Thinking abt dipping into Fighter for 1 level for a Fighting Style and saving throw proficiencies. Then I was like, Fighters also tend to get weapons-based feats. So if I'm building a Cleric multi-class for occasional tanking but also want to do some reasonable damage per round, which of these feats should I plan for after getting an my initial Wisdom boost?
* Dual Wielder - better Armor Class, better chance of hitting per round since two attacks, but spellcaster
* Shield Master - No additional attacks, just defense and a bit of shoving
* Polearm Master - More opportunities for attack, ablility to maintain some distance when I get into melee
On Fighter: is the Cons proficiency, Second Wind, and Fighting Style not worth it on a full caster like a Cleric?
The big problem with trying to dual wield is casting. You’ll always have your hands full. From those choices, I’d probably go shield master. PAM is cool, but won’t you be better off making attacks with your casting stat? And using your BA for healing word?
But also, as is always the case with a full caster, you’ll end up delaying your spell progression for that bit of tankiness. I’d stick cleric, pick an aggressive subclass and go for it that way. fwiw, I played a tempest cleric, heavy armor, martial weapons, up in melee a lot, and I still ended up casting much more than ever swinging my weapon. It was just much more reliable. After I took warcaster and got cantrip OAs, I don’t think I ever used my weapon.
My observation is that Paladins and Rangers still manage to cast spells with their hands full most of the time. Paladins with a sword and board; Rangers with a bow and arrow or while dual-wielding. What is different about a Cleric trying to do the same?
War Clerics love a level of fighter. Maul (for topple), GWM, grab true strike from High elf or some other manner. Hit things hard, knock them down, use spirit guardians. Get Warcaster. Never lose concentration. Hit them again if they try to run away. Your ASI's: 4: Warcaster, 8 GWM, 12 Heavy Armor Master.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
My observation is that Paladins and Rangers still manage to cast spells with their hands full most of the time. Paladins with a sword and board; Rangers with a bow and arrow or while dual-wielding. What is different about a Cleric trying to do the same?
It comes down to components. Hunter’s mark and divine smite only have a verbal component, so full hands don’t matter, for example. But clerics have lots of spells with an S component which requires a free hand.
Also paladins, and clerics, can use their shield as a focus, which can help with M components. But that doesn’t get around the S without warcaster. Even with warcaster, it gets tricky, as that means you can ignore the S if there’s an M, but is a spell is just V S (cure wounds being a good example) you still need a free hand even if you have warcaster.
There’s also the secret third option, that your group just kind of ignores components, which I think is a not uncommon house rule.
My observation is that Paladins and Rangers still manage to cast spells with their hands full most of the time. Paladins with a sword and board; Rangers with a bow and arrow or while dual-wielding. What is different about a Cleric trying to do the same?
It comes down to components. Hunter’s mark and divine smite only have a verbal component, so full hands don’t matter, for example. But clerics have lots of spells with an S component which requires a free hand.
Also paladins, and clerics, can use their shield as a focus, which can help with M components. But that doesn’t get around the S without warcaster. Even with warcaster, it gets tricky, as that means you can ignore the S if there’s an M, but is a spell is just V S (cure wounds being a good example) you still need a free hand even if you have warcaster.
There’s also the secret third option, that your group just kind of ignores components, which I think is a not uncommon house rule.
No, War Caster allows performing somatic components with weapons or a shield in both hands — that benefit is there to help with that specific issue, spells that have an S component but no M component. You don't need a free hand for spells like that if you have War Caster.
But I'm very much a proponent of your secret third option. I've never bothered enforcing any of this.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
Yes and no. If you want to always maintain concentration on spells then warcaster AND con proficiency is very good. If your plan is to primarily use spirit guardians then not dropping your concentration is more valuable than marginal dpr bump from increasing wisdom. Additionally, if you have true strike based on wisdom you can use warcaster with your reaction strikes when people run fleeing from the Spirit Guardians. This is even more damage.
Part of this is based on my experience in play. When the cleric casts spirit guardians they put a large target on their back. They soon get attacked by multiple ranged attackers who want to get it dropped. Improving your AC and chance to maintain the spell becomes critical.
