So I just read Flee, Mortals! By MCDM, and the monster designs were very interesting. Maybe even better designed than the official MM? I'd be curious if anyone else had the book and what their experiences of it were.
I do not think there is any question that Flee Mortals! is better monster design than 5e and, thus far, 5.5e. Minions fix a necessary missing element of D&D by allowing for mass combat. The categories of monster, like Lurker and such, make sorting and finding the type of monster you need much, much easier than the utter lack of meaningful categories in the MM and other core content. A focus on abilities that are interesting, instead of the fairly generic monsters dominated by “BPS multi attack” also leads to more dynamic encounters.
But the amusing part of all of that? Those are all WotC design elements at heart. Everything good about Flee Mortals! was directly lifted from 4th Edition D&D, though minions were improved and expanded on to better fit 5e design. In Wizards quest to distance itself from 4e, Wizards simply avoided 4e design all together, instead of learning from what elements did work. Flee Mortals! does exactly what WotC should have done from the start - directly copy the elements of 4e that worked perfectly and improve on those that were great ideas but needed a bit of additional work.
No, I personally don't think it's better monster design. It's just, largely speaking, a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined with Colville's propensity to make bespoke sub-systems for everything that takes his fancy. Sidekicks get a system, pets get system, minions get a system! Everybody gets a system. Even his boss type monsters get a clunky "on turn one they do this, on turn two they do that" style system. I personally find it inelegant and obtuse, and clunky at the table.
I'm generally not a fan of MCDM design because I don't think it's well informed design. For example, when Colville made the illrigger, he gave the class it's own unique fighting styles because he didn't know that fighting styles were a common pool of options. During his short-lived kickstarter reward live-play, he homebrewed a base class (or used an existing homebrew, I struggle to recall) because he didn't know that College of Swords Bard existed. These are all small indicators of his very narrow design vision that doesn't seem to pull in, or demonstrate awareness of, the game he's designing for outside his own narrow perspective.
That's not even getting into the dumpster fire that was Strongholds & Followers vs Kingdoms & Warfare....
No, I personally don't think it's better monster design. It's just, largely speaking, a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined with Colville's propensity to make bespoke sub-systems for everything that takes his fancy. Sidekicks get a system, pets get system, minions get a system! Everybody gets a system. Even his boss type monsters get a clunky "on turn one they do this, on turn two they do that" style system. I personally find it inelegant and obtuse, and clunky at the table.
I'm generally not a fan of MCDM design because I don't think it's well informed design. For example, when Colville made the illrigger, he gave the class it's own unique fighting styles because he didn't know that fighting styles were a common pool of options. During his short-lived kickstarter reward live-play, he homebrewed a base class (or used an existing homebrew, I struggle to recall) because he didn't know that College of Swords Bard existed. These are all small indicators of his very narrow design vision that doesn't seem to pull in, or demonstrate awareness of, the game he's designing for outside his own narrow perspective.
That's not even getting into the dumpster fire that was Strongholds & Followers vs Kingdoms & Warfare....
What I think is the best part about Flee, Mortals! Is the solo boss designs. I just don't think any single monster in 5.5e is as good for that purpose.
I think Matt has some good ideas in there (whether sourced from 4e or not), but I don't think every table needs to belabor monsters to this degree. It's useful for the groups that want to shake things up, but my groups are getting plenty of mileage out of the Monster Manual as-is.
To build on Davyd's point as an example - I don't need a "minion" tag with its own bespoke rules to have minions in an encounter, I can just run groups of weaker monsters alongside the main ones in a fight that are designed to go down quickly relative to the party's current level/capabilities.
a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined
While I agree with a lot of your complaints about Colville’s other products, I am not sure this is all that fair. Minions are an incredibly useful tool for a DM to have in their toolbox - they feel frightening with their volume and can be quite dangerous, without adding a bunch of extra hitpoint sponges that bog down combat. Very quick way to add lethality players can immediately feel accomplished in addressing, as well as useful tools for repeated spawns and in-combat puzzles.
