I'm playing a level 3 Arcane Trickster Rogue using the 2024 rules, and I have a few questions about how Mage Hand Legerdemain interacts with Sleight of Hand checks and item manipulation, particularly during combat.
The 2024 Mage Hand spell states:
"When you cast the spell, you can use the hand to manipulate an object, open an unlocked door or container, stow or retrieve an item from an open container, or pour the contents out of a vial."
Mage Hand Legerdemain also allows the Arcane Trickster to control the hand as a Bonus Action and make Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) checks through it.
I'm particularly interested in three situations:
1. Pouring Oil with Mage Hand
The Oil item allows a character to take the Utilize action to pour oil onto the ground, covering a 5-foot square within 5 feet of themselves.
Since Mage Hand explicitly allows the hand to "pour the contents out of a vial," would pouring oil onto the ground be a valid use of the spell?
My reasoning is that Mage Hand is performing exactly the physical manipulation described in the Oil item's rules.
If this is allowed, could the Arcane Trickster pour the oil using their Bonus Action to control Mage Hand?
Also, would the 5-foot placement restriction be measured from the caster or from the spectral hand?
I'm not suggesting that Mage Hand could throw an oil flask as an attack, only that it could pour the oil onto the ground.
2. Spreading Caltrops
Caltrops also require the Utilize action to spread them onto the ground.
Would Mage Hand's ability to "manipulate an object" allow it to spread caltrops and produce their normal mechanical effect?
Or is there an important rules distinction between manipulating objects and taking the Utilize action?
I recognize that the argument for caltrops may be weaker than for oil, since Mage Hand explicitly mentions pouring the contents of a vial.
3. Stealing a Sheathed Weapon During Combat
The 2024 Arcane Trickster's Mage Hand Legerdemain allows Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) checks through Mage Hand.
Could an Arcane Trickster use this ability to steal a weapon carried by an enemy but not currently held, such as a dagger or sword in its sheath?
For this question, I'm not assuming the enemy is unaware or distracted.
Imagine an enemy actively engaged in combat. The Arcane Trickster attempts to remove a sheathed dagger using Mage Hand. The enemy may notice the attempt and try to prevent it, but the Rogue might still succeed through superior manual dexterity.
I'm specifically distinguishing this from disarming an enemy who is actively holding a weapon.
Does the 2024 ruleset permit such an attempt using Sleight of Hand, potentially resolved by an ability check, or would it require a separate mechanic or DM adjudication?
And if this is a valid Sleight of Hand check, can the Arcane Trickster perform it through Mage Hand as a Bonus Action?
I'd be fine with a Rogue's Mage Hand pouring a flask of oil or bag of caltrops, but not disarm an enemy. Stealing a sheated weapon by trying to pull it from an unwilling enemy to me would be more a Strength check than a Dexterity check.
I’d just want to add that in combat, it might be tough to pull off. You would need to give the item to the mage hand, which would be your object interaction for that round. Which might not be an issue, but it also might be, depending on circumstances and what else you’re trying to do. You could also use the hand to grab the oil or caltrops from you or I’d allow it to take them from a willing ally, but that would be it’s interaction that round, and it wouldn’t have one left to pour them out on the other end.
Free Object Interaction: Hand the oil flask to Mage Hand.
Bonus Action: Use Mage Hand to pour the oil onto the ground in the enemy's space.
Action: Cast Create Bonfire to ignite the oil.
In terms of action economy, I think this is a pretty good combo, especially at lower levels.
As for stealing items, my idea is to use Mage Hand to steal weapons, arcane focuses, or any other items an enemy is carrying or has sheathed, as long as they aren't actively holding them or the items aren't securely attached to their body.
I'd like to be able to attempt this both during and outside of combat.
To my understanding, technically it's a Bonus Action to control & move the Mage Hand and the Utilize action to pour an Oil fllask in a space. Then lighting it up with Create Bonfire would cause a creature in it to make a Dexterity saving throw or take 1d8 fire damage and also take 5 Fire damage if it ends its turn there.