Taking a level of fighter does a couple of nice things for a War Cleric. 1. it provides weapon masteries which add to the martial flavor of the class. 2. Topple specifically in a spirit guardians area is deadly. 3. It provides Con save proficiency, so while you are 1 level delayed in advancement you don't need to take one of the feats you might want. 4. you can take thaumaturge because protector is redundant.
My observation is that Paladins and Rangers still manage to cast spells with their hands full most of the time. Paladins with a sword and board; Rangers with a bow and arrow or while dual-wielding. What is different about a Cleric trying to do the same?
It comes down to components. Hunter’s mark and divine smite only have a verbal component, so full hands don’t matter, for example. But clerics have lots of spells with an S component which requires a free hand.
Also paladins, and clerics, can use their shield as a focus, which can help with M components. But that doesn’t get around the S without warcaster. Even with warcaster, it gets tricky, as that means you can ignore the S if there’s an M, but is a spell is just V S (cure wounds being a good example) you still need a free hand even if you have warcaster.
There’s also the secret third option, that your group just kind of ignores components, which I think is a not uncommon house rule.
No, War Caster allows performing somatic components with weapons or a shield in both hands — that benefit is there to help with that specific issue, spells that have an S component but no M component. You don't need a free hand for spells like that if you have War Caster.
But I'm very much a proponent of your secret third option. I've never bothered enforcing any of this.
Argh. Yes. My mistake. I was thinking about using a shield as a focus that lets you cast vsm and vm spells. Thanks for the correction.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
Yes and no. If you want to always maintain concentration on spells then warcaster AND con proficiency is very good. If your plan is to primarily use spirit guardians then not dropping your concentration is more valuable than marginal dpr bump from increasing wisdom. Additionally, if you have true strike based on wisdom you can use warcaster with your reaction strikes when people run fleeing from the Spirit Guardians. This is even more damage.
Part of this is based on my experience in play. When the cleric casts spirit guardians they put a large target on their back. They soon get attacked by multiple ranged attackers who want to get it dropped. Improving your AC and chance to maintain the spell becomes critical.
Taking a level of fighter does a couple of nice things for a War Cleric. 1. it provides weapon masteries which add to the martial flavor of the class. 2. Topple specifically in a spirit guardians area is deadly. 3. It provides Con save proficiency, so while you are 1 level delayed in advancement you don't need to take one of the feats you might want. 4. you can take thaumaturge because protector is redundant.
I forgot to mention that I will at a table using mostly 2014 rules. So probably no weapon masteries, but Polearm Master is stronger in that edition as well.
I hear you on the "super important spell, so don't want to lose concentration" but having a higher casting stat means that the opponents' saves are less likely to succeed. If I can't get the spell to stick in the first place, then getting super-concentration seems to be less of a priority and proficiency with CON seems adequate. I feel like i should raise WIS to an 18 at least.
I guess i need to find out how much emphasis the DM will place on the V, S, M part of spellcasting rule enforcemt.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
Yes and no. If you want to always maintain concentration on spells then warcaster AND con proficiency is very good. If your plan is to primarily use spirit guardians then not dropping your concentration is more valuable than marginal dpr bump from increasing wisdom. Additionally, if you have true strike based on wisdom you can use warcaster with your reaction strikes when people run fleeing from the Spirit Guardians. This is even more damage.
Part of this is based on my experience in play. When the cleric casts spirit guardians they put a large target on their back. They soon get attacked by multiple ranged attackers who want to get it dropped. Improving your AC and chance to maintain the spell becomes critical.
[SNIPPED for brevity]
I don't see how taking Warcaster improves your AC. Yes, it helps a little with concentration, but Fighter lvl 1 is basically Resilient (CON) with more benefits. Why increase concentration further than proficiency unless you are guaranteed to play in Tier 3? It seems like making my save-or-suck spells stick should be the higher priority here.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
Yes and no. If you want to always maintain concentration on spells then warcaster AND con proficiency is very good. If your plan is to primarily use spirit guardians then not dropping your concentration is more valuable than marginal dpr bump from increasing wisdom. Additionally, if you have true strike based on wisdom you can use warcaster with your reaction strikes when people run fleeing from the Spirit Guardians. This is even more damage.
