I wasn’t really sure where would be a reasonable place to post about this and I am hoping someone from WotC and Hasbro(it’s most likely a Hasbro call) sees this. Firstly I would like to say kudos on many of the changes since the OGL debacle, credit where credit is due there but I personally think it is bad taste to lock some of the subclass updates into the universes beyond releases. I can understand wanting to get the content out there and I can understand following the thematics, but it just comes off as a blatant way to try to forcibly keep your core audience buying a book while also trying to hook extra fandoms in. That sounds perfectly reasonable in a board room, but in practice it will alienate your existing base if you overdo it. If you still had the microtransactions where you could buy just a single subclass or a single feat out of a book on dndbeyond the issue would be mitigated somewhat, or even an end of year mini book anthology of the player facing options like (and I’m probably going to show my age here) “NOW that’s what I call subclasses 2026” ect. I personally will not be buying the WOW book as I have no interest in running a game in that setting and I do not want to reward what I view as a business decision impacting the way the game operates. If anyone out there feels similarly make sure to chime in, but please keep it respectful and not just a “WotC bad ugh ugh”
I don't see updates in the Warcraft book as any different than updates in a Forgotten Realms book -- they're both books that people who don't run the setting are less interested in buying. Swashbuckler is no different to Bladesinger for me.
Now, I expect that we're eventually going to see a new book like Tasha's at some point, which gathers up many of the setting-locked player options into a general-purpose book. That has been the way of things for the 5e era. If I need the options right now, I can buy the book. If I'm content to wait, I can wait. (I wait, but I also have the advantage of somebody who buys most of the books in my play-group constellation.)
I wasn’t really sure where would be a reasonable place to post about this and I am hoping someone from WotC and Hasbro(it’s most likely a Hasbro call) sees this. Firstly I would like to say kudos on many of the changes since the OGL debacle, credit where credit is due there but I personally think it is bad taste to lock some of the subclass updates into the universes beyond releases. I can understand wanting to get the content out there and I can understand following the thematics, but it just comes off as a blatant way to try to forcibly keep your core audience buying a book while also trying to hook extra fandoms in. That sounds perfectly reasonable in a board room, but in practice it will alienate your existing base if you overdo it. If you still had the microtransactions where you could buy just a single subclass or a single feat out of a book on dndbeyond the issue would be mitigated somewhat, or even an end of year mini book anthology of the player facing options like (and I’m probably going to show my age here) “NOW that’s what I call subclasses 2026” ect. I personally will not be buying the WOW book as I have no interest in running a game in that setting and I do not want to reward what I view as a business decision impacting the way the game operates. If anyone out there feels similarly make sure to chime in, but please keep it respectful and not just a “WotC bad ugh ugh”
Things getting printed in a setting book first before being made more generally available is nothing new, it's been happening since the very first setting book in 5e (SCAG), which introduced subclasses like the Swashbuckler and the Bladesinger before they later got reprinted in Xanathar's and Tasha's respectively, and it happened other times throughout the edition such as the Circle of Spores Druid debuting in Ravnica and the College of Eloquence Bard debuting in Theros, before again showing up in Tasha's. If your aversion to Warcraft is that strong, I'd counsel patience until they do another setting-agnostic compilation.
It’s less there being subclasses in a setting book, but more specifically updated subclasses that were previously in the PHB or xanathars being locked in universes beyond. There is a difference there.
It’s less there being subclasses in a setting book, but more specifically updated subclasses that were previously in the PHB or xanathars being locked in universes beyond. There is a difference there.
There is not really a difference because it is fundamentally the same as their being printed in a universes within product.
The recent Ravenloft book contained a number of 5.5 versions of existing content. I do not play in Ravenloft. Frankly, I have very little interest in playing Ravenloft, as I think everything it brings to the table can be done better in other settings. But I still need to buy that book if I want the updated content.
Same exact thing is true of WoW. I do not play in WoW, nor do I have interest in playing in WoW. But if I want the content, I have to buy something where the setting does not appeal to me.
Honestly, I'd rather see something locked behind the WoW tie-in than, say, yet another forgotten realms book that reprints a bunch of background information they've already published a half dozen times. At least there's a chance the WoW book contains something new.