Your DM will tell if any of this can be done and to what result.
Free Object Interaction: Hand the oil flask to Mage Hand.
Bonus Action: Use Mage Hand to pour the oil onto the ground in the enemy's space.
Action: Cast Create Bonfire to ignite the oil.
In terms of action economy, I think this is a pretty good combo, especially at lower levels.
While in terms of action economy it could work, I’m not sure why you’d do it. The target would get a dex save to avoid the damage (as plaguescarred said). But, you could just cast create bonfire and throw the fire at them, and they get the same dex save to avoid the same damage. It seems like you’ve added extra steps for no real benefit, unless you can somehow force them to stay in that space. And the thrown version has a 60’ range as opposed to 30 for mage hand. I guess it could help if the target has cover, but then it seems like that same cover would apply to trying to hit the oil, maybe? Not sure how that might work.
The benefit comes from the Oil item's description:
«Dousing a Space. You can take the Utilize action to pour an Oil flask on level ground to cover a 5-foot-square area within 5 feet of yourself. If lit, the oil burns until the end of the turn 2 rounds from when the oil was lit (or 12 seconds) and deals 5 Fire damage to any creature that enters the area or ends its turn there. A creature can take this damage only once per turn.»
This means 5 points of guaranteed fire damage, with no saving throw, provided the creature enters the burning area or ends its turn there.
It's a situational combo, particularly useful when an enemy has high AC, is low on HP, or has limited mobility.
I would say that, while none of this is a ridiculous or overpowered request, all of it would require the specific approval of your DM. That is to say, your DM should default to letting you do anything the rules specifically say you can do under their mechanics, but anything going beyond the mechanical allowances of the rules are entirely and only able to happen if the DM rules it.
Your initial post sort of already acknowledges that these things are beyond the letter of the rules. A flask is not a vial, it's a flask. Spreading caltrops involves manipulating more than one object. Stealing a sheathed weapon in combat, if it is possible, probably does involve making a Sleight of Hand check, but the player's handbook does not lay that out as a specific option that is available to a creature at all times (unlike, say, attempting to pick a lock which is a described action option in a lock's item description).
The list of things a mage hand can do looks very similar to one other list - being the list of things a player can do as their free object interaction during their turn. It does not resemble at all the list of things that can be achieved with the full Utilize Action, thus it would not be wise for a player to assume that you will be allowed have the bonus action of the hand do something which normally requires the Utilize action. The Trickster is able to use the hand to make Sleight of Hand checks, which probably allows it to do any one Action or Bonus Action that the rules define as making such a check.
You could definitely have the hand pour out a *vial* of oil, or manipulate and lay out a single caltrop - but then the DM would have to describe the mechanical effect of those things.
That being said, as a DM I would probably agree with others here and allow these uses of mage hand for a trickster. For consistency I would probably pick a gold value of equipment and declare the hand can Utilize any consumable item up to that value, then increase the value with levels if the rogue was keen to continue the trick, possibly as high as some low level magic items for a high level rogue.
TLDR, ask your DM, should be fine, but don't argue the point as you don't have a RAW legal leg to stand on.
As others have mentioned, it appears that the design intent for the Mage Hand spell is that you are using an action in order to be able to perform an Object Interaction at range. In my opinion, this uses an action instead of your Object Interaction (not in addition to your Object Interaction). As such, the first two activities in the OP, which require taking the Utilize action, do not qualify as activities that can be done with the mage hand.
As for stealing a weapon or item from an enemy's person . . . since this activity isn't really covered anywhere by the rules, the DM would have to determine what is required. The rules generally differentiate an activity that can be performed as an Object Interaction from an activity that requires the Utilize action like this:
You normally interact with an object while doing something else, such as when you draw a sword as part of the Attack action. When an object requires an action for its use, you take the Utilize action.
Some magic items and other special objects always require an action to use, as stated in their descriptions.
The DM might require you to use an action for any of these activities when it needs special care or when it presents an unusual obstacle. For instance, the DM might require you to take the Utilize action to open a stuck door or turn a crank to lower a drawbridge.
