hi every one. can u help me with mage slayer .does this counter the no oot misty step? if your trained to react to a spell why not punish them for casting anything even as quick as misty is
If I'm understanding correctly what you're asking, I believe the answer is yes: if you have the old (2014) version of Mage Slayer, you can use your Reaction to make a melee weapon attack against someone who casts Misty Step near you. This is not technically an opportunity attack, and the 2024 version of Mage Slayer no longer has this benefit at all.
Per 2014, Misty Step concludes before the Reaction attack would have a chance to go off, as Misty Step must be cast (and the triggering action be concluded) in order for the reaction to occur. The DMG and Sage Advice clarifies this as well:
"If a reaction has no timing specified, or the timing is unclear, the reaction occurs after its trigger finishes, as in the Ready action."
2024 Mage Slayer got a full rework, removing the bit about 'Taking Reaction Attacks when you see a spell being cast' so you don't need to worry about edge cases like that
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
While teleportation doesn't provoke opportunity attacks, the reaction attack from Polearm Master isn't an opportunity attack, so it comes down to whether you count teleporting as "moving". There is not really a clear answer to this in the official rules, unfortunately.
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
While teleportation doesn't provoke opportunity attacks, the reaction attack from Polearm Master isn't an opportunity attack, so it comes down to whether you count teleporting as "moving". There is not really a clear answer to this in the official rules, unfortunately.
I would say it's not, for the reason that it's not using your movement.
(This opens up the question of all the abilities that give you movement but don't use your movement. Those are less clear, but probably would.)
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
While teleportation doesn't provoke opportunity attacks, the reaction attack from Polearm Master isn't an opportunity attack, so it comes down to whether you count teleporting as "moving". There is not really a clear answer to this in the official rules, unfortunately.
I would say it's not, for the reason that it's not using your movement.
(This opens up the question of all the abilities that give you movement but don't use your movement. Those are less clear, but probably would.)
I agree with this.
It's true that Polearm Master's Reactive Strike doesn't rely on Opportunity Attacks rules. It's triggered when a creature enters your reach with their movement (related: Polearm Master - Reactive Strike), and also if it's forced to enter by Push or Thunderwave, for example.
It won't apply to Teleportation because "If you teleport, you disappear and reappear elsewhere instantly, without moving through the intervening space."
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
While Reactive Strike is not an Opportunity Attack that trigger upon moving, but a Reaction attack when a creature that enters the reach you have with that weapon, so it will depend if you consider reappearing in a space to count as entering it or not. Same reasoning for teleporting in a Moonbeam area of effect.
Reactive Strike: While you're holding a Quarterstaff, a Spear, or a weapon that has the Heavy and Reach properties, you can take a Reaction to make one melee attack against a creature that enters the reach you have with that weapon.
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
While teleportation doesn't provoke opportunity attacks, the reaction attack from Polearm Master isn't an opportunity attack, so it comes down to whether you count teleporting as "moving". There is not really a clear answer to this in the official rules, unfortunately.
I would say it's not, for the reason that it's not using your movement.
(This opens up the question of all the abilities that give you movement but don't use your movement. Those are less clear, but probably would.)
Moving and not using your movement is probably best if one looks at how mounted/dismount movement works. I do not know those mount rules.
If a PC is on a mount. The mount moves it full movement. Can the PC dismount and move it's full movement?
If a PC dismounts, does it use movement to dismount?
Why would teleportation be treated diffenterently?
[...] It's true that Polearm Master's Reactive Strike doesn't rely on Opportunity Attacks rules. It's triggered when a creature enters your reach with their movement (related: Polearm Master - Reactive Strike), and also if it's forced to enter by Push or Thunderwave, for example.
It won't apply to Teleportation because "If you teleport, you disappear and reappear elsewhere instantly, without moving through the intervening space."
[...] Now, for example, if you teleport while you have Spirit Guardians ("Range: Self" and Emanation spell) around you, it should still affect creatures when you reappear because "the Emanation enters a creature’s space", like you and Davyd mentioned earlier.
If I follow my own reasoning, then I think yes: with Teleportation, you're not moving, but you're entering the reach of a weapon, similarly to an Emanation entering a creature's space.
Per 2014, Misty Step concludes before the Reaction attack would have a chance to go off, as Misty Step must be cast (and the triggering action be concluded) in order for the reaction to occur. The DMG and Sage Advice clarifies this as well:
"If a reaction has no timing specified, or the timing is unclear, the reaction occurs after its trigger finishes, as in the Ready action."
https://www.sageadvice.eu/caster-near-mage-slayer/
2024 Mage Slayer got a full rework, removing the bit about 'Taking Reaction Attacks when you see a spell being cast' so you don't need to worry about edge cases like that
Since we're talking about 5.5e rebrand and rewrites... here's another scenario:
Character A has Polearm Mastery and is wielding a polearm with 10 feet of reach.
Character B tries to Misty Step past the pointy edge of the polearm... if Character B Misty Steps to a square next to (within 5 feet) of Character A, does Character A get a chance to use the Polearm Master ability and use their Reaction to get a free attack?
I would think "no', because the Misty Step doesn't constitute a move... but the wording of Polearm Master feels less clear now.
While teleportation doesn't provoke opportunity attacks, the reaction attack from Polearm Master isn't an opportunity attack, so it comes down to whether you count teleporting as "moving". There is not really a clear answer to this in the official rules, unfortunately.
pronouns: he/she/they
I would say it's not, for the reason that it's not using your movement.
(This opens up the question of all the abilities that give you movement but don't use your movement. Those are less clear, but probably would.)
I agree with this.
It's true that Polearm Master's Reactive Strike doesn't rely on Opportunity Attacks rules. It's triggered when a creature enters your reach with their movement (related: Polearm Master - Reactive Strike), and also if it's forced to enter by Push or Thunderwave, for example.
It won't apply to Teleportation because "If you teleport, you disappear and reappear elsewhere instantly, without moving through the intervening space."
As an aside, I recall an interesting thread about Teleportation and Area of Effect spells: Conjure Woodland Beings / Spirit Guardians an teleportation spells
While Reactive Strike is not an Opportunity Attack that trigger upon moving, but a Reaction attack when a creature that enters the reach you have with that weapon, so it will depend if you consider reappearing in a space to count as entering it or not. Same reasoning for teleporting in a Moonbeam area of effect.
Moving and not using your movement is probably best if one looks at how mounted/dismount movement works. I do not know those mount rules.
If a PC is on a mount. The mount moves it full movement. Can the PC dismount and move it's full movement?
If a PC dismounts, does it use movement to dismount?
Why would teleportation be treated diffenterently?
Mmm. I think your own text doesn't make much sense, Tarod... This was one of my thoughts:
If I follow my own reasoning, then I think yes: with Teleportation, you're not moving, but you're entering the reach of a weapon, similarly to an Emanation entering a creature's space.