Part of this is based on my experience in play. When the cleric casts spirit guardians they put a large target on their back. They soon get attacked by multiple ranged attackers who want to get it dropped. Improving your AC and chance to maintain the spell becomes critical.
[SNIPPED for brevity]
I don't see how taking Warcaster improves your AC. Yes, it helps a little with concentration, but Fighter lvl 1 is basically Resilient (CON) with more benefits. Why increase concentration further than proficiency unless you are guaranteed to play in Tier 3? It seems like making my save-or-suck spells stick should be the higher priority here.
He isn't saying that War Caster improves your AC. He's saying that improving your AC and improving your con saves is crucial if you are concentrating on a powerful spell like spirit guardians. You want higher AC to avoid even making a concentration check in the first place. With that in mind War Caster and Con save proficiency almost guarantees that you maintain concentration on your spells. Starting Fighter gives you better AC through armor proficiency and defense fighting style while also helping secure your concentration with con save proficiency.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
Yes and no. If you want to always maintain concentration on spells then warcaster AND con proficiency is very good. If your plan is to primarily use spirit guardians then not dropping your concentration is more valuable than marginal dpr bump from increasing wisdom. Additionally, if you have true strike based on wisdom you can use warcaster with your reaction strikes when people run fleeing from the Spirit Guardians. This is even more damage.
Part of this is based on my experience in play. When the cleric casts spirit guardians they put a large target on their back. They soon get attacked by multiple ranged attackers who want to get it dropped. Improving your AC and chance to maintain the spell becomes critical.
[SNIPPED for brevity]
I don't see how taking Warcaster improves your AC. Yes, it helps a little with concentration, but Fighter lvl 1 is basically Resilient (CON) with more benefits. Why increase concentration further than proficiency unless you are guaranteed to play in Tier 3? It seems like making my save-or-suck spells stick should be the higher priority here.
He isn't saying that War Caster improves your AC. He's saying that improving your AC and improving your con saves is crucial if you are concentrating on a powerful spell like spirit guardians. You want higher AC to avoid even making a concentration check in the first place. With that in mind War Caster and Con save proficiency almost guarantees that you maintain concentration on your spells. Starting Fighter gives you better AC through armor proficiency and defense fighting style while also helping secure your concentration with con save proficiency.
And I point is that taking a feat just to get more Concentration on top of already being proficient in CON saving throws is a major opportunity cost for Druids since they get fewer feats than a Fighter. By the time most campaigns end (around level 11), Druids will only have had 2 ASIs. If Shieldmaster lets you sometimes avoid damage completely, isn't that a better use of your limited ASIs? Not taking damage is better than taking damage and having to roll for the save. Granted, sometimes you will take damage anyway, but why over-invest in concentration?
He isn't saying that War Caster improves your AC. He's saying that improving your AC and improving your con saves is crucial if you are concentrating on a powerful spell like spirit guardians. You want higher AC to avoid even making a concentration check in the first place. With that in mind War Caster and Con save proficiency almost guarantees that you maintain concentration on your spells. Starting Fighter gives you better AC through armor proficiency and defense fighting style while also helping secure your concentration with con save proficiency.
And I point is that taking a feat just to get more Concentration on top of already being proficient in CON saving throws is a major opportunity cost for Druids since they get fewer feats than a Fighter. By the time most campaigns end (around level 11), Druids will only have had 2 ASIs. If Shieldmaster lets you sometimes avoid damage completely, isn't that a better use of your limited ASIs? Not taking damage is better than taking damage and having to roll for the save. Granted, sometimes you will take damage anyway, but why over-invest in concentration?
