sum up the genre well.
Perhaps though we're talking about a group who don't actually want to play gothic horror (or don't actually know what Gothic Horror is). Assuming that is in fact what your players want - to play 'kill the cartoon villain' - great we have a far easier start point.
Just give Strahd an AC of 18, and HP of 300. Throw in a weakness related to one specific item you've seeded in their path, and you've got your Scooby Doo villain. And to be clear, there's nothing wrong with a Scooby Doo villain if that's the genre in which you're playing. The cartoon villain is a legitimate thing and something many players want. They want the easily identifiable bad guy, and they want to kill said bad guy. I don't ever give my hack-n-slash players complex 'thinky' puzzles, because they're not there for that. They however aren't roleplaying, just like those ignoring the epilogue aren't playing in a gothic horror setting.
Which really raises the question - what are you looking for here? If it's just a more difficult to beat enemy, then stack 'em high with hit points and top up the AC. If it's a villain with more special moves and options, steal them from other stat blocks. There's never any harm with rewriting a spell list either. You can also do a lot with Resistances, Immunities, and Vulnerabilities. In fact Resistances and Immunities is where I'd start, but it's only practical for DMs who are a little stingy with the magic items otherwise the resistances all melt away by and large.
I'd suggest here that a couple of you are missing the point of Curse of Strahd which appears in the epilogue.
Honestly, that epilogue is something I would expect most players and DMs to ignore, because "everything you did was pointless" is an annoying way to end an adventure.
Yeah. I always homebrew that there's a hidden path to "Dethrone" Strahd for good.
In which case you entirely missed the point of the genre. Gothic Horror does not, and in fact should not always have a happy ending. Frankenstein for example has a terribly sad ending in the 1818 text (yes there's more than one text). It ends on what I consider to be pure heartbreak. Heck even Buffy the Vampire Slayer which ended on the high note of having destroyed the Hellmouth comes with the dual gut punch of an important character being dead and 'there's another one in Cleveland'. Success with drawbacks generally seems to sum up the genre well.
Perhaps though we're talking about a group who don't actually want to play gothic horror (or don't actually know what Gothic Horror is). Assuming that is in fact what your players want - to play 'kill the cartoon villain' - great we have a far easier start point.
Just give Strahd an AC of 18, and HP of 300. Throw in a weakness related to one specific item you've seeded in their path, and you've got your Scooby Doo villain. And to be clear, there's nothing wrong with a Scooby Doo villain if that's the genre in which you're playing. The cartoon villain is a legitimate thing and something many players want. They want the easily identifiable bad guy, and they want to kill said bad guy. I don't ever give my hack-n-slash players complex 'thinky' puzzles, because they're not there for that. They however aren't roleplaying, just like those ignoring the epilogue aren't playing in a gothic horror setting.
Which really raises the question - what are you looking for here? If it's just a more difficult to beat enemy, then stack 'em high with hit points and top up the AC. If it's a villain with more special moves and options, steal them from other stat blocks. There's never any harm with rewriting a spell list either. You can also do a lot with Resistances, Immunities, and Vulnerabilities. In fact Resistances and Immunities is where I'd start, but it's only practical for DMs who are a little stingy with the magic items otherwise the resistances all melt away by and large.
Eh. That stuff about gothic horror isn't really universal. Dracula ended with a generally upbeat ending, and the titular character of that novel was the original inspiration for Strahd. Strahd reloaded also kept a lot of the gothic horror elements in while giving that more heroic feel to it. Of course, there's nothing wrong with the true, pure gothic, original Curse of Strahd, but I think more players generally want to play a more heroic-styled game.
In which case you entirely missed the point of the genre. Gothic Horror does not, and in fact should not always have a happy ending.
The point is to have a fun D&D campaign, not to write gothic horror, and in any case gothic horror endings are usually "villain is defeated, but in a tragic way". For example, have the realm disintegrate and be consumed by the mists.
Eh. That stuff about gothic horror isn't really universal. Dracula ended with a generally upbeat ending, and the titular character of that novel was the original inspiration for Strahd. Strahd reloaded also kept a lot of the gothic horror elements in while giving that more heroic feel to it. Of course, there's nothing wrong with the true, pure gothic, original Curse of Strahd, but I think more players generally want to play a more heroic-styled game.
