1. What is the non-mechanical pitch for MCDM's way of doing things?
What does that have to do with any of the points I brought up? Yes, there are mechanical reasons for how minions designed. No, those mechanical reasons are not "be better at killing the PCs" or "force PCs to spend more resources". The mechanical reason for minions is "I want the PCs to fight a horde of monsters, possibly as part of a larger encounter, and I don't want fighting that horde to be a boring slog".
No, you're not likely to individually RP with minions, but you're not going to individually RP with most monsters, and minions are not meaningfully different.
1. What is the non-mechanical pitch for MCDM's way of doing things?
What does that have to do with any of the points I brought up? Yes, there are mechanical reasons for how minions designed. No, those mechanical reasons are not "be better at killing the PCs" or "force PCs to spend more resources". The mechanical reason for minions is "I want the PCs to fight a horde of monsters, possibly as part of a larger encounter, and I don't want fighting that horde to be a boring slog".
No, you're not likely to individually RP with minions, but you're not going to individually RP with most monsters, and minions are not meaningfully different.
1. What is the non-mechanical pitch for MCDM's way of doing things?
What does that have to do with any of the points I brought up? Yes, there are mechanical reasons for how minions designed. No, those mechanical reasons are not "be better at killing the PCs" or "force PCs to spend more resources". The mechanical reason for minions is "I want the PCs to fight a horde of monsters, possibly as part of a larger encounter, and I don't want fighting that horde to be a boring slog".
No, you're not likely to individually RP with minions, but you're not going to individually RP with most monsters, and minions are not meaningfully different.
I've yet to hear any definition of how a horde is a boring slog from any angle. THAT'S the per-table/per-player issue I keep hearing. Not everyone has this problem. I don't have it as a DM. Most DMs I've played with are fast enough with placement of enemies & enemy turns.
Regardless of how fast a horde of Monster Manual enemies takes, a horde of equivalent minions WILL be faster. A Bandit has 11 HP, and a Tough has about 30. A minion has 1. Assuming 10 damage per attack, which seems reasonable, a bandit would take 2 hits and a Tough 3. A minion will always take one. Lower time to kill (and rules for running minions quickly) will make the fight resolve faster.
Also, you keep talking about how minions are basically antithetical to the idea of roleplaying and story development. What about minions makes them be like that but not normal enemies?
I've yet to hear any definition of how a horde is a boring slog from any angle. THAT'S the per-table/per-player issue I keep hearing. Not everyone has this problem. I don't have it as a DM. Most DMs I've played with are fast enough with placement of enemies & enemy turns.
How much high level play do you do? It tends to be more of a problem with higher CR mooks because they often have multiattack and substantial hit point totals, so just the sheer bookkeeping and mechanics of rolling dice starts adding up.
5. Killing a bunch of resource-draining cannon fodder that fixes(sic) a per-table/per-player issue of setup w/Fireball is an incidentally satisfactory moment. Not really what I'd think of as story advancement beyond the most personally bland "get through wave(s) of enemies to get to main target of resources". I have trouble conceiving RPing interacting w/a singular minion as MCDM presents them.
And this is your entire problem. Not every single creature is meant to be a full, fleshed out character with hopes and dreams that the party must learn about and care for. Minions as they are presented are not intended, at all, to be roleplayed with. They are presented so that the players can experience the fantasy of standing against a massive horde.
I've yet to hear any definition of how a horde is a boring slog from any angle. THAT'S the per-table/per-player issue I keep hearing. Not everyone has this problem. I don't have it as a DM. Most DMs I've played with are fast enough with placement of enemies & enemy turns.
When you talk about hordes not being a slog, how many creatures are in that horde? Base D&D handles about 10-12 combatants just fine (at low levels), but with minions, 5 or 10 will only take as long to run as one normal enemy, barring saves against AOEs.
What does that have to do with any of the points I brought up? Yes, there are mechanical reasons for how minions designed. No, those mechanical reasons are not "be better at killing the PCs" or "force PCs to spend more resources". The mechanical reason for minions is "I want the PCs to fight a horde of monsters, possibly as part of a larger encounter, and I don't want fighting that horde to be a boring slog".
No, you're not likely to individually RP with minions, but you're not going to individually RP with most monsters, and minions are not meaningfully different.
Unchecked bias deleted
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.
Regardless of how fast a horde of Monster Manual enemies takes, a horde of equivalent minions WILL be faster. A Bandit has 11 HP, and a Tough has about 30. A minion has 1. Assuming 10 damage per attack, which seems reasonable, a bandit would take 2 hits and a Tough 3. A minion will always take one. Lower time to kill (and rules for running minions quickly) will make the fight resolve faster.
Also, you keep talking about how minions are basically antithetical to the idea of roleplaying and story development. What about minions makes them be like that but not normal enemies?
How much high level play do you do? It tends to be more of a problem with higher CR mooks because they often have multiattack and substantial hit point totals, so just the sheer bookkeeping and mechanics of rolling dice starts adding up.
And this is your entire problem. Not every single creature is meant to be a full, fleshed out character with hopes and dreams that the party must learn about and care for. Minions as they are presented are not intended, at all, to be roleplayed with. They are presented so that the players can experience the fantasy of standing against a massive horde.
When you talk about hordes not being a slog, how many creatures are in that horde? Base D&D handles about 10-12 combatants just fine (at low levels), but with minions, 5 or 10 will only take as long to run as one normal enemy, barring saves against AOEs.
After some advice, I have deleted my biased posts & am terminating my involvement in this discussion in this regard.
DM, player & homebrewer(Current homebrew project is an unofficial conversion of SBURB/SGRUB from Homestuck into DND 5e)
Once made Maxwell's Silver Hammer come down upon Strahd's head to make sure he was dead.
Always study & sharpen philosophical razors. They save a lot of trouble.