Murder Among the Stars — Game Thread

Quote from PJtheARCH3R >>

Quote from Weslockes >>

*Dun dun dun…I feel like I’m gonna die*

 *I think you mean DUN Dun DUNNNN!*

*Either way.*

*Was Dry vanilla townie orr?*

Well, that's to be expected considering the analysis Dry has done before (I'm scared now). I doubt it was because he was sussing anyone in particular and I don't think he really had any susses in general, so not that much info to go off of unfortunately.

Who was roleblocked last night? By both Dinao and the consort, if the former wasn't blocked by the latter. Just wanna get that information out there.

I have to go for now, but I'll do a read on everyone in the morning.

I'm nottttttt Biohacker. Trust me

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

*Was Dry vanilla townie orr?*

 

 *yep, sorry, dry was vanilla*

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

Morning, or whatever you want to call it aboard a metal tube speeding through empty space, arrives. It seems that some late nights were had. For one person in particular. 

Dry’s corpse decorates the bleak steel surroundings that all of you are used to by now, with an artistic dash of scarlet amongst the silver. 

Good morning cadets. Go wild. 

No! Dry!

So: 

Dry hasn’t necessarily accused anyone or done much suspicious, for that matter. Could this be revenge? 

Dinao, PJ, and Tarasque all have been acting strangely. (no offense these are just my thoughts)

Honestly, I’m interested. Mafia isn’t going after Dinao because that’d be obvious, instead they’re getting someone else out of the way? Did Dry say anything that I missed that could’ve given away their role?

Quote from Weslockes >>

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

Morning, or whatever you want to call it aboard a metal tube speeding through empty space, arrives. It seems that some late nights were had. For one person in particular. 

Dry’s corpse decorates the bleak steel surroundings that all of you are used to by now, with an artistic dash of scarlet amongst the silver. 

Good morning cadets. Go wild. 

No! Dry!

So: 

Dry hasn’t necessarily accused anyone or done much suspicious, for that matter. Could this be revenge? 

Dinao, PJ, and Tarasque all have been acting strangely. (no offense these are just my thoughts)

Honestly, I’m interested. Mafia isn’t going after Dinao because that’d be obvious, instead they’re getting someone else out of the way? Did Dry say anything that I missed that could’ve given away their role?

 I don't believe Dry has done anything other than ask for a player list, and be the person who posts the doc

Thr most likely reason they got them out is because there a good player, like the reason the mafia got monks out first because there a great player

Well it sucks to loose a good player early, but thankfully he was not a special role. He didn’t seem to be sussing anyone in particular, so no leads there. Diano, who did you role block last night?

Quote from TheGatoLover >>

Quote from Weslockes >>

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

Morning, or whatever you want to call it aboard a metal tube speeding through empty space, arrives. It seems that some late nights were had. For one person in particular. 

Dry’s corpse decorates the bleak steel surroundings that all of you are used to by now, with an artistic dash of scarlet amongst the silver. 

Good morning cadets. Go wild. 

No! Dry!

So: 

Dry hasn’t necessarily accused anyone or done much suspicious, for that matter. Could this be revenge? 

Dinao, PJ, and Tarasque all have been acting strangely. (no offense these are just my thoughts)

Honestly, I’m interested. Mafia isn’t going after Dinao because that’d be obvious, instead they’re getting someone else out of the way? Did Dry say anything that I missed that could’ve given away their role?

 I don't believe Dry has done anything other than ask for a player list, and be the person who posts the doc

Thr most likely reason they got them out is because there a good player, like the reason the mafia got monks out first because there a great player

Yup. Get the suspicious townie out of the way instead of Dinao. But Dinao pretty much announced their role. I don’t feel like the doc and Dry’s suspicion would be enough to take Dry over Dinao. Could there be another reason?

Quote from himynamesare >>

Well it sucks to loose a good player early, but thankfully he was not a special role. He didn’t seem to be sussing anyone in particular, so no leads there. Diano, who did you role block last night?

 or did they get roleblocked?

Quote from Weslockes >>

Quote from TheGatoLover >>

Quote from Weslockes >>

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

Morning, or whatever you want to call it aboard a metal tube speeding through empty space, arrives. It seems that some late nights were had. For one person in particular. 