The 4e Minions, however, were flawed. They still generally acted individually, meaning they took a while to resolve. Colville’s solution on this front is a fairly elegant one - they move, attack, and act together, with some fairly simple multiplication resolving what otherwise would be a significant number of slow rolls. Having extensively played 4e and deployed the Flee Mortals minions, I feel very comfortable saying that the rules might be very slightly more complex, but ultimately lead to a better game state and less convoluted actual play.
That is not something I would say about his other content, but on this front, I think his minion system is ultimately very good for the game.
Edit: To PsyrenXY’s point above about using smaller monsters, I think that is also a perfectly acceptable option for lots of fights. But as a tool, it is very helpful to have a system to quickly resolve a dozen or so bad guys, so you can accomplish popular story beats like mowing down a zombie horde or a swarm of insects.
To build on Davyd's point as an example - I don't need a "minion" tag with its own bespoke rules to have minions in an encounter, I can just run groups of weaker monsters alongside the main ones in a fight that are designed to go down quickly relative to the party's current level/capabilities.
This is kind of my point. MCDM build minions as something that has it's own rules so you need to keep that in mind when running a monster with a minion tag
The elegant approach is you just build the monster with 1 hit point, suitably boosted AC, and then an appropriate trait:
Minion. If ~ would take damage from anything other than a successful attack or a failed saving throw, it ignores that damage
That's literally it, that's how you set up a minion for 5e using the framework established by 4e. But MCDM is very averse to that kind of self contained design
To build on Davyd's point as an example - I don't need a "minion" tag with its own bespoke rules to have minions in an encounter, I can just run groups of weaker monsters alongside the main ones in a fight that are designed to go down quickly relative to the party's current level/capabilities.
This is kind of my point. MCDM build minions as something that has it's own rules so you need to keep that in mind when running a monster with a minion tag
The elegant approach is you just build the monster with 1 hit point, suitably boosted AC, and then an appropriate trait:
Minion. If ~ would take damage from anything other than a successful attack or a failed saving throw, it ignores that damage
That's literally it, that's how you set up a minion for 5e using the framework established by 4e. But MCDM is very averse to that kind of self contained design
Flee Mortals! minions are designed to fill a very specific power fantasy and narrative element - players fighting against hordes of monsters - and do so in a way that is likewise quick to resolve, but feels like you are living that type of encounter. At the present time, there exists no system in the game that fills that particular niche, so, unlike a lot of the other busywork systems MCDM creates, I find it hard to believe anyone wouldn’t see this a filling a current gap in the game’s rules that other options, including the 4e approach, simply cannot adequately fill.
- 4e’s minion design and your “elegant approach” allows you to fill the power fantasy of mowing down lots of monsters, but because each monster rolls individually, the gameplay itself is miserable at high volumes (even if, as I already said, it can work better at small volumes). Let’s not pretend “roll 20 individual attacks” is ever the elegant way to play the game - and, to be perfectly frank, I think any DM who would inflict such a situation on their players has made a grave mistake.
- Using a single creature as a horde might address the attack roll issue, but does not fill the power fantasy of watching members of a horde get picked off in rapid succession, allowing players to feel like they are making progress as creatures fall and tokens get taken off the field.
- Make the horde smaller and more manageable. Sure, this solves one problem, but sometimes players kick the metaphorical and literal hornet’s nest and the appropriate course of action is 20 bugs swarming out. While you can make those numbers smaller, it does not necessarily fit the narrative well, and feels a lot like the DM is limiting the experience due to gameplay constraints
MCDM is wrong on a lot of their content and creates systems that add complexity for the sake of complexity, seemingly creating solutions in search of problems.
But on this particular element, there is a real problem no other solution meaningfully addresses without either creating secondary problems or undermining the narrative feel of the encounter. Is it perfect? No, and I’ve made plenty of adjustments to how I run the Flee Mortals! minions to remove some of the more unnecessary elements of their design. Is it better than the other options currently being offered on D&D Beyond for large-volume combat? There really is not any other offering that actually does what these rules set out to do. Nor have I seen any realistic solution that doesn’t fall apart at scale when one thinks about the actual gameplay implications of the “solution.”
The problem with directly converting 4th edition minions is that 5e primarily makes monsters more powerful by giving them more hit points and damage, not by giving them higher defenses and saves, so there's no way to have high level minions without giving them weird and disproportionate defenses, or by giving them a new mechanic.
