Sorry if this is answered elsewhere, just looking for clarification.
Warlock's prepared spell list is per the column on the Warlock Feature table. A single spell can be swapped for another each level. If a "Warlock Feature" gives a spell that's always prepared, those "don't count" against the list number.
If I prepare Charm Person at first level, and then advance to level 4, I get Ability Score improvement or another feat of my choosing.
If I choose Fey Touched, or more specifically to the scenario in my mind, Treacherous Allure, either could give me Charm Person as "always prepared" and eligible to be cast with Pact Magic slots.
My question: Is gaining that feat my 4th level Warlock Class feature, and therefore the spell becomes a "Warlock Feature?" Does it therefore just drop out of the count and I have a vacancy on my list, not a swap I am making?
Or are feats by definition class-agnostic, so I have two independent sources of the Charm Person spell being prepared and two independent routes to cast it with slots? If I want to rectify that redundancy, I am required to utilize one of my designated 1/level exchanges?
Does that answer change if I prepare Tasha's Hideous Laughter at 1 and get it via the Great Old One Subclass at 3? In that case does a vacancy open up, but not in the feat scenario?
Or are feats by definition class-agnostic, so I have two independent sources of the Charm Person spell being prepared and two independent routes to cast it with slots? If I want to rectify that redundancy, I am required to utilize one of my designated 1/level exchanges?
It's this one. Spells that you get from a feat (or any source outside your class) don't have any impact on the spells you have prepared via your class. In this situation you'd probably want to use your 1/level swap to prepare a different spell.
Does that answer change if I prepare Tasha's Hideous Laughter at 1 and get it via the Great Old One Subclass at 3? In that case does a vacancy open up, but not in the feat scenario?
No, the answer is the same in this scenario.
In practice, if gaining a level results in you getting a bunch of spells that you already have, your DM might well let you swap out more than one, especially if you're new to the game.
That said, I wanted to reuse the following reply from a recent thread. If following this ruling, then feats are class-agnostic as you said, and a spell gained through an ASI won't count as Warlock spell by default, unless the feat says so (e.g. adding its spells to your class list) or the spell is already listed on your Warlock spell list.
[...] * Feats don't count as class features, at least in my opinion, based on on the following information from the PHB:
Chapter 5: Feats This chapter offers a collection of feats, which are special features not tied to a character class. [...] Your background gives you a feat, and at certain levels, your class gives you the Ability Score Improvement feat or the choice of another feat for which you qualify.
This example for Wild Shape:
Game Statistics. Your game statistics are replaced by the Beast’s stat block, but you retain your creature type; Hit Points; Hit Point Dice; Intelligence, Wisdom, and Charisma scores;class features; languages; and feats. You also retain your skill and saving throw proficiencies and use your Proficiency Bonus for them, in addition to gaining the proficiencies of the creature. If a skill or saving throw modifier in the Beast’s stat block is higher than yours, use the one in the stat block.
Feats “Feats” includes the following new and revised elements, which are presented in the order in which they appear in that section.
Feat Descriptions [New Rule]
Feats are now divided into categories, including Origin, General, Fighting Style, and Epic Boon. All feats in this section are new except for the following revised rules.
Ability Score Improvement [Revised Rule]
This rule is now a feat rather than a class feature.
Grappler [Revised Rule]
This feat is revised and is now a General feat.
Fighting Style Feats [Revised Rule]
These rules are now feats rather than class features.
I guess what makes it confusing me is that the language around spells not counting is "Warlock Feature," not "Warlock class feature." Ability Score Improvement is on the "Warlock Features" table, and listed at the top of p155, right between the L3 Subclass and L9 Contact Patron, which are clearly Warlock Class Features. So if getting that feat is not a feature of being a Warlock, what is it? And why is it enumerated in those places instead of back in p41-42 where they specify your proficiency bonus is independent of your specific class and instead part of the overall character level?
Especially in the second scenario of a subclass giving you an always prepared spell, which could extend to a Draconic Sorcerer and Chromatic Orb. In both cases if you are picking a spell at L1 that fits the character concept (Psychic / charm.warlock or Evoker / damaging sorcerer), you are RAW penalized at L3 for thinking ahead and required to use a limited resource, prepared spell swaps?
If the feat is meant to be not a Warlock Feature, it shouldn't be on the "Warlock Feature" table, spelled out on the same pages as the other clearly Warlock Features like Contact Patron, and shouldn't be awarded as the character levels up in the Warlock class. Instead award feats at overall character levels, like the Proficiency bonus.
I guess what makes it confusing me is that the language around spells not counting is "Warlock Feature," not "Warlock class feature." Ability Score Improvement is on the "Warlock Features" table, and listed at the top of p155, right between the L3 Subclass and L9 Contact Patron, which are clearly Warlock Class Features. So if getting that feat is not a feature of being a Warlock, what is it? And why is it enumerated in those places instead of back in p41-42 where they specify your proficiency bonus is independent of your specific class and instead part of the overall character level?
