What changes did you or will you make to the 'Rime of the Frostmaiden'?
I'm about to begin a campaign starting with the adventure but have read that there are some significant issues with the arc.
Specifically - 1) players feeling unconnected to the towns
2) The campaign feeling like it has three major villainous groups that don't relate to each other
3) The Frostmaiden doesn't really have any impact on the campaign until the end (other than the perpetual winter)
4) The whole final adventure is meaningless to the rest of the campaign (you can beat the Frostmaiden and stop Winter in Chapter 5 leaving two more chapters...
So, what changes did you make when you played the campaign or what would you recommend/suggest to change?
To begin the campaign, I thought I'd make the Cult of the Frostmaiden more of a central player and begin the campaign with them.I also want the Chwinga's to be more than just a spasmodic comic relief in the campaign. Finally, I'm going to change the ultimate battle against the Frostmaiden to not occur until the final adventure.
Introduction
The game will begin with a mass gathering in a town during a Sacrifice Lottery. Masked cultists run the lottery, acting as guards and officials while the Town Speaker looks on grim faced. Half of the group are locked in a barred cart to the side of the assembly, caught on the outskirts of the town. At least one will be from the town or is well known in the town and stands in the crowd, while another stands on the outskirts. When the name is called, it's one of the characters in the crowd. A cry of protest bursts out from the character's family/friends, but they are quickly quietened by the cultist guards, and the character is thrown into the cage with the other characters. Then the prison carts begin to roll on to the next town (pulled by Axebeaks)
On the journey, a storm rolls in and the cultists a forced to stop to repair a wagon, the guards becoming distracted. Either one of the party who is a rogue (who has hidden lock picks) and/or another who has another viable means of escape (first option) or a NPC who does (second preference), unlocks the cage and the group are able to escape. The group may try and get to the cart that has their possessions but this hold a risk of being seen.
From here the group try and make their way through the blizzard/snow storm and run into a group of Chwinga who are pretending to eat beneath the cover of a rock. If the group are kind to them, playing along, the Chwinga become excited and then guide the group to the nearest town, also giving them a valuable gem (if they couldn't get their equipment, so they can buy starting equipment) or a 'Nature Charm'. Once at the town the group can equip themselves and begin their first adventure.
Anyway, that's my idea to begin the game to try and throw the group straight into the underlying grim theme of the campaign, to set the cult and Frostmaiden up as main antagonist (I'm also swapping the Knight's of the Black Sword for the cult headquarters), introduce the Chwinga as cute helpful allies and, most importantly, bring the party together.
To add to the above concept, I thought I could add some important NPC's into the prison cart to escape with the characters. This way, it creates an instant connection when the party meets them, and perhaps gets an adventure hook, off them later. I'm still deciding which NPC's these should be but perhaps Dannika Greysteel (Chwinga Enthusiast), Kora (Innkeeper from Bremen), Marta Peskryk (innkeeper from Termalaine), Nimsy Huddle (Halfling speaker from Lonelywood), even Kapanuk Thuunlakalaga (Goliath - perhaps in a separate prison carriage all of his own).
I think your introductions sounds cool and can work (but of course I don´t know your player characters´ backgrounds). In our group, I focused a bit more on the Arcane Brotherhood, but that was something that developed due to how my players acted. When they heard about the everlasting winter and that a couple of mages from the Brotherhood traveled there, my players thought that they were behind all of it and that Auril herself was just an illusion created by the brotherhood. So I took the story a bit more in that direction. The Chwingas also worked quite well in my group, although I didn´t use them as in the starter quest, but instead I turned the starter quest into a sidequest basically and so far, we already had two funny encounters in other quests with the Chwingas :)
So for your specific questions: 1 and 2 are exactly the same for me. I still struggle a bit with getting my players to care about Ten-Towns and their citizens. But that´s mainly due to the fact that my players act quite hostile whenever they meet someone ... But it might work if you just put in some little things here or there. Like maybe just one NPC they do like, emphasize on that, or for example, when my players completed the White Moose quest, the town let them use the hunting cabin, as most of the hunters have given up anyway and it basically stood empty. As for the villainous groups, the only one that has worked for me so far are the Duergar.
3 and 4 are something I thought a lot about (see my other thread) I will definitely not give my players any way to end the everlasting darkness in chapter 5, and personally I don´t like the idea that it can be ended by killing Aurils Roc, that simply doesn´t make sense to me. I changed her background so that Auril discovered Ythrin and the mythallar within. As my players have learned from books about Netheril, a mythallar has the power to change the weather. They also learned from the Arcane Brotherhood that Auril being a lesser goddess, she herself should not be powerful enough to deny the sun from rising, and that´s why the Brotherhood came to investigate, because some powerful magic has to be at work here. So in my campaign, Auril travels to Ythrin to absorb the power of the mythallar, enabling her to cast her spell. This also makes more sense to me why her "rime" is needed to open the passage to Ythrin. So my plan is to let the players encounter Auril in Chapter 5, but she will not bother with fighting them. She will just mock them and leave her giants to deal with them. And I want to use the Roc as the boss of that stage. She just uses her Roc to get to Ythrin and back. And when they kill the Roc, they surely will have angered Auril, who will be encountered in the final boss fight in Ythrin, right next to the mythallar.
