Weapon (dagger), rare (requires attunement by a creature with Martial Weapon proficiency)
A finely crafted enchanted dagger designed for skilled duelists. Rather than relying on brute strength, the weapon enhances its wielder's precision, reflexes, and ability to deflect incoming blows.
Weapon Properties: Finesse, Light, Nick (Mastery)
Enchanted Weapon
You gain a +1 bonus to attack and damage rolls made with this magic dagger.
Destreza Parry
When you are hit by a melee attack while wielding this dagger, you can use your reaction to roll 3d6.
Against a Normal Hit:
- At least one 6: The triggering attack misses instead, dealing no damage and negating any effects that require the attack to hit.
- At least one 4 or 5, but no 6: The damage from the triggering attack is halved.
- All dice show 1, 2, or 3: The attack deals its normal damage.
Against a Critical Hit:
- At least one die shows 4, 5, or 6: The damage from the critical hit is halved.
- All dice show 1, 2, or 3: The critical hit deals its full damage.
A critical hit cannot be turned into a miss through this property.
Limited Uses
You can use Destreza Parry a number of times equal to your Dexterity modifier (minimum of once).
You regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.
A use is expended regardless of the result of the dice.
I also have proposed very rare and legendary versions if you guys would like a better idea of where this is going.
This is pretty good, but there are a few errors and things that I think could be improved.
First, a Dagger is a Dagger. You don't need to remind everyone what its properties are from being a Dagger, especially if you aren't going to include its damage die.
Second, rolling 3d6 and looking at all of the dice to see what particular outcome you got seems like kind of a lot to do as a reaction. One die can get similar numbers and be way easier to handle.
Third, uses and recharging for magic items are ALWAYS based on events and numbers outside of the character.
Here's what I personally think it should look like:
Destreza Dagger
Weapon (Dagger), Rare (requires Attunement by a creature that is proficient with Martial weapons)
You gain a +1 bonus to attack and damage rolls made using this weapon. Additionally, it has 3 charges and regains all expended charges daily at dawn. When a creature you can see hits you with a melee attack while you are holding the dagger, you can expend one charge as a Reaction to roll 1d8. If you roll a 1, you suffer the normal effects of the attack. If you roll a 2-5, you halve the damage you take from the attack. If you roll a 6-8, the attack misses. If the attack was a Critical Hit, a roll of 6-8 has the same effect as rolling a 2-5.
Notes: All dice rolling 3 or less has a 12.5% chance of happening, same as rolling a 1 on a d8. Rolling a 4 or 5, 45.37%. 2-5 on a d8 is a 50% chance. Rolling a 6, 42.13%. 6-8 on a d8 has a 37.5 % chance.
After consideration, here are the changes I came up with
Instead of having the number of uses depend on the character's dex score, I decided that perhaps the dex score could limit or expand the number of uses based on the dagger's rarity.
Rare - 3 maximum uses - 16 dex minimum for all 3 uses to be available.
Very - 4 max uses - 18 dex for max uses
Legendary - 5 max uses - 20 dex.
This would also work downward.
You have the legendary version with only 12 dex? 1 use. 14 dex? 2 uses. Etc.
-----‐--------------
For the 3d6 mechanic, i had designes it as a core component of the upgrade system. I hope this brings to light my thought process behind it.
Destreza Dagger — Very Rare (+2)
The dagger's magical bonus to attack and damage rolls increases to +2.
Vier Versetzen
Your heightened senses and precise reflexes allow you to deflect an enemy's attack in a manner that leaves their guard exposed.
When Destreza Parry causes a melee attack to miss, the next melee attack roll made against the attacking creature before the start of its next turn has advantage.
---
Destreza Dagger — Legendary (+3)
The dagger's magical bonus to attack and damage rolls increases to +3.
The dagger retains all its previous properties, including Vier Versetzen.
En Garde
Your mastery of defensive swordsmanship allows you to execute extraordinary parries against even the most devastating strikes.
