Boon of Spell Recall

This doesn't really seem that powerful to me. Does anyone else have any thoughts?

Yeah, this is pretty lacking. This is the only boon that has a "benefit" beyond score improvement that has no guarantee of ever working.

Quote from PPSS2022 >>

This doesn't really seem that powerful to me. Does anyone else have any thoughts?

 I guess it would be good for a paladin, ranger, arcane trickster, or eldritch knight? It seems kind of underwhelming but most/all of your spells would be 1st-4th level. I wonder if this would actually benefit regular divine smite...

This should be:

Ability Score Increase. Increase your Intelligence, Wisdom or Charisma score by 1 to a maximum of 30.

Free Casting. Choose 4 spells between 1st - 4th Level from a class you have levels in and appropriate spell slots for. They do not cost a spell slot to cast with this feat.

For a 19th-level spellcaster with 13 spell slots from1st to 4th, you gain an average of 4-5 spell slots per long rest, sometimes as high as 10, other times as low as 0. Arcane Recovery for Wizards would allow you to gain more.

I guess warlocks can just suffer

Honestly, it should've just been Spell Mastery from 2014 rules

Yeah weirdly seems like a design to prevent warlocks getting more pact slot usages (at 19th level their pact slots scale to 5th level by Warlock Level 9 so this would actually be unusable by then without a multiclass).

Most warlocks would end up choosing hex anyway, so it wouldn't really matter. Also, they gave us Magical Cunning, so I don't think they don't want us to get more out of pact magic. I think they just forgot how warlocks work with this.

Quote from ceramist >>

For a 19th-level spellcaster with 13 spell slots from1st to 4th, you gain an average of 4-5 spell slots per long rest, sometimes as high as 10, other times as low as 0. Arcane Recovery for Wizards would allow you to gain more.

Isn't 25% of 13 = 3.25, not 4-5?

I still want this. Makes me want to be more gambly and cast spells instead of saving slots because "you never know". 

Quote from Satanihavet >>

Quote from ceramist >>

For a 19th-level spellcaster with 13 spell slots from1st to 4th, you gain an average of 4-5 spell slots per long rest, sometimes as high as 10, other times as low as 0. Arcane Recovery for Wizards would allow you to gain more.

Isn't 25% of 13 = 3.25, not 4-5?

25% of 13 is certainly 3.25, but the average number of spell slots gained isn't just 25% of the spell slots you have, because that fails to take into account the fact that the feat itself allows you to cast more spells than that. 

If you have this feat, once you've cast 13 level 1-4 spells in a single day, you've only actually used (on average) 9.75 spell slots. You can cast 3.25 more spells today, for a total of 16.25 spells. But then of those 3.25 extra spells, 25% of them — about 0.83 — also don't use a spell slot, so you can cast 0.83 more spells. And 25% of them don't use a spell slot, etc. Congratulations, you're in calculus class again, and while I don't feel like fully doing the math right now, the actual average is going to wind up somewhere between 4 and 5.

Quote from wagnarokkr >>

Quote from Satanihavet >>

Quote from ceramist >>

For a 19th-level spellcaster with 13 spell slots from1st to 4th, you gain an average of 4-5 spell slots per long rest, sometimes as high as 10, other times as low as 0. Arcane Recovery for Wizards would allow you to gain more.

Isn't 25% of 13 = 3.25, not 4-5?

25% of 13 is certainly 3.25, but the average number of spell slots gained isn't just 25% of the spell slots you have, because that fails to take into account the fact that the feat itself allows you to cast more spells than that. 

If you have this feat, once you've cast 13 level 1-4 spells in a single day, you've only actually used (on average) 9.75 spell slots. You can cast 3.25 more spells today, for a total of 16.25 spells. But then of those 3.25 extra spells, 25% of them — about 0.83 — also don't use a spell slot, so you can cast 0.83 more spells. And 25% of them don't use a spell slot, etc. Congratulations, you're in calculus class again, and while I don't feel like fully doing the math right now, the actual average is going to wind up somewhere between 4 and 5.

That's not what I said, and also not my point. Please stop being condescending.

Also, still not interested in replies from you.