(OOC - Was Silent able to use his reaction to attack the Sharkbody Abomination that entered melee with him based on his Ready action? Also unless I'm mistaken the only attack that hit Silent was Sahuagin 1's spear so he should still be standing, right? His AC is 16 and his HP was at 20, so he should be at 13.)

(OOC:  You're right, I forgot his AC was so high.  Correcting now, but Silent is still up, yes.)

As the first Sharkbody abomination approached Silent, he was able to get in his readied attack.  (You can roll an attack now.)

Attack 23 Damage: 9 

 (OOC: I dont think Keyo would have been hit either. With BladeSong and Mage Armor up his AC is 20.)

Keyo will swim around to the left of the Shark Abomination to flank with Silent. Keyo then slashes out with his dagger

Attack: Attack: 13 Damage: 7

(OOC:  Man, you all have such high AC!)

Silent's spear thrusts into the first sharkbody abomination as it approaches, severing a large chunk out of the creature's left side.

Keyo flanks the beast, and his quick dagger thrust is vicious and on target, slicing into the already wounded flesh, causing the creature to shudder and seem to issue a wordless howl through its shark mouth.

Pockets and Arael are up. I need a death saving throw from Arael.

Pockets moves up to the right side of Arael and casts Cure Wounds.

Healing her for 7.

Arael, you awake prone but alive and able to take your turn.  What would you like to do?

Arael takes out her daggers and attacks the sharkbody.

Attack 1: 9 Damage: 5

Attack: 5 Damage: 3

The previously uninjured abomination takes two quick dagger stabs, but seems undaunted.

(I believe the off-hand attack doesn't get the +2 modifier, so total 6 piercing damage.)

If the sahuagin leader does anything, you don't notice it.

Dajarkal swims up and also casts Cure Wounds, this time on Silent, healing for 4 points.  She then swims back to where she was.

Silent is up.

Silent nods at Dajarkal and stabs forward with a two-handed spear attack against Ab1 (flanked with Keyo). 

Attack 16 Damage: 8   

The spear pushes into the creature's legs, skewering a thigh before you withdraw it.

Though two sahuagin have remained at a distance, perhaps protecting their leader, three have closed in and they join the sharkbody abominations in attacking you with bite and claw:

Sahuagin 1 attacks Keyo:

Bite Attack: 14 Damage: 4
Claw Attack: 15 Damage: 2

Sahuagin 2 moves in to flank Keyo, and makes its attacks:

Bite Attack: Attack: 21 Damage: 5
Claw Attack: Attack: 18 Damage: 2

(Only the 21 hits, is that right?)

Sahuagin 3, feeling brave perhaps and seeing the healing that Pockets and Dajarkal have done, moves around and attacks the half-orc:

Bite:  Attack: 8 Damage: 2
Claw:  Attack: 22 Damage: 5

Dajarkal swears, possibly at the sahuagin, possibly at you all, but doesn't seem too badly hurt.

The first sharkbody abomination continues a frenzied attack upon Silent, massive jaws snapping shut as it bites:

Attack: 21 Damage: 9

The second creature attacks Arael:

Attack: 22 Damage: 18

Silent takes the blow, but is still up.  The attack on Arael misses.

Round Four
Pockets, Keyo and Arael, in any order
Selachai
Silent and Dajarkal
Sahuagin 1-5
Sharkbody Abominations

Clouds of red blood continue to grow where you are, and drift away into the water beyond.

(I have Silent on 5 HP, does that match your count?)

Pockets, Keyo and Arael are up.

(OOC: Silent was at 13 HP before getting healed for 4 by Dajarkal. If he only suffered 9 damage this round from the bite attack he should be at 12, right? I might have missed something.) 

Pockets attacks Sahuagin 3 to protect Dajarkal.

Attack: 14 Damage: 3

(OOC:  No, you're right.  I recounted, and he's at 12.)

Pockets, this bolt hits and pierces the sahuagin's chest.  Dajarkal gives you a look, the meaning of which is unclear.

Keyo and Arael are up.

Arael looks to Silent, and yells, Here! Catch!

She uses her bonus action to pull out the extra sahuagin spear she looted from the boat and her action to send it over to Silent.

(OOC: What rolls should I make for this?)

Keyo grits his teeth against the pain coursing through him. He slashes out at the Shark Abomination once more.

Attack: 26 Damage: 8

(OOC: @Pengwiny just a heads up, I was reading the rules for two-weapon fighting and it turns out that I'm not actually allowed to use two spears simultaneously because they aren't "light" weapons. Just in case that changes your mind about what you want to do on your turn. My bad, sorry about that! Should've dropped a message in the chat as soon as I found out.) 

(OOC: Oh thanks! NP, DM: can I change my turn?)

Arael attacks the sharkbody abomination again, this time with frostbite

DC: 13 CON

6