My general take on Flee Mortals is that, while it does have generally better stat blocks than 5th edition, it doesn't actually improve on 4th edition, and in some ways it's worse. To be fair, that's hard to do, because monster design was a definite strength of 4th edition; it's not without flaws, but it generally understands the problem better than any other edition. A key feature of 4th edition monster design, that is mostly missing from other editions, is that it was actually really easy to homebrew or adjust monsters, because they were so standardized; you could actually just change the level of a monster in a simple formulaic way, and the result would actually work. Changing the group role was harder, solos in particular were hard to do well, but it was still much less annoying than trying to do the same types of adjustments in 3e or 5e.
a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined
While I agree with a lot of your complaints about Colville’s other products, I am not sure this is all that fair. Minions are an incredibly useful tool for a DM to have in their toolbox - they feel frightening with their volume and can be quite dangerous, without adding a bunch of extra hitpoint sponges that bog down combat. Very quick way to add lethality players can immediately feel accomplished in addressing, as well as useful tools for repeated spawns and in-combat puzzles.
The 4e Minions, however, were flawed. They still generally acted individually, meaning they took a while to resolve. Colville’s solution on this front is a fairly elegant one - they move, attack, and act together, with some fairly simple multiplication resolving what otherwise would be a significant number of slow rolls. Having extensively played 4e and deployed the Flee Mortals minions, I feel very comfortable saying that the rules might be very slightly more complex, but ultimately lead to a better game state and less convoluted actual play.
That is not something I would say about his other content, but on this front, I think his minion system is ultimately very good for the game.
Edit: To PsyrenXY’s point above about using smaller monsters, I think that is also a perfectly acceptable option for lots of fights. But as a tool, it is very helpful to have a system to quickly resolve a dozen or so bad guys, so you can accomplish popular story beats like mowing down a zombie horde or a swarm of insects.
A while back and my friends and I were tooling around with making our own TT rule set, and tried a bunch of different things to hammer out issues and see what works. We independently came up with a very similar approach to minions for the same reasons; fewer rolls, make them feel like the fodder they're supposed to be, and whittle them down every turn. And you can just as easily rebolster stats to represent reinforcements showing up. In a game where greater action economy can be a substitute for raw power, minion and hoard concatenation just makes everything easier.
Compare that to the current approach having 10 tokens on the field and having to strike them down one by one...... sometimes with only attack per round. Even if the player has a massive advantage, it slows down the game to crawl. Imagine that with 15 tokens vs 6 players..... it took an hour to get through 2 rounds of combat.
My problem w/the "Did MCDM do better than WotC" discussion can be answered by the simple matter of Minions as a game design element, & my feelings on it:
It's a patch for DMs who actively want to kill player characters to "win".
So, your problem with MCDM is with things MCDM doesn't actually do? The point of minions is not to be particularly better than anything else at killing the PCs, the point of minions is "I want to have the PCs mow through twenty mooks without it adding an extra hour to the combat".
My problem w/the "Did MCDM do better than WotC" discussion can be answered by the simple matter of Minions as a game design element, & my feelings on it:
It's a patch for DMs who actively want to kill player characters to "win".
So, your problem with MCDM is with things MCDM doesn't actually do? The point of minions is not to be particularly better than anything else at killing the PCs, the point of minions is "I want to have the PCs mow through twenty mooks without it adding an extra hour to the combat".
Also, if you're taking an hour to get through combat that isn't against the boss, that is either REALLY cinematic combat or some kind of per-player/per-table issue.
Taking an hour to get through a combat just requires you to have monsters that are a real slog to kill. For example, twenty ogres against a 10th level party fits within the moderate difficulty budget and based on actual difficulty, that's probably reasonable, but it's just going to take forever to actually resolve because that's 1,360 hp to grind through.