Especially in the second scenario of a subclass giving you an always prepared spell, which could extend to a Draconic Sorcerer and Chromatic Orb. In both cases if you are picking a spell at L1 that fits the character concept (Psychic / charm.warlock or Evoker / damaging sorcerer), you are RAW penalized at L3 for thinking ahead and required to use a limited resource, prepared spell swaps?
If the feat is meant to be not a Warlock Feature, it shouldn't be on the "Warlock Feature" table, spelled out on the same pages as the other clearly Warlock Features like Contact Patron, and shouldn't be awarded as the character levels up in the Warlock class. Instead award feats at overall character levels, like the Proficiency bonus.
Whether the feat counts as a Warlock feature or not is not relevant to your original question.
A spell that's granted as "always prepared" by a class feature, a feat, a species feature, or anything else does not have any effect on spells you've already prepared via your class features. If any such thing grants you a spell as always prepared that you already have prepared, the official rules do not allow you to automatically exchange that already prepared spell for something else for free. As I said above, many DMs (including me) might let you do it anyway.
@DamionW79 When I said that feats don't count as class features, that was merely my interpretation, but it's not the only accepted interpretation on the forums. See for example this recent discussion, also about Warlock prepared spells, features, feats: AU’s Adept Feats and class spells#30.
Level 1 - Per p154, To start preparing spells, Choose two level 1 spells from the Warlock table. I want to be a mind bending kind of Warlock from the start. I pick Charm Person and Tasha's Hideous Laughter.
PREPARED SPELL LIST:
-Charm Person, Prepared from the Pact Magic Feature
-Hideous Laughter, Prepared from the Pact Magic Feature
Level 2 - The number of spells increases as you gain Warlock Levels. That number is now 3. Choose additional spells *until the number of spells on your list* matches the number on the table. I add Bane.
PREPARED SPELL LIST:
-Charm Person - prepared from Pact Magic feature
-Hideous Laughter - prepared from Pact Magic Feature
-Bane - prepared from Pact Magic Feature
Level 3 - I am awarded the SubClass Feature, and choose Great Old One. Upon making that choice, my spell list looks like
PREPARED SPELL LIST:
-L1 Charm Person - Prepared from Pact Magic
-L1 Hideous Laughter - Originally prepared from Pact Magic, now also always prepared from Great Old One Warlock Class Feature.
-L1 Dissonant Whispers - Only prepared from Great Old One subclass. Always Prepared, doesn't count towards Pact Magic total, and is only a Warlock Spell because it was awarded from a Class Feature
-L1 Bane - Prepared through Pact Magic feature
-L2 Detect Thoughts - Same as Dissonant Whispers
-L2 Phantasmal Force - Same as Dissonant Whispers
Now as I return to the Pact Magic feature, the number of Prepared spells to reach is 4 in the column. As I begin selecting spells on my list to add until I add up to 4, why does Hideous Laughter still count but the other Great Old One spells don't? It seems to me I should count ones that don't have an always prepared, then add spells to match up to four. There is only one Hideous Laughter spell in the game, and it has been provided the "Doesn't Count" status, just like all the other Great Old One spells. Do you have a page reference that specifically states it still needs to be on the tally as I work up to four total? Because I would say even plain RAW, by the letter on the page, I count Charm Person, I count Bane, I have a legitimate reason to not count Hideous Laughter, and therefore have two vacant spots on my list. Where is the specific ruling that says I am wrong? That is what I would like help with.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Sorry if this is answered elsewhere, just looking for clarification.
Warlock's prepared spell list is per the column on the Warlock Feature table. A single spell can be swapped for another each level. If a "Warlock Feature" gives a spell that's always prepared, those "don't count" against the list number.
If I prepare Charm Person at first level, and then advance to level 4, I get Ability Score improvement or another feat of my choosing.
If I choose Fey Touched, or more specifically to the scenario in my mind, Treacherous Allure, either could give me Charm Person as "always prepared" and eligible to be cast with Pact Magic slots.
My question: Is gaining that feat my 4th level Warlock Class feature, and therefore the spell becomes a "Warlock Feature?" Does it therefore just drop out of the count and I have a vacancy on my list, not a swap I am making?
Or are feats by definition class-agnostic, so I have two independent sources of the Charm Person spell being prepared and two independent routes to cast it with slots? If I want to rectify that redundancy, I am required to utilize one of my designated 1/level exchanges?
Does that answer change if I prepare Tasha's Hideous Laughter at 1 and get it via the Great Old One Subclass at 3? In that case does a vacancy open up, but not in the feat scenario?
