Pushing Kayassa behind him, Duncan will continue to do his best to [skill]dodge;block attacks[/dodge], as one more hit could take him down, just to hold the line to protect those behind him.

Orro fires again with his crossbow!

Attack: 17 Damage: 11

(Thanks for covering my turn, boss!)

Vulmar grimaces.  Duncan was still in a bad spot but at least he could help now.

He hurls another firebolt at one of the Redbrands.

Attack: 18 Damage: 2

Duncan continues to dodge all incoming attacks (One thing of note, I had mentioned that the Redbrands are intoxicated (poisoned). Basically, they will already have disadvantage on the attacks— just keep that in mind for next turn if you would like... I wouldn’t consider it too metagamey.)

Kayassa fires off another eldritch blast that flies true and hits the front Redbrand, yet the thug is still barely standing (-8hp (Total: -15hp)).

Vulmar casts fire bolt again, sending a blast of fire at the front Redbrand, but it misses and crashes into the nearby stone wall (miss).

The Redbrand takes two more lazy strikes against Duncan.  
Attack: 10 Damage: 3 and Attack: 12 Damage: 5   
Both attacks miss

Daphina throws her second dagger. 
Attack: 16 Damage: 9   
The attack takes out the severely weakened Redbrand 

Orro loads another bolt and shoots, but the attack misses by an inch or two (miss).

Duncan and Kayassa are up! Go ahead and take your actions, everyone else can queue actions for the next round as well. Bless is active on Duncan, Daphina, and Kayassa. There are two thugs left, both completely healthy. Map has been updated; what would you like to do?

"Stop and we will let you go. We don't want any more death." Kayassa says to them to try and end the fight before anymore harm is done. As she does so she will move so they are in ten feet of her and use her Fey Presence to charm them.

They need to make a dc 14 wisdom saving throw or be charmed.

Seeing Kayassa weave her enchanting presence, Vulmar watches carefully.  If one of the Redbrands succeeds against the charm, he will fling another fire bolt.

(If necessary)

Attack: 9 Damage: 9

Surprised to hear the sudden change in character from the satyr at his side but agreeing with the sentiment, as well as seeing these thugs clearly intoxicated, Duncan decides to go on the offensive, but to simply try to knock them out.

(Remember Duncan has bless, which is plus 1d4!)

Orro holds his crossbow shot for if one of the redbrands is hostile.

Daphina pulls out her swords, waiting for a sign of trouble.

Duncan lashes forward with his glaive, hitting the thug with the blunt end, but missing the follow up strike (-11hp).

Kayassa then moves within 10 feet of the two final thugs and exerts her fey presence.

Wisdom Save 1: 3 and Wisdom Save 2: 19

The Redbrand currently in the doorway fighting Duncan looks in surprise at the group, and drops his sword, but the second behind him still has a grim smirk and still seems hostile.

”Wha-what’s happening!” The front thug gasps. “Why are we fighting?!?”

The thug in the back then gives a grunt and pulls the other Redbrand back, shoving him to the ground. He then takes the position at the front fighting the party

Vulmar thens casts fire bolt again, but  it again misses the target.

The hostile but drunk Redbrand takes two more strikes at Duncan.

Attack: 14 Damage: 5 and Attack: 18 Damage: 8

But both attacks lazily swing wide and miss the target.

Daphina, Orro, Duncan, and Kayassa are up! Vulmar may queue his action for the next round as well. There is now only one hostile but healthy Redbrand, while the other is charmed and injured. Bless is also still active on Duncan, Daphina, and Kayassa.

Map has been updated; what would you like to do?

Orro shoots again, aiming for the lead redbrand. He calls out, "you could stop fighting!"

Attack: 15 Damage: 6

Vulmar likewise throws another fire bolt at the lead, hostile redbrand.

Attack: 17 Damage: 1

He also tries to shout towards the charmed man,

"Your comrade is an angry drunk!  We're just defending ourselves!"

"Yes you just wanted to relax and sleep off your drunken state. Now he just wants to keep you up and cause trouble." Kayassa says as she gathers her magic and let's another Eldritch Blast fly towards the still hostile Redbrand.

Eldritch Blast: Attack: 7 Damage: 8

Bless: 1

“This isn’t going well for you! Go down!” Duncan says, turning his attack to the remaining thug, trying to knock him unconscious.

Daphina awaits an opening, helping Vulmar while she waits.

Daphina helps Vulmar, giving him advantage on his next roll.

Orro takes a shot at the hostile Redbrand. It makes contact in the thugs stomach (-6hp).

Duncan likewise continues his assault, one of his attacks leaving a gash down the thugs chest (-6hp (Total: -12hp))

Kayassa fires off another blast of eldritch energy that crackles with dry energy. It hits the thugs square in the chest and he falls backwards to the floor, unconscious.

And with that, combat is over! There is one charmed Redbrand left. He is injured, and currently groggily laying on the floor after being pushed down by the other Redbrand. What would you like to do?

Orro looks around and tries to see who might need healing....

Kayassa will walk over to the groggy Redbrand, producing her dagger as she turns to look at the others. "Should I end it or let the town decide what to do with him?"

"Send the drunken fool away. He's no threat to us now, and likely doesn't care for the cause." Duncan says. "Though he might have some information." Duncan then walks over the lean against the wall and adds, "If we have the time to spare, I could use some time to rest. I only arrived in town this morning, and we've already fought a number of these thugs."

Orro offers to ask the Redbrand questions with Kayassa, so they might learn more about what’s going on here.