In my opinion, this last point is the most relevant. When it comes to pickpocketing or stealing from an enemy's person, I would require an action to attempt such an activity. As such, the mage hand would be unable to do this.
Also, in my opinion, the same idea would apply to lock picking, which requires an action. The way that I read it, even though the Legerdemain allows the mage hand to perform an activity that requires a skill check, that does not mean that the activity in question can be one that requires an action. It just means that it can perform a "more difficult" Object Interaction.
As evidence that picking a pocket requires similar action economy to picking a lock, see the Thief / Fast Hands feature:
As a Bonus Action, you can do one of the following.
Sleight of Hand. Make a Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check to pick a lock or disarm a trap with Thieves’ Tools or to pick a pocket.
As others have mentioned, it appears that the design intent for the Mage Hand spell is that you are using an action in order to be able to perform an Object Interaction at range. In my opinion, this uses an action instead of your Object Interaction (not in addition to your Object Interaction). As such, the first two activities in the OP, which require taking the Utilize action, do not qualify as activities that can be done with the mage hand. [...]
IMO, when you cast the Mage Hand spell and control the hand, or take a Magic action on your later turns to control the hand again, you're not consuming your free object interaction for that turn.
When time is short, such as in combat, interactions with objects are limited: one free interaction per turn. That interaction must occur during a creature’s movement or action.
Mage Hand usually takes an action to cast/use but the Arcane Trickster changes that to a Bonus Action. Thus I'd say that anything any other caster can do with the hand as an Action the rogue can do as a Bonus Action.
The DM might require you to use an action for any of these activities when it needs special care or when it presents an unusual obstacle. For instance, the DM might require you to take the Utilize action to open a stuck door or turn a crank to lower a drawbridge.
In my opinion, this last point is the most relevant. When it comes to pickpocketing or stealing from an enemy's person, I would require an action to attempt such an activity. As such, the mage hand would be unable to do this.
Also, in my opinion, the same idea would apply to lock picking, which requires an action. The way that I read it, even though the Legerdemain allows the mage hand to perform an activity that requires a skill check, that does not mean that the activity in question can be one that requires an action. It just means that it can perform a "more difficult" Object Interaction.
As evidence that picking a pocket requires similar action economy to picking a lock, see the Thief / Fast Hands feature:
I'd have to disagree here. The Mage Hand Legerdemain feature explicitly allows the Rogue to do Dex (Sleight of Hand) checks with the hand as a Bonus Action, if you are going to disallow all such skill checks there are then what's the use of having the feature? I mean, even the example you use to established the action economy comes from a feature that DO allow a character to use a Bonus Action to do a Dex (Sleight of Hand) check that would normally take an Action.
I understand your point that certain tasks explicitly require a specific action, as explained in the rules for the Utilize action. However, the Player's Handbook also establishes that specific abilities or spells can change the normal action economy.
In fact, the section on Bonus Actions in the Player's Handbook gives an example of this:
"Various class features, spells, and other abilities let you take an additional action on your turn called a Bonus Action. The Cunning Action feature, for example, allows a Rogue to take a Bonus Action. You can take a Bonus Action only when a special ability, a spell, or another feature of the game states that you can do something as a Bonus Action."
For example, Dash, Disengage, and Hide normally require an action, but the Rogue's Cunning Action feature specifically allows them to be performed as a Bonus Action.
I believe the same principle applies to the Arcane Trickster's Mage Hand Legerdemain.
The feature explicitly states:
"You can control the hand as a Bonus Action, and through it, you can make Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) checks."
In other words, the feature specifically allows the Arcane Trickster to control Mage Hand as a Bonus Action and perform Sleight of Hand checks through it.
My interpretation is that when a task can be performed through Mage Hand using a Sleight of Hand check, Mage Hand Legerdemain provides a specific exception to the normal action economy, allowing that check to be performed as part of the Bonus Action used to control the hand.
