House of Horrors - Game thread

I’ts still possible that not all roles in the OP exist, like there’s four mafia roles but only three mafia. It’s possible we don’t have some town aligned role and instead got Witness

I'm gonna try to combine my thoughts here, bananer claimed vanilla townie uncontested, that means gato and me are the only two suspects; If I don't reveal my role, this will go on and cast doubt on whatever I say in the future, so revealing my role now is better for the long run. This also means that Gato is mafia. However, now that I revealed my role, I am worried about being killed by the mafia. So I want the doctor to attempt to protect me. Here's the main dilemma right now for townie/mafia. If I am townie, mafia will try to either kill me or roleblock me or use the witch so that they could use my power to kill somebody else. But if I just say that I won't use my power, that means they could possibly use witch on somebody else and/or jailer (we don't know the roles that mafia has.) So to prevent that, I will say this:
I may or may not use my power during the night.

Next, If I am lying and I am mafia and the doctor used their ability on me, we could get a free kill on somebody else, and block others/use their power; This is quite a problem for both teams, that's why I have to ask
Trust me on this, vote Gato, especially if I am not contested. If I am lying and they aren't mafia, get me the next night via vote: also we know I am not Jester or a neutral role due to the murder of Jkae, which was me.

Quote from Balthoran >>

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

I’ts still possible that not all roles in the OP exist, like there’s four mafia roles but only three mafia. It’s possible we don’t have some town aligned role and instead got Witness

 Lover is the most likely to not exist in my opinion

There are 12 people in the game, augur said that there would only be three mafia unless 14 people, since we only have 12, that means 3 mafia. 12-3=9. There is only one neutral, jkae. 9-1=8. There are 8 available people in the game. Since I am vigilente and tara was jailer, and that muffinman and townie was uncontested nor accused of lying that is 8-4=2 roles available. That either means we have an possible doctor/detective, or a townie/detective or a doctor/townie, or a townie/townie. or a lover/lover (as lovers only come in two)

That is unless there are no vanilla townies, which I don't believe

Quote from Balthoran >>

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

I’ts still possible that not all roles in the OP exist, like there’s four mafia roles but only three mafia. It’s possible we don’t have some town aligned role and instead got Witness

 Lover is the most likely to not exist in my opinion

 so I agree, and I personally think it's more likely for there to be a doctor and detective

We also don't know what roles are so to say "set in stone" aka roles that have to exist for townie. Augur, can you tell us if those exist?

bananer would only be mafia if townie didn't exist, which I don't believe

Vote: [Gato]

Edit: https://docs.google.com/document/d/13WlXZqgmF5PF1IkYg5jjDH__XaotuSCYHHsc8Azz5ig/edit?tab=t.sjuh4mybl48h
:)

Uhhhhhhhh hello 

VOTE GATO, DOCTOR PROTECT DRYRUINS, VIGILENTE (me) MAY OR MAY NOT KILL IN CASE WITCH/JAILER USES THEIR ABILITIES ON ME (IF IN THE GAME.) DETECTIVE; INVESTIGATE SOMEONE OTHER THAN DRYRUINS OR BANANER. POSSIBLY INVESTIGATE BALTH AND SAY WHEN YOU FIND SOMETHING.

Quote from 50thAltOfBananer >>

Uhhhhhhhh hello 

 hiya, we voting gato :)

Problem is that we are working under the assumption that witness/white lady is even in the game, so if possible: Reveal your role Gato

Over here, just to let you know, it would be a dumb play to roll the dice that there wasn't any Lost spirit(townie) or white lady(witness) on day 1 to claim it ON DAY ONE. This is why I think bananer and balth aren't mafia

since mafia doesn't know both who has the roles or what roles somebody already has 

Did you get your food Dry?

Quote from Providence_mw19 >>

Did you get your food Dry?

 Oh you mean the muffin? Not from what I know :'(

Quote from DryRuinss >>

Quote from Providence_mw19 >>

Did you get your food Dry?

 Oh you mean the muffin? Not from what I know :'(

 Does this mean eclipse was lying about being muffin man???????

most likely it was just an Augur slip up, there’d be no reason to falsely claim Muffin man (unless eclipse is secretly hiding a better role from the mafia which would be a crazy play)