Pick a pocket is an example uses for Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check so if Mage Hand Legerdemain say it can make such a check through it i have to think it's intended.
Pick a pocket, conceal a handheld object, or perform legerdemain.
This is missing the point that some of us in this thread are describing.
The basic Mage Hand spell seems to allow the hand to perform Object Interactions, not actions. The Legerdemain feature adds this ability:
through it, you can make Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) checks
In my opinion, this has nothing to do with granting additional action economy. It just allows for situations where this upgraded hand is performing an activity which requires passing a specific ability / skill check in order to succeed to be able to do that remotely through the hand.
The above table which lists some example uses for the Sleight of Hand skill is just a generic list of activities -- some of the activities in the table will typically require an action and some will not. A skill check in and of itself is not an action. It's an application of your proficiency bonus on an ability check, which might be rolled when taking an action or at some other moment such as when taking a Reaction or when performing an Object Interaction or when just using some movement, and so on. Regardless of what you are actually doing, the key concept is that you have a chance for success or failure, so you make an ability check to determine the outcome.
For example, the Acrobatics skill can be used to "stay on your feet in a tricky situation". Often, this will just be while you are moving, no action required. The Athletics skill can be used to "jump farther than normal" -- again, that's movement related, no action required. Passive Perception does not require an action. Even one of the examples for the Sleight of Hand skill reads "conceal a handheld object" -- this should likely be ruled as an Object Interaction activity, no action required. As such, in my opinion, THAT is the sort of thing that the Legerdemain can do which would require a Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check.
Lastly is a funky ability that crops up three times in this subclass’s design: the mage hand cantrip. You are a master of using this minor telekinetic ability, and can eventually do everything from picking locks with it to distracting enemies. It seems like a small benefit, but using mage hand to improve the range of your day-to-day rogue skills like picking locks, disarming traps, and stealing items can be incredibly powerful. These abilities are situational—you’ll need to have a DM that includes encounters where you have to disable devices under time pressure or suboptimal conditions—but they allow you to succeed wildly against otherwise insurmountable obstacles.
As I said before, in practice, this is how DMs are likely to rule mage hand activity in general, which is quite a bit more powerful than what is actually written.
For one thing, this above blogpost is likely referencing the 5e version of the Legerdemain feature which explicitly allows the hand to use Thieves' Tools to pick a lock, for example. The 5.5e version of the Legerdemain feature removes that language and it's now not at all clear if that feature is still intended to be able to do that. For one thing, how does this hand even have possession of any Thieves' Tools if the spell was cast such that the hand appears 30 feet away from you? If the hand has to pick up the tools from your possession, should there be action economy associated with that? And so on. In my opinion, in 5.5e, the Legerdemain hand simply cannot do this because that activity now explicitly requires an action and the feature no longer explicitly mentions that it is able to do this.
Again, in most games I expect this to be allowed anyway. I don't think that the rules allow it, but I'm sure that plenty of folks will disagree with that.
When watching the 5.5e pre-release video New Rogue | 2024 Player's Handbook or reading the article about the differences (2024 Rogue vs. 2014 Rogue: What’s New), I didn't get the impression that the 5.5e Arcane Trickster can do fewer things with that feature than the 5e Arcane Trickster.
On the contrary, in the video, they say (min. 13.30): "... the Arcane Trickster continues to be the awesome spell wielding Rogue who can use Mage hand for endless shenanigans ..."
I spoke with my DM, and we've decided to apply many of the things discussed here in our game.
Opening an oil flask, retrieving and handing over the flask, and pouring out its contents are separate interactions. However, opening and handing over the flask are considered free object interactions, as described in the rules under "Free Object Interaction", which allows one free object interaction per turn.
We agreed that interpreting Mage Hand as being unable to perform certain object interactions explicitly described in the spell simply because those interactions would normally require the Utilize action would conflict with the rules for Bonus Actions, which allow exceptions when a feature, spell, or other rule states otherwise. However, we recognize that this part is open to interpretation, so we'll evaluate each situation individually, using common sense.
As for action economy, the issue can be resolved by having the Rogue cast Mage Hand beforehand. The spell doesn't require Concentration and lasts for 1 minute. Since the hand is invisible and the Arcane Trickster can control it as a Bonus Action, you can use it while exploring without significantly disrupting your action economy.
This opens up plenty of creative possibilities. You could explore with Mage Hand already holding an open oil flask, leave an open flask in a strategically chosen location, or use your free object interaction on the first turn to open the flask and then hand it to Mage Hand on the following turn. It all comes down to creativity.
Stealing objects and weapons:
I discussed this with my DM, and we agreed that if an enemy is holding an object or weapon, whether distracted or not, in combat or outside of combat, it cannot be stolen using Sleight of Hand, since that would involve a disarming attempt or a contest of physical strength.
Similarly, if an object is tied, strapped, or otherwise securely attached to a character (such as certain pieces of clothing or a backpack), it obviously couldn't simply be stolen in this manner.
Otherwise, the only obstacle to successfully stealing an accessible object would be passing the appropriate ability check, with the DC varying depending on the circumstances.
This greatly expands the creative possibilities, since my DM hasn't established a fixed DC for every situation.
For example, during combat, I could use Minor Illusion to distract a target and then use my Bonus Action to attempt to steal their sheathed weapon, potentially reducing the difficulty of the check. Alternatively, I could take a bigger gamble and attempt the theft while the enemy is fully alert and paying attention to my character.