My problem w/the "Did MCDM do better than WotC" discussion can be answered by the simple matter of Minions as a game design element, & my feelings on it:
It's a patch for DMs who actively want to kill player characters to "win". This is fundamentally incompatible with DND culture post-mass consumption of liveplays/podcasts. Rejecting consumption of shows like Acquisitions Incorporated, Dimension 20, Critical Role & Legends of Avantris doesn't undo how they changed the culture of TTRPGs, creating a new split in TTRPG ethos. Less milling, more ownership of characters & their agency, more emphasis on the character than the quest & setting vs the classic, more Gygaxian "DM mills players to try & induce strategy so somebody "wins", so make more disposable characters you're less invested in some way in" way.
Both are valid, but post-Mearls WotC game design has focused on what the liveplay fans want more. This creates a vacuum where content creators like Matt Coville, who are more focused on TTRPG mechanics & design(content creation) than characters & their stories(in their content creation) propose mechanics-based solutions for those who favore the Gygaxian "dueling decks" style.
Minions are, quite frankly, a grognard(Affectionate but cautionary, tone-wise, w/this term) solution to wanting to metaphorically mill through the players' deck in an era where newer DMs & players are less incentivized to "win=succeed" vs the less potentially antagonistic "collaborating on a story w/an all-time high in character/OC investment". It's not a panacea. It's moreso akin to running a virtual machine emulator on an existing computer to bypass the costs of retro gaming:Inelegant, overhyped IMO & requiring knowhow, but a valid solution for those who need it.
So no, MCDM didn't do things better or worse, because these things are highly subjective based on individual player, DM & table needs.
Minions eat up player resources for no story/RP-related reason, strictly for mechanical, function-based reasons benefiting the DM as a potential winner over the players in a non-collaborative way, that seems to be based on the traditional Gygaxian style of play(Which the parts you snipped out said was valid for those who like it despite the actual game trending away from that style). Also, if you're taking an hour to get through combat that isn't against the boss, that is either REALLY cinematic combat or some kind of per-player/per-table issue.
Nearly every single element of this post is based not in fact but in harmful stereotypes that exist solely to create conflict within the community as a mechanism for gatekeeping. Some of these obvious and harmful falsehoods include:
1. The idea that this content exists for DMs who "actively want to kill their players" or have some sense that they will "win." As it turns out there are DMs and players who want to be actively challenged in combat because that is what they find fun. They are every bit capable of playing collaborative storytelling, they just also enjoy the thrill of risk. That does not mean the DM wants to kill his players or thinks killing the players is winning - it just means the DM is delivering an experience everyone would want where death is a possibility.
2. Suggesting DMs who enjoy more difficult combat are somehow stepping on player agency is likewise wrong for the same reasons, but is so flagrantly insulting that it deserves to be called out as its own line item.
3. I cannot speak for the other shows on the list, but anyone who has actually watched Critical Role knows that Matt Mercer does not pull punches in combat. He can, and will kill characters, is fully happy throwing far-more-than-deadly encounters at the party, will double tap downed characters to kill them, and very rarely pulls any punches in combat. Critical Role proves literally everything about your post wrong - it shows that DMs absolutely can be incredibly brutal while still facilitating a highly character and story driven game.
4. There are plenty of players who both like livestreams and like lethal gameplay. This, again, should be obvious, as Critical Role is both incredibly lethal and story-driven, and its popularity is in a large part driven by folks who watch a game that reflects how they would like to see games run.
5. Saying "both are valid" is clearly your attempt to seem conciliatory and like you are not gatekeeping. But, of course, this very statement is an act of gatekeeping - by painting the system as a "both" you are inherently making your post into an "us" and "them" statement. In reality, D&D is a spectrum with two general sliders - lethality versus safety on one slider and story versus combat simulator on the other. These are two separate sliders that do not inform one another. Some groups might enjoy lethal story-based games; other groups might enjoy safe combat simulators. There is no "both" there is only a wide spectrum of likes, and categorizing it as a "both" is discounting the spectrum in an incredibly dismissive and harmful way.
6. Terms like "grognard", "Gygaxian", and trying to phrase this as an "era" issue are both stereotyping and plainly wrong. The harmful stereotype is the clear implication that older players liked to play the game one way, but a newer generation likes to play differently. Except, as should be obvious to anyone well versed in this hobby, that is not how the real world works. There were plenty of players in the olden days who liked safe stories or story driven stories. And there are plenty of new players who like incredibly dangerous games or just want to hack and slash their way through a dungeon. This is one of the most harmful stereotypes in the game as it divides generations and creates the false impression that there is "one true way to play the game" - either by justifying the "old" as the one true version or the new as the "true modern version." This is both factually wrong and dangerous.
