Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
D&D has been doing exactly this since 1980’s Expedition to the Barrier Peaks (which has already received a 5e iteration), which was and is one of the best received modules in the game’s history. City of the Gods came out in 1987. Spelljammer came out in 1989 and remained popular across editions, even winning a fan poll on what setting should be revisited in 5e.
Absolutely none of this is new and there’s been a long history of successful commingling of SciFi and D&D.
Ah, yes, Expedition to the Barrier Peaks.......introducing powered armor, blaster pistols into a sword and sorcery setting......the comic Stephen Colbert once remarked how his D&D character ran around in powered armor.
I had often wondered how these suits of powered armor and those blaster pistols were recharged with power once these items exited that space ship or how the spare power cells were recharged as well.
IIRC they weren't. There were quite a few extra power packs in the spaceship, but I don't remember them as being permanent in our campaigns.
Ah, huh, ah, huh, which meant that the fancy powered armor could (and would) run out of juice at the worst possible moment. (In his science fiction novel, "Starship Troopers", Heinlein would remark that an experienced soldier would salvage power cells and ammunition from the suit of a downed comrade, so as to remain in the fight.)
Trying to mix the high technology vibe of Star Wars or Star Trek with the high fantasy vibe of D&D is asking for simply too much. It reminds me of that movie "He Man and the Masters of the Universe", with swords, blaster pistols and shotguns in a riotous mix.
Uh... mixing medieval fantasy and sci-fi elements predates He-Man by a fairly wide margin. Gygax himself listed Poul Anderson's The High Crusade as one of his original inspirations for D&D in Appendix N of the old DMG, which is a 1960 novel wherein a spaceship lands in medieval England. That's a decade+ before D&D, and two decades before He-Man, if you're keeping count.
Who is insisting that all of the various fantasy game settings be rolled into one big blob?
There is no "blob" unless you create one at your table. You really don't have to use every setting book they create in each and every campaign you run, I promise.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Ah, huh, ah, huh, which meant that the fancy powered armor could (and would) run out of juice at the worst possible moment. (In his science fiction novel, "Starship Troopers", Heinlein would remark that an experienced soldier would salvage power cells and ammunition from the suit of a downed comrade, so as to remain in the fight.)
Uh... mixing medieval fantasy and sci-fi elements predates He-Man by a fairly wide margin. Gygax himself listed Poul Anderson's The High Crusade as one of his original inspirations for D&D in Appendix N of the old DMG, which is a 1960 novel wherein a spaceship lands in medieval England. That's a decade+ before D&D, and two decades before He-Man, if you're keeping count.
There is no "blob" unless you create one at your table. You really don't have to use every setting book they create in each and every campaign you run, I promise.