Dense fog does behave differently than darkness. The rules do make a distinction between them.
How dense fog behave differently than darkness and which rules make a distinction between them exactly?
Dense fog and Darkness are both Heavily Obscured areas, which means exactly what the Rules Glossary says that it means.
The distinction between the two is found within the rule for Line of Sight (from the DMG), which has been quoted previously. In that rule, one is used as an example of an effect which blocks vision and the other is not. It is clear that ultimately the DM is meant to determine whether a specific effect blocks vision or not on a case-by-case basis based on the text of the Line of Sight rule, not the Heavily Obscured Area rule. As a result, the best (common sense) ruling is that dense fog blocks vision and Darkness does not, because that's how it works in real life.
In Playing The Game / Exploration / Vision and Light is the Obscured Areas rules in which it explain ''A Heavily Obscured area—such as an area with Darkness, heavy fog, or dense foliage—is opaque.'' That the Glossary defines Heavily Obscured doesn't make a distinction between dense fog and darkness, nor is the omission of example in the Dungeon Master Guide for Line of Sight.
Dense fog does behave differently than darkness. The rules do make a distinction between them.
How dense fog behave differently than darkness and which rules make a distinction between them exactly?
Dense fog and Darkness are both Heavily Obscured areas, which means exactly what the Rules Glossary says that it means.
The distinction between the two is found within the rule for Line of Sight (from the DMG), which has been quoted previously. In that rule, one is used as an example of an effect which blocks vision and the other is not. It is clear that ultimately the DM is meant to determine whether a specific effect blocks vision or not on a case-by-case basis based on the text of the Line of Sight rule, not the Heavily Obscured Area rule.
"It's not used as an example, therefore it behaves differently" is an awfully thin reed to use to support a claim that the rules differentiate.
As a result, the best (common sense) ruling is that dense fog blocks vision and Darkness does not, because that's how it works in real life.
I mean, yes, but that doesn't make it RAW.
And there is no magical darkness in real life to base a common sense ruling on.
And there is no magical darkness in real life to base a common sense ruling on.
And everyone agrees that DMs treat mundane darkness as transparent regardless of what the rules say.
The point that I was making is that the rules say that the DM is meant to make this distinction, as we are all doing already.
The rules for Heavily Obscured areas (which describes areas) are silent on whether objects or effects block vision or not. For that we defer to the rules for Line of Sight in the DMG which gives us some common sense examples and it is clear that the DM is meant to make such determinations for objects and effects on a case-by-case basis.
The rules for Heavily Obscured areas (which describes areas) are silent on whether objects or effects block vision or not.
The rules for heavily obscured areas state that they are opaque, which is to say, they block line of sight. Everyone ignores that in the case of mundane darkness because it's obviously stupid.
The rules for Heavily Obscured areas (which describes areas) are silent on whether objects or effects block vision or not.
The rules for heavily obscured areas state that they are opaque, which is to say, they block line of sight. Everyone ignores that in the case of mundane darkness because it's obviously stupid.
"which is to say, they block line of sight" is an inaccurate assumption. Context matters.
In this game, an "opaque area" is defined differently than an "opaque object". While an opaque object is an object that is not translucent and therefore blocks line of sight, an opaque area is an area where you have the blinded condition when trying to see something there.
"which is to say, they block line of sight" is an inaccurate assumption. Context matters.
The rules say that they block line of sight. "The rules are stupid" is not context.
No. The context is seen when reading the entire section for Obscured Areas together instead of one word at a time or one sentence at a time to see the concepts that they are going for. Within that context, we can clearly see that the word "opaque" is being used in a manner that people are not used to seeing it used.
The section begins by describing the mechanics for Lightly Obscured areas, where the concept is that you can see things there, but not very well. Then, in contrast to that, the concept of Heavily Obscured areas is introduced in which you cannot see things there at all. In this context, this is described as "opaque" -- which differs from the experience of looking into Lightly Obscured areas.
