Level
Cantrip
Casting Time
1 Bonus Action
Range/Area
90 ft.
Components
V, S
Duration
Instantaneous
School
Evocation
Attack/Save
None
Damage/Effect
Force
Using a slashing motion, you evoke pure force to damage a creature or object within range. The target takes 1d4 - 1 force damage.
This spell's damage increases by 1d4 - 1 when you reach 5th level (2d4 - 2), 11th level (3d4 - 3), and 17th level (4d4 - 4).
-
View User Profile
-
Send Message
Posted Dec 24, 2018I've decided to comment on my own things to invite discussion and explain thought process.
So this one is a silly idea. How does one make a reasonable bonus action cantrip. There's certainly nothing wrong with Magic Stone and Shillelagh but those don't deal the damage themselves when you cast them which isn't really what I was looking for. Or how about a damage cantrip that doesn't require an attack roll or saving throw. Tricky balancing act here, call me crazy, figured it would just make the most sense if both these concepts came together to make a rather silly, maybe slightly awkward but reliable baby cantrip. Quick as a whistle and hits like a hard poke in the ribs with the potential of doing absolutely nothing. There of course needs to be a chance of failure, it is a cantrip after all, and it needs to do a low amount of damage to warrant being a bonus action, though one could argue that any damage on a bonus action cantrip is too much. 1d4 is as low as it reasonably gets, with a -1 for 0 damage if you roll a one for a chance of failure with a maximum of 3 damage. Ramps up to 0 to 12 as you level. Force damage is incredibly reliable damage typing. I certainly don't think it needs more damage in any way; it's borderline over powered just because of what it is. I will say, a lot of the intention of the concept is a quick, reliable and easy way to tack on some damage for a caster that finds himself needing his action for something else. Kiting is a good example. Need to dash, disengage, or dodge yourself out of a sticky situation? Scathe lets you do that and still do some damage. Now casting a spell with your action, even just a cantrip and then using your bonus action to cast Scathe might be considered too strong, and reasonably so. All things considered it might not be a bad idea to tag something like "you can't be cast another spell during the same turn" onto it if that's what your worried about.
-
View User Profile
-
Send Message
Posted Dec 31, 2018I'd say to at least get rid of the -1 damage. Compare this spell to its big full action brother, eldritch blast. This spell has the potential to do 4d10 force damage for turn, and could be cast as a bonus action if you quicken it (Warcerer?).
The only thing about bonus action cantrips is features like quicken spell and that one Eldritch Knight feature that I can't remember the name of that allow you to cast full action spells with a bonus action. If I were you, I'd at least get rid of the -1 damage if not bump it up to 1d6 damage, and then make each separate ray require an attack roll (like eldritch).
-
View User Profile
-
Send Message
Posted Jan 1, 2019The problem imo with getting rid of the -1 damage is I would have to add in another chance of failure, presumably either an attack roll or saving throw. I'm not saying I shouldn't do one of those two things instead but the dream is to have a cantrip that doesn't. I'm fine with it being a bad idea heh...
The Eldritch Blast comparison has its good points but also its bad ones. Eldritch Blast is basically the end-all-be-all of damage cantrips and Scathe is specifically supposed to be the opposite of that; Eldritch Blast is supposed to do too much damage and Scathe should really do too little. I'd be wary of the idea of this having separate rays as I don't think it should have the flexibility of splitting its damage like Eldritch Blast.
I actually feel its more comparable to Magic Missile, as it also requires no attack rolls or saving throws, though once again I don't think this cantrip should be able to split its damage.
I don't feel like its really in conflict with abilities and effects that allow you to cast normal action spells as bonus actions as any spell you do that with will almost always be better than casting this anyways. If anything, this gives a better natural progression to such characters as they can sacrifice a cantrip slot for this early and then transition into being able to cast better cantrips and/or other spells, while still holding onto it as a go to backup for when they need to use their action to do something sub-optimal.
Now all of that doesn't necessarily address the entirely reasonable argument that maybe this cantrip either shouldn't be a bonus action or should require an attack roll or saving throw, but definitely not both. Shrug...