Great stuff then. In which case yeah I'd suggest flipping through Monster Manual. Have a look at other stat blocks and outright steal from them. I've often found that picking up a stat block and slapping a new name onto the block works far better than one I'd have come up with. Starting points I'd suggest are the Death Knight whose 2024 version has a nice Hellfire Orb. Their Fell Word Legendary Action is pretty cool feature too. If you slap Regeneration and the other Vampiric elements of Strahd onto the Death Knight I'd say you have a much cooler enemy for the party to face. With a stock AC of 20, and HP of 199 (21d8+105), it's going to be harder to hit and is going to stand up to more punishment especially with the Magic Resistance feature.
So in the Curse of Strahd, no official stat block for Strahd is objectivly good.
His original one is outdated, and wasn't perfect to begin with. His Death House one is effectively just a worse version of his original one.
And his new Ravenloft one? A Joke.
So I could really use some decent stats for this iconic Dnd villian, so does anyone have any ideas? (Also don't suggest the Dragnacarta 3-phase one, I've read that one, and I like it, but I don't think it really suits what I'm planning).
I'd even be happy with someone just suggesting some ideas that I could homebrew. Edit: (Btw I ran one of the bosses from Flee, Mortals! And the players loved it, I'd be interested in a similar thing for Strahd). Re-Edit: I know there's already a vampire boss in that book, but I wouldn't use that for Strahd. Just doesn't feel like him.
The core problem with Strahd in CoS is that a CR 15 is something a 10th level party can beat without any special tools, but the adventure has you going around picking up special tools. The easiest to make him a reasonable challenge is to just be really harsh on leveling (against a 7th level party he'd be pretty terrifying), but the problem for answering your question is "what feels like him to you?"
A version of him with Mythic Actions would be suitably satisfying. The problem with his new Ravenloft one is that it prioritizes locking down players actions (Command as a LA, and a spammable charm ability). This is very bad for a climatic boss fight, where players will want to use everything at their disposal.
I'm a fan of the Dragnacarta stat block, but it's missing one thing I always liked about Curse of Strahd.
The whole adventure is similar to a massive chess game, in a way. The party has pieces, (I.e, Ezmerelda, Van Richten, etc,) and so does Strahd. (I.e, Rahadin, the Brides, etc). This means that, on both sides, if you take out some of the other's pieces, they're "Out of Play." For instance, if you kill Rahadin midway through the adventure, Strahd won't be able to use him to track/fight/kidnap/etc the players later on. This is one of the factors that makes every campaign different, as sometimes Strahd might retain these pieces until the very end.
So Strahd is in a way, the most powerful piece on the opposing side, similar to a Queen. So I always liked the idea that once the party hit level 7-8 and got a sunlight item, they "reached Strahd's power." Once this happens, Strahd is no longer able to leave the castle, waiting for the players to come and take the fight to him, where he'll be able to use all his Lair Actions, Minions, etc, but not be able to just go up to them in a random part of Barovia and kill them.
The Dragnacarta stat block, though, just doesn't do that. Strahd is so powerful, he's basically impossible (and Dragna said this himself,) to beat unless the players are level 10, have all the relics, and about two allies. So, I'm basically aiming for a Strahd stat block that's strong enough to give the players an epic final showdown within the castle, but not strong enough so that he can destroy the players anywhere once they've reached the endgame.
That might have been a little confusing, but I think DM's who've run CoS will get what I mean.
I'd suggest here that a couple of you are missing the point of Curse of Strahd which appears in the epilogue. Strahd isn't some climactic boss fight. Even if your players drop him to 0hp, he's going to come back. Even if you give the people of the lands a way to get free, they find their way back because they've nowhere else to go. He almost should be anti-climactic. Think about any real horror film. Once you see the monster the tension often breaks.
The real bitter pill of it all isn't that Strahd is a difficult and epic boss fight. It's that removing him doesn't do anything. The players aren't killing the BBEG, they're simply trying to survive the circumstance to get home. That's their goal. Their victory is in getting back home safely, free of lingering effects like indefinite madness and with their souls still their own.
