So specific scenario-a group of crossbowmen guards have a readied action to shoot at a spellcaster as soon as they start casting a spell
The spellcaster starts their spell which has a casting time of 1 action
is the spell completed before the attacks occur or do the attacks happen before the spell is completed? i.e. if the attacks drop the caster to 0 hp does the spell go off? If they hit, is there a chance they can disrupt the spell (I.e. require concentration checks to complete?) Can the caster take a reaction and cast shield while casting the other spell (irrelevant if the spell was completed before the readied action takes place).
Per the rules (I think) any reaction, unless otherwise stated, happens after the trigger. In this case, the trigger is the spell being cast, so the shooting happens when the spell is finished.
Per the rules (I think) any reaction, unless otherwise stated, happens after the trigger. In this case, the trigger is the spell being cast, so the shooting happens when the spell is finished.
Well, in the given example, the trigger was "they start casting a spell", which is why it's unclear.
We know it's possible for a Reaction trigger to be the start of a spell being cast and for a Reaction triggered that way to happen before the spell is finished being cast — that's how Counterspell works. What's not clear, I think, is whether you're allowed to assign a trigger that granular for the Ready action.
As a rule, anything that doesn't explicitly say it interacts with a part of the Attack Action- such as Shield, Silvery Barbs, Bardic Inspiration, etc.- can't modify the sequence mid-action.
If you Ready to attack creature as soon as they start casting a spell, i'd rule when the trigger occurs, you can take your Reaction immediately after the spell is cast, not before so.
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
So specific scenario-a group of crossbowmen guards have a readied action to shoot at a spellcaster as soon as they start casting a spell
The spellcaster starts their spell which has a casting time of 1 action
is the spell completed before the attacks occur or do the attacks happen before the spell is completed? i.e. if the attacks drop the caster to 0 hp does the spell go off? If they hit, is there a chance they can disrupt the spell (I.e. require concentration checks to complete?) Can the caster take a reaction and cast shield while casting the other spell (irrelevant if the spell was completed before the readied action takes place).
Per the rules (I think) any reaction, unless otherwise stated, happens after the trigger. In this case, the trigger is the spell being cast, so the shooting happens when the spell is finished.
Well, in the given example, the trigger was "they start casting a spell", which is why it's unclear.
We know it's possible for a Reaction trigger to be the start of a spell being cast and for a Reaction triggered that way to happen before the spell is finished being cast — that's how Counterspell works. What's not clear, I think, is whether you're allowed to assign a trigger that granular for the Ready action.
pronouns: he/she/they
For the proposed scenario, I'd rule the same as other folks said in Readied Action, Vortex Warp: Does this work?:
Also, if it's useful: Can you ready an action to be triggered after an attack is made but before the damage is dealt?
If you Ready to attack creature as soon as they start casting a spell, i'd rule when the trigger occurs, you can take your Reaction immediately after the spell is cast, not before so.