I feel differently about this for WoW or another high fantasy setting vs Star Wars. I find the whole 'Azeroth isn't right for DnD and I want nothing to do with it' argument odd personally, but people feel how they feel. It's a world that clearly had a tremendous amount of DnD influence when it was created and really isn't any different than any other campaign setting in my mind.
I find the WoW world tone and lore much more my thing than Dark Sun, for example. I would never run or play in a Dark Sun campaign. But if Dark Sun has interesting content that I can borrow I will still buy it, as I would with a Runeterra (League of Legends), Wheel of Time, etc... etc... Universes Beyond product that hits the traditional DnD high fantasy feel.
Star Wars to me is tonally different enough from standard DnD that I do really hope they provide content that is intended to be much more setting-specific.
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
D&D has been doing exactly this since 1980’s Expedition to the Barrier Peaks (which has already received a 5e iteration), which was and is one of the best received modules in the game’s history. City of the Gods came out in 1987. Spelljammer came out in 1989 and remained popular across editions, even winning a fan poll on what setting should be revisited in 5e.
Absolutely none of this is new and there’s been a long history of successful commingling of SciFi and D&D.
"X doesn't belong in DND" talk always intrigues me.
Killer Klowns From Outer Space ripoffs in Spelljammer get a pass, but not Star Wars?
But back on subject...
No splatbooks in sight, & that's probably some managerial/executive/accountancy decision being called a logistical one, just like how DND Beyond TOTALLY can't handle A La Carte anymore, even after the site rework, so it "had" to go w/zero public plan on WotC's website to reinstate it after the site rework.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
I don't actually think Star Wars is a good fit for the D&D mechanics*, but it's never had any real "high technology vibe". It's space wizards with laser swords. The space setting gives it a feel of larger scope, but it's fantasy at heart.
* Yes, Star Trek would be worse, but that's not happening at the moment.
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
I don't actually think Star Wars is a good fit for the D&D mechanics*, but it's never had any real "high technology vibe". It's space wizards with laser swords. The space setting gives it a feel of larger scope, but it's fantasy at heart.
* Yes, Star Trek would be worse, but that's not happening at the moment.
Andor, Rogue One, Resistance, The Book of Boba Fett & Solo would say otherwise to that space wizards comment.
I'd also love to play as Soong-Type Androids, Vulcans, Romulans, Bolians, Bajorans, Trill, Betazoids, Klingons, Deltans, Kelpiens, xBs & other such peoples in DND while Star Trekkin' across the universe fighting The Borg, The Dominion, The Breen, The Hirogen, the Tholians and various other antagonists while dealing w/The Q Continuum & other non-corporeal entities..with added exploration & diplomacy rules and The Prime Directive as an optional rule.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
I'd also love to play as Soong-Type Androids, Vulcans, Romulans, Bolians, Bajorans, Trill, Betazoids, Klingons, Deltans, Kelpiens, xBs & other such peoples in DND while Star Trekkin' across the universe fighting The Borg, The Dominion, The Breen, The Hirogen, the Tholians and various other antagonists while dealing w/The Q Continuum & other non-corporeal entities..with added exploration & diplomacy rules and The Prime Directive as an optional rule.
The thing is that there's already an excellent Star Trek TTRPG that has mechanics much more suited to its universe and in which you can do all of those things.
I'd also love to play as Soong-Type Androids, Vulcans, Romulans, Bolians, Bajorans, Trill, Betazoids, Klingons, Deltans, Kelpiens, xBs & other such peoples in DND while Star Trekkin' across the universe fighting The Borg, The Dominion, The Breen, The Hirogen, the Tholians and various other antagonists while dealing w/The Q Continuum & other non-corporeal entities..with added exploration & diplomacy rules and The Prime Directive as an optional rule.
The thing is that there's already an excellent Star Trek TTRPG that has mechanics much more suited to its universe and in which you can do all of those things.