But yes, I´m also still looking for some way to let Auril do something in chapter 2. Right now, the whole thing might as well just be an unusal harsh winter and it wouldn´t change a thing. I would like the players to have at least some kind of connection to her.
Overall, what worked well for me was to look how the group reacts to certain NPCs or factions and then maybe lean more into that. One thing I love about this module is that you have lots of options to go in different directions. The only real criticism I have is that Auril is a bit bland, and as you said, she doesn´t really matter for most of the campaign.
I'm think of making the Arcane Brotherhood a sinister enemy too. My players haven't made their characters yet but I like the idea of creating a secret where one of the characters is a apprentice or Thaylan Squire to Dzaan (Red Wizard) who was separated from him during a Blizzard and then subsequently rounded up by the Cult of Auril and placed in the caged cart (my introduction idea). I thought, when they returned to the town after escaping from the cart and cult soldiers, they would wander into a town and see Dzaan being executed. The character would know that, Dzaan came to the Ten Towns to find the lost secrets of Netheril and that he needed to discover the lost location before four Arcane Brotherhood operatives do.
I also like the idea of ramping up the importance of the Chwingas. I thought that the characters would eventually discover that the Chwinga's are needed to repair the damage done to the mythallar. I'm thinking they get a hint of the Chwinga's elemental 'healing' capabilities when they go to the Black Cabin and a Chwinga (they have befriended earlier who has tagged along) repairs the Summer Star before it explodes. I haven't figured out the specifics yet but I picture the last battle against the Frostmaiden with the Chwingas repairing the Mythallar while the Frostmaiden (or her underlings) attempt to dispatch the little creatures, creating a delemia for the group as they need to split their focus between protecting the Chwinga's and dealing with Auril.
Perhaps one of them might be an Ex-Auril Cultist (or secretly still a cult member).It would be great if one of the players play a Goliath (for the clan war adventure), a dwarf (perhaps secretly a duegar) or a Reghan Barbarian, but I think it's important I make the players like people in the Ten Towns as much as possible.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
What changes did you or will you make to the 'Rime of the Frostmaiden'?
I'm about to begin a campaign starting with the adventure but have read that there are some significant issues with the arc.
Specifically - 1) players feeling unconnected to the towns
2) The campaign feeling like it has three major villainous groups that don't relate to each other
3) The Frostmaiden doesn't really have any impact on the campaign until the end (other than the perpetual winter)
4) The whole final adventure is meaningless to the rest of the campaign (you can beat the Frostmaiden and stop Winter in Chapter 5 leaving two more chapters...
So, what changes did you make when you played the campaign or what would you recommend/suggest to change?
Starting changes
To begin the campaign, I thought I'd make the Cult of the Frostmaiden more of a central player and begin the campaign with them.I also want the Chwinga's to be more than just a spasmodic comic relief in the campaign. Finally, I'm going to change the ultimate battle against the Frostmaiden to not occur until the final adventure.
Introduction
The game will begin with a mass gathering in a town during a Sacrifice Lottery. Masked cultists run the lottery, acting as guards and officials while the Town Speaker looks on grim faced. Half of the group are locked in a barred cart to the side of the assembly, caught on the outskirts of the town. At least one will be from the town or is well known in the town and stands in the crowd, while another stands on the outskirts. When the name is called, it's one of the characters in the crowd. A cry of protest bursts out from the character's family/friends, but they are quickly quietened by the cultist guards, and the character is thrown into the cage with the other characters. Then the prison carts begin to roll on to the next town (pulled by Axebeaks)
On the journey, a storm rolls in and the cultists a forced to stop to repair a wagon, the guards becoming distracted. Either one of the party who is a rogue (who has hidden lock picks) and/or another who has another viable means of escape (first option) or a NPC who does (second preference), unlocks the cage and the group are able to escape. The group may try and get to the cart that has their possessions but this hold a risk of being seen.
From here the group try and make their way through the blizzard/snow storm and run into a group of Chwinga who are pretending to eat beneath the cover of a rock. If the group are kind to them, playing along, the Chwinga become excited and then guide the group to the nearest town, also giving them a valuable gem (if they couldn't get their equipment, so they can buy starting equipment) or a 'Nature Charm'. Once at the town the group can equip themselves and begin their first adventure.
Anyway, that's my idea to begin the game to try and throw the group straight into the underlying grim theme of the campaign, to set the cult and Frostmaiden up as main antagonist (I'm also swapping the Knight's of the Black Sword for the cult headquarters), introduce the Chwinga as cute helpful allies and, most importantly, bring the party together.
