The story you can ignore: I have a player who wanted to use the Pugilist class, but after giving the newest one a read, it seems to me that it's kind of a mess I don't want to deal with as a DM. He proposed going for a Barbarian-Monk multi-class, but I know that it would not be fun for him (he doesn't know the rules that well). My compromise for him was to add a few homebrew things to make a Path of the Berserker Barbarian feel like a street punk, and this feat is the central thing for all that.
Let me know if it looks balanced:
Street Brawler
General Feat (Prerequisites: Level 4+, Tavern Brawler)
You gain the following benefits.
Ability Score Increase. Increase your Strength by 1, to a maximum of 20.
Pugilist. Your Unarmed Strike damage is further increased. You deal Bludgeoning damage equal to 1d6 plus your Strength modifier instead of the enhanced damage from Tavern Brawler.
Fisticuff Specialist. When you hit with bladed knuckles, brass knuckles or spiked knuckles, the attack is considered an Unarmed Strike that deals the same type of damage as that weapon.
Knock-Out. When you use the Push benefit of your Tavern Brawler feat, you can force the target to make a Constitution saving throw (DC equals to 8 plus your Strength modifier and Proficiency Bonus). On a failed save, the target receives the Unconscious condition for 1 minute. The condition ends on a target if it takes damage or someone within 5 feet of it takes an action to wake it up.
You can use this benefit a number of times equal to yourProficiency Bonus, and you regain all expended uses when you finish aLong Rest.
Honestly, this seems fine. I'm assuming you have brass knuckle weapons. Note that outside of your setting this feat may not make sense. Also note that 1 minute unconscious is a lot. Otherwise, this is fine. Since you're the DM here, honestly this call is ultimately up to you, but if you're worried it's too strong, consider not linking it to the Push feature. Otherwise your pushing damaging and knocking out. That's honestly too much and kinda doesn't make sense. Make a new feature. Structure it like the push feature and cross referencewoth the sleep spell. Something like:
Knockout. Once per turn when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike as part of the Attack action on your turn, you can deal damage to the target and force it to make a Constitution saving throw. (DC 8 + your Proficiency Bonus + your Strength modifier) On a failure the target has the Unconscious condition for 1 minute. The condition end early if the creature takes damage or someone within 5 feet of it takes an action to shake it awake. You can use this benefit a number of times equal to your proficiency bonus. You regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.
That's just a suggestion. Hope it helps. I'd love to hear back from you if it does. No one ever talks back on these quiet threads. It's so lonely out here.
Edit. Almost forgot to mention. You may want to specify that Fisticuff Specialist does the same damage type AND amount as the weapon. Note that this can be great for monks.
The story you can ignore: I have a player who wanted to use the Pugilist class, but after giving the newest one a read, it seems to me that it's kind of a mess I don't want to deal with as a DM. He proposed going for a Barbarian-Monk multi-class, but I know that it would not be fun for him (he doesn't know the rules that well). My compromise for him was to add a few homebrew things to make a Path of the Berserker Barbarian feel like a street punk, and this feat is the central thing for all that.
Let me know if it looks balanced:
Street Brawler
General Feat (Prerequisites: Level 4+, Tavern Brawler)
You gain the following benefits.
Ability Score Increase. Increase your Strength by 1, to a maximum of 20.
Pugilist. Your Unarmed Strike damage is further increased. You deal Bludgeoning damage equal to 1d6 plus your Strength modifier instead of the enhanced damage from Tavern Brawler.
Fisticuff Specialist. When you hit with bladed knuckles, brass knuckles or spiked knuckles, the attack is considered an Unarmed Strike that deals the same type of damage as that weapon.
Knock-Out. When you use the Push benefit of your Tavern Brawler feat, you can force the target to make a Constitution saving throw (DC equals to 8 plus your Strength modifier and Proficiency Bonus). On a failed save, the target receives the Unconscious condition for 1 minute. The condition ends on a target if it takes damage or someone within 5 feet of it takes an action to wake it up.
You can use this benefit a number of times equal to your Proficiency Bonus, and you regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.
Thanks!
Honestly, this seems fine. I'm assuming you have brass knuckle weapons. Note that outside of your setting this feat may not make sense. Also note that 1 minute unconscious is a lot. Otherwise, this is fine. Since you're the DM here, honestly this call is ultimately up to you, but if you're worried it's too strong, consider not linking it to the Push feature. Otherwise your pushing damaging and knocking out. That's honestly too much and kinda doesn't make sense. Make a new feature. Structure it like the push feature and cross referencewoth the sleep spell. Something like:
Knockout. Once per turn when you hit a creature with an Unarmed Strike as part of the Attack action on your turn, you can deal damage to the target and force it to make a Constitution saving throw. (DC 8 + your Proficiency Bonus + your Strength modifier) On a failure the target has the Unconscious condition for 1 minute. The condition end early if the creature takes damage or someone within 5 feet of it takes an action to shake it awake. You can use this benefit a number of times equal to your proficiency bonus. You regain all expended uses when you finish a Long Rest.
That's just a suggestion. Hope it helps. I'd love to hear back from you if it does. No one ever talks back on these quiet threads. It's so lonely out here.
Edit. Almost forgot to mention. You may want to specify that Fisticuff Specialist does the same damage type AND amount as the weapon. Note that this can be great for monks.