Quite frankly, I've found that a lot of "This already exists/try this instead" in TTRPG forms do not personally appeal to me. I've tried so many & just not found that I like most of that kind of thing.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
D&D has been doing exactly this since 1980’s Expedition to the Barrier Peaks (which has already received a 5e iteration), which was and is one of the best received modules in the game’s history. City of the Gods came out in 1987. Spelljammer came out in 1989 and remained popular across editions, even winning a fan poll on what setting should be revisited in 5e.
Absolutely none of this is new and there’s been a long history of successful commingling of SciFi and D&D.
Ah, yes, Expedition to the Barrier Peaks.......introducing powered armor, blaster pistols into a sword and sorcery setting......the comic Stephen Colbert once remarked how his D&D character ran around in powered armor.
I had often wondered how these suits of powered armor and those blaster pistols were recharged with power once these items exited that space ship or how the spare power cells were recharged as well.
I'd also love to play as Soong-Type Androids, Vulcans, Romulans, Bolians, Bajorans, Trill, Betazoids, Klingons, Deltans, Kelpiens, xBs & other such peoples in DND while Star Trekkin' across the universe fighting The Borg, The Dominion, The Breen, The Hirogen, the Tholians and various other antagonists while dealing w/The Q Continuum & other non-corporeal entities..with added exploration & diplomacy rules and The Prime Directive as an optional rule.
The thing is that there's already an excellent Star Trek TTRPG that has mechanics much more suited to its universe and in which you can do all of those things.
Quite frankly, I've found that a lot of "This already exists/try this instead" in TTRPG forms do not personally appeal to me. I've tried so many & just not found that I like most of that kind of thing.
But thats just the nature of the beast. Same with video games. You have very specific tastes and low tolerance for deviations from it, its impossible to find a game you'll really click with short of making it yourself. And I've done that before. 3 High Fantasy rule sets using different dice stacks, and 2 Sci-Fi systems, one based on War gaming models (cut outs) and one that gets rid of Hit Probability in favor of active defenses. Suffice to say its not easy.
But I've also lived through 3 WoW exodus events, and I've never even played WoW...... WoW players just keep showing up in other games, and eventually start demanding it be more like WoW. So if you can't be bothered to find a system with exactly what you want, and you can't be bothered to make one yourself, the best you're going to get is modding an existing rule set and just accept other people probably won't agree with you on the changes, or the perceived problems.
I've been trying to explain Path Finder 2 to my 5e Group, but they'd much rather keep trying to find obscure feats and items and argue with the DM about what should or shouldn't be allowed by a bonus action, because it never occurred to them that action economy is a design concept. This basically IS the core issue...... TTRPGs "can" be run like a video game, BUT it doesn't have to be. You can just steal ideas from other systems that make sense, and Frankenstein something together. But the other side of that coin, I WILL argue the need for robust rules for a game system as a foundation, because it makes messing with it much easier.
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
I would say that D&D fits more poorly into Starwars than Starwars fits into D&D. D&D has always been an almost Kitchen sink game, with campaign settings usually being what sets the bounderies.
D&D can absorb starwars elements easily and it not clash, but there are many spells in D&D that clash with the so far shown limits of the force.
If you have an issue with Medival things alongside high tech and think it can't work, then there are several long running franchises and settings that show they can. Rifts, Warhammer 40K, Starfinder, Dune, and yes even Starwars prove it works. The Ewoks, the Mandolarians, the ancient sith, all had primitive weapons that they kept using effectively in a world of blasters and hyperdrives.
Heck look at real life. In the era of Blitzkriegs and tommy guns, the Fairbairn–Sykes fighting knife was in use and it is just a dagger without any frills. In WW1 trench knives got more use than tanks did.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
He/Him. Loooooooooong time Player. The Dark days of the THAC0 system are behind us.