7. Pantagruel666 already adequately addressed why the application of minions is not anything close to what you seem to think it is, so I do not feel like retreading that grounds. The one thing I would add is, as I already stated on this thread, there is a player-driven reason to use minions. There is a certain power fantasy of being able to mow down a large group of small creatures that minions accomplish, without having to engage in complex bookkeeping. Anyone who has played with minions and a Wizard with fireball knows that they can be a source of glee for the players with minimal resource wasting or real chance of the DM killing anyone.
All told, very little about your post is accurate and the overwhelming majority of it is actively harmful to the community as it defines terms in a manner that divides based on abject falsehoods. It is unfair to both the content being analyzed as it has no substantive relevance to the underlying rules and unfair to both players who do or do not like the content for reasons independent than the contrived justifications you provided.
I know that was a lot of writing on this subject (and I have no intention of responding further on these points as I have said what I had to say), but, given how a lot of the points you raise are extremely detrimental to the game and the community, I think they needed to be addressed.
There are ALWAYS exceptions to most cliches. Doesn't mean that they're not grounded in something.
Some cliches are grounded in something. The core problem with your posts isn't that you dislike minions (that's a matter of taste), it's that you're making assertions that simply aren't true.
There are ALWAYS exceptions to most cliches. Doesn't mean that they're not grounded in something.
Some cliches are grounded in something. The core problem with your posts isn't that you dislike minions (that's a matter of taste), it's that you're making assertions that simply aren't true.
I didn't allow for enough exceptions in a spectrum. I get that.
It has absolutely nothing to do with a spectrum. Minions simply aren't designed to do what you say. Specifically, you said things like
It's a patch for DMs who actively want to kill player characters to "win".
DM mills players to try & induce strategy so somebody "wins", so make more disposable characters you're less invested in some way in" way.
Minions are, quite frankly, a grognard(Affectionate but cautionary, tone-wise, w/this term) solution to wanting to metaphorically mill through the players' deck
It's not the effectiveness I object to personally. It's the draining of resources more rapidly than the actual game design intends.
Minions eat up player resources for no story/RP-related reason
Every one of those statements is false.
I assume you dislike Matt Colville's work because you don't like tactical combat, and he's interested in tactical combat. That's your prerogative, and a pure issue of taste. However, it has literally nothing to do with minions, other than who wrote the rules. The only thing in Flee Mortals that even might relate to your concerns is the encounter building rules, and those rules produce easier fights than the 2024 encounter building rules.
I didn't allow for enough exceptions in a spectrum. I get that.
It has absolutely nothing to do with a spectrum. Minions simply aren't designed to do what you say. Specifically, you said things like
It's a patch for DMs who actively want to kill player characters to "win".
DM mills players to try & induce strategy so somebody "wins", so make more disposable characters you're less invested in some way in" way.
Minions are, quite frankly, a grognard(Affectionate but cautionary, tone-wise, w/this term) solution to wanting to metaphorically mill through the players' deck
It's not the effectiveness I object to personally. It's the draining of resources more rapidly than the actual game design intends.
Minions eat up player resources for no story/RP-related reason
Every one of those statements is false.
I assume you dislike Matt Colville's work because you don't like tactical combat, and he's interested in tactical combat. That's your prerogative, and a pure issue of taste. However, it has literally nothing to do with minions, other than who wrote the rules. The only thing in Flee Mortals that even might relate to your concerns is the encounter building rules, and those rules produce easier fights than the 2024 encounter building rules.
So I just read Flee, Mortals! By MCDM, and the monster designs were very interesting. Maybe even better designed than the official MM? I'd be curious if anyone else had the book and what their experiences of it were.
I do not think there is any question that Flee Mortals! is better monster design than 5e and, thus far, 5.5e. Minions fix a necessary missing element of D&D by allowing for mass combat. The categories of monster, like Lurker and such, make sorting and finding the type of monster you need much, much easier than the utter lack of meaningful categories in the MM and other core content. A focus on abilities that are interesting, instead of the fairly generic monsters dominated by “BPS multi attack” also leads to more dynamic encounters.