With the 2024 ruleset war caster would increase your casting stat along with the other aspects of the feat. In your scenario it's actually more advantageous to take war caster because you can get a 20 in wisdom with a point buy character using war caster and an asi. Shield Master does not help with your casting stat and only helps on dex saves and only if you pass the dex save. As a cleric or druid even with a 1st level fighter dip your chance of passing a dex save is slim, probably only 30%. So you would propose passing on something that helps every time you take damage while concentrating for something that only helps 30% of the time on the maybe 1 in 5 instances of taking damage while concentrating. For math purposes that helps about 6% of the time.
Also war caster does more than just grant advantage on con saves for concentration. The reactive spell is helpful and being able to perform somatic components with your hands full can be very important if your DM is a stickler about it. If your DM is a stickler you may not be able to wield a weapon and shield while casting shield.
My observation is that Paladins and Rangers still manage to cast spells with their hands full most of the time. Paladins with a sword and board; Rangers with a bow and arrow or while dual-wielding. What is different about a Cleric trying to do the same?
It comes down to components. Hunter’s mark and divine smite only have a verbal component, so full hands don’t matter, for example. But clerics have lots of spells with an S component which requires a free hand.
Also paladins, and clerics, can use their shield as a focus, which can help with M components. But that doesn’t get around the S without warcaster. Even with warcaster, it gets tricky, as that means you can ignore the S if there’s an M, but is a spell is just V S (cure wounds being a good example) you still need a free hand even if you have warcaster.
There’s also the secret third option, that your group just kind of ignores components, which I think is a not uncommon house rule.
No, War Caster allows performing somatic components with weapons or a shield in both hands — that benefit is there to help with that specific issue, spells that have an S component but no M component. You don't need a free hand for spells like that if you have War Caster.
But I'm very much a proponent of your secret third option. I've never bothered enforcing any of this.
Argh. Yes. My mistake. I was thinking about using a shield as a focus that lets you cast vsm and vm spells. Thanks for the correction.
My two cents: I customize my shield in the character app to explicitly state that I have affixed an Emblem of my deity to the front of my shield, so that when I do a Turn Undead, the shield presents my deity's emblem to the undead for the Turn effect. And, I do not have the War Caster feat.
two handed weapons also allows somantic casting, you simply hold the weapon one handed while you cast, then you grab again and resume two handed fighting. No shield but no need for war caster.
Do you have True Strike? You really should. Since Clerics only get one attack anyway, it should be your go-to to have it and focus on wisdom first and then constitution. Also, your shield can and should act as a spell casting focus via an emblem so you can use feats other than war caster. Don’t get me wrong; it’s still a great feat, but there are other classes that can make better use of it.
Assuming you didn’t go with True Strike, well… you should be using your ranged spells first and foremost and still pimping up wisdom. After that perhaps you boost your strength for melee reassurance?
If you didn’t start out fighter for the constitution proficiency, I really wouldn’t do it at all. Assuming you didn’t though, I’d take the new fighting stance from Arcana Unleashed for True Strike if you can get it. Otherwise, just go defense. The main weapon I think you want is the trident for its topple feature. Just know when to use it is when your ranged allies have something else they can do besides attack that target.
To (finally) answer your question, if you have to take any of these, I would take shield master since you really should be using an emblem for spellcasting anyway.
It would also help to know what stats were being worked with to get a gameplan.
two handed weapons also allows somantic casting, you simply hold the weapon one handed while you cast, then you grab again and resume two handed fighting. No shield but no need for war caster.
But then you still need to access the material component. And the rules specify you must have a free hand for that. It’s kind of a gray area/DM ruling if you can let go of the weapon, access the material component and then grab the weapon again. To me it definitely butts up against free hand, but that doesn’t matter at your table, of course.
two handed weapons also allows somantic casting, you simply hold the weapon one handed while you cast, then you grab again and resume two handed fighting. No shield but no need for war caster.
But then you still need to access the material component. And the rules specify you must have a free hand for that. It’s kind of a gray area/DM ruling if you can let go of the weapon, access the material component and then grab the weapon again. To me it definitely butts up against free hand, but that doesn’t matter at your table, of course.
