Roland's attack was able to injure Sailor 5, but he persevered and his spell activates with a angry red glow from his hands. The 2 dead sailors body convulses for a moment and you hear went slurping noise as theirs skins and flesh literally pull away from their bones.

As you fight everyone hears a dull thudding noise as if something far off is hitting something wooden.

Round 4 Post when able

"Ouch! No fair! You're really going to gang up on a little girl?" Twig yells in annoyance.

She will attack sailor 6 with her daggers.

To hit: 6

To hit:6

(...Not even going to bother rolling damage cause i just got 2 critical fails in a row lol)

Attack 11 (miss I presume)

Bonus action attack, Nat20 for 13 damage to sailor 5.

Zhernon's feathers and skin get ruffled as the spell gets off and they get a very bad feeling about the situation. Did they hit land perhaps? Should they make a run for it?

(Perception to see if Zhernon can discern what made the sound: 19)

Everyone hears another dull thud that is a bit louder this time. Zhernon makes out that its not the ship hitting land as he can still feel the ship moving forward, but he is unsure what is making that sound

Roland only took the briefest of glances to see the monstrosity that was created. "What have you done?!" he roared at the sailor as he again lashed out at him.

ACTION: Attack Sailor 5
* Longsword Slash - Attack: 13, Mundane Slashing Damage: 10
REACTION: If hit again, will cast Shield

Currently: AC 18, 17 HP and 1 used spell slot

Finished!

Tilsu heads to the group targeting the half-elf. He brings out his spirit mace once more, sending it to help Roland and Zhernon. "Do you need healing?" He asks the half elf as he strikes the sailor in front of her.

Mace attack: 23 damage: 4 to sailor 6

Spirit mace attack: 10 damage: 5 to sailor 5

Zhernon attacks hits sailor 5, but takes 3 opportunity of attack

Attack: 10 Damage: 6

Attack: 12 Damage: 6

Attack: 11 Damage: 4

The flesh creature moves to Zhernon and attacks 2x with its fleshy limb

Attack: 23 Damage: 5

Attack: 23 Damage: 7

The 2nd flesh creature attacks Tilsu 2x

Attack: 19 Damage: 4

Attack: 4 Damage: 7

Sailor 3 moves to attack Roland. Zhernon, Twig, Tilsu get opportunity attack against sailor 3

Attack: 16 Damage: 4

Roland attack misses

Sailor 4 is frightened and runs away

Tilsu injures sailor 6 but misses with the spirit mace

Sailor 5 cast mirror image creating 3 duplicates.

Twig misses both attacks

Sailor 6 attacks twig

Attack: 18 Damage: 4

Sailor 7 attacks Twig

Attack: 7 Damage: 7

Sailor 8 attacks Tilsu

Attack: 13 Damage: 6

Since both attack of the flesh creature 1 hits Zhernon is grappled escape DC 13 strength save  on Their turn. So no opportunity attack on sailor 3.

Twig and Tislu get another opportunity attack on the flesh creature 1 for moving to Zhernon

Round 5 post when able

(STR save 20)

Zhernon howls in pain as the flesh creature rips into them and begins bleeding heavily once more, turning their attention to the monstrosity and raging at it with a primal scream!

Action, Attack: 15 for 6 piercing

Bonus action, Attack: 12 for 4 piercing

The farmboy's jaw dropped as three illusory images of his opponent appeared. "This is no ordinary sailor!" he thought, wondering what he'd gotten himself into as he quickly decided to switch tactics.

Sheathing his sword, he immediately brought up his hand toward his foe, invoking one last bit of magical energy by also shouting, "TO-NI-TRUUM!", creating a thunderous boom in front of himself.

FREE: Sheath sword (he'll need the free hand)
ACTION: Cast Thunderwave, directed toward the sailor and his images. DC 12 CON Save is required to take half of 10 thunder damage and avoid being shoved 10 feet back
REACTION: None

Currently: AC 18, 17 HP and both spell slots used

Finished!

Opportunity attack: 

To hit: 17

Damage: 5

“Yuck! What is that thing!” She says as she stabs the fleshy mass. 

Twig gives Sailor 6 another stab before using cunning action to retreat behind the others. Hopefully out of the immediate reach of any of the sailors. She looks pretty hurt. 

To hit: 13

Damage: 5

Sneak attack if possible: 4

Op attack: 10, damage: 3

Tilsu lays a hand onto the half elf, casting cure wounds upon her. He has the spirit mace attack.

Heal for 14

Spirit mace attack: 22, damage: 10

Everyone hears a loud creak as if a door is opening. Sailor 5 has a look of frustration and takes out a ring.

In the next moment the world bleeds away into inky blackness. Everyone smells a strong scent of incense and sitting on the floor is a clay incense burner with bluish smoke hanging heavily in the air. The sailors and the flesh creatures were gone and standing at the doorway was Captain Fray asking "What's going on here?" As you look around there is no signs of fight or blood spatter on the floor besides your own. It was as if the sailors were never there to begin with. Each of you still have your weapons out and injuries. It takes a moment, but you realize the dull thuds you heard were the captains knocks on the door.

"Apologies captain, we'd discovered a few elementals had hidden away here. We were caught off guard by them but we weathered through. They," he motions towards Roland and Zhernon, "managed to finish off the last of them while I tended to the girl's wounds from their explosive deaths." 

Deception(?): 2

(Do I get advantage since we're actually injured?)

Zhernon simply slumps over to one side, breathing hard and attempting to slow the bleeding some while trying to get their bearings as well in the confusion.

Twig flinches at Tilsu's touch but then realizes that she feels better now. She looks at her arms and sees the cuts vanishing, "Wow! Thanks!"

Then the captain comes in. She hears Tilsu's bad lie, and decides to lay it all out.

"Your crew just tried to kill us! They would have killed all my friends in their sleep if I hadn't been wandering around! After we fought them, some of them turned into flesh monsters, and one of them was chanting and threw a smoke thing and now they are gone! Some captain you are if you didn't even know your crew were cannibals! Is it normal for your passengers to go missing?!"

She starts full on yelling at the captain at this point. She is not happy.

Persuasion: 11

(Sorry Tilsu, Twig doesn't see the point in lying here....)

Roland furrowed his brow at the captain's appearance. "What is going on?" he asked himself as he looked around, heard Tilsu's story, then heard Twig's confirmation of the actual incident. He partly withdrew his sword and examined it--even it was clean. Clearly, some strange magic was afoot.

The farmboy fully sheathed his sword again, then waited to see the captain's reaction... watching him closely.

Roland is trying to see if the captain actually is ignorant to the events, or is just acting.

If needed, Insight Check: 18

Persuasion attempt does not get far. Captain Fray walks up to Twig and look her straight into her eyes and glares at her. "So we have liar and you are not a passenger. Now explain yourself before I toss you overboard"

Roland can't tell what the captain is thinking

As the smoke thickens from the incense burner you see smoky phantoms of the sailors you fought.

Captain Fray turns "What foul sorcery is this"