But the amusing part of all of that? Those are all WotC design elements at heart. Everything good about Flee Mortals! was directly lifted from 4th Edition D&D, though minions were improved and expanded on to better fit 5e design. In Wizards quest to distance itself from 4e, Wizards simply avoided 4e design all together, instead of learning from what elements did work. Flee Mortals! does exactly what WotC should have done from the start - directly copy the elements of 4e that worked perfectly and improve on those that were great ideas but needed a bit of additional work.
No, I personally don't think it's better monster design. It's just, largely speaking, a more convoluted version 4e minion design combined with Colville's propensity to make bespoke sub-systems for everything that takes his fancy. Sidekicks get a system, pets get system, minions get a system! Everybody gets a system. Even his boss type monsters get a clunky "on turn one they do this, on turn two they do that" style system. I personally find it inelegant and obtuse, and clunky at the table.
I'm generally not a fan of MCDM design because I don't think it's well informed design. For example, when Colville made the illrigger, he gave the class it's own unique fighting styles because he didn't know that fighting styles were a common pool of options. During his short-lived kickstarter reward live-play, he homebrewed a base class (or used an existing homebrew, I struggle to recall) because he didn't know that College of Swords Bard existed. These are all small indicators of his very narrow design vision that doesn't seem to pull in, or demonstrate awareness of, the game he's designing for outside his own narrow perspective.
That's not even getting into the dumpster fire that was Strongholds & Followers vs Kingdoms & Warfare....
Find my D&D Beyond articles here
What I think is the best part about Flee, Mortals! Is the solo boss designs. I just don't think any single monster in 5.5e is as good for that purpose.
I think Matt has some good ideas in there (whether sourced from 4e or not), but I don't think every table needs to belabor monsters to this degree. It's useful for the groups that want to shake things up, but my groups are getting plenty of mileage out of the Monster Manual as-is.
To build on Davyd's point as an example - I don't need a "minion" tag with its own bespoke rules to have minions in an encounter, I can just run groups of weaker monsters alongside the main ones in a fight that are designed to go down quickly relative to the party's current level/capabilities.
While I agree with a lot of your complaints about Colville’s other products, I am not sure this is all that fair. Minions are an incredibly useful tool for a DM to have in their toolbox - they feel frightening with their volume and can be quite dangerous, without adding a bunch of extra hitpoint sponges that bog down combat. Very quick way to add lethality players can immediately feel accomplished in addressing, as well as useful tools for repeated spawns and in-combat puzzles.
The 4e Minions, however, were flawed. They still generally acted individually, meaning they took a while to resolve. Colville’s solution on this front is a fairly elegant one - they move, attack, and act together, with some fairly simple multiplication resolving what otherwise would be a significant number of slow rolls. Having extensively played 4e and deployed the Flee Mortals minions, I feel very comfortable saying that the rules might be very slightly more complex, but ultimately lead to a better game state and less convoluted actual play.
That is not something I would say about his other content, but on this front, I think his minion system is ultimately very good for the game.
Edit: To PsyrenXY’s point above about using smaller monsters, I think that is also a perfectly acceptable option for lots of fights. But as a tool, it is very helpful to have a system to quickly resolve a dozen or so bad guys, so you can accomplish popular story beats like mowing down a zombie horde or a swarm of insects.
This is kind of my point. MCDM build minions as something that has it's own rules so you need to keep that in mind when running a monster with a minion tag
The elegant approach is you just build the monster with 1 hit point, suitably boosted AC, and then an appropriate trait:
That's literally it, that's how you set up a minion for 5e using the framework established by 4e. But MCDM is very averse to that kind of self contained design
Find my D&D Beyond articles here
Flee Mortals! minions are designed to fill a very specific power fantasy and narrative element - players fighting against hordes of monsters - and do so in a way that is likewise quick to resolve, but feels like you are living that type of encounter. At the present time, there exists no system in the game that fills that particular niche, so, unlike a lot of the other busywork systems MCDM creates, I find it hard to believe anyone wouldn’t see this a filling a current gap in the game’s rules that other options, including the 4e approach, simply cannot adequately fill.