When you use Destreza Parry against a critical hit, if all three dice show 4 or higher, the triggering attack is treated as a normal hit for the purposes of Destreza's properties only.
Resolve Destreza Parry using the original dice results, without rolling again.
- At least one 6: The attack misses, and Vier Versetzen activates.
- All dice show 4 or 5: The damage from the critical hit is halved.
The attack remains a critical hit for all other purposes. If Destreza reduces its damage, the reduction applies to the critical hit's full damage.
--------------------
My idea was that this would be a powerful tool while still requiring skill from the character, as oppose to a basic "i have wand, i shoot magic from it, recharge"
I don't want to be rude, but I don't see anything in the new version that makes 3d6 better than one die. You can get similar results mathematically, and 1 die is so much simpler than 3. You could just have a seperate die table for each rarity.
I agree that 1d8 would simplify the rolls given the 12.5% per number. There is, however, the little discrepancy with the crit nullification, it only comes to an 8.8% on 3d6 and that cannot be replicated by the 1d8 unless we roll again. The easiest thing to do if we roll again would be to add a 1d10 as the second roll (en garde) and the crit fails on a 4 or higher. While the 3d6 does the whole thing.
I completely understand the point of making things easier to understand or mechanically less complex, but I do not believe that everything should be simple just for the sake of it. Also, its more fun to roll 3d6 >_<.
Thank you again, I will take your feedback into consideration.
From my perspective, as a DM I wouldn't allow it and as a player I wouldn't want it. There is just too much going on, too many differing results based on multiple dice and too much randomness in the final result.
A simple AC boost or disadvantage on one attack per round, or granting the Defensive Duelist feat or a limited number of Shield spells per day would provide similar benefits and flavor without all the complexity. You could have it act as adamantine armor once per day to remove a limited number of criticals. Rolling dice is fun but it can slow the combat down.
But your and your table's perspective is the important one. I think we would all like to see the final version going into your game.
Fresh ideas are always interesting to see, enjoy your game!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Destreza Dagger
Weapon (dagger), rare (requires attunement by a creature with Martial Weapon proficiency)
A finely crafted enchanted dagger designed for skilled duelists. Rather than relying on brute strength, the weapon enhances its wielder's precision, reflexes, and ability to deflect incoming blows.
Weapon Properties: Finesse, Light, Nick (Mastery)
Enchanted Weapon
You gain a +1 bonus to attack and damage rolls made with this magic dagger.
Destreza Parry
When you are hit by a melee attack while wielding this dagger, you can use your reaction to roll 3d6.
Against a Normal Hit:
- At least one 6: The triggering attack misses instead, dealing no damage and negating any effects that require the attack to hit.
- At least one 4 or 5, but no 6: The damage from the triggering attack is halved.
- All dice show 1, 2, or 3: The attack deals its normal damage.
Against a Critical Hit:
- At least one die shows 4, 5, or 6: The damage from the critical hit is halved.
- All dice show 1, 2, or 3: The critical hit deals its full damage.
A critical hit cannot be turned into a miss through this property.
Limited Uses
You can use Destreza Parry a number of times equal to your Dexterity modifier (minimum of once).
You regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.
A use is expended regardless of the result of the dice.
I also have proposed very rare and legendary versions if you guys would like a better idea of where this is going.
This is pretty good, but there are a few errors and things that I think could be improved.
First, a Dagger is a Dagger. You don't need to remind everyone what its properties are from being a Dagger, especially if you aren't going to include its damage die.
Second, rolling 3d6 and looking at all of the dice to see what particular outcome you got seems like kind of a lot to do as a reaction. One die can get similar numbers and be way easier to handle.
Third, uses and recharging for magic items are ALWAYS based on events and numbers outside of the character.