Dry’s corpse decorates the bleak steel surroundings that all of you are used to by now, with an artistic dash of scarlet amongst the silver. 

Good morning cadets. Go wild. 

No! Dry!

So: 

Dry hasn’t necessarily accused anyone or done much suspicious, for that matter. Could this be revenge? 

Dinao, PJ, and Tarasque all have been acting strangely. (no offense these are just my thoughts)

Honestly, I’m interested. Mafia isn’t going after Dinao because that’d be obvious, instead they’re getting someone else out of the way? Did Dry say anything that I missed that could’ve given away their role?

 I don't believe Dry has done anything other than ask for a player list, and be the person who posts the doc

Thr most likely reason they got them out is because there a good player, like the reason the mafia got monks out first because there a great player

Yup. Get the suspicious townie out of the way instead of Dinao. But Dinao pretty much announced their role. I don’t feel like the doc and Dry’s suspicion would be enough to take Dry over Dinao. Could there be another reason?

 You do realize that Dry was the soul reason you guys won the last game?

Quote from TheGatoLover >>

Quote from himynamesare >>

Well it sucks to loose a good player early, but thankfully he was not a special role. He didn’t seem to be sussing anyone in particular, so no leads there. Diano, who did you role block last night?

 or did they get roleblocked?

 That too

Quote from Weslockes >>

Quote from MonksAreGreat70 >>

Morning, or whatever you want to call it aboard a metal tube speeding through empty space, arrives. It seems that some late nights were had. For one person in particular. 

Dry’s corpse decorates the bleak steel surroundings that all of you are used to by now, with an artistic dash of scarlet amongst the silver. 

Good morning cadets. Go wild. 

No! Dry!

So: 

Dry hasn’t necessarily accused anyone or done much suspicious, for that matter. Could this be revenge? 

Dinao, PJ, and Tarasque all have been acting strangely. (no offense these are just my thoughts)

Honestly, I’m interested. Mafia isn’t going after Dinao because that’d be obvious, instead they’re getting someone else out of the way? Did Dry say anything that I missed that could’ve given away their role?

 I'm not Biohacker :(

*Tarasque2897 will remember that*

*-5 Approval rating*

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Actually I've figured it out

Banan

Tarasque

PJ

These three are mafia.

Nah these aren't actual accusations, but there's a 3/12 chance at least one of them was scared for a second reading that hehehehe

 I was about to say "Wee bit early for accusations aye?" And then I saw the bottom lol

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

My read: 

Gato seems to be clawing at anything to be suspicious of, I don’t want to do that myself but it seems strange. 

Dinao’s pretty neutral imo. Could be mafia.

Jeff is absolutely mafia and if he is I will worship. 

 Wait who was Gato accusing? Closest thing they did that I recall was the whole Dinao special role thing. Your Tarasque thing was more clawing at straws to be completely honest, but then that also might be me clawing at straws and ahhhhh the cycle never ends

If Dinao is a special role then they're clear, if they actually specify what role they are. Dinao, now is the time to come clean on if you actually are one or not, and if so which one, because leaving it at the obvious quote edit is not helping. (If I had to guess you'll probably still be investigated by phaser tonight either way)

And let's make it clear that from here NO special townies reveal themselves. At most save it for late game when it'll be worth more to know. (Although actual deduction is better then a checklist, I'm still down for it in the end)

I'll make my own reads on everyone once we have more info.

 I’m pretty sure I didn’t accuse Tarasque, that was Dinao. I’m suspicious of Gato and Dinao. 

 Who was Gato accusing tho? You said they were picking at straws but I can't remember what accusations they made.

I've already said my thoughts on Dinao.

And you did just accuse Tarasque

 They accused Dinao, I’m pretty sure, or at least that’s how I interpreted it.

 No, they were saying Dinao is a special role. Dinao said they were, PJ quoted it, then Dinao very obviously edited it and that's what Gato was talking about. Correct me if Gato did accuse them of being mafia tho

 *points at self* this man is a dumbass 

 You're good, I was confused too initially looking at it.

 Wait so is do we have more evidence on what Dinao is? They said they were a special role, and then changed that? Are they avoiding being killed, or the killer?