- 4e’s minion design and your “elegant approach” allows you to fill the power fantasy of mowing down lots of monsters, but because each monster rolls individually, the gameplay itself is miserable at high volumes (even if, as I already said, it can work better at small volumes). Let’s not pretend “roll 20 individual attacks” is ever the elegant way to play the game - and, to be perfectly frank, I think any DM who would inflict such a situation on their players has made a grave mistake.
- Using a single creature as a horde might address the attack roll issue, but does not fill the power fantasy of watching members of a horde get picked off in rapid succession, allowing players to feel like they are making progress as creatures fall and tokens get taken off the field.
- Make the horde smaller and more manageable. Sure, this solves one problem, but sometimes players kick the metaphorical and literal hornet’s nest and the appropriate course of action is 20 bugs swarming out. While you can make those numbers smaller, it does not necessarily fit the narrative well, and feels a lot like the DM is limiting the experience due to gameplay constraints
MCDM is wrong on a lot of their content and creates systems that add complexity for the sake of complexity, seemingly creating solutions in search of problems.
But on this particular element, there is a real problem no other solution meaningfully addresses without either creating secondary problems or undermining the narrative feel of the encounter. Is it perfect? No, and I’ve made plenty of adjustments to how I run the Flee Mortals! minions to remove some of the more unnecessary elements of their design. Is it better than the other options currently being offered on D&D Beyond for large-volume combat? There really is not any other offering that actually does what these rules set out to do. Nor have I seen any realistic solution that doesn’t fall apart at scale when one thinks about the actual gameplay implications of the “solution.”
The problem with directly converting 4th edition minions is that 5e primarily makes monsters more powerful by giving them more hit points and damage, not by giving them higher defenses and saves, so there's no way to have high level minions without giving them weird and disproportionate defenses, or by giving them a new mechanic.
My general take on Flee Mortals is that, while it does have generally better stat blocks than 5th edition, it doesn't actually improve on 4th edition, and in some ways it's worse. To be fair, that's hard to do, because monster design was a definite strength of 4th edition; it's not without flaws, but it generally understands the problem better than any other edition. A key feature of 4th edition monster design, that is mostly missing from other editions, is that it was actually really easy to homebrew or adjust monsters, because they were so standardized; you could actually just change the level of a monster in a simple formulaic way, and the result would actually work. Changing the group role was harder, solos in particular were hard to do well, but it was still much less annoying than trying to do the same types of adjustments in 3e or 5e.
A while back and my friends and I were tooling around with making our own TT rule set, and tried a bunch of different things to hammer out issues and see what works. We independently came up with a very similar approach to minions for the same reasons; fewer rolls, make them feel like the fodder they're supposed to be, and whittle them down every turn. And you can just as easily rebolster stats to represent reinforcements showing up. In a game where greater action economy can be a substitute for raw power, minion and hoard concatenation just makes everything easier.
Compare that to the current approach having 10 tokens on the field and having to strike them down one by one...... sometimes with only attack per round. Even if the player has a massive advantage, it slows down the game to crawl. Imagine that with 15 tokens vs 6 players..... it took an hour to get through 2 rounds of combat.
Delorted due to checking bias
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
So, your problem with MCDM is with things MCDM doesn't actually do? The point of minions is not to be particularly better than anything else at killing the PCs, the point of minions is "I want to have the PCs mow through twenty mooks without it adding an extra hour to the combat".
Delorted due to unchecked bias
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Which minions don't do? Seriously, minions are just designed to be low-bookkeeping mooks.
Taking an hour to get through a combat just requires you to have monsters that are a real slog to kill. For example, twenty ogres against a 10th level party fits within the moderate difficulty budget and based on actual difficulty, that's probably reasonable, but it's just going to take forever to actually resolve because that's 1,360 hp to grind through.