"Hope is a fire that burns in us all If only an ember, awaiting your call To rise up in triumph should we all unite The spark for change is yours to ignite." Kalandra - The State of the World
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
I wasn’t really sure where would be a reasonable place to post about this and I am hoping someone from WotC and Hasbro(it’s most likely a Hasbro call) sees this. Firstly I would like to say kudos on many of the changes since the OGL debacle, credit where credit is due there but I personally think it is bad taste to lock some of the subclass updates into the universes beyond releases. I can understand wanting to get the content out there and I can understand following the thematics, but it just comes off as a blatant way to try to forcibly keep your core audience buying a book while also trying to hook extra fandoms in. That sounds perfectly reasonable in a board room, but in practice it will alienate your existing base if you overdo it. If you still had the microtransactions where you could buy just a single subclass or a single feat out of a book on dndbeyond the issue would be mitigated somewhat, or even an end of year mini book anthology of the player facing options like (and I’m probably going to show my age here) “NOW that’s what I call subclasses 2026” ect. I personally will not be buying the WOW book as I have no interest in running a game in that setting and I do not want to reward what I view as a business decision impacting the way the game operates. If anyone out there feels similarly make sure to chime in, but please keep it respectful and not just a “WotC bad ugh ugh”
Splatbooks have apparently have been off the menu since Dan Ayoub took over WotC.
Think of that what you will.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
I don't see updates in the Warcraft book as any different than updates in a Forgotten Realms book -- they're both books that people who don't run the setting are less interested in buying. Swashbuckler is no different to Bladesinger for me.
Now, I expect that we're eventually going to see a new book like Tasha's at some point, which gathers up many of the setting-locked player options into a general-purpose book. That has been the way of things for the 5e era. If I need the options right now, I can buy the book. If I'm content to wait, I can wait. (I wait, but I also have the advantage of somebody who buys most of the books in my play-group constellation.)
Things getting printed in a setting book first before being made more generally available is nothing new, it's been happening since the very first setting book in 5e (SCAG), which introduced subclasses like the Swashbuckler and the Bladesinger before they later got reprinted in Xanathar's and Tasha's respectively, and it happened other times throughout the edition such as the Circle of Spores Druid debuting in Ravnica and the College of Eloquence Bard debuting in Theros, before again showing up in Tasha's. If your aversion to Warcraft is that strong, I'd counsel patience until they do another setting-agnostic compilation.
EDIT:
Given that he was promoted to the top spot last week, I'm curious which and how many splatbooks you think should have been published in that time.
It’s less there being subclasses in a setting book, but more specifically updated subclasses that were previously in the PHB or xanathars being locked in universes beyond. There is a difference there.
There is not really a difference because it is fundamentally the same as their being printed in a universes within product.
The recent Ravenloft book contained a number of 5.5 versions of existing content. I do not play in Ravenloft. Frankly, I have very little interest in playing Ravenloft, as I think everything it brings to the table can be done better in other settings. But I still need to buy that book if I want the updated content.
Same exact thing is true of WoW. I do not play in WoW, nor do I have interest in playing in WoW. But if I want the content, I have to buy something where the setting does not appeal to me.
Honestly, I'd rather see something locked behind the WoW tie-in than, say, yet another forgotten realms book that reprints a bunch of background information they've already published a half dozen times. At least there's a chance the WoW book contains something new.
I feel differently about this for WoW or another high fantasy setting vs Star Wars. I find the whole 'Azeroth isn't right for DnD and I want nothing to do with it' argument odd personally, but people feel how they feel. It's a world that clearly had a tremendous amount of DnD influence when it was created and really isn't any different than any other campaign setting in my mind.
I find the WoW world tone and lore much more my thing than Dark Sun, for example. I would never run or play in a Dark Sun campaign. But if Dark Sun has interesting content that I can borrow I will still buy it, as I would with a Runeterra (League of Legends), Wheel of Time, etc... etc... Universes Beyond product that hits the traditional DnD high fantasy feel.
Star Wars to me is tonally different enough from standard DnD that I do really hope they provide content that is intended to be much more setting-specific.
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
D&D has been doing exactly this since 1980’s Expedition to the Barrier Peaks (which has already received a 5e iteration), which was and is one of the best received modules in the game’s history. City of the Gods came out in 1987. Spelljammer came out in 1989 and remained popular across editions, even winning a fan poll on what setting should be revisited in 5e.
Absolutely none of this is new and there’s been a long history of successful commingling of SciFi and D&D.
"X doesn't belong in DND" talk always intrigues me.
Killer Klowns From Outer Space ripoffs in Spelljammer get a pass, but not Star Wars?
