I just got done watching Dungeon Dudes latest episode of Seasons of Silence where they fought a Bog Troll. Only one of them had fire damage via Heat Metal (the Druid did. There was also a Bard and a Paladin in the party.) EVENTUALLY, they were able to get a javelin imbedded into the troll and cast Heat Metal. They also improvised a lot, using oil and an ever-burning candle to fire breath and shoot a candle with a bow.
I haven’t taken Heat Metal on a build since 14 rules; there are so many conceivably better spells in the current meta that I cannot see taking it over them. It might depend on the allowed content in the campaign or one-shot, but I’m just trying to plan for everything.
My Artificer’s 2nd level spells are Homoculous Servant and Tortious Shell (I think those are the names/spellings, but bear with me). The first is basically another Battle Familiar (he has the Familiar background), and the shell as I understand it lets him ride on his steel defender but get a +3 to AC since he’s not using his actions to move.
My Bard is also part warlock, so he really only gets two level 2 spells in his progression. Suggestion is too important, especially with Enchantment Adept, and the second spell eventually gets replaced with Battle Familiar. I guess I could use Heat Metal until then?
Lastly, druid has a ton of spells and gets room for plenty of level 2 ones, but between Battle Familiar, Spike Growth, and the two WoW spells among others, I really don’t think I have the room.
So, I know Heat Metal upcast and is arguably a staple in DnD, but is it really worth it still… at least depending on the campaign?
There is another angle to this I considered: a good DM wouldn’t put a Troll against a party without fire damage. Am I looking at this the wrong way perhaps? Obviously, I’d love your opinions and/or example builds. Thanks.
You have Dragon's Breath as an Artificer spell. It can be any common elemental type you need it to be. Prepared spells are limited, but its a good wild card if you're not sure if you need an elemental damage type.
Like lots of spells, heat metal is situational, and can be campaign dependent. If you’re fighting a lot of armored enemies, you can probably get a lot of mileage out of it. In other cases, it will be next to useless.
As far as bad DMimg, I disagree. For one, after you said they don’t have fire damage, you then listed multiple ways they did, indeed, have fire damage. Second, that’s just the kind of thing that makes a fight interesting. It forced the players to get resourceful, and they won. That sounds way more interesting than the wizard spamming fire bolt.
I guess to me those ways just didn’t seem very realistic and kind of dampened the “realism” for me. Yes it’s a fantasy setting, but being too random can be bad too. Still, I guess if the general audience is having fun (not necessarily the players since this is meant for viewing), that is what’s important.
Oh, and I did sub out Tortoise Shell Dragon’s Breath. I misread how the former worked. Thanks for the idea!
I guess to me those ways just didn’t seem very realistic and kind of dampened the “realism” for me. Yes it’s a fantasy setting, but being too random can be bad too. Still, I guess if the general audience is having fun (not necessarily the players since this is meant for viewing), that is what’s important.
Oh, and I did sub out Tortoise Shell Dragon’s Breath. I misread how the former worked. Thanks for the idea!
You're playing a fantasy game where a 9ft tall slab of meat, with the hygiene of an open sewer, is capable of extreme cell division to a level that it bypasses scarring and doesn't demand the metabolic energy output of a furnace. Realism was out the window when you picked a class that routinely violates the laws of thermal dynamics, conservation of energy, and conventional physics.
Verisimilitude is "the quality of seeming true or of having the appearance of being real" ; and in the case of fiction, there has to be a willingness to engage with the fiction on the terms IT lays out. This related to, but not explicitly like, suspension of disbelief; as the latter is the initial barrier for entry, while the other is about maintaining the integrity of an established premise.
The reason I'm homing in on this is due to a player in my group who makes the same kind of arguments you do. But under scrutiny this logic fails or is based on incorrect assumptions about the real world. Especially when they pick and choose what is more favorable to them in a given moment. Like a huge argument broke out about Ever smoking bottle and how far around corners it can go. And it lead to a double standard argument because he wanted to be outside of it, but also also cover enemies on the opposite side of the area effect further down the tunnel.