Here's what I personally think it should look like:
Destreza Dagger
Weapon (Dagger), Rare (requires Attunement by a creature that is proficient with Martial weapons)
You gain a +1 bonus to attack and damage rolls made using this weapon. Additionally, it has 3 charges and regains all expended charges daily at dawn. When a creature you can see hits you with a melee attack while you are holding the dagger, you can expend one charge as a Reaction to roll 1d8. If you roll a 1, you suffer the normal effects of the attack. If you roll a 2-5, you halve the damage you take from the attack. If you roll a 6-8, the attack misses. If the attack was a Critical Hit, a roll of 6-8 has the same effect as rolling a 2-5.
Notes: All dice rolling 3 or less has a 12.5% chance of happening, same as rolling a 1 on a d8. Rolling a 4 or 5, 45.37%. 2-5 on a d8 is a 50% chance. Rolling a 6, 42.13%. 6-8 on a d8 has a 37.5 % chance.
Thank you for your feedback!
After consideration, here are the changes I came up with
Instead of having the number of uses depend on the character's dex score, I decided that perhaps the dex score could limit or expand the number of uses based on the dagger's rarity.
Rare - 3 maximum uses - 16 dex minimum for all 3 uses to be available.
Very - 4 max uses - 18 dex for max uses
Legendary - 5 max uses - 20 dex.
This would also work downward.
You have the legendary version with only 12 dex? 1 use. 14 dex? 2 uses. Etc.
-----‐--------------
For the 3d6 mechanic, i had designes it as a core component of the upgrade system. I hope this brings to light my thought process behind it.
Destreza Dagger — Very Rare (+2)
The dagger's magical bonus to attack and damage rolls increases to +2.
Vier Versetzen
Your heightened senses and precise reflexes allow you to deflect an enemy's attack in a manner that leaves their guard exposed.
When Destreza Parry causes a melee attack to miss, the next melee attack roll made against the attacking creature before the start of its next turn has advantage.
---
Destreza Dagger — Legendary (+3)
The dagger's magical bonus to attack and damage rolls increases to +3.
The dagger retains all its previous properties, including Vier Versetzen.
En Garde
Your mastery of defensive swordsmanship allows you to execute extraordinary parries against even the most devastating strikes.
When you use Destreza Parry against a critical hit, if all three dice show 4 or higher, the triggering attack is treated as a normal hit for the purposes of Destreza's properties only.
Resolve Destreza Parry using the original dice results, without rolling again.
- At least one 6: The attack misses, and Vier Versetzen activates.
- All dice show 4 or 5: The damage from the critical hit is halved.
The attack remains a critical hit for all other purposes. If Destreza reduces its damage, the reduction applies to the critical hit's full damage.
--------------------
My idea was that this would be a powerful tool while still requiring skill from the character, as oppose to a basic "i have wand, i shoot magic from it, recharge"
I don't want to be rude, but I don't see anything in the new version that makes 3d6 better than one die. You can get similar results mathematically, and 1 die is so much simpler than 3. You could just have a seperate die table for each rarity.
I agree that 1d8 would simplify the rolls given the 12.5% per number. There is, however, the little discrepancy with the crit nullification, it only comes to an 8.8% on 3d6 and that cannot be replicated by the 1d8 unless we roll again. The easiest thing to do if we roll again would be to add a 1d10 as the second roll (en garde) and the crit fails on a 4 or higher. While the 3d6 does the whole thing.
I completely understand the point of making things easier to understand or mechanically less complex, but I do not believe that everything should be simple just for the sake of it. Also, its more fun to roll 3d6 >_<.
Thank you again, I will take your feedback into consideration.
From my perspective, as a DM I wouldn't allow it and as a player I wouldn't want it. There is just too much going on, too many differing results based on multiple dice and too much randomness in the final result.
A simple AC boost or disadvantage on one attack per round, or granting the Defensive Duelist feat or a limited number of Shield spells per day would provide similar benefits and flavor without all the complexity. You could have it act as adamantine armor once per day to remove a limited number of criticals. Rolling dice is fun but it can slow the combat down.
But your and your table's perspective is the important one. I think we would all like to see the final version going into your game.
Fresh ideas are always interesting to see, enjoy your game!