From my own persspective, asss a Yuan-Ti anywayss, I find creaturesss with weak consstitutionsss particularly funny...
"OH IT BURNS!", "GODS SAVE ME!", "MY SKIN IS MELTING!"
Hilariousss.
The Caster raises a hand above their head as an orb of vile venom is concentrated above them, the caster then is able to throw down this orb at a location within 5 ft.
Targets hit directly by the orb must make a Dexterity saving throw or take 1d10 poison damage and an additional 1d6 force damage for every 10 ft the orb fell until impact with the ground (Max 6d6). Targets within 5 ft of the main target or location (Collateral) take 1d8 poison damage as the orb splashes upon impact (does not benefit from additional drop damage). Collateral targets that make the dex save take no damage while main targets take half.
This spell will cause main targets who are flying fall to the ground with the orb on a failed save.
This spell can damage its caster.
This spell's damage increases by 1d10(main target) & 1d8(collateral) when you reach 5th level (2d10/2d8), 11th level (3d10/3d8), and 17th level (4d10/4d8).
-
View User Profile
-
Send Message
Posted Sep 27, 2021I'm curious if you've playtested this one, because on paper (err... in pixels i guess) there are a few things that seem off.
1) Half damage on a successful save is normally reserved for leveled spells or evocation wizards' cantrips. Not to say you can't, but it's a significant power boost that would make for a strong cantrip just on its own.
2) The distance at which you can create the orb of venom is unclear, the spells range is 5ft but the description just says the orb "is concentrated above [the caster]". The line about flying creatures hints that the distance is supposed to be pretty significant but since there aren't any details it means asking the GM to interpret how it's supposed to work (put that one in the Staff of Aggravation).
3) The potential damage to the primary target is pretty damn high for a cantrip, up to 6d6 force damage is very nearly fireball levels of damage but with a hard-to-resist damage type.
Sure it depends on where its being cast but there aren't any official cantrips that can get that level of damage boost just from being in a different environment. Its extra bad for flying creatures who take up to 20d6 falling damage for being knocked out of the stratosphere by a magic booger.
On the other hand...
The limited horizontal range, the commonly resisted poison damage and the fact that you have to risk hitting yourself (but not if you're a yuan-ti, nice touch) to get the full force of the spell offsets the potential damage boost a little, but makes for a really weird, finicky, niche spell.
If that's what you wanted, that's fine. Just specify a maximum height you can summon the orb at and/or let flying creatures make a save to avoid falling, then maybe reduce all the damage dice by one or two steps to bring it in line with other splash damage cantrips (d10 > d8 > d6 etc).
But to my mind this cantrip is doing a little too much, so if I wanted to develop a version for my own games here's how I'd do it:
First, figure out what makes this cantrip interesting compared to existing ones.
- The high damage/self damage risk tradeoff?
- The circumstantial damage bonus?
- Messing with flying creatures?
- The potential for puns about dropping acid?
For myself I'd say the most interesting thing is making puns but vicious mockery already exists so lets go for circumstantial damage shenanigans instead.
The idea of a magic blob of venom smacking down your foes is pretty cool so lets keep the orb, but lets change the damage ramping mechanic to something like delayed blast fireball instead. And lets add the ability to redirect the blob of venom after casting, now the caster has a cool little poison dart they can fire around corners.
So it would look something like this:
Hector's Flying Bile
You spit an orb of venom at a point within range, the orb lingers at the chosen point for the duration, if you end your turn more than 60ft away from the orb the spell ends.
You can use an action to fire the orb of venom at a creature you can see within 60 feet of you. Make a ranged spell attack against the target. On a hit, the target takes 1d10 poison damage. The spell then ends.
At the end of each of your turns, the orb's damage increases by 1d6.
If the orb is touched before the the spell ends, the creature touching it must make a Dexterity saving throw. On a failed save, the spell ends immediately and the creature takes damage as if it had been hit by the orb. On a successful save, the creature can can make a ranged spell attack against a creature within 60ft of it using the orb of venom. The attack uses your spellcasting ability modifier for the attack roll.
If the spell ends before the orb is used it dissipates in a puff of green vapor.
This spell’s base damage increases by 1d10 when you reach 5th level (2d10), 11th level (3d10), and 17th level (4d10).
This spell's damage increase at the end of your turn increases by 1d6 when you reach 11th level (2d6).
Now the spell still has massive damage potential, the poison damage tradeoff, a risk of reversal if a clever enemy gets their hands on it (but immunity if you're yuan-ti) and you don't have to worry about how tall the ceilings are (suck it druids and tempest clerics).
Feel free to use this rework as an update to this spell, I've got a private copy of Flying Bile so no worries if you'd prefer to keep it as is.