Let's clarify some stuff though:
Most of the complaints I've ever heard about the stat block come down to unimaginative DMs who've just never learnt how to use a monster to their full effect. Or they've been DMs who've been overly generous with the magic items. Strahd doesn't require you to be a chess grandmaster - he's not that smart. He's a cowardly, cunning b****** who will use every advantage he can get. He'll hide, he'll take the low blow, he'll stab in the back. He'll use darkness.
I'd suggest you don't want a more nasty stat block for him, you want to play him differently.
DM session planning template - My version of maps for 'Lost Mine of Phandelver' - Send your party to The Circus - Other DM Resources - Maps, Tokens, Quests - 'Better' Player Character Injury Tables?
Actor, Writer, Director & Teacher by day - GM/DM in my off hours.
Honestly, that epilogue is something I would expect most players and DMs to ignore, because "everything you did was pointless" is an annoying way to end an adventure.
Yeah. I always homebrew that there's a hidden path to "Dethrone" Strahd for good.
In which case you entirely missed the point of the genre. Gothic Horror does not, and in fact should not always have a happy ending. Frankenstein for example has a terribly sad ending in the 1818 text (yes there's more than one text). It ends on what I consider to be pure heartbreak. Heck even Buffy the Vampire Slayer which ended on the high note of having destroyed the Hellmouth comes with the dual gut punch of an important character being dead and 'there's another one in Cleveland'. Success with drawbacks generally seems to sum up the genre well.
Perhaps though we're talking about a group who don't actually want to play gothic horror (or don't actually know what Gothic Horror is). Assuming that is in fact what your players want - to play 'kill the cartoon villain' - great we have a far easier start point.
Just give Strahd an AC of 18, and HP of 300. Throw in a weakness related to one specific item you've seeded in their path, and you've got your Scooby Doo villain. And to be clear, there's nothing wrong with a Scooby Doo villain if that's the genre in which you're playing. The cartoon villain is a legitimate thing and something many players want. They want the easily identifiable bad guy, and they want to kill said bad guy. I don't ever give my hack-n-slash players complex 'thinky' puzzles, because they're not there for that. They however aren't roleplaying, just like those ignoring the epilogue aren't playing in a gothic horror setting.
Which really raises the question - what are you looking for here? If it's just a more difficult to beat enemy, then stack 'em high with hit points and top up the AC. If it's a villain with more special moves and options, steal them from other stat blocks. There's never any harm with rewriting a spell list either. You can also do a lot with Resistances, Immunities, and Vulnerabilities. In fact Resistances and Immunities is where I'd start, but it's only practical for DMs who are a little stingy with the magic items otherwise the resistances all melt away by and large.
DM session planning template - My version of maps for 'Lost Mine of Phandelver' - Send your party to The Circus - Other DM Resources - Maps, Tokens, Quests - 'Better' Player Character Injury Tables?
Actor, Writer, Director & Teacher by day - GM/DM in my off hours.
Eh. That stuff about gothic horror isn't really universal. Dracula ended with a generally upbeat ending, and the titular character of that novel was the original inspiration for Strahd. Strahd reloaded also kept a lot of the gothic horror elements in while giving that more heroic feel to it. Of course, there's nothing wrong with the true, pure gothic, original Curse of Strahd, but I think more players generally want to play a more heroic-styled game.
The point is to have a fun D&D campaign, not to write gothic horror, and in any case gothic horror endings are usually "villain is defeated, but in a tragic way". For example, have the realm disintegrate and be consumed by the mists.
Great stuff then. In which case yeah I'd suggest flipping through Monster Manual. Have a look at other stat blocks and outright steal from them. I've often found that picking up a stat block and slapping a new name onto the block works far better than one I'd have come up with. Starting points I'd suggest are the Death Knight whose 2024 version has a nice Hellfire Orb. Their Fell Word Legendary Action is pretty cool feature too. If you slap Regeneration and the other Vampiric elements of Strahd onto the Death Knight I'd say you have a much cooler enemy for the party to face. With a stock AC of 20, and HP of 199 (21d8+105), it's going to be harder to hit and is going to stand up to more punishment especially with the Magic Resistance feature.
DM session planning template - My version of maps for 'Lost Mine of Phandelver' - Send your party to The Circus - Other DM Resources - Maps, Tokens, Quests - 'Better' Player Character Injury Tables?
Actor, Writer, Director & Teacher by day - GM/DM in my off hours.