In terms of the writing style, when the author transitions from talking about one type of area to the other, a new paragraph is started. The first sentence of the new paragraph serves as a transition from one concept to another, introducing the new concept with a topic sentence. In terms of game mechanics, this is flavor text. As such, it's not included in the Rules Glossary. Then, as is common, the topic sentence is followed by additional sentences which provide the supporting details for the concept that was introduced. These two sentences in this paragraph are not describing two different things. It is one concept written across two sentences -- a topic sentence followed by what that topic sentence means in this context. This is an incredibly common way to write.
Let's try a quick thought exercise. Let's pretend for a moment that I am correct about the writing style and sentence structure, but, for whatever reason, we still do not like the word choice. Let's assume that we are trying to describe a concept which is that you have the Blinded condition when trying to see something in the area AND that this is conceptually different from how the other type of area works. We are choosing a flavor text adjective to introduce and describe this concept. Which adjective would you use here?
"You can see things in a Lightly Obscured area, but not very well. In contrast to that, a Heavily Obscured area is __________. You have the Blinded condition when trying to see something there."
In Playing The Game / Exploration / Vision and Light is the Obscured Areas rules in which it explain ''A Heavily Obscured area—such as an area with Darkness, heavy fog, or dense foliage—is opaque.'' That the Glossary defines Heavily Obscured doesn't make a distinction between dense fog and darkness, nor is the omission of example in the Dungeon Master Guide for Line of Sight.
And there is no magical darkness in real life to base a common sense ruling on.
And everyone agrees that DMs treat mundane darkness as transparent regardless of what the rules say.
The point that I was making is that the rules say that the DM is meant to make this distinction, as we are all doing already.
The rules for Heavily Obscured areas (which describes areas) are silent on whether objects or effects block vision or not. For that we defer to the rules for Line of Sight in the DMG which gives us some common sense examples and it is clear that the DM is meant to make such determinations for objects and effects on a case-by-case basis.
The rules for heavily obscured areas state that they are opaque, which is to say, they block line of sight. Everyone ignores that in the case of mundane darkness because it's obviously stupid.
"which is to say, they block line of sight" is an inaccurate assumption. Context matters.
In this game, an "opaque area" is defined differently than an "opaque object". While an opaque object is an object that is not translucent and therefore blocks line of sight, an opaque area is an area where you have the blinded condition when trying to see something there.
The rules say that they block line of sight. "The rules are stupid" is not context.
No. The context is seen when reading the entire section for Obscured Areas together instead of one word at a time or one sentence at a time to see the concepts that they are going for. Within that context, we can clearly see that the word "opaque" is being used in a manner that people are not used to seeing it used.
The section begins by describing the mechanics for Lightly Obscured areas, where the concept is that you can see things there, but not very well. Then, in contrast to that, the concept of Heavily Obscured areas is introduced in which you cannot see things there at all. In this context, this is described as "opaque" -- which differs from the experience of looking into Lightly Obscured areas.
In terms of the writing style, when the author transitions from talking about one type of area to the other, a new paragraph is started. The first sentence of the new paragraph serves as a transition from one concept to another, introducing the new concept with a topic sentence. In terms of game mechanics, this is flavor text. As such, it's not included in the Rules Glossary. Then, as is common, the topic sentence is followed by additional sentences which provide the supporting details for the concept that was introduced. These two sentences in this paragraph are not describing two different things. It is one concept written across two sentences -- a topic sentence followed by what that topic sentence means in this context. This is an incredibly common way to write.
Let's try a quick thought exercise. Let's pretend for a moment that I am correct about the writing style and sentence structure, but, for whatever reason, we still do not like the word choice. Let's assume that we are trying to describe a concept which is that you have the Blinded condition when trying to see something in the area AND that this is conceptually different from how the other type of area works. We are choosing a flavor text adjective to introduce and describe this concept. Which adjective would you use here?
"You can see things in a Lightly Obscured area, but not very well. In contrast to that, a Heavily Obscured area is __________. You have the Blinded condition when trying to see something there."
Fill in the blank. Which adjective would you use?
I wouldn't have written that sentence in the first place, because it's completely impossible for it to be correct.