Ruby of the war mage takes care of that.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Thinking abt dipping into Fighter for 1 level for a Fighting Style and saving throw proficiencies. Then I was like, Fighters also tend to get weapons-based feats. So if I'm building a Cleric multi-class for occasional tanking but also want to do some reasonable damage per round, which of these feats should I plan for after getting an my initial Wisdom boost?
* Dual Wielder - better Armor Class, better chance of hitting per round since two attacks, but spellcaster
* Shield Master - No additional attacks, just defense and a bit of shoving
* Polearm Master - More opportunities for attack, ablility to maintain some distance when I get into melee
On Fighter: is the Cons proficiency, Second Wind, and Fighting Style not worth it on a full caster like a Cleric?
The big problem with trying to dual wield is casting. You’ll always have your hands full.
From those choices, I’d probably go shield master. PAM is cool, but won’t you be better off making attacks with your casting stat? And using your BA for healing word?
But also, as is always the case with a full caster, you’ll end up delaying your spell progression for that bit of tankiness. I’d stick cleric, pick an aggressive subclass and go for it that way.
fwiw, I played a tempest cleric, heavy armor, martial weapons, up in melee a lot, and I still ended up casting much more than ever swinging my weapon. It was just much more reliable. After I took warcaster and got cantrip OAs, I don’t think I ever used my weapon.
My observation is that Paladins and Rangers still manage to cast spells with their hands full most of the time. Paladins with a sword and board; Rangers with a bow and arrow or while dual-wielding. What is different about a Cleric trying to do the same?
War Clerics love a level of fighter. Maul (for topple), GWM, grab true strike from High elf or some other manner. Hit things hard, knock them down, use spirit guardians. Get Warcaster. Never lose concentration. Hit them again if they try to run away. Your ASI's: 4: Warcaster, 8 GWM, 12 Heavy Armor Master.
I feel like part of the reason to start level 1 w/ Fighter is to avoid spending a feat on Warcaster, no? Aren't there some better feats to get if you already start with saving throw prof. in Constitution?
It comes down to components. Hunter’s mark and divine smite only have a verbal component, so full hands don’t matter, for example. But clerics have lots of spells with an S component which requires a free hand.
Also paladins, and clerics, can use their shield as a focus, which can help with M components. But that doesn’t get around the S without warcaster. Even with warcaster, it gets tricky, as that means you can ignore the S if there’s an M, but is a spell is just V S (cure wounds being a good example) you still need a free hand even if you have warcaster.
There’s also the secret third option, that your group just kind of ignores components, which I think is a not uncommon house rule.
No, War Caster allows performing somatic components with weapons or a shield in both hands — that benefit is there to help with that specific issue, spells that have an S component but no M component. You don't need a free hand for spells like that if you have War Caster.
But I'm very much a proponent of your secret third option. I've never bothered enforcing any of this.
pronouns: he/she/they
Yes and no. If you want to always maintain concentration on spells then warcaster AND con proficiency is very good. If your plan is to primarily use spirit guardians then not dropping your concentration is more valuable than marginal dpr bump from increasing wisdom. Additionally, if you have true strike based on wisdom you can use warcaster with your reaction strikes when people run fleeing from the Spirit Guardians. This is even more damage.
Part of this is based on my experience in play. When the cleric casts spirit guardians they put a large target on their back. They soon get attacked by multiple ranged attackers who want to get it dropped. Improving your AC and chance to maintain the spell becomes critical.
Taking a level of fighter does a couple of nice things for a War Cleric. 1. it provides weapon masteries which add to the martial flavor of the class. 2. Topple specifically in a spirit guardians area is deadly. 3. It provides Con save proficiency, so while you are 1 level delayed in advancement you don't need to take one of the feats you might want. 4. you can take thaumaturge because protector is redundant.
Argh. Yes. My mistake. I was thinking about using a shield as a focus that lets you cast vsm and vm spells. Thanks for the correction.
It is needlessly complicated and very easy to misunderstand/misremember, which is a good argument in favor of the "just ignore it" approach.
pronouns: he/she/they
I forgot to mention that I will at a table using mostly 2014 rules. So probably no weapon masteries, but Polearm Master is stronger in that edition as well.
