Items in D&D that are being held, carried, or worn almost never take damage. I see no reason why a Bag Of Holding would change that.
If the bag is overloaded, pierced, or torn, it ruptures and is destroyed, and its contents are scattered in the Astral Plane.
It pretty much takes an intentional attack on the Bag Of Holding to get it cut, pierced, or torn. Bludgeoning damage won't do it. Even that doesn't damage the items inside. They are just scattered around in the Astral Plane unharmed.
I would say the items in another dimension are unarmed.
So if you put a glass of water inside a bag of holding and then pick it up and swing it around over your head and then put it back down and look inside... not a drop of water has been spilled.
MAGIC!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"A rightful place awaits you in the Realms Above, in the Land of the Great Light. Come in peace, and live beneath the sun again, where trees and flowers grow."
— The message of Eilistraee to all decent drow.
"Run thy sword across my chains, Silver Lady, that I may join your dance.”
The items aren’t actually in the bag. The bag simply acts as a gate to a small, isolated micro-dimension in the astral plane. So unless you actually impair/damage the bag, nothing happens to the items inside. But if you rupture it, the gate and micro-dimension collapse, scattering the contents on the astral plane.
So no, punching the bag won’t do anything to the contents of the bag.
lets supouse that someone kept a fragile item inside his bag of holding and i hit this bag or he fall from a rooft on his back...
the item now is broken? or should he trought a D100 to see te chances? or the bag being magic protect it?
Items in D&D that are being held, carried, or worn almost never take damage. I see no reason why a Bag Of Holding would change that.
It pretty much takes an intentional attack on the Bag Of Holding to get it cut, pierced, or torn. Bludgeoning damage won't do it. Even that doesn't damage the items inside. They are just scattered around in the Astral Plane unharmed.
<Insert clever signature here>
I would say the items in another dimension are unarmed.
So if you put a glass of water inside a bag of holding and then pick it up and swing it around over your head and then put it back down and look inside... not a drop of water has been spilled.
MAGIC!
The items aren’t actually in the bag. The bag simply acts as a gate to a small, isolated micro-dimension in the astral plane. So unless you actually impair/damage the bag, nothing happens to the items inside. But if you rupture it, the gate and micro-dimension collapse, scattering the contents on the astral plane.
So no, punching the bag won’t do anything to the contents of the bag.
What they said. Magic, dimension-y reasons.