Mage Hand usually takes an action to cast/use but the Arcane Trickster changes that to a Bonus Action. Thus I'd say that anything any other caster can do with the hand as an Action the rogue can do as a Bonus Action. [...]
Sorry, Thezzaruz. I'm not sure if this is in response to my earlier reply, but I agree with you about the intent. Maybe I said something that gave a different impression?
It means the Oil fllask would need to be already out, opened and the hand would first need to manipulate it in order to then pour the content, meaning you're looking at least 2 turns to do so.
Sorry, Thezzaruz. I'm not sure if this is in response to my earlier reply, but I agree with you about the intent. Maybe I said something that gave a different impression?
Nah mate, that wasn't aimed at any one in particular, just my general thought on the issue.
I'd have to disagree here. The Mage Hand Legerdemain feature explicitly allows the Rogue to do Dex (Sleight of Hand) checks with the hand as a Bonus Action, if you are going to disallow all such skill checks there are then what's the use of having the feature? I mean, even the example you use to established the action economy comes from a feature that DO allow a character to use a Bonus Action to do a Dex (Sleight of Hand) check that would normally take an Action.
In practice, I think that most DM's are going to allow the Mage Hand Legerdemain to pick a pocket which seems to normally require an action (a Bonus Action if using the Fast Hands feature). This may or may not be intended. As written, I just don't think that the rules allow that. I think that the rules are allowing this hand to participate in a "difficult" Object Interaction (but not something that would require taking the Utilize action) that the DM decides requires a skill check to see whether or not the activity is successful. With a "normal" Mage Hand, such an activity would just auto-fail since that Mage Hand doesn't have abilities or skills that can be applied to such checks. That's my read on it anyway.
Pick a pocket is an example uses for Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check so if Mage Hand Legerdemain say it can make such a check through it i have to think it's intended.
Lastly is a funky ability that crops up three times in this subclass’s design: the mage hand cantrip. You are a master of using this minor telekinetic ability, and can eventually do everything from picking locks with it to distracting enemies. It seems like a small benefit, but using mage hand to improve the range of your day-to-day rogue skills like picking locks, disarming traps, and stealing items can be incredibly powerful. These abilities are situational—you’ll need to have a DM that includes encounters where you have to disable devices under time pressure or suboptimal conditions—but they allow you to succeed wildly against otherwise insurmountable obstacles.
Hi everyone, I have been following this thread because our group also has an Arcane Trickster, and the oil question came up at our table as well. I would say the oil is the strongest of the three examples, because the spell itself says the hand can pour the contents out of a vial, so that part at least feels like it is doing exactly what Mage Hand was written to do. Caltrops feel weaker to me, because spreading a whole bag over an area is more than just manipulating one object, even if I would still let a hand drop a few of them in a pinch.
Stealing a sheathed weapon is the one I would be most careful with, because the enemy is awake, armed, and actively fighting, so it should not feel like an easy free disarm. In my opinion, Mage Hand Legerdemain does let you make a Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check through the hand as a bonus action, and picking a pocket is one of the usual examples for that skill, so I think the attempt itself should be allowed. The check should still be hard, though, and I would expect the DM to set a high difficulty or ask for a contest, especially if the weapon is strapped in or the enemy notices the hand moving toward them.
What really helped our table was agreeing the practical steps in advance, so the rogue needs the flask already out and open before the hand can pour it, and the hand cannot also draw a new item, open a pouch, and pour everything in the same bonus action. I also think it helps to measure the oil from where the hand actually pours it, rather than from the caster standing far away, because otherwise the range starts to feel too generous. As others have said, none of this is a clear-cut rules answer, so I would ask the DM before building a whole tactic around it, and I would not argue the point at the table if they rule against it.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Hi everyone!
I'm playing a level 3 Arcane Trickster Rogue using the 2024 rules, and I have a few questions about how Mage Hand Legerdemain interacts with Sleight of Hand checks and item manipulation, particularly during combat.
The 2024 Mage Hand spell states:
Mage Hand Legerdemain also allows the Arcane Trickster to control the hand as a Bonus Action and make Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) checks through it.
