Alright y'all, curious on folks' thoughts on the most updated version of the Bladesinger Wizard in 2024/5.5 from Heroes of Faerun. I have many questions:
1) Dual wield or not? I've never done it, but see lots recommending this as most dpr. Uses Bonus Action, which is likely occupied 1st round turning on Blade song, and you can't support it with Fighting Styles or Weapon Masteries without mutliclassing. But is a single blade viable, or are you leaving too much damage on the table since you can't even hold it with 2 hands to get the Versatile d10 damage? Seems like if you have spells that do rider damage, hard to see it compete with Dual Wielding? Unless there are other cool things to do with your BA with a Bladesinger?
2) Multiclass or no? I'm inclined to say no, but are dips into Fighter good enough? Weapon Mastery, Fighting Style, Second Wind, and Action Surge if you go 2. Maybe at the end of a build?
Spells: Sounds like maybe there are some must-have spells to get the most out of Bladesinger? Namely concentration spells?
3) True Strike: At level 5, adds +d6 dmg to your weapon dmg. So at level 6, makes sense to replace one of your two attacks with this every time? Or is Booming Blade better:
4) Booming Blade: Adds +d8 dmg to your weapon damage and holds a d8 for when they move? Now that Bladesingers use their INT to attack anyway, this is better, yes?
5) Shadow Blade: Is this still usable in 2014? Or is that by table? And if so how does this fit with True Strike and Booming Blade?
I'm of the mind that if you have magic, spell casting at higher levels overshadows what you'd gain from Fighter dips; unless you're purposely ignoring options to just straight whack things with swords. And the Spell blade feat by itself can turn any half caster or martial into a mini Gish with higher damage output, because one of those attacks is a damage scaled cantrip.
So in terms of hyper optimized of having all your levels upfront, yeah, multiclassing is always the more optimal approach. But if you have to play those levels, the faster you reach 3, 4 and 5 level spell slots, the better it feels to play.
Cool, yeah my inclination is to not multiclass out of the gate this time. I suppose if I were to dual wield, that'd help more.
Seems like it would particularly benefit Dual Wielding, no? But then I have a question: don't RAW say you can't cast certain spells with both hands full, even if one is holding your focus, sine you need a free hand for the somatic components? Or is that largely waved by DMs?
I've played a Bladesinger. The only issue is that at the end of the day, playing it as you would any other wizard is your best option and several other subclasses are better spellcasters.
Cool, yeah my inclination is to not multiclass out of the gate this time. I suppose if I were to dual wield, that'd help more.
Seems like it would particularly benefit Dual Wielding, no? But then I have a question: don't RAW say you can't cast certain spells with both hands full, even if one is holding your focus, sine you need a free hand for the somatic components? Or is that largely waved by DMs?
The benefit of duel wielding basically boils down to number of attacks possible within the given action economy. This does NOT automatically translate into higher damage, due to light weapons having smaller damage dice. However, the more "per hit' damage bonuses you have, there is an amplifying effect by having more attacks on which it can trigger.
The typical duel wielding build would be duel wield fighting style (which is important to scaling), Dual wielding feat, and a pair of light weapons where one has Nick, and preferably the other has Vex. If we assume 2 attacks per Attack action (which is the standard for martial and martial adjacent subclasses), you have the following:
Attack action, and first strike with the Vex weapon, which gives a follow up attack Adv. Nick activates for a second strike attempt. You then attack with either weapon for the second strike of your Attack action. Then Duel Wielding Feat let you make a follow up attack with the Bonus action. This results in 4 strikes total. This chain requires that specific order for all the interacting rules to execute correctly. If you lack Nick, you're limited to 3 attacks; but there is a weird interaction that lets you use a non-light weapon and a light weapon together, where normally you need two light weapons.
Damage calculations (assuming they all hit) end up looking like this. Assuming Short Sword and Scimitar, and +4 ability score bonus. First strike is d6+4, Second strike from Nick is d6+4, second attack from attack action makes a third strike d6+4, and the Duel wield bonus action strike is d6+4. (4~24)+16 or 40 Max damage if they all hit.
If we go with a 2 handed weapon build, its 2 attacks at 2d6+4, so (4~24)+8.
Duel wield feat for full sized main hand, light off hand. 1d6+4, 1d8+4, and 1d8+4 for a range of (3~22)+12.
So consider that Conjure Minor Elemental adds an extra 2d8 per hit, so you multiple that extra per number of attacks.
And thats before the math of substituting a cantrip for an attack.. which I'm not gonna bother due to the number of permutations introduced by the new Spell Blade cantrips.
Max potential is 104 damage.... but keep in mind this is single target best possible, and having to reliably land all attacks. Average expected is closer to 30 if you account for bounded accuracy.
...... or save yourself the trouble and just upcast fireball for 9d6 damage to everything in a 20ft radius, which is 9-54 fire damage, and half if they save, for the same cost of a 4th level spell slot.
Haha, super helpful. Thank you for crunching the numbers. Next thoughts/questions:
1) Dual wielding does seem to synergize best with per-hit damage bonuses like Conjure Minor Elementals. Probably hard to replicate with a single weapon. So question is: if not dual wielding, is there something comparable you can do with your bonus action instead (not necessarily damage but a spell or Telekinetic push/pull, etc.)?
2) Would a dual wielding Bladesinger be better off with a martial dip for Two Weapon Fighting, or better off not slowing their Wizard levels?
3) Bladesinger's alternative to dual wielding, would just be a one-handed weapon (d8), since it loses Bladesong if wielding anything two-handed. So, that likely drops the damage way down. But is the resulting tradeoff comparable: no martial dips, save a feat from no Dual Wielder, free Bonus Action?