But back on subject...
No splatbooks in sight, & that's probably some managerial/executive/accountancy decision being called a logistical one, just like how DND Beyond TOTALLY can't handle A La Carte anymore, even after the site rework, so it "had" to go w/zero public plan on WotC's website to reinstate it after the site rework.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
I don't actually think Star Wars is a good fit for the D&D mechanics*, but it's never had any real "high technology vibe". It's space wizards with laser swords. The space setting gives it a feel of larger scope, but it's fantasy at heart.
* Yes, Star Trek would be worse, but that's not happening at the moment.
Andor, Rogue One, Resistance, The Book of Boba Fett & Solo would say otherwise to that space wizards comment.
I'd also love to play as Soong-Type Androids, Vulcans, Romulans, Bolians, Bajorans, Trill, Betazoids, Klingons, Deltans, Kelpiens, xBs & other such peoples in DND while Star Trekkin' across the universe fighting The Borg, The Dominion, The Breen, The Hirogen, the Tholians and various other antagonists while dealing w/The Q Continuum & other non-corporeal entities..with added exploration & diplomacy rules and The Prime Directive as an optional rule.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
The thing is that there's already an excellent Star Trek TTRPG that has mechanics much more suited to its universe and in which you can do all of those things.
pronouns: he/she/they
Quite frankly, I've found that a lot of "This already exists/try this instead" in TTRPG forms do not personally appeal to me. I've tried so many & just not found that I like most of that kind of thing.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Ah, yes, Expedition to the Barrier Peaks.......introducing powered armor, blaster pistols into a sword and sorcery setting......the comic Stephen Colbert once remarked how his D&D character ran around in powered armor.
I had often wondered how these suits of powered armor and those blaster pistols were recharged with power once these items exited that space ship or how the spare power cells were recharged as well.
But thats just the nature of the beast. Same with video games. You have very specific tastes and low tolerance for deviations from it, its impossible to find a game you'll really click with short of making it yourself. And I've done that before. 3 High Fantasy rule sets using different dice stacks, and 2 Sci-Fi systems, one based on War gaming models (cut outs) and one that gets rid of Hit Probability in favor of active defenses. Suffice to say its not easy.
But I've also lived through 3 WoW exodus events, and I've never even played WoW...... WoW players just keep showing up in other games, and eventually start demanding it be more like WoW. So if you can't be bothered to find a system with exactly what you want, and you can't be bothered to make one yourself, the best you're going to get is modding an existing rule set and just accept other people probably won't agree with you on the changes, or the perceived problems.
I've been trying to explain Path Finder 2 to my 5e Group, but they'd much rather keep trying to find obscure feats and items and argue with the DM about what should or shouldn't be allowed by a bonus action, because it never occurred to them that action economy is a design concept. This basically IS the core issue...... TTRPGs "can" be run like a video game, BUT it doesn't have to be. You can just steal ideas from other systems that make sense, and Frankenstein something together. But the other side of that coin, I WILL argue the need for robust rules for a game system as a foundation, because it makes messing with it much easier.
I would say that D&D fits more poorly into Starwars than Starwars fits into D&D. D&D has always been an almost Kitchen sink game, with campaign settings usually being what sets the bounderies.
D&D can absorb starwars elements easily and it not clash, but there are many spells in D&D that clash with the so far shown limits of the force.
If you have an issue with Medival things alongside high tech and think it can't work, then there are several long running franchises and settings that show they can.
Rifts, Warhammer 40K, Starfinder, Dune, and yes even Starwars prove it works. The Ewoks, the Mandolarians, the ancient sith, all had primitive weapons that they kept using effectively in a world of blasters and hyperdrives.
Heck look at real life. In the era of Blitzkriegs and tommy guns, the Fairbairn–Sykes fighting knife was in use and it is just a dagger without any frills.
In WW1 trench knives got more use than tanks did.
He/Him. Loooooooooong time Player.
The Dark days of the THAC0 system are behind us.
"Hope is a fire that burns in us all If only an ember, awaiting your call
To rise up in triumph should we all unite
The spark for change is yours to ignite."
Kalandra - The State of the World