I'm particularly interested in three situations:
1. Pouring Oil with Mage Hand
The Oil item allows a character to take the Utilize action to pour oil onto the ground, covering a 5-foot square within 5 feet of themselves.
Since Mage Hand explicitly allows the hand to "pour the contents out of a vial," would pouring oil onto the ground be a valid use of the spell?
My reasoning is that Mage Hand is performing exactly the physical manipulation described in the Oil item's rules.
If this is allowed, could the Arcane Trickster pour the oil using their Bonus Action to control Mage Hand?
Also, would the 5-foot placement restriction be measured from the caster or from the spectral hand?
I'm not suggesting that Mage Hand could throw an oil flask as an attack, only that it could pour the oil onto the ground.
2. Spreading Caltrops
Caltrops also require the Utilize action to spread them onto the ground.
Would Mage Hand's ability to "manipulate an object" allow it to spread caltrops and produce their normal mechanical effect?
Or is there an important rules distinction between manipulating objects and taking the Utilize action?
I recognize that the argument for caltrops may be weaker than for oil, since Mage Hand explicitly mentions pouring the contents of a vial.
3. Stealing a Sheathed Weapon During Combat
The 2024 Arcane Trickster's Mage Hand Legerdemain allows Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) checks through Mage Hand.
Could an Arcane Trickster use this ability to steal a weapon carried by an enemy but not currently held, such as a dagger or sword in its sheath?
For this question, I'm not assuming the enemy is unaware or distracted.
Imagine an enemy actively engaged in combat. The Arcane Trickster attempts to remove a sheathed dagger using Mage Hand. The enemy may notice the attempt and try to prevent it, but the Rogue might still succeed through superior manual dexterity.
I'm specifically distinguishing this from disarming an enemy who is actively holding a weapon.
Does the 2024 ruleset permit such an attempt using Sleight of Hand, potentially resolved by an ability check, or would it require a separate mechanic or DM adjudication?
And if this is a valid Sleight of Hand check, can the Arcane Trickster perform it through Mage Hand as a Bonus Action?
I'd be fine with a Rogue's Mage Hand pouring a flask of oil or bag of caltrops, but not disarm an enemy. Stealing a sheated weapon by trying to pull it from an unwilling enemy to me would be more a Strength check than a Dexterity check.
I agree with plaguescarred on both points.
I’d just want to add that in combat, it might be tough to pull off. You would need to give the item to the mage hand, which would be your object interaction for that round. Which might not be an issue, but it also might be, depending on circumstances and what else you’re trying to do. You could also use the hand to grab the oil or caltrops from you or I’d allow it to take them from a willing ally, but that would be it’s interaction that round, and it wouldn’t have one left to pour them out on the other end.
Related to #3. Not sure if it's useful or interesting, but we had this example for the 5e Level 3 Mage Hand Legerdemain:
As a side note, it was a contested check, something not present in the 5.5e rules.
My idea is to use the following action economy:
Free Object Interaction: Hand the oil flask to Mage Hand.
Bonus Action: Use Mage Hand to pour the oil onto the ground in the enemy's space.
Action: Cast Create Bonfire to ignite the oil.
In terms of action economy, I think this is a pretty good combo, especially at lower levels.
As for stealing items, my idea is to use Mage Hand to steal weapons, arcane focuses, or any other items an enemy is carrying or has sheathed, as long as they aren't actively holding them or the items aren't securely attached to their body.
I'd like to be able to attempt this both during and outside of combat.
To my understanding, technically it's a Bonus Action to control & move the Mage Hand and the Utilize action to pour an Oil fllask in a space. Then lighting it up with Create Bonfire would cause a creature in it to make a Dexterity saving throw or take 1d8 fire damage and also take 5 Fire damage if it ends its turn there.
Your DM will tell if any of this can be done and to what result.
While in terms of action economy it could work, I’m not sure why you’d do it. The target would get a dex save to avoid the damage (as plaguescarred said). But, you could just cast create bonfire and throw the fire at them, and they get the same dex save to avoid the same damage. It seems like you’ve added extra steps for no real benefit, unless you can somehow force them to stay in that space. And the thrown version has a 60’ range as opposed to 30 for mage hand.