Nearly every single element of this post is based not in fact but in harmful stereotypes that exist solely to create conflict within the community as a mechanism for gatekeeping. Some of these obvious and harmful falsehoods include:
1. The idea that this content exists for DMs who "actively want to kill their players" or have some sense that they will "win." As it turns out there are DMs and players who want to be actively challenged in combat because that is what they find fun. They are every bit capable of playing collaborative storytelling, they just also enjoy the thrill of risk. That does not mean the DM wants to kill his players or thinks killing the players is winning - it just means the DM is delivering an experience everyone would want where death is a possibility.
2. Suggesting DMs who enjoy more difficult combat are somehow stepping on player agency is likewise wrong for the same reasons, but is so flagrantly insulting that it deserves to be called out as its own line item.
3. I cannot speak for the other shows on the list, but anyone who has actually watched Critical Role knows that Matt Mercer does not pull punches in combat. He can, and will kill characters, is fully happy throwing far-more-than-deadly encounters at the party, will double tap downed characters to kill them, and very rarely pulls any punches in combat. Critical Role proves literally everything about your post wrong - it shows that DMs absolutely can be incredibly brutal while still facilitating a highly character and story driven game.
4. There are plenty of players who both like livestreams and like lethal gameplay. This, again, should be obvious, as Critical Role is both incredibly lethal and story-driven, and its popularity is in a large part driven by folks who watch a game that reflects how they would like to see games run.
5. Saying "both are valid" is clearly your attempt to seem conciliatory and like you are not gatekeeping. But, of course, this very statement is an act of gatekeeping - by painting the system as a "both" you are inherently making your post into an "us" and "them" statement. In reality, D&D is a spectrum with two general sliders - lethality versus safety on one slider and story versus combat simulator on the other. These are two separate sliders that do not inform one another. Some groups might enjoy lethal story-based games; other groups might enjoy safe combat simulators. There is no "both" there is only a wide spectrum of likes, and categorizing it as a "both" is discounting the spectrum in an incredibly dismissive and harmful way.
6. Terms like "grognard", "Gygaxian", and trying to phrase this as an "era" issue are both stereotyping and plainly wrong. The harmful stereotype is the clear implication that older players liked to play the game one way, but a newer generation likes to play differently. Except, as should be obvious to anyone well versed in this hobby, that is not how the real world works. There were plenty of players in the olden days who liked safe stories or story driven stories. And there are plenty of new players who like incredibly dangerous games or just want to hack and slash their way through a dungeon. This is one of the most harmful stereotypes in the game as it divides generations and creates the false impression that there is "one true way to play the game" - either by justifying the "old" as the one true version or the new as the "true modern version." This is both factually wrong and dangerous.
7. Pantagruel666 already adequately addressed why the application of minions is not anything close to what you seem to think it is, so I do not feel like retreading that grounds. The one thing I would add is, as I already stated on this thread, there is a player-driven reason to use minions. There is a certain power fantasy of being able to mow down a large group of small creatures that minions accomplish, without having to engage in complex bookkeeping. Anyone who has played with minions and a Wizard with fireball knows that they can be a source of glee for the players with minimal resource wasting or real chance of the DM killing anyone.
All told, very little about your post is accurate and the overwhelming majority of it is actively harmful to the community as it defines terms in a manner that divides based on abject falsehoods. It is unfair to both the content being analyzed as it has no substantive relevance to the underlying rules and unfair to both players who do or do not like the content for reasons independent than the contrived justifications you provided.
I know that was a lot of writing on this subject (and I have no intention of responding further on these points as I have said what I had to say), but, given how a lot of the points you raise are extremely detrimental to the game and the community, I think they needed to be addressed.
Baleted due to unchecked bias
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Some cliches are grounded in something. The core problem with your posts isn't that you dislike minions (that's a matter of taste), it's that you're making assertions that simply aren't true.
Delteated due to unchecked bias
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
It has absolutely nothing to do with a spectrum. Minions simply aren't designed to do what you say. Specifically, you said things like
Every one of those statements is false.
I assume you dislike Matt Colville's work because you don't like tactical combat, and he's interested in tactical combat. That's your prerogative, and a pure issue of taste. However, it has literally nothing to do with minions, other than who wrote the rules. The only thing in Flee Mortals that even might relate to your concerns is the encounter building rules, and those rules produce easier fights than the 2024 encounter building rules.
EDIT:Deleted unchecked bias
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.