5e Purposely ignore minutia of detail in favor of simple to follow rules.... and resists any attempt to modify that, lest you have to overhaul everything it touches. IE: "realism" NEVER works if it requires you to think/explain a premise for more than 3 seconds. As a player you have to accept that, and how the DM has carte blanche to rule however they want; final adjudication. Not all DMs are good, but the vast majority of players are even worse. The more you focus on the idea that its not about if its realistic or not, what matters is if its consistently applied throughout the setting, and the reason the way something makes sense in that context.
While I personally don’t entirely agree, you bring up some good points. Probably the biggest one wasn’t mentioned yet though: fun. It would be boring if you couldn’t do anything. I still think there needs to be a balance, but that is ultimately the DM’s job (the players can have some say/negotiations, but the ultimate ruling comes from the DM). Some of these expectations should probably be brought up in session zero… or at least ahead of time.
Anyway, I’m sorry if I triggered you or indirectly brought up something you are having a negative experience with. I hope ultimately this was just us talking and nothing personal. That’s thr last thing I want about a game that I agree is ultimately meant to be an escape from reality.
I love heat metal. Cast it on a weapon or shield to try to make them to drop it (disarmed or -2 to AC), or cast on armor or something else to not only cause a 2d8 of damage each round as a bonus action, but also impose disadvantage on attacks and ability checks - that's pretty strong stuff in my opinion.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
"...at worst if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat."
I’m still having trouble working it in despite this.
Mu Artificer at this level prefers homoculous servant and invisibility, my bars also prefers invisibility and suggestion (subtly due to enchantment adept), and my druid prefers pass without trace and the spike growth/thorn whip combo.
Maybe improvised fire damage is the way… at least for me?
I’m still having trouble working it in despite this.
Mu Artificer at this level prefers homoculous servant and invisibility, my bars also prefers invisibility and suggestion (subtly due to enchantment adept), and my druid prefers pass without trace and the spike growth/thorn whip combo.
Maybe improvised fire damage is the way… at least for me?
Or just carry some torches. No need to over complicate it. Acid does the trick as well if you have access to some of that.
I’m still having trouble working it in despite this.
Mu Artificer at this level prefers homoculous servant and invisibility, my bars also prefers invisibility and suggestion (subtly due to enchantment adept), and my druid prefers pass without trace and the spike growth/thorn whip combo.
Maybe improvised fire damage is the way… at least for me?
Or just carry some torches. No need to over complicate it. Acid does the trick as well if you have access to some of that.
…really? I’ll have to check if any of those classes have the acid spray cantrip. I already gave up true strike on my battle smith for fire bolt just for this reason, but I’m pretty sure it gets acid spray or something like it too for a cantrip.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I just got done watching Dungeon Dudes latest episode of Seasons of Silence where they fought a Bog Troll. Only one of them had fire damage via Heat Metal (the Druid did. There was also a Bard and a Paladin in the party.) EVENTUALLY, they were able to get a javelin imbedded into the troll and cast Heat Metal. They also improvised a lot, using oil and an ever-burning candle to fire breath and shoot a candle with a bow.
I haven’t taken Heat Metal on a build since 14 rules; there are so many conceivably better spells in the current meta that I cannot see taking it over them. It might depend on the allowed content in the campaign or one-shot, but I’m just trying to plan for everything.
My Artificer’s 2nd level spells are Homoculous Servant and Tortious Shell (I think those are the names/spellings, but bear with me). The first is basically another Battle Familiar (he has the Familiar background), and the shell as I understand it lets him ride on his steel defender but get a +3 to AC since he’s not using his actions to move.
My Bard is also part warlock, so he really only gets two level 2 spells in his progression. Suggestion is too important, especially with Enchantment Adept, and the second spell eventually gets replaced with Battle Familiar. I guess I could use Heat Metal until then?
Lastly, druid has a ton of spells and gets room for plenty of level 2 ones, but between Battle Familiar, Spike Growth, and the two WoW spells among others, I really don’t think I have the room.
So, I know Heat Metal upcast and is arguably a staple in DnD, but is it really worth it still… at least depending on the campaign?
There is another angle to this I considered: a good DM wouldn’t put a Troll against a party without fire damage. Am I looking at this the wrong way perhaps? Obviously, I’d love your opinions and/or example builds. Thanks.