To add to the above concept, I thought I could add some important NPC's into the prison cart to escape with the characters. This way, it creates an instant connection when the party meets them, and perhaps gets an adventure hook, off them later. I'm still deciding which NPC's these should be but perhaps Dannika Greysteel (Chwinga Enthusiast), Kora (Innkeeper from Bremen), Marta Peskryk (innkeeper from Termalaine), Nimsy Huddle (Halfling speaker from Lonelywood), even Kapanuk Thuunlakalaga (Goliath - perhaps in a separate prison carriage all of his own).
Hey, I´m running that campaign at the moment (we´re in the middle of chapter 2) and I asked myself a couple of those questions as well.
I started another thread about Auril herself here:
https://www.dndbeyond.com/forums/dungeons-dragons-discussion/dungeon-masters-only/246347-pimp-my-auril
I think your introductions sounds cool and can work (but of course I don´t know your player characters´ backgrounds).
In our group, I focused a bit more on the Arcane Brotherhood, but that was something that developed due to how my players acted. When they heard about the everlasting winter and that a couple of mages from the Brotherhood traveled there, my players thought that they were behind all of it and that Auril herself was just an illusion created by the brotherhood. So I took the story a bit more in that direction.
The Chwingas also worked quite well in my group, although I didn´t use them as in the starter quest, but instead I turned the starter quest into a sidequest basically and so far, we already had two funny encounters in other quests with the Chwingas :)
So for your specific questions: 1 and 2 are exactly the same for me. I still struggle a bit with getting my players to care about Ten-Towns and their citizens. But that´s mainly due to the fact that my players act quite hostile whenever they meet someone ...
But it might work if you just put in some little things here or there. Like maybe just one NPC they do like, emphasize on that, or for example, when my players completed the White Moose quest, the town let them use the hunting cabin, as most of the hunters have given up anyway and it basically stood empty.
As for the villainous groups, the only one that has worked for me so far are the Duergar.
3 and 4 are something I thought a lot about (see my other thread)
I will definitely not give my players any way to end the everlasting darkness in chapter 5, and personally I don´t like the idea that it can be ended by killing Aurils Roc, that simply doesn´t make sense to me.
I changed her background so that Auril discovered Ythrin and the mythallar within. As my players have learned from books about Netheril, a mythallar has the power to change the weather. They also learned from the Arcane Brotherhood that Auril being a lesser goddess, she herself should not be powerful enough to deny the sun from rising, and that´s why the Brotherhood came to investigate, because some powerful magic has to be at work here. So in my campaign, Auril travels to Ythrin to absorb the power of the mythallar, enabling her to cast her spell. This also makes more sense to me why her "rime" is needed to open the passage to Ythrin.
So my plan is to let the players encounter Auril in Chapter 5, but she will not bother with fighting them. She will just mock them and leave her giants to deal with them. And I want to use the Roc as the boss of that stage. She just uses her Roc to get to Ythrin and back.
And when they kill the Roc, they surely will have angered Auril, who will be encountered in the final boss fight in Ythrin, right next to the mythallar.
But yes, I´m also still looking for some way to let Auril do something in chapter 2. Right now, the whole thing might as well just be an unusal harsh winter and it wouldn´t change a thing.
I would like the players to have at least some kind of connection to her.
Overall, what worked well for me was to look how the group reacts to certain NPCs or factions and then maybe lean more into that. One thing I love about this module is that you have lots of options to go in different directions. The only real criticism I have is that Auril is a bit bland, and as you said, she doesn´t really matter for most of the campaign.
I'm think of making the Arcane Brotherhood a sinister enemy too. My players haven't made their characters yet but I like the idea of creating a secret where one of the characters is a apprentice or Thaylan Squire to Dzaan (Red Wizard) who was separated from him during a Blizzard and then subsequently rounded up by the Cult of Auril and placed in the caged cart (my introduction idea). I thought, when they returned to the town after escaping from the cart and cult soldiers, they would wander into a town and see Dzaan being executed. The character would know that, Dzaan came to the Ten Towns to find the lost secrets of Netheril and that he needed to discover the lost location before four Arcane Brotherhood operatives do.
I also like the idea of ramping up the importance of the Chwingas. I thought that the characters would eventually discover that the Chwinga's are needed to repair the damage done to the mythallar. I'm thinking they get a hint of the Chwinga's elemental 'healing' capabilities when they go to the Black Cabin and a Chwinga (they have befriended earlier who has tagged along) repairs the Summer Star before it explodes. I haven't figured out the specifics yet but I picture the last battle against the Frostmaiden with the Chwingas repairing the Mythallar while the Frostmaiden (or her underlings) attempt to dispatch the little creatures, creating a delemia for the group as they need to split their focus between protecting the Chwinga's and dealing with Auril.
Perhaps one of them might be an Ex-Auril Cultist (or secretly still a cult member).It would be great if one of the players play a Goliath (for the clan war adventure), a dwarf (perhaps secretly a duegar) or a Reghan Barbarian, but I think it's important I make the players like people in the Ten Towns as much as possible.