My idea is to keep my spider familiar on my shoulder (it's a Tiny creature with Spider Climb) so I can consistently qualify for Sneak Attack.
According to Sage Advice, a familiar counts as an ally for the purposes of Sneak Attack. Since the spider would be riding on my shoulder, whenever I'm within 5 feet of an enemy, the spider would also be within 5 feet of that enemy, satisfying the Sneak Attack requirements.
Also, since the spider would be carried by me rather than using its own movement, it shouldn't provoke opportunity attacks when I use Cunning Action to Disengage and move away from the enemy.
I'm aware that this strategy comes with several risks for the familiar, such as area-of-effect attacks and other threats, but I believe it's still a valid combo under the 2024 rules.
Am I interpreting these rules correctly, or is there anything I'm overlooking?
The next rule is also relevant, but I'd say your scenario is not affected by it:
You can’t willingly end a move in a space occupied by another creature. If you somehow end a turn in a space with another creature, you have the Prone condition (see the rules glossary) unless you are Tiny or are of a larger size than the other creature.
The question here is, can a humanoid act as an independent mount for a tiny creature that is well equipped to ride on that humanoid? I can't see why not.
But, you must remain aware that this spider is very much involved in the battle. It is true that a mount (e.g. a humanoid rogue) can use the Disengage action to avoid an OA, and a rider is not normally a target of an OA anyway since it is being moved without using its own movement. But that is where the protection ends. The spider can be seen and targeted by any attack within range as normal. It will need to make its own save against any area effect that covers your space. Additionally, if you (the mount) are moved against your will by any effect or you fall prone, then the spider must make a DC10 Dex save or it falls to a nearby space and lands prone.
Helping to grant advantage is one of the common uses of a familiar in combat, but they are notoriously fragile so unlikely to live through the average combat.
I understand that the owl is generally considered the best familiar, and that overall, both in and out of combat, it's probably the most useful option. However, I'm trying to do something different.
My main goal with the spider familiar is to use it as an effective espionage tool, combining its abilities with my Arcane Trickster features.
Here are a few examples of what I have in mind:
Stealthy scouting and eavesdropping: A spider can act as a much more discreet spy than most other familiars, especially when sneaking into buildings, hiding in small spaces, or listening to conversations.
Planting the spider on an enemy: Since Mage Hand Legerdemain allows me to make Sleight of Hand checks through Mage Hand, I could potentially slip my spider into an enemy's backpack. This would allow it to spy on someone or inspect the contents of their backpack, helping me identify valuable items worth stealing.
Using Mage Hand to transport the spider: Even though spiders can't fly, I could use my invisible Mage Hand to carry the familiar in any direction, using my Action to move the hand and my Bonus Action to perceive through the spider's senses. This could provide a discreet way to scout areas from different angles, including elevated positions.
Of course, I'd also like my spider to have at least some practical usefulness in combat, which is why I'm exploring whether keeping it on my shoulder could help enable Sneak Attack.
However, combat isn't the primary reason I chose the spider. I know there are more reliable ways to qualify for Sneak Attack, and this would simply be one additional option.
Ultimately, I want my familiar to be a versatile espionage and infiltration tool that complements my Arcane Trickster's abilities, rather than just choosing the mechanically strongest familiar for combat.
I understand that the owl is generally considered the best familiar, and that overall, both in and out of combat, it's probably the most useful option. However, I'm trying to do something different.
My main goal with the spider familiar is to use it as an effective espionage tool, combining its abilities with my Arcane Trickster features.
Here are a few examples of what I have in mind:
Stealthy scouting and eavesdropping: A spider can act as a much more discreet spy than most other familiars, especially when sneaking into buildings, hiding in small spaces, or listening to conversations.
Planting the spider on an enemy: Since Mage Hand Legerdemain allows me to make Sleight of Hand checks through Mage Hand, I could potentially slip my spider into an enemy's backpack. This would allow it to spy on someone or inspect the contents of their backpack, helping me identify valuable items worth stealing.
Using Mage Hand to transport the spider: Even though spiders can't fly, I could use my invisible Mage Hand to carry the familiar in any direction, using my Action to move the hand and my Bonus Action to perceive through the spider's senses. This could provide a discreet way to scout areas from different angles, including elevated positions.
Of course, I'd also like my spider to have at least some practical usefulness in combat, which is why I'm exploring whether keeping it on my shoulder could help enable Sneak Attack.
However, combat isn't the primary reason I chose the spider. I know there are more reliable ways to qualify for Sneak Attack, and this would simply be one additional option.
Ultimately, I want my familiar to be a versatile espionage and infiltration tool that complements my Arcane Trickster's abilities, rather than just choosing the mechanically strongest familiar for combat.