I guess it could help if the target has cover, but then it seems like that same cover would apply to trying to hit the oil, maybe? Not sure how that might work.
The benefit comes from the Oil item's description:
«Dousing a Space. You can take the Utilize action to pour an Oil flask on level ground to cover a 5-foot-square area within 5 feet of yourself. If lit, the oil burns until the end of the turn 2 rounds from when the oil was lit (or 12 seconds) and deals 5 Fire damage to any creature that enters the area or ends its turn there. A creature can take this damage only once per turn.»
This means 5 points of guaranteed fire damage, with no saving throw, provided the creature enters the burning area or ends its turn there.
It's a situational combo, particularly useful when an enemy has high AC, is low on HP, or has limited mobility.
I would say that, while none of this is a ridiculous or overpowered request, all of it would require the specific approval of your DM. That is to say, your DM should default to letting you do anything the rules specifically say you can do under their mechanics, but anything going beyond the mechanical allowances of the rules are entirely and only able to happen if the DM rules it.
Your initial post sort of already acknowledges that these things are beyond the letter of the rules. A flask is not a vial, it's a flask. Spreading caltrops involves manipulating more than one object. Stealing a sheathed weapon in combat, if it is possible, probably does involve making a Sleight of Hand check, but the player's handbook does not lay that out as a specific option that is available to a creature at all times (unlike, say, attempting to pick a lock which is a described action option in a lock's item description).
The list of things a mage hand can do looks very similar to one other list - being the list of things a player can do as their free object interaction during their turn. It does not resemble at all the list of things that can be achieved with the full Utilize Action, thus it would not be wise for a player to assume that you will be allowed have the bonus action of the hand do something which normally requires the Utilize action. The Trickster is able to use the hand to make Sleight of Hand checks, which probably allows it to do any one Action or Bonus Action that the rules define as making such a check.
You could definitely have the hand pour out a *vial* of oil, or manipulate and lay out a single caltrop - but then the DM would have to describe the mechanical effect of those things.
That being said, as a DM I would probably agree with others here and allow these uses of mage hand for a trickster. For consistency I would probably pick a gold value of equipment and declare the hand can Utilize any consumable item up to that value, then increase the value with levels if the rogue was keen to continue the trick, possibly as high as some low level magic items for a high level rogue.
TLDR, ask your DM, should be fine, but don't argue the point as you don't have a RAW legal leg to stand on.
As others have mentioned, it appears that the design intent for the Mage Hand spell is that you are using an action in order to be able to perform an Object Interaction at range. In my opinion, this uses an action instead of your Object Interaction (not in addition to your Object Interaction). As such, the first two activities in the OP, which require taking the Utilize action, do not qualify as activities that can be done with the mage hand.
As for stealing a weapon or item from an enemy's person . . . since this activity isn't really covered anywhere by the rules, the DM would have to determine what is required. The rules generally differentiate an activity that can be performed as an Object Interaction from an activity that requires the Utilize action like this:
In my opinion, this last point is the most relevant. When it comes to pickpocketing or stealing from an enemy's person, I would require an action to attempt such an activity. As such, the mage hand would be unable to do this.
Also, in my opinion, the same idea would apply to lock picking, which requires an action. The way that I read it, even though the Legerdemain allows the mage hand to perform an activity that requires a skill check, that does not mean that the activity in question can be one that requires an action. It just means that it can perform a "more difficult" Object Interaction.
As evidence that picking a pocket requires similar action economy to picking a lock, see the Thief / Fast Hands feature:
IMO, when you cast the Mage Hand spell and control the hand, or take a Magic action on your later turns to control the hand again, you're not consuming your free object interaction for that turn.
Time-Limited Object Interactions:
Mage Hand usually takes an action to cast/use but the Arcane Trickster changes that to a Bonus Action. Thus I'd say that anything any other caster can do with the hand as an Action the rogue can do as a Bonus Action.