You have to retrain it in all cases so it would use your 1 spell per level swap.
It's this one. Spells that you get from a feat (or any source outside your class) don't have any impact on the spells you have prepared via your class. In this situation you'd probably want to use your 1/level swap to prepare a different spell.
No, the answer is the same in this scenario.
In practice, if gaining a level results in you getting a bunch of spells that you already have, your DM might well let you swap out more than one, especially if you're new to the game.
pronouns: he/she/they
I agree with wagnarokkr.
That said, I wanted to reuse the following reply from a recent thread. If following this ruling, then feats are class-agnostic as you said, and a spell gained through an ASI won't count as Warlock spell by default, unless the feat says so (e.g. adding its spells to your class list) or the spell is already listed on your Warlock spell list.
EDIT#1: for clarity. EDIT#2: fix errata.
I guess what makes it confusing me is that the language around spells not counting is "Warlock Feature," not "Warlock class feature." Ability Score Improvement is on the "Warlock Features" table, and listed at the top of p155, right between the L3 Subclass and L9 Contact Patron, which are clearly Warlock Class Features. So if getting that feat is not a feature of being a Warlock, what is it? And why is it enumerated in those places instead of back in p41-42 where they specify your proficiency bonus is independent of your specific class and instead part of the overall character level?
Especially in the second scenario of a subclass giving you an always prepared spell, which could extend to a Draconic Sorcerer and Chromatic Orb. In both cases if you are picking a spell at L1 that fits the character concept (Psychic / charm.warlock or Evoker / damaging sorcerer), you are RAW penalized at L3 for thinking ahead and required to use a limited resource, prepared spell swaps?
If the feat is meant to be not a Warlock Feature, it shouldn't be on the "Warlock Feature" table, spelled out on the same pages as the other clearly Warlock Features like Contact Patron, and shouldn't be awarded as the character levels up in the Warlock class. Instead award feats at overall character levels, like the Proficiency bonus.
Whether the feat counts as a Warlock feature or not is not relevant to your original question.
A spell that's granted as "always prepared" by a class feature, a feat, a species feature, or anything else does not have any effect on spells you've already prepared via your class features. If any such thing grants you a spell as always prepared that you already have prepared, the official rules do not allow you to automatically exchange that already prepared spell for something else for free. As I said above, many DMs (including me) might let you do it anyway.
pronouns: he/she/they
@DamionW79 When I said that feats don't count as class features, that was merely my interpretation, but it's not the only accepted interpretation on the forums. See for example this recent discussion, also about Warlock prepared spells, features, feats: AU’s Adept Feats and class spells#30.
Ok, well let's do a character build:
Level 1 - Per p154, To start preparing spells, Choose two level 1 spells from the Warlock table. I want to be a mind bending kind of Warlock from the start. I pick Charm Person and Tasha's Hideous Laughter.
PREPARED SPELL LIST:
-Charm Person, Prepared from the Pact Magic Feature
-Hideous Laughter, Prepared from the Pact Magic Feature
Level 2 - The number of spells increases as you gain Warlock Levels. That number is now 3. Choose additional spells *until the number of spells on your list* matches the number on the table. I add Bane.
PREPARED SPELL LIST:
-Charm Person - prepared from Pact Magic feature
-Hideous Laughter - prepared from Pact Magic Feature
-Bane - prepared from Pact Magic Feature
Level 3 - I am awarded the SubClass Feature, and choose Great Old One. Upon making that choice, my spell list looks like
PREPARED SPELL LIST:
-L1 Charm Person - Prepared from Pact Magic
-L1 Hideous Laughter - Originally prepared from Pact Magic, now also always prepared from Great Old One Warlock Class Feature.
-L1 Dissonant Whispers - Only prepared from Great Old One subclass. Always Prepared, doesn't count towards Pact Magic total, and is only a Warlock Spell because it was awarded from a Class Feature
-L1 Bane - Prepared through Pact Magic feature
-L2 Detect Thoughts - Same as Dissonant Whispers
-L2 Phantasmal Force - Same as Dissonant Whispers
Now as I return to the Pact Magic feature, the number of Prepared spells to reach is 4 in the column. As I begin selecting spells on my list to add until I add up to 4, why does Hideous Laughter still count but the other Great Old One spells don't? It seems to me I should count ones that don't have an always prepared, then add spells to match up to four. There is only one Hideous Laughter spell in the game, and it has been provided the "Doesn't Count" status, just like all the other Great Old One spells. Do you have a page reference that specifically states it still needs to be on the tally as I work up to four total? Because I would say even plain RAW, by the letter on the page, I count Charm Person, I count Bane, I have a legitimate reason to not count Hideous Laughter, and therefore have two vacant spots on my list. Where is the specific ruling that says I am wrong? That is what I would like help with.