Having just literally killed (napkin to squeeze) two spiders about 2 seconds before I clicked this thread, I wonder if that might occur in game?
Exactly my thoughts. The spider on my shoulder can simply take the Dodge action on its turns, or, if it's no longer needed, hide inside my backpack or one of my pockets.
Exactly my thoughts. The spider on my shoulder can simply take the Dodge action on its turns, or, if it's no longer needed, hide inside my backpack or one of my pockets.
There isn't really a mechanic for a creature to leave the battlefield into a pocket or backpack. Most DMs will let a familiar be conveniently not involved in a combat if the owner doesn't want it there, but if you want to gain the mechanical benefit of the spider's help with a sneak attack then you may have to face the ongoing risk of losing that spider for the rest of the combat.
I think if you are using the spider as an inactive ally it will be less likely targeted compared to say an Owl actively helping.
I would say if the spider is "helping" enough to distract the enemy so that sneak attack triggers, then it would make sense it would be targeted the same.
It's not RAW technically, but for me the idea behind having an ally within 5 feet triggering sneak attack is that the ally is splitting the attention of the enemy somehow, making it less able to defend itself from your precise damaging attack. Because the spider is riding on you and in your space, I still assume it must be doing something to make its presence known to the enemy to draw its attention, and therefor as a DM I would still have the enemy potentially attack it.
As a DM, if you stated the spider was simply hiding on your back or something, but was "still within 5 feet", I'd make a ruling that sneak attack wouldn't trigger, even if technically you met the RAW requirements for it.
As stated in the Sage Advice Compendium, a familiar counts as an ally and can normally enable Sneak Attack.
A Tiny creature can occupy the same space as a creature at least two sizes larger without any issues, and a creature can serve as a mount for another creature as long as the mount is at least one size category larger than its rider.
I understand that some interpretation is involved here, but I believe that having an ally perched on the Rogue's shoulder, who can also be targeted by enemy attacks, reasonably satisfies the conditions required for Sneak Attack (and remember, I'm not talking about gaining the benefits of the Help action), since the familiar would be within 5 feet of the enemy.
I also mentioned that if the spider is no longer useful during combat, it could take the Hide action on its turn while retreating into one of my pockets or my backpack, potentially gaining the benefits of hiding. Of course, that wouldn't automatically remove it from combat or make it untargetable.
Alternatively, it could remain on my shoulder and take the Dodge action.
In either case, the idea is to improve the familiar's chances of surviving the encounter.
I also mentioned that if the spider is no longer useful during combat, it could take the Hide action on its turn while retreating into one of my pockets or my backpack, potentially gaining the benefits of hiding. Of course, that wouldn't automatically remove it from combat or make it untargetable...
And I'm saying there is no definition of hiding in pockets or backpack in the rules which you can definitely use to take that action.
Some of the things you are proposing are allowed under the rules, and some do not have any rules that allow them. According to the rules, your spider can take the same actions (except attacking) that your PC could take if you were riding an unusually large horse. There is no action to hide in your mount's saddlebags.
All things in the game depend on DM interpretation and approval eventually, but actions which do not have any rules which specifically allow them are very much the kind of thing you should ask your DM about before you try the tactic.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
My idea is to keep my spider familiar on my shoulder (it's a Tiny creature with Spider Climb) so I can consistently qualify for Sneak Attack.
According to Sage Advice, a familiar counts as an ally for the purposes of Sneak Attack. Since the spider would be riding on my shoulder, whenever I'm within 5 feet of an enemy, the spider would also be within 5 feet of that enemy, satisfying the Sneak Attack requirements.
Also, since the spider would be carried by me rather than using its own movement, it shouldn't provoke opportunity attacks when I use Cunning Action to Disengage and move away from the enemy.
I'm aware that this strategy comes with several risks for the familiar, such as area-of-effect attacks and other threats, but I believe it's still a valid combo under the 2024 rules.
Am I interpreting these rules correctly, or is there anything I'm overlooking?
RAW, seems legit to me.
The next rule is also relevant, but I'd say your scenario is not affected by it:
Btw, wouldn't it be easier with an Owl (Fly speed, Flyby if needed, and it's also Tiny)?
EDIT: for clarity.
The question here is, can a humanoid act as an independent mount for a tiny creature that is well equipped to ride on that humanoid? I can't see why not.
But, you must remain aware that this spider is very much involved in the battle. It is true that a mount (e.g. a humanoid rogue) can use the Disengage action to avoid an OA, and a rider is not normally a target of an OA anyway since it is being moved without using its own movement. But that is where the protection ends. The spider can be seen and targeted by any attack within range as normal. It will need to make its own save against any area effect that covers your space. Additionally, if you (the mount) are moved against your will by any effect or you fall prone, then the spider must make a DC10 Dex save or it falls to a nearby space and lands prone.