You have Dragon's Breath as an Artificer spell. It can be any common elemental type you need it to be. Prepared spells are limited, but its a good wild card if you're not sure if you need an elemental damage type.
Like lots of spells, heat metal is situational, and can be campaign dependent. If you’re fighting a lot of armored enemies, you can probably get a lot of mileage out of it. In other cases, it will be next to useless.
As far as bad DMimg, I disagree. For one, after you said they don’t have fire damage, you then listed multiple ways they did, indeed, have fire damage. Second, that’s just the kind of thing that makes a fight interesting. It forced the players to get resourceful, and they won. That sounds way more interesting than the wizard spamming fire bolt.
I guess to me those ways just didn’t seem very realistic and kind of dampened the “realism” for me. Yes it’s a fantasy setting, but being too random can be bad too. Still, I guess if the general audience is having fun (not necessarily the players since this is meant for viewing), that is what’s important.
Oh, and I did sub out Tortoise Shell Dragon’s Breath. I misread how the former worked. Thanks for the idea!
Heat metal is very strong against a small subset of enemies; its big problem is that it's very situational rather than generally useful.
You're playing a fantasy game where a 9ft tall slab of meat, with the hygiene of an open sewer, is capable of extreme cell division to a level that it bypasses scarring and doesn't demand the metabolic energy output of a furnace. Realism was out the window when you picked a class that routinely violates the laws of thermal dynamics, conservation of energy, and conventional physics.
Verisimilitude is "the quality of seeming true or of having the appearance of being real" ; and in the case of fiction, there has to be a willingness to engage with the fiction on the terms IT lays out. This related to, but not explicitly like, suspension of disbelief; as the latter is the initial barrier for entry, while the other is about maintaining the integrity of an established premise.
The reason I'm homing in on this is due to a player in my group who makes the same kind of arguments you do. But under scrutiny this logic fails or is based on incorrect assumptions about the real world. Especially when they pick and choose what is more favorable to them in a given moment. Like a huge argument broke out about Ever smoking bottle and how far around corners it can go. And it lead to a double standard argument because he wanted to be outside of it, but also also cover enemies on the opposite side of the area effect further down the tunnel.
5e Purposely ignore minutia of detail in favor of simple to follow rules.... and resists any attempt to modify that, lest you have to overhaul everything it touches. IE: "realism" NEVER works if it requires you to think/explain a premise for more than 3 seconds. As a player you have to accept that, and how the DM has carte blanche to rule however they want; final adjudication. Not all DMs are good, but the vast majority of players are even worse. The more you focus on the idea that its not about if its realistic or not, what matters is if its consistently applied throughout the setting, and the reason the way something makes sense in that context.
While I personally don’t entirely agree, you bring up some good points. Probably the biggest one wasn’t mentioned yet though: fun. It would be boring if you couldn’t do anything. I still think there needs to be a balance, but that is ultimately the DM’s job (the players can have some say/negotiations, but the ultimate ruling comes from the DM). Some of these expectations should probably be brought up in session zero… or at least ahead of time.
Anyway, I’m sorry if I triggered you or indirectly brought up something you are having a negative experience with. I hope ultimately this was just us talking and nothing personal. That’s thr last thing I want about a game that I agree is ultimately meant to be an escape from reality.
I love heat metal. Cast it on a weapon or shield to try to make them to drop it (disarmed or -2 to AC), or cast on armor or something else to not only cause a 2d8 of damage each round as a bonus action, but also impose disadvantage on attacks and ability checks - that's pretty strong stuff in my opinion.
"...at worst if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat."
I’m still having trouble working it in despite this.
Mu Artificer at this level prefers homoculous servant and invisibility, my bars also prefers invisibility and suggestion (subtly due to enchantment adept), and my druid prefers pass without trace and the spike growth/thorn whip combo.
Maybe improvised fire damage is the way… at least for me?
Or just carry some torches. No need to over complicate it.
Acid does the trick as well if you have access to some of that.
…really? I’ll have to check if any of those classes have the acid spray cantrip. I already gave up true strike on my battle smith for fire bolt just for this reason, but I’m pretty sure it gets acid spray or something like it too for a cantrip.