Troubles in Paradise

In that case, Hansel joins in on the noggin-bopping...

Attack: 23 Damage: 8 bludgeoning plus 3 radiant damage

(Did Davis somehow block one of the attack that could hit? The one that was 20 for 19 damage? Same question to Nameless - did that 24 attack hit for 8 damage?)

The devastating attacks of the giant warrior hit hard and pushed the sahuagin away, but the opponent was by far not a jellyfish. He soaked up the heavy blows and moved after his chosen enemy again.

(Davis - AoO)

S3 vs Davis:

Attack: 17 Damage: 13
Attack: 15 Damage: 12
Attack: 15 Damage: 8

Same did the heavy armoured sahuagin 30ft above, that was fighting the nameless girl and now Yusko:

S1 vs Nameless Attack: 22 Damage: 17
S1 vs Nameless Attack: 7 Damage: 16

S1 vs Yusko:Attack: 25 Damage: 17

Hansel elegantly bludgeoned his opponent. The sharkman was probably unable to appreciate the look of his enemy, but definitely understood the language of the mace. He hissed audibly and turned from Trudie to the young cleric.

Nameless, Trudie and Yusko!

(The 20 would hit. I was going by your description of the shark-man's blade being too slow, so didn't bother to check. He took 9 damage as he has resistance to the damage, as long as it is not magical.)

Opportunity Attack: 14 Damage: 19

If it hits, the shark-man is slowed another ten feet, and pushed back another five.

(DM, I am guessing those 26s are critical hits. Can you let me know what the damage is without the critical? Davis's armor protects him from critical hits, so, while they do hit, they only do normal damage. I cannot see the individual rolls though, so cannot parse that out.)

(AoO did not hit (and I'll try to keep mechanic and RP separately). Just needed to know if Davis was bloodied at all. He was.)

Yes, 26 is crit. Without it (take the first rolled number) it is 5 and 16 pure slashing damage.

(Yep, I cannot read the rolls, just the total, mouseover doesn't work with my software. I took 2 and 8 then, thanks to resistance from the Hill Rune.)

The Nameless girl gets struck once, then twice more, rather badly.  She hisses in pain but all that emerges are bubbles.  Her Hunter's mark drops, either by pain or on purpose. She instead casts Zephyr Strike and zipping through the water she escapes from the heavily armored enemy, fleeing 65 feet. Then she turns back and fires her crossbow twice...

(First attack is Zephyr Strike, so advantage +1d8)

Attack: 22 Damage: 9 + 2

Attack: 19 Damage: 7

+6 sneak attack damage on the first one to hit. 

“My what big teeth you have…” Trudie would muse from her attackers bite. His claws didn’t get by her tough skin. 

Reaction on S2: 5 Necrotic Damage 

With another spin and flourish of her staff, the old tort would jab at her opponent before wafting a current of magic towards Davis. “You can call him Squishie, and he shall be yours.” A spectral jellyfish would appear on the big mans shoulder. “He will be your Squishie.”

On S2
Attack: 13 Damage: 9 

In Davis’ Bubble
BA: Healing Spirit lvl 4 Jellyfish Heal: 18 

Yusko took the blow and frowned.  "That will cost you..." he says as a bit of his blood leaks into the water.  "And I'll take it out of your scales."  Then is rapid succession he strikes outs with his hardened fingers jabbing bits of exposed flesh.

Attack: 14 Damage: 7

Attack: 25 Damage: 5

1 ki point spent to utilize harming hand dealing 3 necrotic damage and be poisoned until the end of my next turn.  Poison gives him disadvantage on all attack rolls and skill checks

1 ki point for 2 attacks on bonus action, flurry of blows

Attack: 22 Damage: 6

Attack: 11 Damage: 10

Hitting that scaly creature felt like fighting a rock covered by barnacles. Good thing that underwater the impact on your own hands was not harmful but Yusko felt that only one attack truly harmed the shark-man, though, harmed seriously, the enemy looked dizzy now.  

At the same time, below that scene, spectral "Squishie" gently clung to Davis's shoulder, healing up wish wound, while Trudie kindly whacked S2 with her staff. The enemy was not dead yet and continued to attack, with his eye sparkling every time a wisp of blood touched his nostrils.