Helping to grant advantage is one of the common uses of a familiar in combat, but they are notoriously fragile so unlikely to live through the average combat.
I understand that the owl is generally considered the best familiar, and that overall, both in and out of combat, it's probably the most useful option. However, I'm trying to do something different.
My main goal with the spider familiar is to use it as an effective espionage tool, combining its abilities with my Arcane Trickster features.
Here are a few examples of what I have in mind:
Stealthy scouting and eavesdropping: A spider can act as a much more discreet spy than most other familiars, especially when sneaking into buildings, hiding in small spaces, or listening to conversations.
Planting the spider on an enemy: Since Mage Hand Legerdemain allows me to make Sleight of Hand checks through Mage Hand, I could potentially slip my spider into an enemy's backpack. This would allow it to spy on someone or inspect the contents of their backpack, helping me identify valuable items worth stealing.
Using Mage Hand to transport the spider: Even though spiders can't fly, I could use my invisible Mage Hand to carry the familiar in any direction, using my Action to move the hand and my Bonus Action to perceive through the spider's senses. This could provide a discreet way to scout areas from different angles, including elevated positions.
Of course, I'd also like my spider to have at least some practical usefulness in combat, which is why I'm exploring whether keeping it on my shoulder could help enable Sneak Attack.
However, combat isn't the primary reason I chose the spider. I know there are more reliable ways to qualify for Sneak Attack, and this would simply be one additional option.
Ultimately, I want my familiar to be a versatile espionage and infiltration tool that complements my Arcane Trickster's abilities, rather than just choosing the mechanically strongest familiar for combat.
Ah, now I understand. Have fun with your Spidey!
Having just literally killed (napkin to squeeze) two spiders about 2 seconds before I clicked this thread, I wonder if that might occur in game?
I think if you are using the spider as an inactive ally it will be less likely targeted compared to say an Owl actively helping.
Exactly my thoughts. The spider on my shoulder can simply take the Dodge action on its turns, or, if it's no longer needed, hide inside my backpack or one of my pockets.
There isn't really a mechanic for a creature to leave the battlefield into a pocket or backpack. Most DMs will let a familiar be conveniently not involved in a combat if the owner doesn't want it there, but if you want to gain the mechanical benefit of the spider's help with a sneak attack then you may have to face the ongoing risk of losing that spider for the rest of the combat.
I would say if the spider is "helping" enough to distract the enemy so that sneak attack triggers, then it would make sense it would be targeted the same.
It's not RAW technically, but for me the idea behind having an ally within 5 feet triggering sneak attack is that the ally is splitting the attention of the enemy somehow, making it less able to defend itself from your precise damaging attack. Because the spider is riding on you and in your space, I still assume it must be doing something to make its presence known to the enemy to draw its attention, and therefor as a DM I would still have the enemy potentially attack it.
As a DM, if you stated the spider was simply hiding on your back or something, but was "still within 5 feet", I'd make a ruling that sneak attack wouldn't trigger, even if technically you met the RAW requirements for it.
As stated in the Sage Advice Compendium, a familiar counts as an ally and can normally enable Sneak Attack.
A Tiny creature can occupy the same space as a creature at least two sizes larger without any issues, and a creature can serve as a mount for another creature as long as the mount is at least one size category larger than its rider.
I understand that some interpretation is involved here, but I believe that having an ally perched on the Rogue's shoulder, who can also be targeted by enemy attacks, reasonably satisfies the conditions required for Sneak Attack (and remember, I'm not talking about gaining the benefits of the Help action), since the familiar would be within 5 feet of the enemy.
I also mentioned that if the spider is no longer useful during combat, it could take the Hide action on its turn while retreating into one of my pockets or my backpack, potentially gaining the benefits of hiding. Of course, that wouldn't automatically remove it from combat or make it untargetable.
Alternatively, it could remain on my shoulder and take the Dodge action.
In either case, the idea is to improve the familiar's chances of surviving the encounter.
And I'm saying there is no definition of hiding in pockets or backpack in the rules which you can definitely use to take that action.
Some of the things you are proposing are allowed under the rules, and some do not have any rules that allow them. According to the rules, your spider can take the same actions (except attacking) that your PC could take if you were riding an unusually large horse. There is no action to hide in your mount's saddlebags.
All things in the game depend on DM interpretation and approval eventually, but actions which do not have any rules which specifically allow them are very much the kind of thing you should ask your DM about before you try the tactic.