Quote from tarasque2897 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

My read: 

Gato seems to be clawing at anything to be suspicious of, I don’t want to do that myself but it seems strange. 

Dinao’s pretty neutral imo. Could be mafia.

Jeff is absolutely mafia and if he is I will worship. 

 Wait who was Gato accusing? Closest thing they did that I recall was the whole Dinao special role thing. Your Tarasque thing was more clawing at straws to be completely honest, but then that also might be me clawing at straws and ahhhhh the cycle never ends

If Dinao is a special role then they're clear, if they actually specify what role they are. Dinao, now is the time to come clean on if you actually are one or not, and if so which one, because leaving it at the obvious quote edit is not helping. (If I had to guess you'll probably still be investigated by phaser tonight either way)

And let's make it clear that from here NO special townies reveal themselves. At most save it for late game when it'll be worth more to know. (Although actual deduction is better then a checklist, I'm still down for it in the end)

I'll make my own reads on everyone once we have more info.

 I’m pretty sure I didn’t accuse Tarasque, that was Dinao. I’m suspicious of Gato and Dinao. 

 Who was Gato accusing tho? You said they were picking at straws but I can't remember what accusations they made.

I've already said my thoughts on Dinao.

And you did just accuse Tarasque

 They accused Dinao, I’m pretty sure, or at least that’s how I interpreted it.

 No, they were saying Dinao is a special role. Dinao said they were, PJ quoted it, then Dinao very obviously edited it and that's what Gato was talking about. Correct me if Gato did accuse them of being mafia tho

 *points at self* this man is a dumbass 

 You're good, I was confused too initially looking at it.

 Wait so is do we have more evidence on what Dinao is? They said they were a special role, and then changed that? Are they avoiding being killed, or the killer?

 Or it could just be Diano being Diano. We should definitely keep an eye on him though. 

Quote from himynamesare >>

Quote from tarasque2897 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

Quote from TheMadGibber >>

Quote from Bananer28046 >>

My read: 

Gato seems to be clawing at anything to be suspicious of, I don’t want to do that myself but it seems strange. 

Dinao’s pretty neutral imo. Could be mafia.

Jeff is absolutely mafia and if he is I will worship. 

 Wait who was Gato accusing? Closest thing they did that I recall was the whole Dinao special role thing. Your Tarasque thing was more clawing at straws to be completely honest, but then that also might be me clawing at straws and ahhhhh the cycle never ends

If Dinao is a special role then they're clear, if they actually specify what role they are. Dinao, now is the time to come clean on if you actually are one or not, and if so which one, because leaving it at the obvious quote edit is not helping. (If I had to guess you'll probably still be investigated by phaser tonight either way)

And let's make it clear that from here NO special townies reveal themselves. At most save it for late game when it'll be worth more to know. (Although actual deduction is better then a checklist, I'm still down for it in the end)

I'll make my own reads on everyone once we have more info.

 I’m pretty sure I didn’t accuse Tarasque, that was Dinao. I’m suspicious of Gato and Dinao. 

 Who was Gato accusing tho? You said they were picking at straws but I can't remember what accusations they made.

I've already said my thoughts on Dinao.

And you did just accuse Tarasque

 They accused Dinao, I’m pretty sure, or at least that’s how I interpreted it.

 No, they were saying Dinao is a special role. Dinao said they were, PJ quoted it, then Dinao very obviously edited it and that's what Gato was talking about. Correct me if Gato did accuse them of being mafia tho

 *points at self* this man is a dumbass 

 You're good, I was confused too initially looking at it.

 Wait so is do we have more evidence on what Dinao is? They said they were a special role, and then changed that? Are they avoiding being killed, or the killer?

 Or it could just be Diano being Diano. We should definitely keep an eye on him though. 

 Ok

Quote from himynamesare >>

Well it sucks to loose a good player early, but thankfully he was not a special role. He didn’t seem to be sussing anyone in particular, so no leads there. Diano, who did you role block last night?

 Tar tar

I am back :) 

I have susses 

I need the vigilante to trust me and kill Gato tonight. 

Wow that sounded weirder than I thought. 

Any susses y'all want me to role block tonight