Nameless girl, meanwhile, found another crack in the S1 armour and struck true. However, just like the others, even if wounded the legged fish did not look like leaving the fight.

S2 definitely was not planning to do that. Losing track of his foes he reacted to the immediate attacker and tried to bite and claws Trudie again, more viciously than before!

vs Trudie Attack: 14 Damage: 9

vs Trudie Attack: 16 Damage: 7
vs Trudie Attack: 22 Damage: 5

Hansel and Davis! (Davis is at full health again and still has one heavy armored sahuagin with 5ft of him)

Having recovered his senses a little more, Hansel continues the noggin-bopping, but this time conjures the radiant riding-crop which begins spanking the sahuagin...

Ugly Stick v S2: 24 Damage: 12 bludgeoning plus Unable to parse dice roll. radiant damage

BA: Spiritual Weapon (2nd level, to appear on opposite side of S2 to Hansel, just below S1 and to the left of Yusko)
Attack v S2: 15 Damage: 11 radiant damage

Also: Is Shield of Faith still active on Nameless? Hansel cast that in the first round

("You lose Concentration on a spell if you are Incapacitated or if you die." Hansel was incapacitated. Shield should be out?)

Davis strikes at the shark-man nearest him... < br />
Attack: 17 Damage: 9
Attack: 11 Damage: 10
Bonus action Attack: 25 Damage: Unable to parse dice roll.

Again, add 4 to the first attack to hit, and it pushes the sharkman away 5 feet. On a hit the enemy has their speed reduced by 10 feet. Also add 2 damage, from Giant's Might, for the first attack to hit.

On a hit Davis will step another 5 feet away, making the distance from him to the enemy be 15 feet, so it will have to enter his reach if it wishes to attack him in melee again.

Bludgeoning down (or up, or sidewise) the shark-people proved to be a surprisingly slow process. Whether it was a different environment (underwater did take some time to get used to) or the sturdiness of sahuagin (those that attacked the island seemed weaker) but the sea devils were still fighting. Even S2 - cut, beaten up and burned - was still ... snarling? With the fish-silent warriors, it was hard to tell.

Davis made another slashing and crashing attack, some of which got through but the enemy was not that easy to push away and stack to the giant.

Before we move on, Davis, a couple of questions:

1. In which direction do you move? Towards the others, away from them, up, down? (So far I was moving you towards the others)

2. If I am not mistaken, Glave is a slashing weapon. You get to push someone away only if you deal bludgeoning damage. With PAM it means only when Bonus Action hits. Am I right?

3. If it is "yes" to N2, then would Davis move if BA did not hit and, hence, the sahuagin was not pushed away?

Due to his patron he can add bashing damage to any attack that hits. Thus he can add it to the slashing damage of the primary glaive attack. This is the 4 damage he has been adding from his patron. He would be moving towards his companions.

Perfect. The S3 is pushed away and Davis moved to the others, closing with S2. S3 followed right away (Davis is now surrounded by two sahuagin - a dying S2 and not-so-dying S3 and got his AoO).

S3 vs Davis:

Attack: 12 Damage: 7
Attack: 22 Damage: 13
Attack: 22 Damage: 14

S1 kept slashing Nameless and Yousko trying to get each even if a little (2 1 2) :

S1 vs Yusko: Attack: 20 Damage: 14
S1 vs Yusko: Attack: 17 Damage: 18

S1 vs Nameless: Attack: 18 Damage: 8

 Nameless, Trudie and Yusko!

Was all of S1's made with disadvantage because he is poisoned?  I can tell from my cell.  Of so damn for rolling 2 20s.

Missed one disadvantage for Nameless. Here it is: 8

Davis's attack of opportunity then.

Attack: 17 Damage: 16

Already added the 4 from his patron to the damage, this is bashing damage to add to the slashing. If it hits the enemy is moved 10 feet back they way they came from, and their speed is reduced by another 10, which makes 20 reduction so far to their movement this round.

(Nameless fled 65 feet away on her last turn, I don't think she could be attacked.) 

Happy to be keeping her distance, Nameless continues firing crossbow bolts at the one fighting Yusko. 

Attack: 20 Damage: 20

Attack: 24 Damage: 15

+ 4 sneak attack damage to the first to hit.