I think Eldritch Knight Fighter and Valor Bard are better suited for the extra attack cantrip approach. With a Bladesinger, I'd lean more heavily into the wizard side of things.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
Alright y'all, curious on folks' thoughts on the most updated version of the Bladesinger Wizard in 2024/5.5 from Heroes of Faerun. I have many questions:
1) Dual wield or not? I've never done it, but see lots recommending this as most dpr. Uses Bonus Action, which is likely occupied 1st round turning on Blade song, and you can't support it with Fighting Styles or Weapon Masteries without mutliclassing. But is a single blade viable, or are you leaving too much damage on the table since you can't even hold it with 2 hands to get the Versatile d10 damage? Seems like if you have spells that do rider damage, hard to see it compete with Dual Wielding? Unless there are other cool things to do with your BA with a Bladesinger?
2) Multiclass or no? I'm inclined to say no, but are dips into Fighter good enough? Weapon Mastery, Fighting Style, Second Wind, and Action Surge if you go 2. Maybe at the end of a build?
Spells: Sounds like maybe there are some must-have spells to get the most out of Bladesinger? Namely concentration spells?
3) True Strike: At level 5, adds +d6 dmg to your weapon dmg. So at level 6, makes sense to replace one of your two attacks with this every time? Or is Booming Blade better:
4) Booming Blade: Adds +d8 dmg to your weapon damage and holds a d8 for when they move? Now that Bladesingers use their INT to attack anyway, this is better, yes?
5) Shadow Blade: Is this still usable in 2014? Or is that by table? And if so how does this fit with True Strike and Booming Blade?
I'm of the mind that if you have magic, spell casting at higher levels overshadows what you'd gain from Fighter dips; unless you're purposely ignoring options to just straight whack things with swords. And the Spell blade feat by itself can turn any half caster or martial into a mini Gish with higher damage output, because one of those attacks is a damage scaled cantrip.
So in terms of hyper optimized of having all your levels upfront, yeah, multiclassing is always the more optimal approach. But if you have to play those levels, the faster you reach 3, 4 and 5 level spell slots, the better it feels to play.
Cool, yeah my inclination is to not multiclass out of the gate this time. I suppose if I were to dual wield, that'd help more.
Seems like it would particularly benefit Dual Wielding, no? But then I have a question: don't RAW say you can't cast certain spells with both hands full, even if one is holding your focus, sine you need a free hand for the somatic components? Or is that largely waved by DMs?
I've played a Bladesinger. The only issue is that at the end of the day, playing it as you would any other wizard is your best option and several other subclasses are better spellcasters.
The benefit of duel wielding basically boils down to number of attacks possible within the given action economy. This does NOT automatically translate into higher damage, due to light weapons having smaller damage dice. However, the more "per hit' damage bonuses you have, there is an amplifying effect by having more attacks on which it can trigger.
The typical duel wielding build would be duel wield fighting style (which is important to scaling), Dual wielding feat, and a pair of light weapons where one has Nick, and preferably the other has Vex. If we assume 2 attacks per Attack action (which is the standard for martial and martial adjacent subclasses), you have the following:
Attack action, and first strike with the Vex weapon, which gives a follow up attack Adv. Nick activates for a second strike attempt. You then attack with either weapon for the second strike of your Attack action. Then Duel Wielding Feat let you make a follow up attack with the Bonus action. This results in 4 strikes total. This chain requires that specific order for all the interacting rules to execute correctly. If you lack Nick, you're limited to 3 attacks; but there is a weird interaction that lets you use a non-light weapon and a light weapon together, where normally you need two light weapons.
Damage calculations (assuming they all hit) end up looking like this. Assuming Short Sword and Scimitar, and +4 ability score bonus. First strike is d6+4, Second strike from Nick is d6+4, second attack from attack action makes a third strike d6+4, and the Duel wield bonus action strike is d6+4. (4~24)+16 or 40 Max damage if they all hit.
If we go with a 2 handed weapon build, its 2 attacks at 2d6+4, so (4~24)+8.
Duel wield feat for full sized main hand, light off hand. 1d6+4, 1d8+4, and 1d8+4 for a range of (3~22)+12.
So consider that Conjure Minor Elemental adds an extra 2d8 per hit, so you multiple that extra per number of attacks.
And thats before the math of substituting a cantrip for an attack.. which I'm not gonna bother due to the number of permutations introduced by the new Spell Blade cantrips.
Max potential is 104 damage.... but keep in mind this is single target best possible, and having to reliably land all attacks. Average expected is closer to 30 if you account for bounded accuracy.
...... or save yourself the trouble and just upcast fireball for 9d6 damage to everything in a 20ft radius, which is 9-54 fire damage, and half if they save, for the same cost of a 4th level spell slot.
Haha, super helpful. Thank you for crunching the numbers. Next thoughts/questions:
1) Dual wielding does seem to synergize best with per-hit damage bonuses like Conjure Minor Elementals. Probably hard to replicate with a single weapon. So question is: if not dual wielding, is there something comparable you can do with your bonus action instead (not necessarily damage but a spell or Telekinetic push/pull, etc.)?
2) Would a dual wielding Bladesinger be better off with a martial dip for Two Weapon Fighting, or better off not slowing their Wizard levels?
3) Bladesinger's alternative to dual wielding, would just be a one-handed weapon (d8), since it loses Bladesong if wielding anything two-handed. So, that likely drops the damage way down. But is the resulting tradeoff comparable: no martial dips, save a feat from no Dual Wielder, free Bonus Action?
I think Eldritch Knight Fighter and Valor Bard are better suited for the extra attack cantrip approach. With a Bladesinger, I'd lean more heavily into the wizard side of things.