I hear you on the "super important spell, so don't want to lose concentration" but having a higher casting stat means that the opponents' saves are less likely to succeed. If I can't get the spell to stick in the first place, then getting super-concentration seems to be less of a priority and proficiency with CON seems adequate. I feel like i should raise WIS to an 18 at least.
I guess i need to find out how much emphasis the DM will place on the V, S, M part of spellcasting rule enforcemt.
I don't see how taking Warcaster improves your AC. Yes, it helps a little with concentration, but Fighter lvl 1 is basically Resilient (CON) with more benefits. Why increase concentration further than proficiency unless you are guaranteed to play in Tier 3? It seems like making my save-or-suck spells stick should be the higher priority here.
He isn't saying that War Caster improves your AC. He's saying that improving your AC and improving your con saves is crucial if you are concentrating on a powerful spell like spirit guardians. You want higher AC to avoid even making a concentration check in the first place. With that in mind War Caster and Con save proficiency almost guarantees that you maintain concentration on your spells. Starting Fighter gives you better AC through armor proficiency and defense fighting style while also helping secure your concentration with con save proficiency.
And I point is that taking a feat just to get more Concentration on top of already being proficient in CON saving throws is a major opportunity cost for Druids since they get fewer feats than a Fighter. By the time most campaigns end (around level 11), Druids will only have had 2 ASIs. If Shieldmaster lets you sometimes avoid damage completely, isn't that a better use of your limited ASIs? Not taking damage is better than taking damage and having to roll for the save. Granted, sometimes you will take damage anyway, but why over-invest in concentration?
With the 2024 ruleset war caster would increase your casting stat along with the other aspects of the feat. In your scenario it's actually more advantageous to take war caster because you can get a 20 in wisdom with a point buy character using war caster and an asi. Shield Master does not help with your casting stat and only helps on dex saves and only if you pass the dex save. As a cleric or druid even with a 1st level fighter dip your chance of passing a dex save is slim, probably only 30%. So you would propose passing on something that helps every time you take damage while concentrating for something that only helps 30% of the time on the maybe 1 in 5 instances of taking damage while concentrating. For math purposes that helps about 6% of the time.
Also war caster does more than just grant advantage on con saves for concentration. The reactive spell is helpful and being able to perform somatic components with your hands full can be very important if your DM is a stickler about it. If your DM is a stickler you may not be able to wield a weapon and shield while casting shield.
My two cents: I customize my shield in the character app to explicitly state that I have affixed an Emblem of my deity to the front of my shield, so that when I do a Turn Undead, the shield presents my deity's emblem to the undead for the Turn effect. And, I do not have the War Caster feat.
two handed weapons also allows somantic casting, you simply hold the weapon one handed while you cast, then you grab again and resume two handed fighting. No shield but no need for war caster.
Life's hard - get a helmet!
Do you have True Strike? You really should. Since Clerics only get one attack anyway, it should be your go-to to have it and focus on wisdom first and then constitution. Also, your shield can and should act as a spell casting focus via an emblem so you can use feats other than war caster. Don’t get me wrong; it’s still a great feat, but there are other classes that can make better use of it.
Assuming you didn’t go with True Strike, well… you should be using your ranged spells first and foremost and still pimping up wisdom. After that perhaps you boost your strength for melee reassurance?
If you didn’t start out fighter for the constitution proficiency, I really wouldn’t do it at all. Assuming you didn’t though, I’d take the new fighting stance from Arcana Unleashed for True Strike if you can get it. Otherwise, just go defense. The main weapon I think you want is the trident for its topple feature. Just know when to use it is when your ranged allies have something else they can do besides attack that target.
To (finally) answer your question, if you have to take any of these, I would take shield master since you really should be using an emblem for spellcasting anyway.
It would also help to know what stats were being worked with to get a gameplan.
But then you still need to access the material component. And the rules specify you must have a free hand for that. It’s kind of a gray area/DM ruling if you can let go of the weapon, access the material component and then grab the weapon again. To me it definitely butts up against free hand, but that doesn’t matter at your table, of course.
Ruby of the war mage takes care of that.