I'd have to disagree here. The Mage Hand Legerdemain feature explicitly allows the Rogue to do Dex (Sleight of Hand) checks with the hand as a Bonus Action, if you are going to disallow all such skill checks there are then what's the use of having the feature? I mean, even the example you use to established the action economy comes from a feature that DO allow a character to use a Bonus Action to do a Dex (Sleight of Hand) check that would normally take an Action.
I understand your point that certain tasks explicitly require a specific action, as explained in the rules for the Utilize action. However, the Player's Handbook also establishes that specific abilities or spells can change the normal action economy.
In fact, the section on Bonus Actions in the Player's Handbook gives an example of this:
For example, Dash, Disengage, and Hide normally require an action, but the Rogue's Cunning Action feature specifically allows them to be performed as a Bonus Action.
I believe the same principle applies to the Arcane Trickster's Mage Hand Legerdemain.
The feature explicitly states:
In other words, the feature specifically allows the Arcane Trickster to control Mage Hand as a Bonus Action and perform Sleight of Hand checks through it.
My interpretation is that when a task can be performed through Mage Hand using a Sleight of Hand check, Mage Hand Legerdemain provides a specific exception to the normal action economy, allowing that check to be performed as part of the Bonus Action used to control the hand.
Sorry, Thezzaruz. I'm not sure if this is in response to my earlier reply, but I agree with you about the intent. Maybe I said something that gave a different impression?
Mage Hand Legerdemain let you move & control the Mage Hand as a Bonus Action and use it to;
It means the Oil fllask would need to be already out, opened and the hand would first need to manipulate it in order to then pour the content, meaning you're looking at least 2 turns to do so.
Nah mate, that wasn't aimed at any one in particular, just my general thought on the issue.
In practice, I think that most DM's are going to allow the Mage Hand Legerdemain to pick a pocket which seems to normally require an action (a Bonus Action if using the Fast Hands feature). This may or may not be intended. As written, I just don't think that the rules allow that. I think that the rules are allowing this hand to participate in a "difficult" Object Interaction (but not something that would require taking the Utilize action) that the DM decides requires a skill check to see whether or not the activity is successful. With a "normal" Mage Hand, such an activity would just auto-fail since that Mage Hand doesn't have abilities or skills that can be applied to such checks. That's my read on it anyway.
Pick a pocket is an example uses for Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check so if Mage Hand Legerdemain say it can make such a check through it i have to think it's intended.
We can also check this D&D blogpost Rogue 101: Arcane Trickster | Dungeons & Dragons to see how Arcane Trickster are intended to use the spell with Skill.
Hi everyone, I have been following this thread because our group also has an Arcane Trickster, and the oil question came up at our table as well. I would say the oil is the strongest of the three examples, because the spell itself says the hand can pour the contents out of a vial, so that part at least feels like it is doing exactly what Mage Hand was written to do. Caltrops feel weaker to me, because spreading a whole bag over an area is more than just manipulating one object, even if I would still let a hand drop a few of them in a pinch.
Stealing a sheathed weapon is the one I would be most careful with, because the enemy is awake, armed, and actively fighting, so it should not feel like an easy free disarm. In my opinion, Mage Hand Legerdemain does let you make a Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check through the hand as a bonus action, and picking a pocket is one of the usual examples for that skill, so I think the attempt itself should be allowed. The check should still be hard, though, and I would expect the DM to set a high difficulty or ask for a contest, especially if the weapon is strapped in or the enemy notices the hand moving toward them.
What really helped our table was agreeing the practical steps in advance, so the rogue needs the flask already out and open before the hand can pour it, and the hand cannot also draw a new item, open a pouch, and pour everything in the same bonus action. I also think it helps to measure the oil from where the hand actually pours it, rather than from the caster standing far away, because otherwise the range starts to feel too generous. As others have said, none of this is a clear-cut rules answer, so I would ask the DM before building a whole tactic around it, and I would not argue the point at the table if they rule against it.