One final point I'd like to emphasize:
An Arcane Trickster's Mage Hand is one of the stealthiest tools imaginable. It makes no sound, is invisible, and floats smoothly through the air. The main giveaway is the Verbal and Somatic components performed when the caster initially casts the spell, and the caster could easily be several feet away from the target.
Now imagine what happens when I eventually take the Telekinetic feat!
Rollback Post to RevisionRollBack
To post a comment, please login or register a new account.
This is missing the point that some of us in this thread are describing.
The basic Mage Hand spell seems to allow the hand to perform Object Interactions, not actions. The Legerdemain feature adds this ability:
In my opinion, this has nothing to do with granting additional action economy. It just allows for situations where this upgraded hand is performing an activity which requires passing a specific ability / skill check in order to succeed to be able to do that remotely through the hand.
The above table which lists some example uses for the Sleight of Hand skill is just a generic list of activities -- some of the activities in the table will typically require an action and some will not. A skill check in and of itself is not an action. It's an application of your proficiency bonus on an ability check, which might be rolled when taking an action or at some other moment such as when taking a Reaction or when performing an Object Interaction or when just using some movement, and so on. Regardless of what you are actually doing, the key concept is that you have a chance for success or failure, so you make an ability check to determine the outcome.
For example, the Acrobatics skill can be used to "stay on your feet in a tricky situation". Often, this will just be while you are moving, no action required. The Athletics skill can be used to "jump farther than normal" -- again, that's movement related, no action required. Passive Perception does not require an action. Even one of the examples for the Sleight of Hand skill reads "conceal a handheld object" -- this should likely be ruled as an Object Interaction activity, no action required. As such, in my opinion, THAT is the sort of thing that the Legerdemain can do which would require a Dexterity (Sleight of Hand) check.
As I said before, in practice, this is how DMs are likely to rule mage hand activity in general, which is quite a bit more powerful than what is actually written.
For one thing, this above blogpost is likely referencing the 5e version of the Legerdemain feature which explicitly allows the hand to use Thieves' Tools to pick a lock, for example. The 5.5e version of the Legerdemain feature removes that language and it's now not at all clear if that feature is still intended to be able to do that. For one thing, how does this hand even have possession of any Thieves' Tools if the spell was cast such that the hand appears 30 feet away from you? If the hand has to pick up the tools from your possession, should there be action economy associated with that? And so on. In my opinion, in 5.5e, the Legerdemain hand simply cannot do this because that activity now explicitly requires an action and the feature no longer explicitly mentions that it is able to do this.
Again, in most games I expect this to be allowed anyway. I don't think that the rules allow it, but I'm sure that plenty of folks will disagree with that.
When watching the 5.5e pre-release video New Rogue | 2024 Player's Handbook or reading the article about the differences (2024 Rogue vs. 2014 Rogue: What’s New), I didn't get the impression that the 5.5e Arcane Trickster can do fewer things with that feature than the 5e Arcane Trickster.
On the contrary, in the video, they say (min. 13.30): "... the Arcane Trickster continues to be the awesome spell wielding Rogue who can use Mage hand for endless shenanigans ..."
I spoke with my DM, and we've decided to apply many of the things discussed here in our game.
Opening an oil flask, retrieving and handing over the flask, and pouring out its contents are separate interactions. However, opening and handing over the flask are considered free object interactions, as described in the rules under "Free Object Interaction", which allows one free object interaction per turn.
We agreed that interpreting Mage Hand as being unable to perform certain object interactions explicitly described in the spell simply because those interactions would normally require the Utilize action would conflict with the rules for Bonus Actions, which allow exceptions when a feature, spell, or other rule states otherwise. However, we recognize that this part is open to interpretation, so we'll evaluate each situation individually, using common sense.
As for action economy, the issue can be resolved by having the Rogue cast Mage Hand beforehand. The spell doesn't require Concentration and lasts for 1 minute. Since the hand is invisible and the Arcane Trickster can control it as a Bonus Action, you can use it while exploring without significantly disrupting your action economy.
This opens up plenty of creative possibilities. You could explore with Mage Hand already holding an open oil flask, leave an open flask in a strategically chosen location, or use your free object interaction on the first turn to open the flask and then hand it to Mage Hand on the following turn. It all comes down to creativity.
Stealing objects and weapons:
I discussed this with my DM, and we agreed that if an enemy is holding an object or weapon, whether distracted or not, in combat or outside of combat, it cannot be stolen using Sleight of Hand, since that would involve a disarming attempt or a contest of physical strength.
Similarly, if an object is tied, strapped, or otherwise securely attached to a character (such as certain pieces of clothing or a backpack), it obviously couldn't simply be stolen in this manner.
Otherwise, the only obstacle to successfully stealing an accessible object would be passing the appropriate ability check, with the DC varying depending on the circumstances.
This greatly expands the creative possibilities, since my DM hasn't established a fixed DC for every situation.
For example, during combat, I could use Minor Illusion to distract a target and then use my Bonus Action to attempt to steal their sheathed weapon, potentially reducing the difficulty of the check. Alternatively, I could take a bigger gamble and attempt the theft while the enemy is fully alert and paying attention to my character.
One final point I'd like to emphasize:
An Arcane Trickster's Mage Hand is one of the stealthiest tools imaginable. It makes no sound, is invisible, and floats smoothly through the air. The main giveaway is the Verbal and Somatic components performed when the caster initially casts the spell, and the caster could easily be several feet away from the target.
Now imagine what happens when I eventually take the Telekinetic feat!