Tibi continues to keep an eye on the pirates ready to move at a moment's notice.

As Darvin answers the man she begins an incantation. The man, and the others with him immediately spring into action as they came looking for a fight.

Initiative - Darvin 14, Tibi 8, Gilbert 7, Whistler 13, Captain 19, Bandits 13

Captain (?), Darvin (31/31), Whistler (35/35), Bandits Tibi (35/35), Gilbert (30/30) 

Darvin is quick, but the captain is a bit quicker and he suddenly throws two daggers at Darvin as he yells "5 gold pieces to anyone who helps me kill these louts!" 22

Attack: 20 Damage: 5

Attack: 10 Damage: 5

Darvin finishes his spell as the 

Dex Saves:

Captain 10

2 18

3 7

4 10

5 4

6 21

7 13

8 6

Darvin easily dodges the 2 knives thrown at him and suddenly all but one of the bandits is lit up.

None of the other patrons seem interested in involving themselves in the fight as people get out of the way.

Whistler is up

Advantage on attacks on all of the enemies except #3

 OoC: It doesn't end up mattering for this round since the captain didn't move out of the AoE, but Darvin should have advantage on initiative checks due to his rapier of warning. But it might matter next round if Darvin gets another turn before El Capitan... Second die: 21

Corrected initiative:

Darvin (31/31), Captain (?), Whistler (35/35), Bandits Tibi (35/35), Gilbert (30/30) 

Whistler is up 

Whistler sighs as they launch into combat, drawing his magic shortsword, he darts towards the nearest glowing bandit. He slashes with his short sword and follows up with two quick unarmed strikes with his off hand.

Sword Attack: 26 Damage: 11

Off Hand 1 Attack: 23 Damage: 6

Off Hand 2 Attack: 11 Damage: 8

Whistler launches forward and with a quick slash cuts the throat of bandit #8 killing him.

He then turns to #6 and delivers a couple quick punches striking with the first and the bandit blocks the second.

Bandit #2 fires a light crossbow at Darvin

Attack: 5 Damage: 3

Bandit #3 fires a light crossbow at Darvin

Attack: 6 Damage: 8

Bandit #4 attacks Whistler with a scimitar

Attack: 5 Damage: 4

Bandit #3 fires a light crossbow at Darvin

Bandit #5 rushes forward and swings at Darvin with a scimitar

Attack: 8 Damage: 2

Bandit #6 sweeps a scimitar out and attacks Whistler

Attack: 17 Damage: 4

Bandit #7 moves around the tables and swings at Darvin with a scimitar

Attack: 6 Damage: 3

Annnnnd they ALL miss!

Darvin (31/31), Captain (?), Whistler (35/35), Bandits, Tibi (35/35), Gilbert (30/30) 

Bandit #6 (6)

Tibi is up!

OoC: Wow, that was an amazing string of whiffs by the bandits!

OoC: For reference, is a check needed to leap onto/over the tables, or is it difficult terrain, or...?

I'll go with difficult terrain. 

Tibi takes his hat off and passes it to one of the ladies "It seems my services are required. Look after this for me will you and don't damage the feather!" He draws both rapiers with a flourish and  moves to where he can attack Bandit #6 with his right hand rapier (Attack: 19 Damage: 7 plus Sneak Attack of 8). If it drops he then attacks Bandit #2 with his left hand rapier (Attack: 15 Damage: 5)

Tibi wades into the fight and cuts the bandit down and delivers a followup blow to #2.

Gilbert fires off a series of magic missiles at the cluster of bandits. (I'll redirect the bolt aimed at #6, who is now dead, at the captain)

Darvin (31/31), Captain (10), Whistler (35/35), Bandits, Tibi (35/35), Gilbert (30/30)

Bandit #2 (7), Bandit #3 (4), Bandit #4 (5), Bandit #5 (2), Bandit #7 (3)

Darvin is up

Darvin retaliates at the scimitar-wielding bandit on his left (#5), thrusting a rapier in their direction.

Attack: 22 Damage: 8

He then pulls his rapier out of the bandit's flesh with a vicious twist, and prepares to parry further attacks (using defensive flourish: add 6 to both the damage and to his AC until his next turn)

Darvin's blade cuts deeply and with a flourish he finishes off the one bandit.

The bandit captain, seeing his crew getting cut down, draws a scimtar and attacks Whistler

Attack: 25 Damage: 8

Attack: 13 Damage: 8

His first blow catches Whistler in the side.

Darvin (31/31), Captain (10), Whistler (27/35), Bandits, Tibi (35/35), Gilbert (30/30)

Bandit #2 (7), Bandit #3 (4), Bandit #4 (5), Bandit #7 (3)

Whistler is up!

Whistler composes himself as he shrugs off the blow. He turns to the captain and slashes with his sword, following up with two strikes.

Sword Attack: 22 Damage: 8

Hand #1 Attack: 22 Damage: 5

Hand #2 Attack: 24 Damage: 5

Whistler hits the captain with a flurry of blows while the rest of the bandits press the attack

Bandits 2 & 3 strike out at Tibi

Attack: 10 Damage: 5

Attack: 10 Damage: 6

Bandit 4 attacks Whistler

Attack: 10 Damage: 4

and Bandit 7 attacks Darvin

Attack: 5 Damage: 5

And again the bandit's are incapable of landing a blow

Tibi is up

Darvin (31/31), Captain (28), Whistler (27/35), Bandits, Tibi (35/35), Gilbert (30/30)

Bandit #2 (7), Bandit #3 (4), Bandit #4 (5), Bandit #7 (3)

Tibi looks over his shoulder to see if the women are still watching them, gives a quick bow before re-engaging Bandit #2 (RIght Hand Rapier = Attack: 18 Damage: 10) and if that drops him switches his attack - left hand rapier -  to Bandit #3 Attack: 7 Damage: 1.

Gilbert would point his staff towards the captain and mutter an incantation before casting ray of frost. An Icy beam would shoot from the tip of his arcane focus towards the leader before the small verdan scurries away towards the northwest corner of the room.

Attack: 12 Damage: 3

Darvin thrusts his rapier at the bandit next to him, trying to cleanly finish him off before leaping up onto the table and then down again to flank the captain opposite Whistler.

Attack: 26 Damage: 9

He again goes into a defensive stance using his rapier to try to deflect incoming blows (defensive flourish for 6 to AC; technically also to damage vs 7, but I assume that doesn't matter)